What do you think?
Rate this book
Meddle & Mend #4
Dear Bartleby
Dear Bartleby, Tutting-on-Cress is so small as to be idyllic. Hate it already.
Sent down from Oxford for playing one prank too many, Sebastian Hartford is well aware that he’s a disappointment to his family. Ordered to stay with — and learn from — two of his more respectable older siblings, Seb is prepared to be miserable in the country.
Saddled with extracurricular schooling to keep him out of trouble, Seb can only let his mischievous mind run loose on the pages of his journal, “Bartleby.” But when he is offered a job as a spellcaster’s assistant to the enigmatic Lord Finlington, Seb’s creative flair finds a place to flourish.
Soon, he is at the center of a search for a new Royal Spellcaster to the Crown — and falling in love with one of the contenders.
But right as a future with a man who loves him starts to unfold, Seb’s past mistakes threaten to bar him from securing happiness. And jumping through social hoops may prove his growth to everyone — except himself.
Sent down from Oxford for playing one prank too many, Sebastian Hartford is well aware that he’s a disappointment to his family. Ordered to stay with — and learn from — two of his more respectable older siblings, Seb is prepared to be miserable in the country.
Saddled with extracurricular schooling to keep him out of trouble, Seb can only let his mischievous mind run loose on the pages of his journal, “Bartleby.” But when he is offered a job as a spellcaster’s assistant to the enigmatic Lord Finlington, Seb’s creative flair finds a place to flourish.
Soon, he is at the center of a search for a new Royal Spellcaster to the Crown — and falling in love with one of the contenders.
But right as a future with a man who loves him starts to unfold, Seb’s past mistakes threaten to bar him from securing happiness. And jumping through social hoops may prove his growth to everyone — except himself.
294 pages, Paperback
First published September 6, 2023
12 people are currently reading
203 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews
November 9, 2024
Like a warm hug, this is the lovely story of strangers to friends to lovers between Seb, the prankster troublemaker and youngest in the family sent to live with his older brother and his husband (the MCs of book 1), and Laurence, the sweetest trans man whom Seb meets through his new job. I can't praise this magical world enough - the gradual progression of these two's relationship, Seb's beautiful growth into himself, and his beautiful friendship with Pip (introduced in book 2 then getting his own story in book 3) only scratch the surface.
I've said this many times already, but I love this universe, the characters, and the return to the first book's epistolary format (this time in the form of journal entries). To say I’m grateful for these fictional worlds to escape into would be the understatement of the century.
I've said this many times already, but I love this universe, the characters, and the return to the first book's epistolary format (this time in the form of journal entries). To say I’m grateful for these fictional worlds to escape into would be the understatement of the century.
September 6, 2023
This book is a treasure. I'm not sure what kind of magic Sarah Wallace puts in their books, but I loved every single word.
Dear Bartleby is the fourth book in this series, but it can easily be read as a standalone. I would advise you to at least read the first book because all the characters that I met and loved in Letters to Half Moon Street play major parts in this one.
This is the story of Sebastian Hartford, a troubled 20 year old man who is sent by his father from Oxford to the small town of Tutting-on-Cress for playing one too many pranks on his teachers. He is set to live with his older brother, Gavin, and his husband, Mr. Charles Kentworthy. His sister is living with them as well, so Seb is basically thrust into the hands of his family, with the purpose of doing some introspection and ultimately grow up.
The book is narrated solely through Seb's journal entries, and my god, the emotions that come alive through his words are both heartwarming and heartbreaking, I actually teared up a few times. He undergoes the most wonderful transformation, going from a lost, lonely, insecure guy to a stronger, polished and more settled version of himself, a side of himself that was there all along, but stifled by all that mischief and by keeping the wrong company. The character growth is absolutely outstanding.
In a magic filled, queer normative world, he strikes a beautiful friendship with Mr. Laurence Ayles, one of the applicants for the Royal Spellcaster job. He is a trans man, and their friendship gradually develops into something more, the way it progressed was so organic and absolutely brilliant. Their connection was so strong and tender, it made my heart burst with happiness.
Seb is working for Lord Finlington who is meant to search for the best 3 candidates for this particular post. He ends up being invaluable to the lord, and it was brilliant to see him flourish like that. Seb is also taken under his brother in law's wing, Charles taking it upon himself to educate him on various aspects. I loved their dynamic so much, how every relationship Seb develops is handled with so much care and compassion. He learns the meaning of true friendship, his worth, but also his place in the family. This entire group of characters make my heart happy. He even mends his relationship with his father, and ah, that was so emotional to witness.
I will say, I am mad at myself for not reading book 2 and 3 first, because one of the side characters, Pip, is too precious. He becomes one of Seb's closest friends, and although his story is heartbreaking, they're friendship is beautiful and I wish I had more insight into Pip's life before reading this book. Because I cried when the incident involving Pip happened. I cried so much.
If you want a magical world, with kind, caring and diverse characters that unconditionally love and support each other, this is the book for you. Seb is an unforgettable character, his journal entries paint such a vivid image of his struggles, the feelings of inadequacy that plague him at the beginning, the loneliness that envelops him like a toxic vise, only to later witness his transformation, the way he is slowly building himself up, taking charge of his life by making decisions based on his wants, finding and exploring his strengths.
I am in awe of this author for managing to create such a complex and beautiful character.
I have a lot more notes that I've made while reading this ARC, and I could write a thousand more words, but I better not. I do however encourage you all to pick this book up.
Dear Bartleby is the fourth book in this series, but it can easily be read as a standalone. I would advise you to at least read the first book because all the characters that I met and loved in Letters to Half Moon Street play major parts in this one.
This is the story of Sebastian Hartford, a troubled 20 year old man who is sent by his father from Oxford to the small town of Tutting-on-Cress for playing one too many pranks on his teachers. He is set to live with his older brother, Gavin, and his husband, Mr. Charles Kentworthy. His sister is living with them as well, so Seb is basically thrust into the hands of his family, with the purpose of doing some introspection and ultimately grow up.
The book is narrated solely through Seb's journal entries, and my god, the emotions that come alive through his words are both heartwarming and heartbreaking, I actually teared up a few times. He undergoes the most wonderful transformation, going from a lost, lonely, insecure guy to a stronger, polished and more settled version of himself, a side of himself that was there all along, but stifled by all that mischief and by keeping the wrong company. The character growth is absolutely outstanding.
In a magic filled, queer normative world, he strikes a beautiful friendship with Mr. Laurence Ayles, one of the applicants for the Royal Spellcaster job. He is a trans man, and their friendship gradually develops into something more, the way it progressed was so organic and absolutely brilliant. Their connection was so strong and tender, it made my heart burst with happiness.
Seb is working for Lord Finlington who is meant to search for the best 3 candidates for this particular post. He ends up being invaluable to the lord, and it was brilliant to see him flourish like that. Seb is also taken under his brother in law's wing, Charles taking it upon himself to educate him on various aspects. I loved their dynamic so much, how every relationship Seb develops is handled with so much care and compassion. He learns the meaning of true friendship, his worth, but also his place in the family. This entire group of characters make my heart happy. He even mends his relationship with his father, and ah, that was so emotional to witness.
I will say, I am mad at myself for not reading book 2 and 3 first, because one of the side characters, Pip, is too precious. He becomes one of Seb's closest friends, and although his story is heartbreaking, they're friendship is beautiful and I wish I had more insight into Pip's life before reading this book. Because I cried when the incident involving Pip happened. I cried so much.
If you want a magical world, with kind, caring and diverse characters that unconditionally love and support each other, this is the book for you. Seb is an unforgettable character, his journal entries paint such a vivid image of his struggles, the feelings of inadequacy that plague him at the beginning, the loneliness that envelops him like a toxic vise, only to later witness his transformation, the way he is slowly building himself up, taking charge of his life by making decisions based on his wants, finding and exploring his strengths.
I am in awe of this author for managing to create such a complex and beautiful character.
I have a lot more notes that I've made while reading this ARC, and I could write a thousand more words, but I better not. I do however encourage you all to pick this book up.
July 26, 2023
I want every single historical fiction book to be set in this universe. The casual queerness and magical elements make it so cozy and comforting while also dealing with serious topics. I cried multiple times reading this one because Seb just stole my freaking heart. His relationship with his siblings and with his dad and with his love interest are all so perfectly crafted to elicit emotion. Like you're going to cry. I still want more Pip but I am taking what is being given and I loved his little cameos in the story.
Gay rep, POC trans rep, many many secondary queer characters.
Gay rep, POC trans rep, many many secondary queer characters.
Read
March 29, 2025Me, writing this review: A sweet coming of age story with a classic slow burn friends-to-lovers romance that ends as the protagonist and his love interest discuss the future they’ll build together, this novel -
Audience member: (clearing throat awkwardly) Uh actually you’re 55% of the way through the book, there’s a lot more -
Me, narrowing eyes, continuing review: - is a cozy, Regency-inspired fantasy written in the form the protagonist’s diary entries, reluctant at first and then more and more sweetly sincere as the book goes on. The author smartly weaves an ongoing competition for the post of Royal Spellcaster into the background without letting it overpower the protagonist’s story. The way the author never resolves that plotline is part and parcel with the soothingly engaging slice-of-village-life style. The -
Audience member: (clearing throat more purposely) Actually that plotline IS -
Me, more loudly, pretending I can’t hear anything: - ensemble of characters are HEARTWARMING and UNFAILINGLY KIND, a JOY to spend time with, and the BOOK smartly DRAWS to a CLOSE BEFORE the charm has a CHANCE to wear -
The screen freezes on me, on the stage, lit by a single spotlight. A figure in the audience, mostly in shadow, is halfway to their feet.
My voiceover starts:
“Yep, that’s me! I bet you’re wondering how I got here. Well, I read half of this book in one sitting. It was delightful! I loved Seb, and I loved the epistolary style. And then, I won’t lie to you, it took a little bit of a turn. Not a huge turn! No swerving going on here! But the MC and his love interest had a conversation about their future, and they seemed to have it all figured out. And the Royal Spellcaster plotline, I’ll be real, is pretty boring - a cast of Agatha Christie archetypes, with no murder to be found! So I thought to myself, ‘What if I just ended it here? It’s basically at the HEA already!’ And so that’s what I did.
“Okay, now that I say it out loud, it’s not that controversial! It’s a good book, and I recommend. And I hope this review is appreciated in the spirit it’s intended!”
(There are some muffled, scratchy microphone noises, and then a pause.)
“…. Does anyone remember how Ferris ended his one of these? How do I turn this thing off?”
Audience member: (clearing throat awkwardly) Uh actually you’re 55% of the way through the book, there’s a lot more -
Me, narrowing eyes, continuing review: - is a cozy, Regency-inspired fantasy written in the form the protagonist’s diary entries, reluctant at first and then more and more sweetly sincere as the book goes on. The author smartly weaves an ongoing competition for the post of Royal Spellcaster into the background without letting it overpower the protagonist’s story. The way the author never resolves that plotline is part and parcel with the soothingly engaging slice-of-village-life style. The -
Audience member: (clearing throat more purposely) Actually that plotline IS -
Me, more loudly, pretending I can’t hear anything: - ensemble of characters are HEARTWARMING and UNFAILINGLY KIND, a JOY to spend time with, and the BOOK smartly DRAWS to a CLOSE BEFORE the charm has a CHANCE to wear -
The screen freezes on me, on the stage, lit by a single spotlight. A figure in the audience, mostly in shadow, is halfway to their feet.
My voiceover starts:
“Yep, that’s me! I bet you’re wondering how I got here. Well, I read half of this book in one sitting. It was delightful! I loved Seb, and I loved the epistolary style. And then, I won’t lie to you, it took a little bit of a turn. Not a huge turn! No swerving going on here! But the MC and his love interest had a conversation about their future, and they seemed to have it all figured out. And the Royal Spellcaster plotline, I’ll be real, is pretty boring - a cast of Agatha Christie archetypes, with no murder to be found! So I thought to myself, ‘What if I just ended it here? It’s basically at the HEA already!’ And so that’s what I did.
“Okay, now that I say it out loud, it’s not that controversial! It’s a good book, and I recommend. And I hope this review is appreciated in the spirit it’s intended!”
(There are some muffled, scratchy microphone noises, and then a pause.)
“…. Does anyone remember how Ferris ended his one of these? How do I turn this thing off?”
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 22, 2024
4.5 stars
December 29, 2023
4.5 stars
MY HEART!!!
Whereas book 2 and 3 almost felt like their own contained duology, Dear Bartleby feels more in -line with the vibes of book 1, Letters to Half Moon Street.
Yet this time, we're doing diary entries instead of letters!
I fell in love with Seb as a sidecharacter in book 1 and have been dying to see more of him ever since, so finding out that he was the protagonist here was just an absolute treat!! He is admittedly not without his flaws at the start of the story, but the believable and well-earned character growth is... simply chef's kiss!! Because this story is told through his diary entries, the story has a very introspective quality to it that allows you to get so emotionally invested in Seb as he lays his soul bare on the page, and I absolutely loved that.
This series is just a true treasure, and it is truly beyond me how Wallace keeps knocking it out of the park with these stories. The found family vibes are off the charts, the queer love is just bursting off the page, the mental health representation is so authentically woven into the narrative, the magical shenanigans are utterly whimsical and entrancing, and all the beautiful interpersonal relationships (be they platonic, familial, or romantic) are just so so so tender and heartfelt.
A true new favourite series, I can't get enough of these characters!!
MY HEART!!!
Whereas book 2 and 3 almost felt like their own contained duology, Dear Bartleby feels more in -line with the vibes of book 1, Letters to Half Moon Street.
Yet this time, we're doing diary entries instead of letters!
I fell in love with Seb as a sidecharacter in book 1 and have been dying to see more of him ever since, so finding out that he was the protagonist here was just an absolute treat!! He is admittedly not without his flaws at the start of the story, but the believable and well-earned character growth is... simply chef's kiss!! Because this story is told through his diary entries, the story has a very introspective quality to it that allows you to get so emotionally invested in Seb as he lays his soul bare on the page, and I absolutely loved that.
This series is just a true treasure, and it is truly beyond me how Wallace keeps knocking it out of the park with these stories. The found family vibes are off the charts, the queer love is just bursting off the page, the mental health representation is so authentically woven into the narrative, the magical shenanigans are utterly whimsical and entrancing, and all the beautiful interpersonal relationships (be they platonic, familial, or romantic) are just so so so tender and heartfelt.
A true new favourite series, I can't get enough of these characters!!
August 31, 2023
Dear diary,
I am in love with this book. It was sweet and romantic without it focusing only on the love story. It was about Sebastian and his growth from a prankster brat to a mature young man with dreams and people to rely on, something he didn't have. The friends he thought he had were none other than fellow bullies and being in his big brother Gavin's house, away from their influence, makes Seb realise he might be lonelier than he thought. Luckily all the amazing characters we came to love in previous books of this great series, are there to support Sebastian and to slap some sense into him, giving him purpose and lending him their shoulder and ear whenever he needed it. It was just what he needed and it proved serendipitous because his growth and newly found maturity led him to Lawrence, a handsome man that caught his eye, making him feel butterflies in his stomach, even more when said feelings are reciprocated. The love story along with Seb's personal journey are interwoven and will make your heart smile. Those are two cuties in love and there's nothing to add; happily ever after material for sure!
So, diary, this is me telling you I loved everything about this book told in diary entries, and I left those pages utterly joyful!
I am in love with this book. It was sweet and romantic without it focusing only on the love story. It was about Sebastian and his growth from a prankster brat to a mature young man with dreams and people to rely on, something he didn't have. The friends he thought he had were none other than fellow bullies and being in his big brother Gavin's house, away from their influence, makes Seb realise he might be lonelier than he thought. Luckily all the amazing characters we came to love in previous books of this great series, are there to support Sebastian and to slap some sense into him, giving him purpose and lending him their shoulder and ear whenever he needed it. It was just what he needed and it proved serendipitous because his growth and newly found maturity led him to Lawrence, a handsome man that caught his eye, making him feel butterflies in his stomach, even more when said feelings are reciprocated. The love story along with Seb's personal journey are interwoven and will make your heart smile. Those are two cuties in love and there's nothing to add; happily ever after material for sure!
So, diary, this is me telling you I loved everything about this book told in diary entries, and I left those pages utterly joyful!
August 27, 2023
I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review. Sarah Wallace was kind enough to send me both the ebook and audiobook ARC’s.
Since first reading his letters in Letters to Half Moon Street, I knew Seb and his story would be my favorite! I was not disappointed, to say the least! I loved it.
This book got a lot of emotions out of me. I laughed out loud. I cried multiple times, especially at some of the wholesome scenes at the end. And there was one scene, an overheard conversation, that made me have to take a break from reading for an hour because I was so upset at one character and so upset on behalf of another. The scene after was extremely realistic and well-written, too. While an overall cozy read, it goes to some very deep places, all handled with care and respect.
Dear Bartleby is cathartic, healing, and so sweet! I want to give Seb, and all his loved ones, a big hug! I think readers will enjoy this coming-of-age queer historical regency romance as either a standalone or as part of the Meddle & Mend series.
Since first reading his letters in Letters to Half Moon Street, I knew Seb and his story would be my favorite! I was not disappointed, to say the least! I loved it.
This book got a lot of emotions out of me. I laughed out loud. I cried multiple times, especially at some of the wholesome scenes at the end. And there was one scene, an overheard conversation, that made me have to take a break from reading for an hour because I was so upset at one character and so upset on behalf of another. The scene after was extremely realistic and well-written, too. While an overall cozy read, it goes to some very deep places, all handled with care and respect.
Dear Bartleby is cathartic, healing, and so sweet! I want to give Seb, and all his loved ones, a big hug! I think readers will enjoy this coming-of-age queer historical regency romance as either a standalone or as part of the Meddle & Mend series.
June 13, 2023
What can I say about this book and the Meddle & Mend series that I haven’t already?
It’s got everything I love: historical fantasy, incredible magic, beautiful locations, found family, cozy AF romance, diverse characters. I have never wanted to live inside a book more than when I read what Sarah has written.
Dear Bartleby is an epistolary style novel just like Letters to Half Moon Street, only this time it follows Seb, the youngest brother in the Hartford family, as he documents his adventures in his journal.
This book is the longest in the series so far and I’m glad, because are you ready? It’s my new favorite. The balance of old characters I already loved with new characters who brought so much to the story was perfect. Watching Seb grow up (and fall in love) through his own point of view felt authentic and so sweet.
Thank you to the author for sharing an ARC with me!
It’s got everything I love: historical fantasy, incredible magic, beautiful locations, found family, cozy AF romance, diverse characters. I have never wanted to live inside a book more than when I read what Sarah has written.
Dear Bartleby is an epistolary style novel just like Letters to Half Moon Street, only this time it follows Seb, the youngest brother in the Hartford family, as he documents his adventures in his journal.
This book is the longest in the series so far and I’m glad, because are you ready? It’s my new favorite. The balance of old characters I already loved with new characters who brought so much to the story was perfect. Watching Seb grow up (and fall in love) through his own point of view felt authentic and so sweet.
Thank you to the author for sharing an ARC with me!
July 20, 2023
This was another fantastic installment in the Meddle & Mend series, which I absolutely love. We are back to the epistolary style format in this one, which I enjoy immensely. We get to see more of our favourite characters (I have a soft spot for Gavin and Charles so I was really glad to see them a lot) and are introduced to new characters to love.
I enjoyed getting to know Seb better and see his growth. We also learn much more about magic and society in this book and I really appreciated that additional world building and can't wait to see more. I also really loved to see the approach to a trans character in this queer-normative world.
I received an audiobook ARC of this book but all views are my own and I can't wait for everyone else to be able to get their hands on this one! 🤍
I enjoyed getting to know Seb better and see his growth. We also learn much more about magic and society in this book and I really appreciated that additional world building and can't wait to see more. I also really loved to see the approach to a trans character in this queer-normative world.
I received an audiobook ARC of this book but all views are my own and I can't wait for everyone else to be able to get their hands on this one! 🤍
September 21, 2023
4.5
These books are absolute perfection.
Always adorable, careful in the representation and detail-oriented when it comes to giving body and life to their characters.
These books are absolute perfection.
Always adorable, careful in the representation and detail-oriented when it comes to giving body and life to their characters.
April 16, 2024
How are all of Sarah Wallace's MCs such precious cinnamon rolls??
Very wholesome read with some journal entries that hit me surprisingly hard. Loved Seb and I enjoyed watching his growth and his journey to finding happiness.
Reading the books in order, I feel that the author is improving with each one! This one is my favorite of this series so far (despite my love for Charles!).
Very wholesome read with some journal entries that hit me surprisingly hard. Loved Seb and I enjoyed watching his growth and his journey to finding happiness.
Reading the books in order, I feel that the author is improving with each one! This one is my favorite of this series so far (despite my love for Charles!).
January 15, 2025
Sebastian was a far more sympathetic character than I expected. His story was sweet and lovely.
July 28, 2025
3.75☆
September 3, 2023
Dear Bartleby is my new favorite in the Meddle and Mend series. While this is Sebastian’s first appearance in the series and can be read as a standalone, I do recommend at least reading Letters to Half Moon Street first to familiarize yourself with the already established characters you will meet. It may also serve to familiarize you with the writing style, as they are both epistolary.
Set in the idyllic backdrop of Tutting-on-Cress, the story captures the charm and warmth of the setting perfectly, proving that its idyllic nature is far from a flaw, Seb! I love this little village so much. From the overall atmosphere, to the people who inhabit it, every book makes me fall in love with it even more.
Speaking of the characters, while I was already acquainted with most of them from Sarah’s previous books, I’ve been eagerly awaiting Sebastian’s appearance since he was first mentioned. The story of Sebastian Hartford's transformation from a troublemaker to a young man seeking redemption and purpose is beautifully crafted.
As Sebastian seeks a sense of self away from the negative influences in his life, forms genuine friendships, strives for his family's approval, and discovers love, the narrative grips you with its emotional depth. Wallace's writing effortlessly draws you into the world of Tutting-on-Cress, making you root for Sebastian every step of the way.
As for the love interest, while I can't personally speak to the accuracy of the trans representation, the character felt genuine and warm, and added depth to the narrative. His chemistry with Sebastian was beautifully written, making their relationship an integral part of the story. He’s now a part of the ever-growing cast of characters of whom I can’t wait to see more.
Dear Bartleby is a five-star read that not only tugs at your heartstrings but also leaves you longing for more of these wonderful characters in the books to come. Sarah Wallace has truly outdone themself with this enchanting addition to the Meddle and Mend series.
Set in the idyllic backdrop of Tutting-on-Cress, the story captures the charm and warmth of the setting perfectly, proving that its idyllic nature is far from a flaw, Seb! I love this little village so much. From the overall atmosphere, to the people who inhabit it, every book makes me fall in love with it even more.
Speaking of the characters, while I was already acquainted with most of them from Sarah’s previous books, I’ve been eagerly awaiting Sebastian’s appearance since he was first mentioned. The story of Sebastian Hartford's transformation from a troublemaker to a young man seeking redemption and purpose is beautifully crafted.
As Sebastian seeks a sense of self away from the negative influences in his life, forms genuine friendships, strives for his family's approval, and discovers love, the narrative grips you with its emotional depth. Wallace's writing effortlessly draws you into the world of Tutting-on-Cress, making you root for Sebastian every step of the way.
As for the love interest, while I can't personally speak to the accuracy of the trans representation, the character felt genuine and warm, and added depth to the narrative. His chemistry with Sebastian was beautifully written, making their relationship an integral part of the story. He’s now a part of the ever-growing cast of characters of whom I can’t wait to see more.
Dear Bartleby is a five-star read that not only tugs at your heartstrings but also leaves you longing for more of these wonderful characters in the books to come. Sarah Wallace has truly outdone themself with this enchanting addition to the Meddle and Mend series.
October 17, 2023
an absolute gem!!!
I absolutely adored this book!!
I realize I read this out of order and will definitely be reading the rest. I loved this world so much!
Sebastian is such a sweet character. Though he seems to be clown of his family, we soon discover that there’s more to him than pranks and jokes. He’s actually quite sensitive and sweet, and I loved watching him grow and find his way. He leads a wonderful cast of characters, and their interactions are heartfelt and hilarious. And LAURENCE!!! How I loved him to bits and pieces; he is the most beautiful soul!!!
The world Sarah created was so wonderful. It’s 1800s England but with magic, casual queerness, and a diverse cast of LGBTQ+ characters. I loved that there’s no big thing made about several of the characters being gay, it just was. I’m looking forward to spending more time is this darling world.
-Open magic system
-Casual queerness
-A very sweet boy who grows up before our eyes
-His loving suitor
-A beautiful cast of supporting characters
I absolutely adored this book!!
I realize I read this out of order and will definitely be reading the rest. I loved this world so much!
Sebastian is such a sweet character. Though he seems to be clown of his family, we soon discover that there’s more to him than pranks and jokes. He’s actually quite sensitive and sweet, and I loved watching him grow and find his way. He leads a wonderful cast of characters, and their interactions are heartfelt and hilarious. And LAURENCE!!! How I loved him to bits and pieces; he is the most beautiful soul!!!
The world Sarah created was so wonderful. It’s 1800s England but with magic, casual queerness, and a diverse cast of LGBTQ+ characters. I loved that there’s no big thing made about several of the characters being gay, it just was. I’m looking forward to spending more time is this darling world.
-Open magic system
-Casual queerness
-A very sweet boy who grows up before our eyes
-His loving suitor
-A beautiful cast of supporting characters
June 13, 2023
Rep & tropes: Queernormative historical fiction, gay man x trans m, full cast of queer side characters with different body types and skin tones, instant attraction with a slow burn, fluffy not smutty
I love these little books. This one follows the youngest Hartford sibling, Seb, after he's been yanked out of school for causing trouble. While in the countryside he lives with Gavin, Gerry, Pip and Charles and works for Bertie (all characters who we've seen before). While working for Bertie he meets Laurence, a charming trans man.
I love how these books normalize queerness. Seb is a gay man and when he finds out Laurence is trans, he never once questions his attraction or feelings for him. Laurence binds and has a cycle and no one ever thinks anything of it. There's never conflict because of queerness and there's always such healthy communication. Plus it's all wrapped up in a cozy historical fantasy with a pinch of magic.
I love these little books. This one follows the youngest Hartford sibling, Seb, after he's been yanked out of school for causing trouble. While in the countryside he lives with Gavin, Gerry, Pip and Charles and works for Bertie (all characters who we've seen before). While working for Bertie he meets Laurence, a charming trans man.
I love how these books normalize queerness. Seb is a gay man and when he finds out Laurence is trans, he never once questions his attraction or feelings for him. Laurence binds and has a cycle and no one ever thinks anything of it. There's never conflict because of queerness and there's always such healthy communication. Plus it's all wrapped up in a cozy historical fantasy with a pinch of magic.
March 31, 2024
This epistolary novel (novella?) is compelling specifically because of the character arc, which works because the pacing's excellent. For awhile I was going to dock it half a star for the unrealistic diary entries, but that becomes part of the story, Seb's note-taking ability. And, it is a magical alternate reality, after all.
I admire how easily gender differences and pronouns are handled. Good job, author. Also, the language is beautifully consistently early 1800s England plus magic plus less bigotry. Really lovely to read. Also-also, the 14 August 1817 made me laugh out loud.
I admire how easily gender differences and pronouns are handled. Good job, author. Also, the language is beautifully consistently early 1800s England plus magic plus less bigotry. Really lovely to read. Also-also, the 14 August 1817 made me laugh out loud.
October 27, 2024
3.5⭐
This was absolutely darling, but I guess it didn't make me feel as many emotions as the previous books did (especially Pip's story, which set the bar quite high). Still full of comfort and love, but I must admit my favourite moments were when characters from the other books showed up, allowing us to witness some of their development beyond what we had seen in their respective stories.
It's all personal preference and didn't prevent me from having a good time with this book however.
Special mention to the dukex, I just love them. And Pip, Bertie, Gerry, Gavin and Charles.
This was absolutely darling, but I guess it didn't make me feel as many emotions as the previous books did (especially Pip's story, which set the bar quite high). Still full of comfort and love, but I must admit my favourite moments were when characters from the other books showed up, allowing us to witness some of their development beyond what we had seen in their respective stories.
It's all personal preference and didn't prevent me from having a good time with this book however.
Special mention to the dukex, I just love them. And Pip, Bertie, Gerry, Gavin and Charles.
August 31, 2023
3.75 rounding up!
I am so happy I picked up this book! It is so warm, and cozy, and really just a delightful little read.
I want to preface this by saying this is the first book I've read in the series (as I was so generously provided an arc for review by the author). It's a series I've had my eye on for a while, but I just hadn't gotten around to it. I had hoped to read the first three books before I made it to this one, but alas, time snuck up on me. All of this is to say, that I think I would have rated this book higher if I had read the others because I wish I knew the other characters a little more going in. There is a lot of back story that is clearly there and I think it would have only enhanced my enjoyment of this installment. (I already purchased book 1 and I'm hoping to read it soon...tbr be damned and all of that).
Anyway, back to this story. I really enjoyed all the characters we get to know. The MC is a bit of a rascal who we really get to see grow over time. The LI in the story was the sweetest human I've ever read about and I loved him so. All the side characters brought so much to the story and although at the beginning I had some trouble remembering who was who (probably a me problem), I eventually got it all ironed out. The love story was sweet and warm and gave me gooey feelings!
I have to say though, the shining star of this book is the world! It is absolutely so delightfully queer and I couldn't get enough. I want a million books where queer is the norm and that isn't the source of conflict for the story. It just makes me happy to know it exists, even if just in a story. So yes, obviously I will be reading the rest of the series because I had to leave this cozy queer world far too soon.
Also it's told in journal entries only (I believe the whole series is epistolary!) and I just loved the format!
I am so happy I picked up this book! It is so warm, and cozy, and really just a delightful little read.
I want to preface this by saying this is the first book I've read in the series (as I was so generously provided an arc for review by the author). It's a series I've had my eye on for a while, but I just hadn't gotten around to it. I had hoped to read the first three books before I made it to this one, but alas, time snuck up on me. All of this is to say, that I think I would have rated this book higher if I had read the others because I wish I knew the other characters a little more going in. There is a lot of back story that is clearly there and I think it would have only enhanced my enjoyment of this installment. (I already purchased book 1 and I'm hoping to read it soon...tbr be damned and all of that).
Anyway, back to this story. I really enjoyed all the characters we get to know. The MC is a bit of a rascal who we really get to see grow over time. The LI in the story was the sweetest human I've ever read about and I loved him so. All the side characters brought so much to the story and although at the beginning I had some trouble remembering who was who (probably a me problem), I eventually got it all ironed out. The love story was sweet and warm and gave me gooey feelings!
I have to say though, the shining star of this book is the world! It is absolutely so delightfully queer and I couldn't get enough. I want a million books where queer is the norm and that isn't the source of conflict for the story. It just makes me happy to know it exists, even if just in a story. So yes, obviously I will be reading the rest of the series because I had to leave this cozy queer world far too soon.
Also it's told in journal entries only (I believe the whole series is epistolary!) and I just loved the format!
July 27, 2023
When I first started reading this, I was a tad hesitant because I didn't realize each chapter was a diary entry. Usually, that isn't my thing. That being said, any hesitation I had evaporated once I got to know the characters. I came to love each diary entry the more the book went on. I really enjoyed reading Seb's growth as a character, and his relationship with Laurence grow. Their relationship was so cute! I also enjoyed reading each side character and cared about what happened to them.
Fantasy isn't my favorite genre to read, but in this story, I did like it! I liked that the magic wasn't necessarily the focus of the story itself, and it's just present in a completely normalized way. The way that queerness was normalized was very refreshing, as well. The complete lack of relationship drama was also something I really appreciated! Sometimes, you just need that😉.
Since I loved this story so much, I'll definitely be buying the first 3 books of this series! I really want to know more about the side characters!
I received an advanced copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Fantasy isn't my favorite genre to read, but in this story, I did like it! I liked that the magic wasn't necessarily the focus of the story itself, and it's just present in a completely normalized way. The way that queerness was normalized was very refreshing, as well. The complete lack of relationship drama was also something I really appreciated! Sometimes, you just need that😉.
Since I loved this story so much, I'll definitely be buying the first 3 books of this series! I really want to know more about the side characters!
I received an advanced copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
June 16, 2023
I loved this book, maybe more than all the others in the series. I read last night until I had to sleep and then started reading first thing this morning and didn't stop until I finished. Sorry to all of the work I should have done, but it was totally worth it!
I will be back with more thoughts. For now I'll say that I'm thrilled to have read this arc. If you like cozy, historical fantasies with a little romance, a supportive circle of found and birth family, and a beautiful queernorm world, start reading this series now so you're ready for this book in November. (Yes, read them in order. There are no cliffhangers, but the story will be more satisfying if you have the backstory and know the characters as they're introduced.)
I will be back with more thoughts. For now I'll say that I'm thrilled to have read this arc. If you like cozy, historical fantasies with a little romance, a supportive circle of found and birth family, and a beautiful queernorm world, start reading this series now so you're ready for this book in November. (Yes, read them in order. There are no cliffhangers, but the story will be more satisfying if you have the backstory and know the characters as they're introduced.)
January 12, 2024
4.75*s. This series is so consistently wonderful that I require hair-splitting decimals to differentiate my reactions to the books within it!
This is another epistolary book (yay!), this time — a diary, which is delightful, but less fun than the letters from the first book. This book is also just a tiny bit too long for my liking, but I did like Seb's "coming of age" story a great deal — it's much less dire and traunatic than Pip's, but it might have required more character growth and change than any other character in this series had to do within these books.
And it was lovely to see these wonderful characters thriving.
I can already tell that I'll be reaching for this series whenever I need a dose of pure joy. (Books 1 and 4 — for sure, but the others, too, probably.)
This is another epistolary book (yay!), this time — a diary, which is delightful, but less fun than the letters from the first book. This book is also just a tiny bit too long for my liking, but I did like Seb's "coming of age" story a great deal — it's much less dire and traunatic than Pip's, but it might have required more character growth and change than any other character in this series had to do within these books.
And it was lovely to see these wonderful characters thriving.
I can already tell that I'll be reaching for this series whenever I need a dose of pure joy. (Books 1 and 4 — for sure, but the others, too, probably.)
Read
December 19, 2024This was my least favorite book in the series but I did still enjoy the cozy fantasy vibes and the trans rep is quite sweet. I started off hating the audiobook narrator, like how did they find the most annoying sounding person ever to read this lol. but it turns out there was a purpose to that and as the character evolves, the narrator's voice changes. Really thoughtful to do it that way, I have never noticed that in an audiobook before. Honestly this series deserves so much more attention from readers, and I hope this author's audience grows.
July 12, 2025
I loved that this one was in epistolary format again, even though the last two books in the series dropped that.
Telling a romance in letters seems so unlikely, but somehow it just works. Especially in combination with the super slow pace and very low stakes of the plot, this was a super calm and comfortable read.
I liked meeting Sebastian, the youngest Hardford sibling, and Laurie was just right for him. I also really enjoyed that the romance features a transgender love interest - somehow I rarely encounter that, even in the queer romance I read, especially with cis protagonists.
Telling a romance in letters seems so unlikely, but somehow it just works. Especially in combination with the super slow pace and very low stakes of the plot, this was a super calm and comfortable read.
I liked meeting Sebastian, the youngest Hardford sibling, and Laurie was just right for him. I also really enjoyed that the romance features a transgender love interest - somehow I rarely encounter that, even in the queer romance I read, especially with cis protagonists.
Read
October 31, 2025this was such a sweet and calming book. i loved that everything is so matter of fact. the magic, the sexuality, gender equality(ish). I really expected this to be some kind of agnst filled secret lgbt regency romance, but instead i got a gentle coming of age story where a young man falls in with a bad crowd and his loving family do what they can to help him straighten up. this really hit the spot, and will probably become a favorite re-read.
October 5, 2023
I absolutely loved this book. As soon as I finished reading Letters to Half Moon Street I wanted to know more about Seb and his story so I got this book right away.
Dear Bartleby is another epistolary romance where we get to see the story develop through Seb's journal entries. In the beginning we get to see how alone and conflicted he feels when he gets sent to his brother's house after he gets expelled from Oxford for one too many pranks. During his stay with Gavin and Charles (read book 1!) he discovers who he really is, what he is capable of doing, who are his friends and his future role in the world. It is absolutely lovely to see his growth surrounded by people that loves him. I am obsessed with this series and I am on to book 2 and 3!
"Tutting-on-cress is small, but it has a funny way of giving a person what they need, even if they don't know yet what that may be".
Dear Bartleby is another epistolary romance where we get to see the story develop through Seb's journal entries. In the beginning we get to see how alone and conflicted he feels when he gets sent to his brother's house after he gets expelled from Oxford for one too many pranks. During his stay with Gavin and Charles (read book 1!) he discovers who he really is, what he is capable of doing, who are his friends and his future role in the world. It is absolutely lovely to see his growth surrounded by people that loves him. I am obsessed with this series and I am on to book 2 and 3!
"Tutting-on-cress is small, but it has a funny way of giving a person what they need, even if they don't know yet what that may be".
September 13, 2023
I was nervous I would not enjoy Seb as much as I did Gavin, Nell, and Pip, but dear readers, I was very wrong. I adored this book and absolutely loved seeing all the familiar faces and meeting Laurence. This entire series is so warm and comforting. I cannot wait for the next book!
January 13, 2024
After reading the entires series (4 books so far) I must say I really adored book 1 (epistolary) and 4 (diary entries). I didn't expect to like those styles, but found them both a lovely way to learn about the characters.
I hope to hear more from this world and be able to read more about all these characters!
I hope to hear more from this world and be able to read more about all these characters!
January 14, 2025
Crying in the club rn
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews