Finding a 'History of Somalia' in my local library was a great shock. It is already a great surprise to have such a book not just printed but even written. However, despite all those hopes, this is not a proper essay, but just a list of events that are not very well explained. I can understand the lack of sources for the pre-colonial time, even if the definition of what a Somali or what a clan is (how clans identify themselves or others, for instance), results quite shallow.
I felt like reading a long Wikipedia entry, with no interpretations, not even quoting journalistic sources and dramatically no maps (yes, no maps: only 3 maps at the end of the sections where they should be useful). As an example, I am sure there may be papers and books, and long reports on specialised media, about al Shabab, and reading this book it seems that there is just a group of thieves who occasionally kill people without any religious or ideological drive. Why al Shabab even exist in a mostly Muslim country? As a reaction to the times of Barre? Just for the vicinity of the Arabian peninsula? There can't be answers if there are no questions.
I can't exaggerate and say that I knew more about Somalia before reading the book than now, but certainly, I have now more basic questions than answers. This work seems a long PhD thesis that was transformed into a book with minimal changes, and I am somehow disappointed. However, I trust the author will manage to produce really interesting, analytical books on the topic, as he goes up the university ladder.