Started this on a trip to Kerala, finished it a couple of days after returning, and enjoyed it thoroughly.
This is probably the best edited anthology I've read until now. Only someone who understands the place, its literature and is familiar with all the writers it has inspired could have done this. And it's not just about who to choose, it's also about exactly which passages to choose as well, so justice is done both to the writer and the theme. In Ramachandra Guha's essay about EMS Namboodiripad, he points out an error in Arundhati Roy's celebrated masterpiece The God of Small Things. So thorough is the editing and the selection that the passage in question, in which Roy makes the error, is also here, so we know why this is important. I've never seen such attention to detail in a book of this sort.
The lineup is stellar, it just never ends. Salman Rushdie, MT Vasudevan Nair, Basheer, Anita Nair herself, David Davidar, Dalrymple, Pankaj Mishra, Shashi Tharoor, OV Vijayan, M Mukundan, all of them are there. Which means that when you finish a story and want to pause for a while, you see another literary great's name on the next. You have to read him/her, so you read some more, and then some more. You literally don't want this book to end.
The best pieces were, in my opinion, Shashi Tharoor's little memoir, the extract from Salman Rushdie's The Moor's Last Sigh, and the extract from Jaishree Mishra's Ancient Promises, which made me want buy the book immediately to see what happens next. But the star was for me, of course, Basheer's Neelavelicham, translated as The Blue Light, which I first read as a Katha translation, and have been looking for ever since. I'm glad I have it in print now. Though the anthology has much less poetry than I thought it would, the Jeet Thayil poem is a masterwork, demanding to be read over and over again so you understand all its secrets and sidesteps. This whole book is worth buying just for that one page poem.
It's only about 300 or so pages, this anthology, but it feels like a lot more, and by the time you're done, you've been to a world and back. That's what any literature of place aims to do, and that's what this book achieves gloriously. Next time you are going to Kerala, take this book with you.