What do you think?
Rate this book
My Heart Remembers #1
My Heart Remembers
Seventeen years after being separated from her brother and sister when they were adopted by different families in Missouri, Maelle, the orphaned daughter of Irish immigrants, continues to search for her family.
352 pages, Hardcover
First published March 1, 2008
272 people are currently reading
3614 people want to read
About the author
Kim Vogel Sawyer
79 books1,208 followersAward-winning, bestselling author Kim Vogel Sawyer told her kindergarten teacher that someday people would check out her book in the library. The little-girl dream came true in 2006 with the release of Waiting for Summer's Return. Kim's titles now exceed 1.5 million copies and are available in six different languages. A former elementary school teacher, she now enjoys a full-time writing and speaking ministry. Kim's passion lies in writing stories that point the reader to a deeper, more intimate relationship with God. When Kim isn't writing, you'll find her traveling with her retired military hubby, spoiling her granddarlings, petting the cats, quilting, or--as time allows--participating in community theater. You can learn more about Kim's writing and speaking ministries at her website, KimVogelSawyer.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 408 reviews
February 20, 2020
3/30/18
This book never fails to make me weep! Such happy, emotional tears I will always embrace. The rich spiritual and emotional journeys in this novel are what I've come to expect and deeply appreciate in a Kim Vogel Sawyer story, and this particular tale never gets old. This is now my fourth read of it, though it's my first listen to the audio version.
The narrator, Heather O'Neill did a wonderful job, even nailing the Irish accent from the get-go, which gave me happy chills and a broad smile. Her delivery did have a few choppy, abrupt moments, but overall, she was a delight to listen to. I'd look for other books narrated by her.
Molly's journey stood out to me more this time than any other. I'm not sure why I've always forgotten how much of her story is woven into this lovely book. My guess is that I've always adored Maelle the most, thus paying the most attention to her part of things.
My favorite thing this go-around was how Petey provided the thread that linked the siblings together throughout. It was neat to see how he constantly popped in and out of the lives of Maelle, Matty, and Molly.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves a great orphan train story, emotional journey, deep spiritual journey, and/or a completely sweet tale.
I was not compensated for my honest review.
2/11-2/17/20
Yet another read of this favorite. I was blown away again by how several characters new each of the Gallaghers without their realizing it. Such artistry and finesse to pull that off well!
This book never fails to make me weep! Such happy, emotional tears I will always embrace. The rich spiritual and emotional journeys in this novel are what I've come to expect and deeply appreciate in a Kim Vogel Sawyer story, and this particular tale never gets old. This is now my fourth read of it, though it's my first listen to the audio version.
The narrator, Heather O'Neill did a wonderful job, even nailing the Irish accent from the get-go, which gave me happy chills and a broad smile. Her delivery did have a few choppy, abrupt moments, but overall, she was a delight to listen to. I'd look for other books narrated by her.
Molly's journey stood out to me more this time than any other. I'm not sure why I've always forgotten how much of her story is woven into this lovely book. My guess is that I've always adored Maelle the most, thus paying the most attention to her part of things.
My favorite thing this go-around was how Petey provided the thread that linked the siblings together throughout. It was neat to see how he constantly popped in and out of the lives of Maelle, Matty, and Molly.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves a great orphan train story, emotional journey, deep spiritual journey, and/or a completely sweet tale.
I was not compensated for my honest review.
2/11-2/17/20
Yet another read of this favorite. I was blown away again by how several characters new each of the Gallaghers without their realizing it. Such artistry and finesse to pull that off well!
March 18, 2018
Simply perfection! What a delightful story, as the three siblings make their way toward the reunion they have long dreamed of accomplishing. Maelle was my favorite but not by a long shot, because Matt and Isabelle (Molly) were great in their own right (plus, who can resist Petey?) If you're looking for beautifully-written fiction from a strong Christian standpoint (definitely preaches the gospel) and with a romantic-focus value of nearly 0, grab it immediately and dive in!
I loved every moment, even the sad ones, and you may very well need a box of tissues handy. Easily a favorite of the books I've read this year.
I loved every moment, even the sad ones, and you may very well need a box of tissues handy. Easily a favorite of the books I've read this year.
May 23, 2019
I admit that it took me much too long to finish this book. I also admit that that was only because I was so worried about how things were going to end that I let myself skip ahead when I first picked it up. Bad, bad me. I know. But this subject could have been handled in so many ways, and I'm not a fan of certain kinds of tearjerkers, so I really wanted to know that everything was going to turn out all right. (Also, this is only my second book by Kim Vogel Sawyer. I have a feeling I will be much more trusting when picking up my next book by her.) ;)
I absolutely loved the way the author handled the deeply painful circumstances and separation. And I loved the characters, although it took some time to understand Maelle's prickliness, and Molly/Isabelle was a bit of a spoiled brat for a while. ;) Mattie was definitely my favorite of the three! :D
I really appreciated the spiritual messages and themes, and although my mind was racing with uncomfortable possibilities, the whole issue of Maelle in her boys' clothes (especially as a child) was handled pretty well and without too much detail, which I was thankful for. I did find it interesting that Maelle was always searching for her brother and sister by their birth names, but she continued to go by the name she had grown up with, even though that would have made it harder for anyone to find her... I enjoyed the little bits of sweet romance--no kissing!!!!--and liked what I got to see of both Jackson and Aaron. And I loved how each of the main characters' experiences led them to help other orphans in one way or another. <3
Overall, this was a beautiful story that brought tears (the good kind!) to my eyes at the end. I'll be eager to discover more of the author's work. :)
4.5 stars
Content--a man suggests that a woman become his mistress (refused); a girl is mistaken for a boy, and the mistake is discovered when a man walks in on her in the bathtub (no details, and nothing happens); mentions of accidents and deaths; mentions of blood, wounds, and vomiting (not graphic); mentions of children being abused and beaten; mentions of men accosting and frightening a woman; some noticing and touching between couples
I absolutely loved the way the author handled the deeply painful circumstances and separation. And I loved the characters, although it took some time to understand Maelle's prickliness, and Molly/Isabelle was a bit of a spoiled brat for a while. ;) Mattie was definitely my favorite of the three! :D
I really appreciated the spiritual messages and themes, and although my mind was racing with uncomfortable possibilities, the whole issue of Maelle in her boys' clothes (especially as a child) was handled pretty well and without too much detail, which I was thankful for. I did find it interesting that Maelle was always searching for her brother and sister by their birth names, but she continued to go by the name she had grown up with, even though that would have made it harder for anyone to find her... I enjoyed the little bits of sweet romance--no kissing!!!!--and liked what I got to see of both Jackson and Aaron. And I loved how each of the main characters' experiences led them to help other orphans in one way or another. <3
Overall, this was a beautiful story that brought tears (the good kind!) to my eyes at the end. I'll be eager to discover more of the author's work. :)
4.5 stars
Content--a man suggests that a woman become his mistress (refused); a girl is mistaken for a boy, and the mistake is discovered when a man walks in on her in the bathtub (no details, and nothing happens); mentions of accidents and deaths; mentions of blood, wounds, and vomiting (not graphic); mentions of children being abused and beaten; mentions of men accosting and frightening a woman; some noticing and touching between couples
June 24, 2022
Maelle, Mattie, and Molly, children of Irish immigrants, are left orphaned after a fire ravishes their tenement house. They are taken first to an orphanage in New York and then placed on an orphan train headed to Missouri. There, even as 8 year old Maelle fights to keep them together, they are torn apart and each ends up with a different family. Maelle, dressed as a boy, heads off with a photographer to become his assistant, Mattie is taken by a rancher as a child laborer. And baby Molly is taken by a well-to-do couple. Maelle sends both Mattie and Molly with a token of their family so they won't forget who they are, and Maelle vows to spend her life searching for her brother and sister.
This is a tender, poignantly written story. I couldn't help falling in love with each of the three children as they grew to adulthood and faced trials that made each of their lives more difficult. But in the midst of their trials, each one found Jesus as their Savior and became more and more dependent on Him as they lived their lives and made decisions. Lots of great secondary characters who added more special touches to this story. Definitely a happy tears moment as they are all finally reunited at the close of the book even though it was easy to predict. I hated to see the book end and I look forward to reading the sequel: In Every Heartbeat.
This is a tender, poignantly written story. I couldn't help falling in love with each of the three children as they grew to adulthood and faced trials that made each of their lives more difficult. But in the midst of their trials, each one found Jesus as their Savior and became more and more dependent on Him as they lived their lives and made decisions. Lots of great secondary characters who added more special touches to this story. Definitely a happy tears moment as they are all finally reunited at the close of the book even though it was easy to predict. I hated to see the book end and I look forward to reading the sequel: In Every Heartbeat.
March 9, 2017
Take care o' the wee ones. Don't let them o' yer sight. D'ya hear me,lass?
These are the last words that eight year old Maelle Gallagher hears before her mother and father perish in a fire in their tenement house. With their only family gone, Maelle, her brother Mattie, and baby sister, Molly are thrown at the mercy of a New York City orphanage. Soon the three Irish immigrants find themselves on an orphan train headed for Missouri. Upon learning that she will be separated from her siblings, Maelle, now known as Mike, gives each a gift to remember her by. The family bible goes to her baby sister and a family photograph to Mattie. Maelle tells her brother that when they meet again she will know her siblings by these things and they will know her by their mother's carefully kept love letters.
Seventeen years pass, part two of the book is narrated by Maelle, a photographer( now known as Mike Watts), Mattie is now Matt Tucker, ranch hand and Molly is Isabelle Standler, a young heiress who is becoming aware of her real story. Each begins an unexpected journey to Missouri and to each other. Of course, there are many helping hearts and hands that all three characters encounter and who will be instrumental in the three long lost siblings to be reunited.
"My Heart Remembers" will leave you will a smile on your face and a few tears in your eyes.
These are the last words that eight year old Maelle Gallagher hears before her mother and father perish in a fire in their tenement house. With their only family gone, Maelle, her brother Mattie, and baby sister, Molly are thrown at the mercy of a New York City orphanage. Soon the three Irish immigrants find themselves on an orphan train headed for Missouri. Upon learning that she will be separated from her siblings, Maelle, now known as Mike, gives each a gift to remember her by. The family bible goes to her baby sister and a family photograph to Mattie. Maelle tells her brother that when they meet again she will know her siblings by these things and they will know her by their mother's carefully kept love letters.
Seventeen years pass, part two of the book is narrated by Maelle, a photographer( now known as Mike Watts), Mattie is now Matt Tucker, ranch hand and Molly is Isabelle Standler, a young heiress who is becoming aware of her real story. Each begins an unexpected journey to Missouri and to each other. Of course, there are many helping hearts and hands that all three characters encounter and who will be instrumental in the three long lost siblings to be reunited.
"My Heart Remembers" will leave you will a smile on your face and a few tears in your eyes.
December 10, 2019
This book was awesome! Kim Vogel Sawyer is a classic go-to author for me if I KNOW I want to enjoy a good story with a solid message to it.
What I Liked: This author’s characters always seem to be so real with the struggles they face. Oh my, I nearly cried a few times in this book and that is quite a feat for me. My heart was ripped out a few times and the suspense kept me listening to the audio version of this book I was listening to. The perseverance and persistence of the main character, Maelle, to find her siblings was sweet to see and I was rooting for her the entire way. I appreciated how Kim Vogel Sawyer gave the reader the perspectives of all three children so you truly understood what was going on.
What I Didn’t Like: I don’t think that there was anything that I really disliked about this story.
I give this book 5/5 stars and it is also going on my favorites of 2019 list.
What I Liked: This author’s characters always seem to be so real with the struggles they face. Oh my, I nearly cried a few times in this book and that is quite a feat for me. My heart was ripped out a few times and the suspense kept me listening to the audio version of this book I was listening to. The perseverance and persistence of the main character, Maelle, to find her siblings was sweet to see and I was rooting for her the entire way. I appreciated how Kim Vogel Sawyer gave the reader the perspectives of all three children so you truly understood what was going on.
What I Didn’t Like: I don’t think that there was anything that I really disliked about this story.
I give this book 5/5 stars and it is also going on my favorites of 2019 list.
March 22, 2019
My heart remembers a fost de multa vreme pe lista mea de lecturi si a tot fost amanata. Am ales-o acum pentru ca imi doream sa citesc o drama si eram oarecum familiarizata cu subiectul. Poate ca nu mi-a placut atat de mult din cauza faptului ca mai citisem romane cu aceasta tema, mult mai bune decat cel de fata: Trenul Orfanilor, Inainte sa fim ai vostri, etc. Cred ca ele m-au facut sa am oarecum alte asteptari. Povestea mi s-a parut mult prea simpla, la fel si limbajul si stilul narativ. Din pacate, nu m-a impresionat prin nimic. Am asemanat stilul autoarei cu cel al Janette Oke, care mie mi se pare plictisitor si monoton. Parca i-a lipsit sarea si piperul. A avut o poveste trista, care insa nu a ajuns la mine.
Romanul surprinde povestea a trei dintre miile de copii orfani, ce sunt dati de colo colo, rupti de mediul lor si aruncati in viata fara niciun ajutor. E o poveste reala din Anglia anilor 1800 a trei frati, despartiti de sistem, dar cu credinta si speranta ca intr-o zi, cu ajutorul lui Dumnezeu, se vor regasi. E un roman ce surprinde credinta ca tema principala. Nu l-as numi neaparat religios, dar are multe motive religioase, in special ideea ca trebuie sa accepti umil tot ce iti ofera viata si sa te increzi in Dumnezeu ca ti-a rezervat si lucruri mai bune. O idee greu de acceptat intr-o societate moderna, in care, cred eu, fiecare lupta pentru o viata mai buna pentru el si pentru copii lui si in care trebuie sa te auto-depasesti pentru a supravietui. Mi-a placut insa faptul ca autoarea nu a incercat sa promoveze ideile religioase in mod agresiv, sa iti bage pe gat convingerile ei. Povestea in sine mi s-a parut previzibila, nu a avut vreun element special, iar finalul a fost demn de telenovela ...insa m-am atasat putin in special de Maelle, sora cea mare.
A fost o lectura scurta si usoara, dar destul de banala, in ciuda temei alese si a copertii, care mi se pare foarte reusita. :)
Romanul surprinde povestea a trei dintre miile de copii orfani, ce sunt dati de colo colo, rupti de mediul lor si aruncati in viata fara niciun ajutor. E o poveste reala din Anglia anilor 1800 a trei frati, despartiti de sistem, dar cu credinta si speranta ca intr-o zi, cu ajutorul lui Dumnezeu, se vor regasi. E un roman ce surprinde credinta ca tema principala. Nu l-as numi neaparat religios, dar are multe motive religioase, in special ideea ca trebuie sa accepti umil tot ce iti ofera viata si sa te increzi in Dumnezeu ca ti-a rezervat si lucruri mai bune. O idee greu de acceptat intr-o societate moderna, in care, cred eu, fiecare lupta pentru o viata mai buna pentru el si pentru copii lui si in care trebuie sa te auto-depasesti pentru a supravietui. Mi-a placut insa faptul ca autoarea nu a incercat sa promoveze ideile religioase in mod agresiv, sa iti bage pe gat convingerile ei. Povestea in sine mi s-a parut previzibila, nu a avut vreun element special, iar finalul a fost demn de telenovela ...insa m-am atasat putin in special de Maelle, sora cea mare.
A fost o lectura scurta si usoara, dar destul de banala, in ciuda temei alese si a copertii, care mi se pare foarte reusita. :)
March 8, 2018
5 "pitcher" Stars!!
What a refreshing change! Kim Vogel Sawyer lead me on a beautiful journey through the lives of Maelle, Mattie and Molly. I have not read a story written in this way before and I loved it! The style was unique and very creative.
The story took a hold of me from chapter one. Breaking my heart at times. But also healing my heart along the way. Rearly do I cry when reading but this story did make me cry for joy more than sad tears a few times. If I'm honest my heart longs for more of this story!
I really liked the characters they all had there own likeable personalities except one or two but we can't like them all. My personal favourite was Petey :)
The writing was beautiful and extremely engaging. This was my first book by Kim Vogel Sawyer and I will definitely be reading ALOT more in the near future. Including book 2 to this series.
I definitely recommend this book! especially if your looking for a change from man meets woman storyline :)
What a refreshing change! Kim Vogel Sawyer lead me on a beautiful journey through the lives of Maelle, Mattie and Molly. I have not read a story written in this way before and I loved it! The style was unique and very creative.
The story took a hold of me from chapter one. Breaking my heart at times. But also healing my heart along the way. Rearly do I cry when reading but this story did make me cry for joy more than sad tears a few times. If I'm honest my heart longs for more of this story!
I really liked the characters they all had there own likeable personalities except one or two but we can't like them all. My personal favourite was Petey :)
The writing was beautiful and extremely engaging. This was my first book by Kim Vogel Sawyer and I will definitely be reading ALOT more in the near future. Including book 2 to this series.
I definitely recommend this book! especially if your looking for a change from man meets woman storyline :)
March 9, 2018
A very sweeping historical narrative, the story of Maelle and her siblings was touching at times, heartbreaking at others. I enjoyed it.
January 10, 2011
This was a surprisingly good novel. I received it as a Christmas gift from my grandmother, and while I ordinarily do not dabble in the Christian fiction genre for one reason or another, I figured there was no harm in giving it a try. The story really sucked me in, especially with the three altering narratives from each of the protagonists. A quick read, but an enticing story that I couldn't put down. While the characters were all Christian, they certainly weren't perfect and were all the more believable. A heartbreaking story with the perfect ending that makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside, like all is right in the world. I have a weakness for historical fiction, and I enjoyed Sawyer's descriptions of Missouri town life in the early 20th century. Surprising bits of enticing romance too, which I was not expecting, and carried out very well.
Not quite on par with Francine River's Redeeming Love, as far as Christian fiction goes, but still worth a read. Full of Truth, but not too preachy...I liked that it focused on the theme of Psalm 139, which coincidentally happens to be one of my absolute favorite psalms. I think it might appeal slightly more to the Protestant crowd, just because of some of the theological elements presented (e.g. welcoming the Lord into your heart as your personal Savior automatically granting a believer entrance into Heaven). Also odd that the three siblings are of Irish origin, but there is no mention of a Catholic background. Although considering the importance of the family Bible in the plot and the fact that they are immigrants could mean they are of the Irish Protestant minority...either way, it makes for a heartwarming, inspiring story. And sometimes you really need to read those kinds of things.
Not quite on par with Francine River's Redeeming Love, as far as Christian fiction goes, but still worth a read. Full of Truth, but not too preachy...I liked that it focused on the theme of Psalm 139, which coincidentally happens to be one of my absolute favorite psalms. I think it might appeal slightly more to the Protestant crowd, just because of some of the theological elements presented (e.g. welcoming the Lord into your heart as your personal Savior automatically granting a believer entrance into Heaven). Also odd that the three siblings are of Irish origin, but there is no mention of a Catholic background. Although considering the importance of the family Bible in the plot and the fact that they are immigrants could mean they are of the Irish Protestant minority...either way, it makes for a heartwarming, inspiring story. And sometimes you really need to read those kinds of things.
March 22, 2018
I loved it! I couldn't put it down several times. I still had about a 100 pages to the end, and I couldn't just stop; I had to finish it!
I loved the faith element. I loved the characters. I loved the history. I loved the interweaving of the three stories to finally merge at the end. The only thing I didn't absolutely love was the resolution. I realize there is a sequel, but I think the last thread could have been easily tied up in an epilogue.
On the whole, definitely going into my re-read pile!
Favorite quotes:
1. “And in a little church in Spring Arbor, Michigan, Maelle had met someone who would never be taken away from her. Since then, her reason for church attendance had become two-fold. She still sought her brother and sister, but she also sought to grow in her knowledge of Jesus” (p.61).
2. "Peter shrugged. 'Wasn't that hard to find her. Mike was standin' right on the boardwalk'" (p.298).
I loved the faith element. I loved the characters. I loved the history. I loved the interweaving of the three stories to finally merge at the end. The only thing I didn't absolutely love was the resolution. I realize there is a sequel, but I think the last thread could have been easily tied up in an epilogue.
On the whole, definitely going into my re-read pile!
Favorite quotes:
1. “And in a little church in Spring Arbor, Michigan, Maelle had met someone who would never be taken away from her. Since then, her reason for church attendance had become two-fold. She still sought her brother and sister, but she also sought to grow in her knowledge of Jesus” (p.61).
2. "Peter shrugged. 'Wasn't that hard to find her. Mike was standin' right on the boardwalk'" (p.298).
July 9, 2011
This was, overall, an excellent read. (Heart-wrenching, tear-jerking parts!)
I was not impressed with the writing, however. It has a "modern" feel to it, with very short sentences for which I don't really care.
Also, there were some parts where the unmarried couples would touch, etc. In one part, one of the main characters shied away from being hugged by a man and then later on, she realizes that she enjoys his touch now and that God brought her that "healing." I disagree whole-heartedly that a man and woman may touch one another when unmarried.
I was not impressed with the writing, however. It has a "modern" feel to it, with very short sentences for which I don't really care.
Also, there were some parts where the unmarried couples would touch, etc. In one part, one of the main characters shied away from being hugged by a man and then later on, she realizes that she enjoys his touch now and that God brought her that "healing." I disagree whole-heartedly that a man and woman may touch one another when unmarried.
June 24, 2022
Going into this book, I know a lot of my Goodreads friends had recommended this book and rated it high, so I had high hopes, like every other Kim Vogel Sawyer book I have read. This story was filled with so many emotions, so keep the tissues close.
The opening scenes was heart-breaking, and I was surprised with Maelle's story, because I feared it was going to be different. Mattie's story was very different to what I expected, but perfect for the plot of fighting for orphans everyone wants to forget. Isabella was the character I felt went through the biggest character growth of all three siblings. The supporting male characters in Maelle and Isabella's life was strong.
There was a lot of times where I feared that there would not have been happy endings. You will just have to read this story to see what happened.
I listened to the audiobook and the narrator was engaging and did a brilliant job with the Irish accents. If you prefer audiobooks, I highly recommend this one.
All fans of Kim Vogel Sawyer and Historical fiction should pick up this one.
*I listened to this on Scribd.*
The opening scenes was heart-breaking, and I was surprised with Maelle's story, because I feared it was going to be different. Mattie's story was very different to what I expected, but perfect for the plot of fighting for orphans everyone wants to forget. Isabella was the character I felt went through the biggest character growth of all three siblings. The supporting male characters in Maelle and Isabella's life was strong.
There was a lot of times where I feared that there would not have been happy endings. You will just have to read this story to see what happened.
I listened to the audiobook and the narrator was engaging and did a brilliant job with the Irish accents. If you prefer audiobooks, I highly recommend this one.
All fans of Kim Vogel Sawyer and Historical fiction should pick up this one.
*I listened to this on Scribd.*
July 11, 2022
What a heartwarming, inspiring story! Following the Gallagher siblings as they went through some challenging seasons was truly a pleasure. The emphasis and history regarding poor, orphaned/abandoned children touched my heart, as well. I really appreciated the spiritual encouragement in this book. It was very realistic and practical.
Some seem to think the story was too simple at the end…well considering that the whole book is based on prayer and trusting God, I felt it was very realistic. God does answer prayer and work through tough situations for the good of His children and for His glory.
Definitely would reread this one and recommend it ❤️
Some seem to think the story was too simple at the end…well considering that the whole book is based on prayer and trusting God, I felt it was very realistic. God does answer prayer and work through tough situations for the good of His children and for His glory.
Definitely would reread this one and recommend it ❤️
April 8, 2008
I believe this is Kim’s best novel yet. I was a little concerned when I realized she intended to take me on a journey with three different storylines… but she did it well.
At a tender age, Maelle, Mattie, and Molly Gallagher’s parents are killed in an apartment fire. The three orphans are put on a westbound train to be adopted out. Their only ties to home are the family Bible, a photo, and a stack of letters exchanged by their parents. When the three siblings are separated, will they ever be able to find each other again?
Molly is adopted by a weathly family who gives her the name Isabelle. She’s never told anything about her past until her adoptive parents die and her brother, who always resented her, disowns her. Forced to work as a servant for a family in Shay’s Ford, Missouri, Isabelle can’t believe how her life has changed. Then she meets Aaron Rowley, a shopkeeper’s son, who opens her eyes to the plight of local orphans. Can Aaron open her eyes to her need for a Savior? Will she find room in her heart for this man who she would’ve previously considered below her station?
As a kid, Maelle pretended to be a boy - Michael - in order to stay with her brother at the orphan’s home. Now she’s all grown up, but “Mike” still wears trousers. After inheriting her adoptive uncle’s travelling photography studio, Maelle made it her mission to find her long-lost brother and sister. When she arrives in Shay’s Ford, Missouri, she has no intention of staying, but a local lawyer, Jackson, changes her mind. Is he interested in her just for the promotion she can provide through her pictures of working children from across the country? Or could Jackson be interested in her for another reason?
Mistreated as a child, Mattie left Missouri and never planned to return. But when his job in Texas goes away, he has no choice but to take the job offered to him - in Shay’s Ford. Will his return be a disaster, or could it be a godsend? Will he find the family he has always longed for?
And could God have a plan to reunite these three siblings?
I absolutely loved this book. Could not put it down. Kim does a great job with all three storylines. Both of the girls’ storylines have a bit of romance in them, which I loved, but it doesn’t overpower their own character arcs or the overall story of the family trying to find each other.
Mattie’s story of overcoming his fears and his past while becoming the man God intended him to be just warmed my heart.
Kim’s well-written characters will make you love them and root for them the whole time. This book was just incredibly done and I highly recommend it.
At a tender age, Maelle, Mattie, and Molly Gallagher’s parents are killed in an apartment fire. The three orphans are put on a westbound train to be adopted out. Their only ties to home are the family Bible, a photo, and a stack of letters exchanged by their parents. When the three siblings are separated, will they ever be able to find each other again?
Molly is adopted by a weathly family who gives her the name Isabelle. She’s never told anything about her past until her adoptive parents die and her brother, who always resented her, disowns her. Forced to work as a servant for a family in Shay’s Ford, Missouri, Isabelle can’t believe how her life has changed. Then she meets Aaron Rowley, a shopkeeper’s son, who opens her eyes to the plight of local orphans. Can Aaron open her eyes to her need for a Savior? Will she find room in her heart for this man who she would’ve previously considered below her station?
As a kid, Maelle pretended to be a boy - Michael - in order to stay with her brother at the orphan’s home. Now she’s all grown up, but “Mike” still wears trousers. After inheriting her adoptive uncle’s travelling photography studio, Maelle made it her mission to find her long-lost brother and sister. When she arrives in Shay’s Ford, Missouri, she has no intention of staying, but a local lawyer, Jackson, changes her mind. Is he interested in her just for the promotion she can provide through her pictures of working children from across the country? Or could Jackson be interested in her for another reason?
Mistreated as a child, Mattie left Missouri and never planned to return. But when his job in Texas goes away, he has no choice but to take the job offered to him - in Shay’s Ford. Will his return be a disaster, or could it be a godsend? Will he find the family he has always longed for?
And could God have a plan to reunite these three siblings?
I absolutely loved this book. Could not put it down. Kim does a great job with all three storylines. Both of the girls’ storylines have a bit of romance in them, which I loved, but it doesn’t overpower their own character arcs or the overall story of the family trying to find each other.
Mattie’s story of overcoming his fears and his past while becoming the man God intended him to be just warmed my heart.
Kim’s well-written characters will make you love them and root for them the whole time. This book was just incredibly done and I highly recommend it.
January 1, 2018
Oh, I loved this book!! It has officially taken its place as my favorite book by Kim Vogel Sawyer. Such a sweet, sweet story! At first, I liked Isabelle's (Molly's) story the best. And then Matthew's story developed. And then I just liked Maelle. Such beautiful characters. The orphan train is dear to my heart anyway, so reading a story of three orphans who "rode the train" and were separated... loved it.
This book was just beautifully done. When one character "got their life together" then things intensified for another character. The story never, ever felt like it was dragging. It was so very well crafted.
I just feel like gushing "this was such a good book, such a GOOD book." :D Yeah, a cohesive review isn't happening tonight. It was just a very lovely read.
Okay, cohesive now...
Romance... yes, there was romance. I'll admit that sometimes I feel not the best judge of how much romance because when it gets to a part I don't care for as much, I tend to skim. There were some hugs and maybe a kiss before marriage, but the feelings weren't too exploited. I might would recommend it for 16-up of conservative readers.
Spiritual... the salvation was a bit washy to me (just "ask God into your heart" and nothing about repenting for sins, but accepting God's love). But the spiritual lives of the other two was pretty solid (wanting to please God, seeking Him). So I definitely put it as a Christian novel.
Interestingly enough, though one of the main women characters wore trousers, I didn't find her to be too independent or a feminist (which is a trend for most "Christian Historical Fiction"). I appreciated that.
So all-in-all, a very enjoyable read. It wasn't perfect all across the board, but I just want to give it five stars. ;)
This book was just beautifully done. When one character "got their life together" then things intensified for another character. The story never, ever felt like it was dragging. It was so very well crafted.
I just feel like gushing "this was such a good book, such a GOOD book." :D Yeah, a cohesive review isn't happening tonight. It was just a very lovely read.
Okay, cohesive now...
Romance... yes, there was romance. I'll admit that sometimes I feel not the best judge of how much romance because when it gets to a part I don't care for as much, I tend to skim. There were some hugs and maybe a kiss before marriage, but the feelings weren't too exploited. I might would recommend it for 16-up of conservative readers.
Spiritual... the salvation was a bit washy to me (just "ask God into your heart" and nothing about repenting for sins, but accepting God's love). But the spiritual lives of the other two was pretty solid (wanting to please God, seeking Him). So I definitely put it as a Christian novel.
Interestingly enough, though one of the main women characters wore trousers, I didn't find her to be too independent or a feminist (which is a trend for most "Christian Historical Fiction"). I appreciated that.
So all-in-all, a very enjoyable read. It wasn't perfect all across the board, but I just want to give it five stars. ;)
October 4, 2011
I took advantage of a "free" Kindle book offer and downloaded this book. It is a story about three orphans who board an "orphan train" on their way to an orphanage. The year : 1886. The parents who were Irish immigrants perished in a fire leaving them to fend for themselves. Maelle is 9 and a half years old, Mattie, 6 years old and one-year old Molly. Predictably, they are adopted by three different families. But just before the younger kids are taken by their adoptive parents, Maelle manages to give them things to remind them that they were once a family.
Fast-forward to 1902 when Maelle, now known as Mike, is 25, Mattie, now called Matt, is 22, and the baby Molly's name has been changed to Isabelle, 17. And that is the last two-thirds of the book.
Right from the get-go, I knew they would find each other. (Consider this a spoiler alert). But when it happened, it still tugged at my heart and as I read, my tears were flowing, to my embarrassment. The book has a lot of religious references which can be off-putting to other readers.
Reading this brought me to my Mills & Boon years (the good ones, and yes, there were a few). Easy read and entertaining.
Fast-forward to 1902 when Maelle, now known as Mike, is 25, Mattie, now called Matt, is 22, and the baby Molly's name has been changed to Isabelle, 17. And that is the last two-thirds of the book.
Right from the get-go, I knew they would find each other. (Consider this a spoiler alert). But when it happened, it still tugged at my heart and as I read, my tears were flowing, to my embarrassment. The book has a lot of religious references which can be off-putting to other readers.
Reading this brought me to my Mills & Boon years (the good ones, and yes, there were a few). Easy read and entertaining.
January 20, 2020
I loved reading My Heart Remembers. This is now my favorite book by Kim Vogel Sawyer. ~ Lizzie :)
March 6, 2018
I loved this book. I am interested in geneology and this book talked about a family from Ireland. They moved to New York and lived in a tenement. This was a very loving family, but tragedy struck them and the children became orphans. I would like to read more books about the history of the "Orphan Trains".
These three children were split up even though Maelle, the oldest sibling tried to keep them together because her father asked her to "Take care of the wee ones". Little did Maelle know in the future how she would "take care of the wee ones".
There was drama, adventure, romance and true love and redemption in this book. Praise the Lord that all children came to know Jesus as their personal Savior and Lord.
These three children were split up even though Maelle, the oldest sibling tried to keep them together because her father asked her to "Take care of the wee ones". Little did Maelle know in the future how she would "take care of the wee ones".
There was drama, adventure, romance and true love and redemption in this book. Praise the Lord that all children came to know Jesus as their personal Savior and Lord.
October 21, 2011
About 75 percent into this book I knew that I could not give this book more than two stars. I also knew that I had to review it, which I don't do very often.The plot was extremely predictable to me. I knew what was going to happen, and found myself wanting the siblings to meet each other so it could be done with. The characters fell flat. A lot of these characters were suppose to have a lot of different issues in their lives, and yet the back story to most of them fell short. I found myself wondering what really happened with the 3 siblings during all their time apart. The biggest turn off was the faith based portion in this book. I knew it was Christian fiction going in, and while I am not a Christian I don't normally have a problem reading books with religion in them. I read some of the reviews of this book stating that the religion was not in your face preachy. That was part of the reason that I picked up this book. I found that this statment was extremely wrong. A lot of the dialogue about Jesus just seemed out of place, and there was definitely a lot of in your face preaching (example: just because Maelle wore pants she was not a good christian.) The only good thing to come from this book was the historical aspect of it. It was interesting learning about the orphan trains, something I will definitely be looking into reading more about. In the end I just can't reccommend this book and will probably be deleting it from my kindle.
April 14, 2018
My Heart Remembers had my emotions pulled in so many directions. Author Kim Vogel Sawyer is gifted to write historical fiction with grace and love.
Three young orphans, Maelle, Matthew and Molly Gallagher were separated when they went sent on an orphan train from New York to Missouri. Maelle remembered her dad's last words the night of the fire in the tenement house they were residing in--those words being "Take care o' the wee ones." Maelle was heart broken when they were not allowed to stay together that fateful day at the church. She vowed she would find them as her new "uncle" was a traveling photographer.
Sawyer's research for this book was evident throughout the story including events that happened to young orphan children in the late 1800's and early 1900's until laws were passed. I appreciated the history of how Maelle (Mike) Matthew and Molly's life played out as youngsters into adulthood. She had another orphan boy, Petey that had connected with Matthew earlier in life along with Mike and Molly toward the end. My Heart Remembers is filled with heartbreak, determination, faith, kindness by strangers, forgiveness, and new beginnings.
Three young orphans, Maelle, Matthew and Molly Gallagher were separated when they went sent on an orphan train from New York to Missouri. Maelle remembered her dad's last words the night of the fire in the tenement house they were residing in--those words being "Take care o' the wee ones." Maelle was heart broken when they were not allowed to stay together that fateful day at the church. She vowed she would find them as her new "uncle" was a traveling photographer.
Sawyer's research for this book was evident throughout the story including events that happened to young orphan children in the late 1800's and early 1900's until laws were passed. I appreciated the history of how Maelle (Mike) Matthew and Molly's life played out as youngsters into adulthood. She had another orphan boy, Petey that had connected with Matthew earlier in life along with Mike and Molly toward the end. My Heart Remembers is filled with heartbreak, determination, faith, kindness by strangers, forgiveness, and new beginnings.
March 20, 2008
This was actually a really great read. The writing was tight, the characters well developed and unique, the plot engaging, and the conclusion satisfying. It even has a social message.
March 1, 2022
What a lovely book. I was crying at the end. The story of the 3 orphan siblings touched my heart.
November 10, 2018
This book is the first book I’ve read in a long time to make me shed a few tears. The journey is riveting, the characters likable, and it’s a voyage that isn’t short of emotional ups and downs.
When I began reading, I was suddenly transported into this enchanting and touching story, told from a little girl’s perspective - all care and responsibility were set upon her shoulders to care for her siblings after their parents tragic death in a tenement fire. I found myself quickly sympathizing with Maelle as I watched not only her home and parents being torn away from her, but the only two siblings she had left were also taken, despite her efforts at keeping them safe.
As she ages, the grievance of her losses are clearly expressed as she further reflects upon them: “A pang of guilt accompanied the realization that she’d lost the memory of her siblings’ faces - Da had instructed her to look after the wee ones, but she’d failed him. Other pictures had crowded her mind - of other children she’d encountered in her travels. How many photographs had she taken of children hiding their sad, hopeless situation behind a forced smile? Each time she’d tried to coax a genuine smile, she’d thought of her brother and sister and prayed the same despondency didn’t exist in their eyes, wherever they were.”
I was enveloped by the brutal and harsh reality these three orphans had to face but lurking between all of that was also a sense of hope as well as a child-like innocence that filled these pages. Despite the main characters being adults for the majority of this novel, the fact that they held onto that promise of one day reuniting with oneanother once again, really solidified that. This was prevalent mainly with Maelle and Matthew’s scenes since Molly’s circumstances were quite different.
I absolutely loved seeing the growth Molly had undergone as a character. She was completely stripped of a life filled with riches and extreme comfort to a more simple, humble yet all the more fulfilling and meaningful one; as if the Lord removed all of those things from her life so that she could learn, grow and be reborn as His daughter in Christ Jesus. Because of this, I’d have to say that Molly was by far my favorite character and I thoroughly enjoyed the moments I got to experience her world through her perspective.
There are a lot of valuable spiritual truths that can be found throughout this novel. I loved how the characters were always going back and seeking God’s wisdom and guidance during rough times while also thanking Him for the many blessings that have taken place in their lives. This book isn’t short of a happy ending because Kim Vogel Sawyer certainly delivered a tear-jerking one. I’m very excited to see what the sequel ‘In Every Heartbeat’ has in store!
When I began reading, I was suddenly transported into this enchanting and touching story, told from a little girl’s perspective - all care and responsibility were set upon her shoulders to care for her siblings after their parents tragic death in a tenement fire. I found myself quickly sympathizing with Maelle as I watched not only her home and parents being torn away from her, but the only two siblings she had left were also taken, despite her efforts at keeping them safe.
As she ages, the grievance of her losses are clearly expressed as she further reflects upon them: “A pang of guilt accompanied the realization that she’d lost the memory of her siblings’ faces - Da had instructed her to look after the wee ones, but she’d failed him. Other pictures had crowded her mind - of other children she’d encountered in her travels. How many photographs had she taken of children hiding their sad, hopeless situation behind a forced smile? Each time she’d tried to coax a genuine smile, she’d thought of her brother and sister and prayed the same despondency didn’t exist in their eyes, wherever they were.”
I was enveloped by the brutal and harsh reality these three orphans had to face but lurking between all of that was also a sense of hope as well as a child-like innocence that filled these pages. Despite the main characters being adults for the majority of this novel, the fact that they held onto that promise of one day reuniting with oneanother once again, really solidified that. This was prevalent mainly with Maelle and Matthew’s scenes since Molly’s circumstances were quite different.
I absolutely loved seeing the growth Molly had undergone as a character. She was completely stripped of a life filled with riches and extreme comfort to a more simple, humble yet all the more fulfilling and meaningful one; as if the Lord removed all of those things from her life so that she could learn, grow and be reborn as His daughter in Christ Jesus. Because of this, I’d have to say that Molly was by far my favorite character and I thoroughly enjoyed the moments I got to experience her world through her perspective.
There are a lot of valuable spiritual truths that can be found throughout this novel. I loved how the characters were always going back and seeking God’s wisdom and guidance during rough times while also thanking Him for the many blessings that have taken place in their lives. This book isn’t short of a happy ending because Kim Vogel Sawyer certainly delivered a tear-jerking one. I’m very excited to see what the sequel ‘In Every Heartbeat’ has in store!
August 7, 2019
Three orphaned siblings become separated when they are taken in by three different families. As adults they found one another again by the grace of God and in answer to many prayers. The action takes place in Missouri in the early twentieth century. Orphaned children were frequently used and abused by their keepers. This book exposes such activity and the need for legislation to stop said abuse. The author did not develop her characters, and my heartstrings were not pulled. I was more interested in the Child Labor Laws that would one day be passed protecting children from unfair employment practices. I wish the author had written more on that subject. I find federal laws that were passed in 1939 (check date), but I did not have the time to check on Missouri state laws except to find that such legislation was passed.
The book was short, and grammar was good.
Thank you, Ms. Sawyer, for the read.
The book was short, and grammar was good.
Thank you, Ms. Sawyer, for the read.
May 25, 2021
I'm torn about this book. It is rife with unbelievable coincidences and implausible situations. The reader's emotions are manipulated throughout. The ending is predictable and far-fetched. Yet, I found myself moved by the overall message of helping orphaned children and giving them an education and new start in life. That is a noble goal and in spite of the deficiencies of this book and Sawyer's writing style, I found myself sucked in. I can't heartily recommend it, but it turned out to be better than I had believed based on the first half of the book.
March 11, 2024
A touching tale about three orphaned siblings who are rent apart after the tragic death of their parents and are thrown into various upbringings. The oldest girl, Maelle, is determined to one day be reunited with siblings, Mattie and Molly. As their stories unfold, we see God's sovereignty take hold, guiding them back into each other's lives in a unique way.
March 8, 2019
Wow!!! What a great book and I really enjoyed the story. I'm so happy maelle, Molly and Mattie are reunited with each other. My daughter Amanda recommended this book to me
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 27, 2020
Ok, so maybe it was predictable...but when I fight a hiccup sob when that moment finally happens that I've been waiting for since the beginning I HAVE to give it at least a 4 out of 5.
January 2, 2024
This book had me on the edge of my seat in several parts. There were a few times I giggled and many times I had tears in my eyes as I read the historically-based book. Ms. Sawyer certainly did her research, and it made for an excellent book. I'm only leaving four stars because the storyline was quite predictable.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 408 reviews