After things fell apart in Rockton, Detective Casey Duncan and her husband, Sheriff Eric Dalton, created a town called Haven’s Rock in one of the most remote reaches of the Yukon for people who want to disappear. Meant to protect those who need it by being a well-hidden sanctuary, Casey and Eric still draw a firm line at who can be admitted. Background checks are done and dangerous criminals aren’t permitted. Especially given what happened in Rockton.
Haven’s Rock, however, is a fairly new community and most of its residents aren’t necessarily aware of the dangers that the wilds of Canada can pose. For this reason there are strict rules. The most important one is to avoid going into the woods alone. With wild animals looking for their next meal and a mining operation nearby, it’s just not safe without someone who can recognize when to raise an alarm.
The new townspeople, however, are curious, so Casey has organized hikes for anyone who is interested. Ten year old Max is just such a person. Intrigued by his new environment, he’s soaking up all of the lessons that Sheriff Eric has given him—especially how to track animals. One day while he’s out on a trek through the woods with some of the staff, he notices all the hallmarks of an animal following the group—including snapping twigs and silenced wildlife. Before he realizes it, he glimpses a bear. One that he swears, however, had human eyes.
Immediately, Casey and Eric take action. Despite the fact that Max claimed the bear had human features, a bear stalking a group of humans is not something that can be ignored. The decision is made to hunt it down before it can harm someone—or worse. But before they know it, worrisome things start to happen around town. First someone goes missing. Not long later, a body is found. Is there a stranger hiding out in the woods with a score to settle against one of the new residents? Or is the culprit one of their own?
I just don’t know how Kelley Armstrong does it. For the second time in a row, I was blown away by one of her crime fiction novels. The Boy Who Cried Bear had everything you could want in just such a book. With the perfect locked room mystery type setting, intriguing characters, and finely layered plot, I was hooked from the very first word. Even better, however, was the dread lacing through the pages. Trust me when I say, I read just one more chapter more times than I could count.
Between the characters and the layout of the plot, the former just barely won out as the star feature. Starting off with the endearing couple at the center of the action, Casey and Eric came complete with a sweet relationship that I can’t wait to watch unfold further. Second, but not far behind, was the rest of the cast of characters who were both somewhat unreliable as well as wholly relatable. Running from unknown events, we don’t know whether to trust them or not, which plays perfectly into the premise.
As for the storyline, there were several different subplots going on at the same time. And while that could’ve been confusing, it was anything but. At the same time, however, I couldn’t, for the life of me, figure out how all of the threads came together. Part of me, though, still doesn’t quite… But I’ll come back to that in a bit. All in all, told primarily from Casey’s POV with the occasional chapter from Max, this crime fiction tale felt decidedly more action-packed than most, with plenty of enticing thrills and chills as well as dynamite twists.
Okay. So there was one aspect that didn’t fill me with glee. By the end of the book, not everything was wrapped up with a nice, tiny, little bow like I prefer. On the contrary, there was one whopper of a cliffhanger that tied in directly to the main plot of the book. Granted, there was a definite happily ever after as well, but I personally like all of my answers spelled out. If this doesn’t bother you, take my warning with a rather large grain of salt.
Given that, however, I was still a huge fan of the second book in the Haven’s Rock series. Supposedly suggested as a stand-alone, I highly recommend reading these in order. Otherwise, you’ll miss out not only on characters and their growth (of which there was plenty), but underlying drama within the complex group dynamics. That said, the events in this novel didn’t extend from book one, which will surely not be the case as the series continues.
Wrapping up my review, I must say I’m even more of an Armstrong fan than I was going in. Original and fresh, this plot deviated greatly from all crime fiction that I’ve read in the past, but only in the best possible way. I also loved how there was a depth to the characters as many were struggling with past trauma, including Casey herself. All said and done, two massive thumbs up. Now I sadly have a long, impatient wait for book three. Rating of 4.5 stars.
Thank you to Kelley Armstrong, St. Martin’s Press, and NetGalley got my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DAY: February 20, 2024
Trigger warning: kidnapping, racism, pregnancy, mention of: fatal stabbing, pedophilia