Ken Blanchard and Wally Armstrong have created a parable that will either have profound, new insights or relevant reminders for most, if not all, readers. The characters and events in the book might seem to be over-simplified and without nuance, but that is the purpose of a parable – to illustrate succinctly the love of God and how to live according to His will.
The two protagonists of the story are the Old Pro and Paul McAllister, and the former helps the latter find out how to achieve his golf goals (have fun, develop relationships, and enjoy the scenery) and his life goals. Even though I understand the authors’ desire to simplify and focus on their theme, they are inexplicably dismissive of two other golf goals – competing and exercising. In fact (on page 56) the Old Pro asks, “Is it [the reason Paul plays golf] for fun, for camaraderie, for beauty, or for the competition?” This implies that having fun and competing are mutually exclusive, and I find that – for most recreational golfers – friendly competition is one of the best ways to have fun.
It is noteworthy that – in the acknowledgements - Wally Armstrong thanks Dr. David Cook (author of “Seven Days in Utopia,” another excellent book with a similar message linking golf and life) for “teaching me the mental truths of golf: 'see it, feel it, trust it.'” Dr. Cook’s “see it, feel it, trust it” approach is similar to the “Visualize, practice, and commit” concept taught by the Old Pro in “The Mulligan.”