What do you think?
Rate this book
Moonstruck #1
Draw Down the Moon
New York Times bestsellers P.C. Cast and Kristin Cast return with a new duology set in a dark and magickal world filled with incredible danger and irresistible romance.
Wren Nightingale isn't supposed to have any powers. Born of magickal parents but not under a moon sign, she was destined for life as a Mundane—right up until she starts glowing on her eighteenth birthday. In a heartbeat, Wren's life is turned upside down, and she's suddenly leaving her home for the mystical Academia de la Luna—a secret magickal school on a hidden island off the Seattle coast.
Lee Young has always known about his future at the Academia. He has one goal: pass the trials, impress the Moon Council, and uphold his family's reputation. But he wasn't expecting to be attending alongside the girl he's been secretly in love with for as long as he can remember.
As Wren and Lee are thrown into the Academie's gruelling trials, they quickly learn there's something different--and dangerous--about the school this year. Wren will have to navigate a web of secrets, prophecies--and murder. And Lee will have to decide who to protect--his family's legacy, or the girl he loves.
Wren Nightingale isn't supposed to have any powers. Born of magickal parents but not under a moon sign, she was destined for life as a Mundane—right up until she starts glowing on her eighteenth birthday. In a heartbeat, Wren's life is turned upside down, and she's suddenly leaving her home for the mystical Academia de la Luna—a secret magickal school on a hidden island off the Seattle coast.
Lee Young has always known about his future at the Academia. He has one goal: pass the trials, impress the Moon Council, and uphold his family's reputation. But he wasn't expecting to be attending alongside the girl he's been secretly in love with for as long as he can remember.
As Wren and Lee are thrown into the Academie's gruelling trials, they quickly learn there's something different--and dangerous--about the school this year. Wren will have to navigate a web of secrets, prophecies--and murder. And Lee will have to decide who to protect--his family's legacy, or the girl he loves.
326 pages, Hardcover
First published April 2, 2024
249 people are currently reading
30354 people want to read
About the author
P.C. Cast
163 books28.2k followersPC was born in the Midwest, and grew up being shuttled back-and-forth between Illinois and Oklahoma, which is where she fell in love with Quarter Horses and mythology (at about the same time). After high school, she joined the United States Air Force and began public speaking and writing. After her tour in the USAF, she taught high school for 15 years before retiring to write full time. PC is a #1 New York Times and #1 USA Today Best-Selling author and a member of the Oklahoma Writers Hall of Fame. Her novels have been awarded the prestigious: Oklahoma Book Award, YALSA Quick Pick for Reluctant Readers, Romantic Times Reviewers’ Choice Award, the Prism, Holt Medallion, Daphne du Maurier, Booksellers’ Best, and the Laurel Wreath. PC is an experienced teacher and talented speaker. Ms. Cast lives in Oregon near her fabulous daughter, her adorable pack of dogs, her crazy Maine Coon, and a bunch of horses. House of Night Other World, book 4, FOUND, releases July 7th, 2020. More info to come soon about the HoN TV series!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 670 reviews
August 25, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for this arc in exchange for my review! (The audiobook voices were spot on 💕)
⤷ Some quotes may be different!
4/5 stars for Draw Down the Moon
✨ Female MC: Wren 🌙
Wren Nightingale isn't supposed to have any powers. Born of magickal parents but not under a moon sign, she was destined for life as a Mundane—right up until she starts glowing on her eighteenth birthday. In a heartbeat, Wren's life is turned upside down, and she's suddenly leaving her home for the mystical Academia de la Luna—a secret magickal school on a hidden island off the Seattle coast.
Wren is such a relatable girl boss that I just want to give a big hug to. She is so scared of change even if it’s what she wants and thinks if she hides her emotions, the feelings will go away. Wren is such a well written character who I immediately fell in love with.
“Wishing for something you can never have is a waste of time”
✨ Male MC: Lee 🌙
Lee Young has always known about his future at the Academia. He has one goal: pass the trials, impress the Moon Council, and uphold his family's reputation. But he wasn't expecting to be attending alongside the girl he's been secretly in love with for as long as he can remember.
Boy do I have a lot to say about Lee…
First off, he fell so hard. Like he even admitted it. He writes poetry about her. Two words, GREEN FLAG. Where can I find a man like this? I love his snarky retorts, he’s so supportive and JUST SO CUTE… ahem
Lee is torn between a make belief dream of making his parents proud by acting like his sister and saving and helping Wren. The way his emotions are written is so authentic and relatable. You really feel for him, trying to be the perfect child and impress his parents. How he cares about his appearance even when he doesn’t want to. How he tries to be something he’s not.
“If she’s not magical, I don’t know who is”
-> Lee is also Aquarius too!! I’d also be a healer, but I wasn’t born on a full moon (yes, I checked hehe)
✨ Plot 🌙
As Wren and Lee are thrown into the Academie's gruelling trials, they quickly learn there's something different--and dangerous--about the school this year. Wren will have to navigate a web of secrets, prophecies--and murder. And Lee will have to decide who to protect--his family's legacy, or the girl he loves.
I love books that set in (magical) schools and learning about the way things are and I really enjoyed entering this magical world, especially because its set in present times with magical elements, which I wasn’t expecting, but absolutely love. You can relate more and you aren’t overloaded with a completely new world. There was even a ruPaul reference 😭😂
"Shall I remind you of the time you thought Ryan Gosling was cute?"
"No. Never. I will never go back."
I love multiple perspectives, although sometimes I got confused and I loved how we got straight into the action. Sometimes the dialogue was confusing and I couldn’t always picture how some of the characters looked. Sometimes I felt like information was missing. (This is mainly why I gave it 4 stars).
I was honestly expecting full on fantasy, but I loved how there was also a hint mystery and adventure.
✨ Wren + Lee 🌙
YALL THIS RELATIONSHIP>>>
Them liking each other is so cute and the way they describe each other AHHHH the whole time your like "JUST TELL EACH OTHER ALREADY!"
"Lee belongs with you, I’ve been waiting for you two to realize you’re more than friends for years"
I love the way you get both perspectives of how they feel about each other.
“Wren you’re my best friend, I could never think you were useless”
“I’m always ok, as long as I’m with you”
The way they weren’t telling each other and thinking the other didn’t like them like that AHHHHHH THE STRESS I FELT 😭
"We’re just friends, the sooner I see that, the better"
NO LEE 😭😭
Their friendship is so cute. They have their own inside jokes and you feel like you’re intruding on something and the way Lee lets his walls fall around Wren is so cute and sad and I love them so much 😭
“Lee, you scared the crap out of me"
“Lies, I see no poo”
✨ Ending 🌙
Y’ALL WHY IS IT A CLIFFHANGER
"Instead I’m here. two peoples blood sticky on my hands, another piece of my heart missing”
✨ Overall 🌙
This book was truly magical. The characters were spot on, the plot was enticing and adventurous and this is definitely one of my new favorites.
Read this for a cute, fun and easy fantasy with a touch of mystery and lots of adventure
Also… THE COVER IS GORGEOUS 💗
✨ 4 golden stars ✨
my review of book two: Give Up the Night ✨
✩₊˚.⋆☾⋆⁺₊✧
pre-read pt 1
this cover is so pretty 🥹✋
just got the arc approved, so excited! 🫶
April 16, 2024
1.0 Star
Thank you NetGalley and MacMillan Audio | Macmillan Young Listeners for the arc in exchange for an honest review!
Thoughts:
Draw Down the Moon felt like it was trying too hard to be Harry Potter with a splash of Divergent and Hunger Games in cursive with zodiac throw-ins.
I really really really wanted to like this one, but sadly this was a case of ‘it’s the book and not me’. (I honestly considered dnf-ing, but I stuck through it when I shouldn’t have.) After recently reading ‘Marked (House of Night, #1)’ by the same authors, the parallels between the two are uncanny.
This is a YA read, however, if I had to categorize it, then middle school read would be more suitable. Even with their ages, our characters acted very child-like and juvenile. My biggest pet peeve is too many unnecessary pop culture references and modern slang, and this book did exactly that. Not in an ironic and HAHA way either at times. *rubs temples*
After 336 pages or 10 hours of listening…. nothing really happened. The ending was rushed. The climax to the cliffhanger is laughable. We are missing so much background information and solid worldbuilding. The main trope is Friends to Lovers, and by the end of it I wasn’t even rooting for them.
I wish I could say that I was more disappointed than mad, but after reading the summary, I was so hopeful that now I am upset. I don’t have the energy to even anticipate what is coming for the characters in book two of this duology. It’s going to be a no from me.
Paperback/Hardcover/Audiobook/E-book:
Audiobook
Pace:
Slow to fast to slow to fast
Cover thoughts:
This cover is beautiful! The best cover of any other PC Cast or Kristin Cast books!
POV: (single or multi)
Multi - Wren Nightingale and Lee Young
Triggers:
Death, Violence, Blood, Bullying, Grief, etc.
________________________
preread 🤗 I got the arc! 🌙
Thank you NetGalley and MacMillan Audio | Macmillan Young Listeners for the arc in exchange for an honest review!
Thoughts:
Draw Down the Moon felt like it was trying too hard to be Harry Potter with a splash of Divergent and Hunger Games in cursive with zodiac throw-ins.
I really really really wanted to like this one, but sadly this was a case of ‘it’s the book and not me’. (I honestly considered dnf-ing, but I stuck through it when I shouldn’t have.) After recently reading ‘Marked (House of Night, #1)’ by the same authors, the parallels between the two are uncanny.
This is a YA read, however, if I had to categorize it, then middle school read would be more suitable. Even with their ages, our characters acted very child-like and juvenile. My biggest pet peeve is too many unnecessary pop culture references and modern slang, and this book did exactly that. Not in an ironic and HAHA way either at times. *rubs temples*
After 336 pages or 10 hours of listening…. nothing really happened. The ending was rushed. The climax to the cliffhanger is laughable. We are missing so much background information and solid worldbuilding. The main trope is Friends to Lovers, and by the end of it I wasn’t even rooting for them.
I wish I could say that I was more disappointed than mad, but after reading the summary, I was so hopeful that now I am upset. I don’t have the energy to even anticipate what is coming for the characters in book two of this duology. It’s going to be a no from me.
Paperback/Hardcover/Audiobook/E-book:
Audiobook
Pace:
Slow to fast to slow to fast
Cover thoughts:
This cover is beautiful! The best cover of any other PC Cast or Kristin Cast books!
POV: (single or multi)
Multi - Wren Nightingale and Lee Young
Triggers:
Death, Violence, Blood, Bullying, Grief, etc.
________________________
preread 🤗 I got the arc! 🌙
November 12, 2023
In "Draw Down the Moon," we're whisked away into a world teeming with enchantment and danger, as two seemingly ordinary youths, Wren Nightingale and Lee Young, embark on a spellbinding adventure. A tale filled with magic and mystery, it offers a fresh and captivating twist on the classic young adult fantasy genre.
Wren, our young heroine, has led her life believing she had no magical powers. However, on her eighteenth birthday, everything changes. Her radiant glow marks her as a "Moonstruck" and sets her on an unexpected journey to the Academia de la Luna, a clandestine magical school hidden away on a secluded island near Seattle.
Her childhood friend, Lee, has always been aware of his magical heritage, striving to carry on his family's legacy by succeeding in the trials and earning a place on the Moon Council. But he didn't anticipate attending the academy alongside the girl he's been secretly in love with for as long as he can remember.
As the two delve into the Academia's grueling trials, they uncover a school year brimming with secrets and shadows. Wren becomes embroiled in a complex web of prophecies, murder, and dangerous mysteries that put her life at risk. In the midst of it all, Lee faces a difficult choice between upholding his family's reputation and protecting the girl he loves.
What makes this book a must-read is its unique magical world. The infusion of various elements and zodiac signs, along with the intriguing magical school setting, makes for a riveting experience. The romance, typical for a young adult novel, adds sweetness to the tale while not overshadowing its enthralling plot.
However, it's important to remember that "Draw Down the Moon" is just the beginning of this captivating journey. The intricate world-building and magical school setting lay a solid foundation for what promises to be an engaging duology.
P.C. Cast and Kristin Cast, renowned for their "House of Night" series, deliver a compelling narrative that embraces the themes of destiny, friendship, love, and sacrifice. This book is perfect for readers transitioning from middle grade to young adult fiction, offering a delightful blend of magic, mystery, and budding romance.
While the story follows a familiar trope of young love and coming-of-age adventures, it doesn't fail to provide a captivating, enjoyable read. The promise of an equally gripping sequel is something readers can look forward to.
So, if you're ready for a bewitching tale of magic and young love, "Draw Down the Moon" should be on your reading list. Get lost in this enchanting world and look forward to the concluding chapter of this compelling duology.
Huge thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press/ Wednesday Books for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest opinions.
medium.com
instagram
facebook
twitter
Wren, our young heroine, has led her life believing she had no magical powers. However, on her eighteenth birthday, everything changes. Her radiant glow marks her as a "Moonstruck" and sets her on an unexpected journey to the Academia de la Luna, a clandestine magical school hidden away on a secluded island near Seattle.
Her childhood friend, Lee, has always been aware of his magical heritage, striving to carry on his family's legacy by succeeding in the trials and earning a place on the Moon Council. But he didn't anticipate attending the academy alongside the girl he's been secretly in love with for as long as he can remember.
As the two delve into the Academia's grueling trials, they uncover a school year brimming with secrets and shadows. Wren becomes embroiled in a complex web of prophecies, murder, and dangerous mysteries that put her life at risk. In the midst of it all, Lee faces a difficult choice between upholding his family's reputation and protecting the girl he loves.
What makes this book a must-read is its unique magical world. The infusion of various elements and zodiac signs, along with the intriguing magical school setting, makes for a riveting experience. The romance, typical for a young adult novel, adds sweetness to the tale while not overshadowing its enthralling plot.
However, it's important to remember that "Draw Down the Moon" is just the beginning of this captivating journey. The intricate world-building and magical school setting lay a solid foundation for what promises to be an engaging duology.
P.C. Cast and Kristin Cast, renowned for their "House of Night" series, deliver a compelling narrative that embraces the themes of destiny, friendship, love, and sacrifice. This book is perfect for readers transitioning from middle grade to young adult fiction, offering a delightful blend of magic, mystery, and budding romance.
While the story follows a familiar trope of young love and coming-of-age adventures, it doesn't fail to provide a captivating, enjoyable read. The promise of an equally gripping sequel is something readers can look forward to.
So, if you're ready for a bewitching tale of magic and young love, "Draw Down the Moon" should be on your reading list. Get lost in this enchanting world and look forward to the concluding chapter of this compelling duology.
Huge thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press/ Wednesday Books for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest opinions.
medium.com
big-fat-dnf
May 6, 2024꒰ 𖦹 ⊹˚. pre-read.
⤿ 06 / 05 / 2024.
iso, the people scream, why would you read this when the average rating is... less than optimal? won't you just end up hating it and going like "why would i ever read this?" the answer is i am a human. and humans like pretty things. such as this book cover. case in point: i only have myself to blame for my misfortune (｡◝‿◜｡)
⤿ 06 / 05 / 2024.
iso, the people scream, why would you read this when the average rating is... less than optimal? won't you just end up hating it and going like "why would i ever read this?" the answer is i am a human. and humans like pretty things. such as this book cover. case in point: i only have myself to blame for my misfortune (｡◝‿◜｡)
January 17, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley and St Martin's Press for this arc in exchange for an honest review!
2.5 stars
This book perfectly highlights the disparity that now exists in the young adult genre. This was so juvenile compared to other YA books and it's such a shame. PC and Kristin Cast always have really interesting and magical stories to tell, but they always emphasize the Young in Young Adult.
The characters in this book are 18, which is certainly young adult, but there are so many books with the same criteria where it doesn't feel like you're actually reading about high schoolers.
I think there needs to be some discussions about how to categorize books nowadays. This is really, in a lot of ways, more suited to middle school level even though they're 18. Some of the language and scenes could be described as more adult, but that's what makes this book feel all over the place.
2.5 stars
This book perfectly highlights the disparity that now exists in the young adult genre. This was so juvenile compared to other YA books and it's such a shame. PC and Kristin Cast always have really interesting and magical stories to tell, but they always emphasize the Young in Young Adult.
The characters in this book are 18, which is certainly young adult, but there are so many books with the same criteria where it doesn't feel like you're actually reading about high schoolers.
I think there needs to be some discussions about how to categorize books nowadays. This is really, in a lot of ways, more suited to middle school level even though they're 18. Some of the language and scenes could be described as more adult, but that's what makes this book feel all over the place.
November 5, 2023
Despite the main characters being eighteen, this reads for a younger audience.
I enjoyed the setting, a magical school, where powers are based on the moon. It is a fun and easy magic system to grasp, which makes it a suitable starter fantasy for young teens. It has a whimsical element to it, set on a magical island hidden from mundanes.
I really struggled with the writing style. It reads like a middle-grade or even chapter book with a "quirky" sense of humor. The overuse of parentheses, ellipses, and exclamations point made it hard for me to think of this as YA. The sense of humor was also really bad. Our two characters have graduated high school, yet they talk and joke like my friends and I did at twelve years old. There was a lack of maturity and depth that I was expecting.
The plot line added nothing new to the YA genre. A seemingly normal girl who ends up being a "chosen one" has been around for ages. Thankfully, the characters avoided being Mary Sue, but just barely.
I read and enjoy both middle grade and YA, so it was easy for me to note that, if this book had been marketed for a younger audience, I would have gone in with a different mindset. Alas, I was expecting something with a little more depth and uniqueness. This isn't a bad book; it's great for those trying out fantasy, or YA novels. I would recommend this to younger readers. If you are already a firm lover of either genre, I'd skip this one. You won't find anything new or stand out here.
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press Wednesday Books for the advance copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
I enjoyed the setting, a magical school, where powers are based on the moon. It is a fun and easy magic system to grasp, which makes it a suitable starter fantasy for young teens. It has a whimsical element to it, set on a magical island hidden from mundanes.
I really struggled with the writing style. It reads like a middle-grade or even chapter book with a "quirky" sense of humor. The overuse of parentheses, ellipses, and exclamations point made it hard for me to think of this as YA. The sense of humor was also really bad. Our two characters have graduated high school, yet they talk and joke like my friends and I did at twelve years old. There was a lack of maturity and depth that I was expecting.
The plot line added nothing new to the YA genre. A seemingly normal girl who ends up being a "chosen one" has been around for ages. Thankfully, the characters avoided being Mary Sue, but just barely.
I read and enjoy both middle grade and YA, so it was easy for me to note that, if this book had been marketed for a younger audience, I would have gone in with a different mindset. Alas, I was expecting something with a little more depth and uniqueness. This isn't a bad book; it's great for those trying out fantasy, or YA novels. I would recommend this to younger readers. If you are already a firm lover of either genre, I'd skip this one. You won't find anything new or stand out here.
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press Wednesday Books for the advance copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
Want to read
April 19, 2024IM SORRY DNF FOR NOW, I JUST GOT MY HANDS ON ONE DARK WINDOW.
July 4, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley, Wednesday Books, and St. Martin's Press for this advanced copy. You can pick up Draw Down the Moon on April 2, 2024.
What a book. I won't lie to you -- I'm glad I stuck with it purely because of the number of times I cackled while reading this. Would I recommend it to anyone??? Loaded question. Depends on what you're looking for in a YA fantasy.
If you're looking for an interesting premise with zodiac signs and moon magic, you've come to the right place. If you're looking for quality writing, actual character arcs, and a plot that's more interesting than just "the chosen one," I'd look elsewhere.
I wish I were joking, but my Goodreads updates about this book said it all. Not only was "chosen one" but in Spanish an actual plot point, so was the concept of virginal magic, Hunger Games-esque Trials, and the MCs saying "I love you" on page 157.
I've also NEVER encountered a book where I didn't like the found family. AND YET, this found family grated on me so much because it felt forced? Not found? Is forced family a thing? It felt less like things happened in the book to make me enjoy these characters together, and more like I was being TOLD I would like these characters together.
I felt no attachment to any single character, despite the dual POVs giving me a look inside both love interests' heads. The friends-to-lovers trope was as poorly done as I've ever seen it, and neither character felt different from the beginning of the story to the end of the story.
Don't even get me started on the ending. Maybe I rushed through reading it, but the final "battle," made no sense, the MMC made weird decisions that confused me AND the FMC, and we have zero explanation for any of what happened all in the name of leaving things off with a "cliffhanger." Safe to say we've plunged fully over the cliff at this point and need a rescue crew to help us figure out what the fuck is going on.
I'll end this rant/review by touching on the writing style and why it wasn't for me, personally. Now, I was a YA girlie in the 2010s. I know the deep lore. And while some books try to touch on the nostalgia from that day and age (cough Fourth Wing cough), other books completely transport us back a decade to some truly heinous writing choices.
Tell me this character with "aquamarine eyes" and "porcelain skin" who smells like "sugar cookies" isn't the epitome of a 2010s pick me. She's so quirky, she pours dish soap in public fountains for fun on her birthday! And she's so small! I could pull out a dozen other examples to show why this writing definitely seems to cater to a younger YA crowd.
But the cover's pretty! And the premise has potential, even if it was poorly executed, in my opinion. Pick it up if you feel like seeing all this for yourself!
What a book. I won't lie to you -- I'm glad I stuck with it purely because of the number of times I cackled while reading this. Would I recommend it to anyone??? Loaded question. Depends on what you're looking for in a YA fantasy.
If you're looking for an interesting premise with zodiac signs and moon magic, you've come to the right place. If you're looking for quality writing, actual character arcs, and a plot that's more interesting than just "the chosen one," I'd look elsewhere.
I wish I were joking, but my Goodreads updates about this book said it all. Not only was "chosen one" but in Spanish an actual plot point, so was the concept of virginal magic, Hunger Games-esque Trials, and the MCs saying "I love you" on page 157.
I've also NEVER encountered a book where I didn't like the found family. AND YET, this found family grated on me so much because it felt forced? Not found? Is forced family a thing? It felt less like things happened in the book to make me enjoy these characters together, and more like I was being TOLD I would like these characters together.
I felt no attachment to any single character, despite the dual POVs giving me a look inside both love interests' heads. The friends-to-lovers trope was as poorly done as I've ever seen it, and neither character felt different from the beginning of the story to the end of the story.
Don't even get me started on the ending. Maybe I rushed through reading it, but the final "battle," made no sense, the MMC made weird decisions that confused me AND the FMC, and we have zero explanation for any of what happened all in the name of leaving things off with a "cliffhanger." Safe to say we've plunged fully over the cliff at this point and need a rescue crew to help us figure out what the fuck is going on.
I'll end this rant/review by touching on the writing style and why it wasn't for me, personally. Now, I was a YA girlie in the 2010s. I know the deep lore. And while some books try to touch on the nostalgia from that day and age (cough Fourth Wing cough), other books completely transport us back a decade to some truly heinous writing choices.
Tell me this character with "aquamarine eyes" and "porcelain skin" who smells like "sugar cookies" isn't the epitome of a 2010s pick me. She's so quirky, she pours dish soap in public fountains for fun on her birthday! And she's so small! I could pull out a dozen other examples to show why this writing definitely seems to cater to a younger YA crowd.
But the cover's pretty! And the premise has potential, even if it was poorly executed, in my opinion. Pick it up if you feel like seeing all this for yourself!
January 12, 2024
P.C. Cast and Kristin Cast's 'Draw Down the Moon' embarks on an enchanting journey into a world where magic intertwines with destiny and love. Set in the mystical Academia de la Luna, the novel introduces us to Wren Nightingale and Lee Young, two young adults whose lives are irrevocably changed by the powers of the moon and the secrets of their past.
The premise of 'Draw Down the Moon' is intriguing—a magical school hidden on an island, where powers are bestowed based on the lunar calendar. Wren's unexpected transformation into a Moonstruck on her eighteenth birthday catapults her into this enigmatic world, far from the mundane life she believed was her destiny. Lee, on the other hand, is a character forged from the expectations of legacy and tradition, his path seemingly predetermined.
The magical school setting is both whimsical and captivating, offering readers an escape into a world where the impossible feels tangible. The moon-based magic system is straightforward yet alluring, providing a fresh perspective on magical abilities and their origins.
However, the novel seems to straddle the line between middle-grade and young adult fiction. Despite its protagonists being eighteen, the narrative voice and style lean towards a younger audience. The humor and dialogue often feel more suited to early teens, which might disconnect readers expecting a more mature YA tone. This disparity in writing style and target audience creates a mismatch in expectations.
The plot, while enchanting, treads familiar ground in the YA fantasy genre. Wren’s 'chosen one' storyline echoes themes we’ve seen before, though the Casts manage to avoid veering into cliché territory. Lee’s struggle between duty and desire adds depth to his character, creating a compelling narrative arc.
'Draw Down the Moon' is best suited for readers new to the fantasy genre or younger YA audiences. For seasoned fans, like myself, the novel might lack the complexity and depth they seek. However, the book shines as an entry point into the world of fantasy, offering a gentle introduction to magical lore and young romance.
Thank you to St Martin’s Press and Wednesday Books for the ARC.
The premise of 'Draw Down the Moon' is intriguing—a magical school hidden on an island, where powers are bestowed based on the lunar calendar. Wren's unexpected transformation into a Moonstruck on her eighteenth birthday catapults her into this enigmatic world, far from the mundane life she believed was her destiny. Lee, on the other hand, is a character forged from the expectations of legacy and tradition, his path seemingly predetermined.
The magical school setting is both whimsical and captivating, offering readers an escape into a world where the impossible feels tangible. The moon-based magic system is straightforward yet alluring, providing a fresh perspective on magical abilities and their origins.
However, the novel seems to straddle the line between middle-grade and young adult fiction. Despite its protagonists being eighteen, the narrative voice and style lean towards a younger audience. The humor and dialogue often feel more suited to early teens, which might disconnect readers expecting a more mature YA tone. This disparity in writing style and target audience creates a mismatch in expectations.
The plot, while enchanting, treads familiar ground in the YA fantasy genre. Wren’s 'chosen one' storyline echoes themes we’ve seen before, though the Casts manage to avoid veering into cliché territory. Lee’s struggle between duty and desire adds depth to his character, creating a compelling narrative arc.
'Draw Down the Moon' is best suited for readers new to the fantasy genre or younger YA audiences. For seasoned fans, like myself, the novel might lack the complexity and depth they seek. However, the book shines as an entry point into the world of fantasy, offering a gentle introduction to magical lore and young romance.
Thank you to St Martin’s Press and Wednesday Books for the ARC.
July 17, 2024
When I saw the cover and heard the premise of Draw Down the Moon, I was excited to give it a go. However, the authors have a reputation for their early-2010's writing style, so I was a little nervous. Still, I thought maybe their writing would have matured by now. Unfortunately, it has not.
At face value, the premise of Draw Down the Moon is interesting. A girl discovers she has powers drawn from the moon and goes to a school to train and take place in "deadly" trials. She meets other students with powers derived from their astrological sign, and a fanatical plot ensues. Unfortunately, in reality, this premise didn't end up being as unique as I'd have liked, and the majority of this book just felt like a Harry Potter knockoff. I mean, on her birthday a girl discovers she has magic. She then goes to a school divided into four houses to improve her magic. She meets a bully on her first day, but luckily also unites with her two best friends. She then realizes she is the chosen one, and some weird stuff is going on at school. Not all the professors can be trusted, but with the help of her bookworm best friend who is always studying and memorizing knowledge, she'll get to the bottom of things ...
In addition to the utter lack of originality, as I mentioned, I hated this book's writing style. Even though the characters are all 18+, this reads like middle grade. All the characters are incredibly shallow, yet overly quirky. The main character and her best friend/love interest are always pretending they're in Bridgeton and saying "Milday". We're introduced to the main character's bookworm friend by seeing her walking down the street loudly singing a song from Beauty and the Beast for no particular reason. It's just too much quirk. In addition to the weak characters, the pacing and exposition are wretched. The exposition is delivered incredibly bluntly, and the pacing is nonsensical. The main character doesn't arrive to school until the 25% mark. Then like half the plot happens in two days. Then 3 weeks are told to have passed at the beginning of a chapter. And not to mention that there are no scenes of the main character actually learning to use her magic. She arrives at school and is told the trials will help her perfect her magic, but the professors never explain how to use it. They just present the students with problems and ask them to use their magic to solve them. Truly, I have no idea how this magic system works. So while this book had a decent premise, I simply couldn't get past the writing to actually immerse myself in the world.
Thank you to the publisher for the eARC in exchange for an honest review!
At face value, the premise of Draw Down the Moon is interesting. A girl discovers she has powers drawn from the moon and goes to a school to train and take place in "deadly" trials. She meets other students with powers derived from their astrological sign, and a fanatical plot ensues. Unfortunately, in reality, this premise didn't end up being as unique as I'd have liked, and the majority of this book just felt like a Harry Potter knockoff. I mean, on her birthday a girl discovers she has magic. She then goes to a school divided into four houses to improve her magic. She meets a bully on her first day, but luckily also unites with her two best friends. She then realizes she is the chosen one, and some weird stuff is going on at school. Not all the professors can be trusted, but with the help of her bookworm best friend who is always studying and memorizing knowledge, she'll get to the bottom of things ...
In addition to the utter lack of originality, as I mentioned, I hated this book's writing style. Even though the characters are all 18+, this reads like middle grade. All the characters are incredibly shallow, yet overly quirky. The main character and her best friend/love interest are always pretending they're in Bridgeton and saying "Milday". We're introduced to the main character's bookworm friend by seeing her walking down the street loudly singing a song from Beauty and the Beast for no particular reason. It's just too much quirk. In addition to the weak characters, the pacing and exposition are wretched. The exposition is delivered incredibly bluntly, and the pacing is nonsensical. The main character doesn't arrive to school until the 25% mark. Then like half the plot happens in two days. Then 3 weeks are told to have passed at the beginning of a chapter. And not to mention that there are no scenes of the main character actually learning to use her magic. She arrives at school and is told the trials will help her perfect her magic, but the professors never explain how to use it. They just present the students with problems and ask them to use their magic to solve them. Truly, I have no idea how this magic system works. So while this book had a decent premise, I simply couldn't get past the writing to actually immerse myself in the world.
Thank you to the publisher for the eARC in exchange for an honest review!
April 8, 2024
In this first of a Young Adult duology, the authors have done a lovely job of creating a contemporary world that holds both "mundane" (humans) and supernatural witches living side by side but without the humans having any cognizance of magic. Wren (FMC) is one of the rare few because she was born into a magical family but without any magic, herself. That is until her eighteenth birthday when everything changes dramatically. Suddenly she is shipped off to a secret academy to learn the extent of her powers, along with all other magic-holding teenagers.
The premise, while nothing terribly unique, is engaging and the characters are compelling. There is just one single problem - but that problem affects the entire reading experience: The characters read MUCH younger than their stated 18 years old! If the premise was of 14 to 16 year old protagonists, the entire feel and enjoyment would have been substantially higher. As is, however, all of the inner dialogue, immature musings, reactions etc. throw the reader completely out of the story because it just doesn't fit with the age they are supposed to be.
SO... if the story were to be promoted to a middle school/tween age market, this story would absolutely be a five star read. Geared to an older YA or even a YA that adults might enjoy, it doesn't work well.
The premise, while nothing terribly unique, is engaging and the characters are compelling. There is just one single problem - but that problem affects the entire reading experience: The characters read MUCH younger than their stated 18 years old! If the premise was of 14 to 16 year old protagonists, the entire feel and enjoyment would have been substantially higher. As is, however, all of the inner dialogue, immature musings, reactions etc. throw the reader completely out of the story because it just doesn't fit with the age they are supposed to be.
SO... if the story were to be promoted to a middle school/tween age market, this story would absolutely be a five star read. Geared to an older YA or even a YA that adults might enjoy, it doesn't work well.
March 23, 2024
I adore P.C. And Kristin Cast. The House of Night Series was iconic of my teen/early adult years. This book isn’t bad, but it isn’t super entertaining either. That said though it is only the first book, and this book seems to be doing the ground work of the world building. I will definitely read the next and would say it’s worth reading! Also, this is YA and for the most part, it’s pretty heavy on the Y so keep that in mind.
April 28, 2024
So when I first started I was really confused by the low ratings.
I was entranced by the magic system and them going through the trials.
I enjoyed Ween figuring out her power and solving some mysteries.
However, by the end…I understood the rating. Wren and Lee for all that they proclaim to be they best of friends…don’t really communicate. It’s a lot of not giving each other grace or trust. It was exhausting to read by the end.
Loved the magic system. Disliked the relationship.
I was entranced by the magic system and them going through the trials.
I enjoyed Ween figuring out her power and solving some mysteries.
However, by the end…I understood the rating. Wren and Lee for all that they proclaim to be they best of friends…don’t really communicate. It’s a lot of not giving each other grace or trust. It was exhausting to read by the end.
Loved the magic system. Disliked the relationship.
March 26, 2024
Draw Down the Moon
By P.C. Cast & Kristin Cast
Moonstruck #1
YA Fantasy
NetGalley ARC
St. Martin's Press
Pub. Date: Apr. 2, 2024
Ages: 14+
Even though both of her parents were magickal, Wren wasn't born under a moon sign, so she was never gifted magick and was content with living a Mundane life taking over her uncles' bookshop when the time came.
While hanging out with her magickal best friend Lee, standing in the moonlight at the exact time she turned eighteen, she was moonstruck, and suddenly gifted with an unknown magick.
The future Wren had seen for herself was gone, and she was taken to a secret magickal school on an island off the Seattle coast with Lee by her side.
Starting off interesting, this story, while still good, became convenient. Her best friend was already going to the magick school, as was another one of her friends, and I could not help but compare this with the H.P. Books. The school is a castle, the kids are 'sorted' by their moon sign, there are 'ghosts', trials, etc.
I use the term kids because even though the characters are eighteen, they come across as much younger; fourteen through sixteen.
As to the magick system, it's creative, though not explained in depth. I get that Wren is the MC and it's her magick that's center, but to get the impact of her magick the others need to be explained better.
And on that note, the ending was rushed. I liked what happened but the execution was so lazy that I hated it, thus taking away a star. A hundred more words would've made it concrete, understandable, and believable.
Thankfully, while there is romance, it's not borderline unlike another of the authors' YA books, so it's suitable for readers 14+.
3 Stars
By P.C. Cast & Kristin Cast
Moonstruck #1
YA Fantasy
NetGalley ARC
St. Martin's Press
Pub. Date: Apr. 2, 2024
Ages: 14+
Even though both of her parents were magickal, Wren wasn't born under a moon sign, so she was never gifted magick and was content with living a Mundane life taking over her uncles' bookshop when the time came.
While hanging out with her magickal best friend Lee, standing in the moonlight at the exact time she turned eighteen, she was moonstruck, and suddenly gifted with an unknown magick.
The future Wren had seen for herself was gone, and she was taken to a secret magickal school on an island off the Seattle coast with Lee by her side.
Starting off interesting, this story, while still good, became convenient. Her best friend was already going to the magick school, as was another one of her friends, and I could not help but compare this with the H.P. Books. The school is a castle, the kids are 'sorted' by their moon sign, there are 'ghosts', trials, etc.
I use the term kids because even though the characters are eighteen, they come across as much younger; fourteen through sixteen.
As to the magick system, it's creative, though not explained in depth. I get that Wren is the MC and it's her magick that's center, but to get the impact of her magick the others need to be explained better.
And on that note, the ending was rushed. I liked what happened but the execution was so lazy that I hated it, thus taking away a star. A hundred more words would've made it concrete, understandable, and believable.
Thankfully, while there is romance, it's not borderline unlike another of the authors' YA books, so it's suitable for readers 14+.
3 Stars
September 4, 2024
I've conceded with the fact that this is a Harry Potter wannabe, even though I've tried my level best to deny it.
My problem(s) with the book rises not from this (—in fact, I wholeheartedly support anything creative and unique that does stem from the Harry Potter world), BUT with the way the story was presented and how incredibly flat the characters seemed to have been written, especially for their ages (18 🫢!!!). This is not the first time I've encountered this problem, and thus, I blindly put it aside and proceeded with reading.
Plot:
Albeit the story itself was not an extremely bad one, it lacked a few crucial ingredients, as it just meandered without any sort of purpose at all and was plainly covered by empty and predictable dialogues peppered with several pop culture references. Some may have had a good laugh at it - reading their dialogue, but well...I just couldn't take it in any longer, and ended up take a huge break away from it.
When I picked it up again - a few weeks later, it was due to the ease of reading and not being overloaded with intense fantasy world-building, that I skimmed through it quite quickly and finally ended it. So, decidedly that may have not been a bad thing at all.
While I was at it, I kind of ended up trying to match several events of this book (ups-and-downs included), with that of the first instalment of Harry Potter.😂 There were A LOT- like I mentioned earlier. NOTHING was comparable to that although- let me tell you and tbf, the action scenes were comical and ridiculous really. (No offense🤞)
↪️ Room of Requirement 🙈
↪️ Restricted section of the library (Nicholas Flamel...) 👀
↪️ WTH...Chosen one!??!? I'm not seeing things right?
Characters:
Wren: I've got to admit she had incredible potential to be a very unique character at the beginning, and I was curious of how this character would be developed further in the story, but was very, very disappointed. 😔
Lee: This guy was our typical male protagonist in regular YA novels, although some aspects of his personality were admittedly good and relatable (poetry!?😳), nothing was developed beyond this particular aspect in him. And— when there was actually some inkling of change and intrigue created withing this character, it was towards the end of the story. Unfortunately, this was too late for me.
The Wren+Lee relationship was cute, though its development was very, very cliché , or I've outgrown it, idk? — I don't think it's worth mentioning that much, anyways.
The side characters:
Tbh, they were as boring as everyone else in the story, to the point that I didn't even feel a thing when . Villains weren't even villainous or extremely hateable at all. Maybe they were the most decent characters of all of 'em? — NO.
So....what did I even like in this book? IDK. It was light-hearted? Easy? Quirky?
I doubt that I'd bother to even touch the sequel in this case, despite that cliff-hanger 👀. Sorry.
🅣🅗🅞🅤🅖🅗🅣🅢 🅦🅗🅘🅛🅔 🅡🅔🅐🅓🅘🅝🅖:
🌷This feels so eerily similar to Harry Potter...It gives me so very, very similar vibes. MC finds out she has magick powers and gets sent to a magic academy less than 24 hrs later? Um, hello?
🌷Hold on now... It still goes on: The academy is split into 4 houses based on the Zodiac Sign they are born under. Each house has a different power, and... guess what — the MC isn't like other girls since she was "Moonstruck" and she wasn't born under any of the 4 zodiac moons.
🌷Plus, the age of the characters is a tad bit underwhelming — I feel like it's geared more toward middle-grade & early YA readers, than older YA readers.
🌷Hope this book redeems itself... 🤞 I'm just going to pause reading for now.
🅟🅡🅔-🅡🅔🅐🅓:
Wish me luck! Am I going to read the book due to its absolutely gorgeous cover? YES.
My problem(s) with the book rises not from this (—in fact, I wholeheartedly support anything creative and unique that does stem from the Harry Potter world), BUT with the way the story was presented and how incredibly flat the characters seemed to have been written, especially for their ages (18 🫢!!!). This is not the first time I've encountered this problem, and thus, I blindly put it aside and proceeded with reading.
Plot:
Albeit the story itself was not an extremely bad one, it lacked a few crucial ingredients, as it just meandered without any sort of purpose at all and was plainly covered by empty and predictable dialogues peppered with several pop culture references. Some may have had a good laugh at it - reading their dialogue, but well...I just couldn't take it in any longer, and ended up take a huge break away from it.
When I picked it up again - a few weeks later, it was due to the ease of reading and not being overloaded with intense fantasy world-building, that I skimmed through it quite quickly and finally ended it. So, decidedly that may have not been a bad thing at all.
While I was at it, I kind of ended up trying to match several events of this book (ups-and-downs included), with that of the first instalment of Harry Potter.😂 There were A LOT- like I mentioned earlier. NOTHING was comparable to that although- let me tell you and tbf, the action scenes were comical and ridiculous really. (No offense🤞)
What is that?” I whisper to Sam.
“I know, right? The librarian with the dean is really cute.”
I give Sam’s shoulders a little shake and turn her to face me. “Not the librarian. Did you not see where they came from?”
Sam shrugs. “Yeah, from the wall behind—” Her eyes go big and round. “Holy crap! There’s a secret door behind the counter!”
↪️ Room of Requirement 🙈
Sam, what if there are more books inside whatever super secret room that door leads to? Restricted books.”
↪️ Restricted section of the library (Nicholas Flamel...) 👀
a lot of trouble to be sure the chosen one and the strength of a maiden are a dead end, so it’s not like they’d leave books explaining those phrases out here where anyone can read them.
↪️ WTH...Chosen one!??!? I'm not seeing things right?
Characters:
Wren: I've got to admit she had incredible potential to be a very unique character at the beginning, and I was curious of how this character would be developed further in the story, but was very, very disappointed. 😔
Lee: This guy was our typical male protagonist in regular YA novels, although some aspects of his personality were admittedly good and relatable (poetry!?😳), nothing was developed beyond this particular aspect in him. And— when there was actually some inkling of change and intrigue created withing this character, it was towards the end of the story. Unfortunately, this was too late for me.
The Wren+Lee relationship was cute, though its development was very, very cliché , or I've outgrown it, idk? — I don't think it's worth mentioning that much, anyways.
”Lee, I want you, I want us. I’ve missed you so much. I should have trusted you, I should’ve talk to you even if that meant i was gonna hear something that was gonna break my heart”
…
“We could never be nothing Wren, never. I love you”
“I love you Lee Young”
The side characters:
Tbh, they were as boring as everyone else in the story, to the point that I didn't even feel a thing when . Villains weren't even villainous or extremely hateable at all. Maybe they were the most decent characters of all of 'em? — NO.
So....what did I even like in this book? IDK. It was light-hearted? Easy? Quirky?
I doubt that I'd bother to even touch the sequel in this case, despite that cliff-hanger 👀. Sorry.
🅣🅗🅞🅤🅖🅗🅣🅢 🅦🅗🅘🅛🅔 🅡🅔🅐🅓🅘🅝🅖:
🌷This feels so eerily similar to Harry Potter...It gives me so very, very similar vibes. MC finds out she has magick powers and gets sent to a magic academy less than 24 hrs later? Um, hello?
🌷Hold on now... It still goes on: The academy is split into 4 houses based on the Zodiac Sign they are born under. Each house has a different power, and... guess what — the MC isn't like other girls since she was "Moonstruck" and she wasn't born under any of the 4 zodiac moons.
🌷Plus, the age of the characters is a tad bit underwhelming — I feel like it's geared more toward middle-grade & early YA readers, than older YA readers.
🌷Hope this book redeems itself... 🤞 I'm just going to pause reading for now.
🅟🅡🅔-🅡🅔🅐🅓:
Wish me luck! Am I going to read the book due to its absolutely gorgeous cover? YES.
March 14, 2024
Draw Down The Moon is one you won’t want to miss! I absolutely fell in love with the gorgeous cover and the premise of the book. I will always want to read anything that has a magic school in it, because it always sounds so fun to read about.
I really loved the characters throughout this story and the magic system as well. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this one and I’m certain that many other people will too, especially fans of young adult fantasy.
Thank you to the publisher for sending me a copy for an honest review.
I really loved the characters throughout this story and the magic system as well. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this one and I’m certain that many other people will too, especially fans of young adult fantasy.
Thank you to the publisher for sending me a copy for an honest review.
Read
April 16, 2024I’m too old for this
April 1, 2024
This is another book where I love the concept but I don't like the execution. The magic system was a bit confusing I wish we could have had a bit more information about it. The characters acted WAY younger than 18, it was more like a bunch of 13 year olds. The romance was not very consistent which made it really hard to get attached to the romance. This is very much a slow paced book, it takes a long time for things to move along plot wise since there was a lot of focus on building the scene. I did appreciate that the book ended on a cliff hanger, I just didn't like it.
Thank you Netgalley and the publishers for a copy of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review!
Thank you Netgalley and the publishers for a copy of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review!
dnf
July 8, 2025Yea....
I got 20% in and immediately knew this wasn't going to work. P.C. Cast and Kristin Cast are not for me at all.
I got 20% in and immediately knew this wasn't going to work. P.C. Cast and Kristin Cast are not for me at all.
September 2, 2024
3/5, really interseating, i def enjoyed it but i was also confused at the end lolol
July 4, 2024
★ ˖ ࣪ 2.5 stars ᳝ ꒷
. ݁₊ ⊹ wanted to love this one because of the beautiful cover but it was so disappointing. it would be a 2 star if my reading experience was terrible. it was my first time listening to an audiobook and it helped me so much getting through with this book as i had a hard time thinking if i should dnf it
what i liked about this book is ofc the magical school and i found the magic system quite unique, i fear that’s the only thing i liked about this book.
first of all, it tried so hard to be harry potter, obviously wasn’t expecting the similarities to be there (i should’ve) but it was so plainly obvious. most of the scenes happening was so cliche to me, i cringed in most parts
the writing was definitely not young adult as it is categorized, it read more like middle grade. i haven’t read middle grade, and i wouldn’t mind reading that genre however, all of the characters here are 18 and they acted like children. so yea the writing was definitely not for me.
overall, really disappointing considering how much i loved this cover and the concept of it, nothing happened for the majority of the book and the ending just made me so confused.
𖥦 ⪧ ◟ tropes:
𓄹 magical school
𓄹 friends to lovers
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁౨ৎ. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁ . ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁౨ৎ. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁ . ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁౨ৎ. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖
. ݁₊ ⊹ wanted to love this one because of the beautiful cover but it was so disappointing. it would be a 2 star if my reading experience was terrible. it was my first time listening to an audiobook and it helped me so much getting through with this book as i had a hard time thinking if i should dnf it
what i liked about this book is ofc the magical school and i found the magic system quite unique, i fear that’s the only thing i liked about this book.
first of all, it tried so hard to be harry potter, obviously wasn’t expecting the similarities to be there (i should’ve) but it was so plainly obvious. most of the scenes happening was so cliche to me, i cringed in most parts
the writing was definitely not young adult as it is categorized, it read more like middle grade. i haven’t read middle grade, and i wouldn’t mind reading that genre however, all of the characters here are 18 and they acted like children. so yea the writing was definitely not for me.
overall, really disappointing considering how much i loved this cover and the concept of it, nothing happened for the majority of the book and the ending just made me so confused.
𖥦 ⪧ ◟ tropes:
𓄹 magical school
𓄹 friends to lovers
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁౨ৎ. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁ . ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁౨ৎ. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁ . ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁౨ৎ. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖
May 13, 2024
I really enjoyed this. It reminded me a lot of the Harry Potter world but was still very different. The story line was great and it was a quick read.
April 1, 2024
I am disappointed to state that reading this book was not a pleasant experience. I think the writing was a little too juvenile for my liking. There were a lot of sentences and lines of dialogue that made me outwardly cringe. This brought me back to the worst parts of 2010s writing which is something that I don’t say lightly. That being said, I probably should’ve DNF’ed this book because I don’t have a lot of nice things to say about it.
I want to actually start with the buildup to the ending and the ending itself, and all I really have to say is “HUH???”. I am going to be SO honest, the ending had me so confused. Like I get that this is book is going to be part of a series and it needed a cliffhanger…just maybe I don’t know, have a better cliffhanger? The story is left off on confusing territory.
Working backwards a bit, I am so sorry but I did not like any of these characters. They were so flat and one-dimensional, literally in the first chapter Wren outlining her relationship to Lee in a repetitive manner was just unnecessary. Lee had a bit more nuance to his character as he had background with his sister passing away and that changing the structure of his family; therefore changing what he needed to accomplish for his family’s sake. I liked Lee, but what was this poor boy on during those last few chapters??? I don’t understand that change in mindset that I won’t spoil. I will say I really disliked Wren, she was incredibly childish and a lot, if not all, the miscommunication that occurred in this book was because of her. I hate the miscommunication trope with a passion especially when it’s done poorly like in this book.
The pacing of this book is slow, the flip flopping between perspectives got a bit annoying towards the end especially when Wren was finally having her moment. The romance was not…it. I personally wish I was a supporter of Wren and Lee but I find myself wishing they could just stay friends because they did not do it for me as lovers.
If this book had been published in 2016 when I was getting into reading, this would’ve been my bread and butter. However, it just fell flat for me but if you’re looking for a book that used zodiac in its magic system or a book about teenagers attending a magical school, this book is for you!
Thank you to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
I want to actually start with the buildup to the ending and the ending itself, and all I really have to say is “HUH???”. I am going to be SO honest, the ending had me so confused. Like I get that this is book is going to be part of a series and it needed a cliffhanger…just maybe I don’t know, have a better cliffhanger? The story is left off on confusing territory.
Working backwards a bit, I am so sorry but I did not like any of these characters. They were so flat and one-dimensional, literally in the first chapter Wren outlining her relationship to Lee in a repetitive manner was just unnecessary. Lee had a bit more nuance to his character as he had background with his sister passing away and that changing the structure of his family; therefore changing what he needed to accomplish for his family’s sake. I liked Lee, but what was this poor boy on during those last few chapters??? I don’t understand that change in mindset that I won’t spoil. I will say I really disliked Wren, she was incredibly childish and a lot, if not all, the miscommunication that occurred in this book was because of her. I hate the miscommunication trope with a passion especially when it’s done poorly like in this book.
The pacing of this book is slow, the flip flopping between perspectives got a bit annoying towards the end especially when Wren was finally having her moment. The romance was not…it. I personally wish I was a supporter of Wren and Lee but I find myself wishing they could just stay friends because they did not do it for me as lovers.
If this book had been published in 2016 when I was getting into reading, this would’ve been my bread and butter. However, it just fell flat for me but if you’re looking for a book that used zodiac in its magic system or a book about teenagers attending a magical school, this book is for you!
Thank you to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
July 9, 2024
*3.5 rounded up*
ARC provided by Publisher in exchange for an honest review.
I would like to thank St. Martin's Press, Wednesday Books and NetGalley for the copy of this eARC. P.C. Cast and the Marked series was a milestone for me as a reader and I followed those characters up until I went to college. I am still convinced I will go back and revist the House of Night to finish Zoey's story soon.
That being said, when I saw she was coming out with a new YA series I was intrigued. Its been almost 15 years since I first read a book from this author and I was so curious to see how her story telling has grown and if her world captured me as much as it did when I was a teen.
By 20% through I couldn't help but see the similarities between this book and the Marked series and it reminded me how great P.C. Cast is at crafting these magical academies and the students that belong in them. It felt like getting to reread one of my favorite series again for the first time, even though this world of magic is far different.
At time the world building did felt clunky or a bit too obvious with where some of the plot points were going, but it did not stop me from enjoying the book. It is for sure a YA book through and through, and I would've been curious to see how the story would've faired with an aged up cast. At the moment it felt like a "Zodiac Academy" but make it for teens with some of the bullying aspects and the mystery's going on around the school.
I'm excited to see where the story goes from here, but hope we get a little more character development from Zee, as his POV chapters often left me wanting. I think the book could have faired a bit better by being all in Wren's POV. And to be completely honest, Zee made me so angry at the end with him working to save Celeste. Communication is a big no for me trope wise and I couldn't help but think how much could've been solved if we had less secrecy between the main cast.
I would easily recommend this book to any teen walking into my store looking for a bit of dark academia fantasy, but wouldn't necessarily be my go-to suggestion for an adult audience.
ARC provided by Publisher in exchange for an honest review.
I would like to thank St. Martin's Press, Wednesday Books and NetGalley for the copy of this eARC. P.C. Cast and the Marked series was a milestone for me as a reader and I followed those characters up until I went to college. I am still convinced I will go back and revist the House of Night to finish Zoey's story soon.
That being said, when I saw she was coming out with a new YA series I was intrigued. Its been almost 15 years since I first read a book from this author and I was so curious to see how her story telling has grown and if her world captured me as much as it did when I was a teen.
By 20% through I couldn't help but see the similarities between this book and the Marked series and it reminded me how great P.C. Cast is at crafting these magical academies and the students that belong in them. It felt like getting to reread one of my favorite series again for the first time, even though this world of magic is far different.
At time the world building did felt clunky or a bit too obvious with where some of the plot points were going, but it did not stop me from enjoying the book. It is for sure a YA book through and through, and I would've been curious to see how the story would've faired with an aged up cast. At the moment it felt like a "Zodiac Academy" but make it for teens with some of the bullying aspects and the mystery's going on around the school.
I'm excited to see where the story goes from here, but hope we get a little more character development from Zee, as his POV chapters often left me wanting. I think the book could have faired a bit better by being all in Wren's POV. And to be completely honest, Zee made me so angry at the end with him working to save Celeste. Communication is a big no for me trope wise and I couldn't help but think how much could've been solved if we had less secrecy between the main cast.
I would easily recommend this book to any teen walking into my store looking for a bit of dark academia fantasy, but wouldn't necessarily be my go-to suggestion for an adult audience.
December 27, 2023
Read if you like:
- Lower YA books
- Magical and astrology world
- Ya romance
- Friends to lovers
- Magic school
I think this book was enjoyable, easy to read with a really cool magical world. This book is in two povs, the fmc Wren and her best friend Lee. In the beginning of the book Wren is a disappointed that she doesn't have magickal powers even although she is from a magickal family. On her 18th birthday she discovers some abilities and is enrolled into the magickal school with Lee who already had his powers. As she learns to wield her powers at the school she meets new friends that become family, learns more about spells and astrology and the world. She also discovers that there are many secrets in this school and works to find them out. I loved the atmospheric and astrological feel to the school. There's also a cute blossoming romance between Lee and Wren that I'm glad was in here. This book read younger even though the main character was 18, the characters actions and behaviors were very younger ya and at times it was a bit annoying. The ending though was very fast paced with a lot of action that left me wanting to read the next book. I would recommend this especially to lovers of ya books! Thank you Wednesday Books for this arc for an honest review.
3.5/5
- Lower YA books
- Magical and astrology world
- Ya romance
- Friends to lovers
- Magic school
I think this book was enjoyable, easy to read with a really cool magical world. This book is in two povs, the fmc Wren and her best friend Lee. In the beginning of the book Wren is a disappointed that she doesn't have magickal powers even although she is from a magickal family. On her 18th birthday she discovers some abilities and is enrolled into the magickal school with Lee who already had his powers. As she learns to wield her powers at the school she meets new friends that become family, learns more about spells and astrology and the world. She also discovers that there are many secrets in this school and works to find them out. I loved the atmospheric and astrological feel to the school. There's also a cute blossoming romance between Lee and Wren that I'm glad was in here. This book read younger even though the main character was 18, the characters actions and behaviors were very younger ya and at times it was a bit annoying. The ending though was very fast paced with a lot of action that left me wanting to read the next book. I would recommend this especially to lovers of ya books! Thank you Wednesday Books for this arc for an honest review.
3.5/5
April 21, 2024
This was an enjoyable story for the most part. However, I was under the impression this was suppose to be an Adult Fantasy. This is definitely a YA fantasy, with the characters having just turned 18 and the writing felt on the younger side of YA as well.
The dual POV did not enhance the story, I feel like writing this just from Wren’s POV would have been a lot more enjoyable.
However, I enjoyed the premise of the story and the idea of having certain kinds of magic based on the moon & your birth. I felt like Wren and Sam were both very likable characters, but I struggled to root for the relationship blossoming between Lee and Wren because of how insufferable I found his POV.
Overall, I would only recommend this book to someone who already enjoys YA Fantasy.
The dual POV did not enhance the story, I feel like writing this just from Wren’s POV would have been a lot more enjoyable.
However, I enjoyed the premise of the story and the idea of having certain kinds of magic based on the moon & your birth. I felt like Wren and Sam were both very likable characters, but I struggled to root for the relationship blossoming between Lee and Wren because of how insufferable I found his POV.
Overall, I would only recommend this book to someone who already enjoys YA Fantasy.
dnfs
August 21, 2024I'm so disappointed by this book. It had great potential to be 5 stars. I liked the concept but it failed to keep me interested or invested in the plot or the characters. I had zero interest in anything to do with the two main characters.
November 28, 2023
DNF @ 30%
When she turns eighteen, Wren’s discovers she is Moonstruck, and her plans for the future change so she can attend a magical academy.
While I always to my best to not DNF books, especially this early into them, I could not get through it. The premise is interesting, where one’s magic is determined by their moon sign, and the Academia is split into four zodiac houses (Leo, Taurus, Scorpio, and Aquarius), but the prose is what did me in.
This books reads more like a young teenager’s bad fanfiction, with childish inner monologue and cringey dialogue. (I can relate because my bad fanfiction at 15 sounded just like this.) The fact that our main characters are eighteen does not come across easily, as they often behave and speak like ten-year-olds.
I really wish I could have gotten through more of this book because it might have ended really well, but life is too short to read about adult people who sing “grace kelly is smelly”.
Thank you to NetGalley & Wednesday Books for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
When she turns eighteen, Wren’s discovers she is Moonstruck, and her plans for the future change so she can attend a magical academy.
While I always to my best to not DNF books, especially this early into them, I could not get through it. The premise is interesting, where one’s magic is determined by their moon sign, and the Academia is split into four zodiac houses (Leo, Taurus, Scorpio, and Aquarius), but the prose is what did me in.
This books reads more like a young teenager’s bad fanfiction, with childish inner monologue and cringey dialogue. (I can relate because my bad fanfiction at 15 sounded just like this.) The fact that our main characters are eighteen does not come across easily, as they often behave and speak like ten-year-olds.
I really wish I could have gotten through more of this book because it might have ended really well, but life is too short to read about adult people who sing “grace kelly is smelly”.
Thank you to NetGalley & Wednesday Books for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
March 30, 2024
♡ Audiobook Review ♡
♤ Release April 2 ♤
-
YA (Younger Ya)
Friends to Lover
Magic School
Black Male Character
-
Judging a book by its cover because this COVER is gorgeous!
This is book 1 in the Moonstruck duology.
This is YA but is more ages 10-14 years old YA, very middle school vibes. It has great potential to be an amazing book.
This book gave me Harry Potter-ish vibes with the way they sorted the kids until their hall. Also, it gave me a Goble of Fire with the trails.
The narrators, Ina Marie Smith and Jordan Barton, both did a great job bringing the characters and story to life.
Draw Down the Moon is set in a dark and magical world filled with incredible danger and irresistible romance. It's a mystical school. A mysterious death. A magickal romance.
Wren Nightingale is born of magical parents but not under one of the four fated astrological full moons. She was destined to live her life as a mundane, a person with no magical powers Up until her 18th birthday. Then we have Lee Young, who is Wren best friend. He has always known about his future at the school and the three goals he has set.
As Wren and Lee are thrown into the academy’s grueling trials, they quickly learn there’s something different—and dangerous—about the school this year. Wren will have to navigate a web of secrets, prophecies . . . and murder.
This book does leave on a cliffhanger, so be prepared for that!
-
♡ Thank you, Netgalley, and MacmillanAudio for the ALC for my honest opinion ♡
♤ Release April 2 ♤
-
YA (Younger Ya)
Friends to Lover
Magic School
Black Male Character
-
Judging a book by its cover because this COVER is gorgeous!
This is book 1 in the Moonstruck duology.
This is YA but is more ages 10-14 years old YA, very middle school vibes. It has great potential to be an amazing book.
This book gave me Harry Potter-ish vibes with the way they sorted the kids until their hall. Also, it gave me a Goble of Fire with the trails.
The narrators, Ina Marie Smith and Jordan Barton, both did a great job bringing the characters and story to life.
Draw Down the Moon is set in a dark and magical world filled with incredible danger and irresistible romance. It's a mystical school. A mysterious death. A magickal romance.
Wren Nightingale is born of magical parents but not under one of the four fated astrological full moons. She was destined to live her life as a mundane, a person with no magical powers Up until her 18th birthday. Then we have Lee Young, who is Wren best friend. He has always known about his future at the school and the three goals he has set.
As Wren and Lee are thrown into the academy’s grueling trials, they quickly learn there’s something different—and dangerous—about the school this year. Wren will have to navigate a web of secrets, prophecies . . . and murder.
This book does leave on a cliffhanger, so be prepared for that!
-
♡ Thank you, Netgalley, and MacmillanAudio for the ALC for my honest opinion ♡
May 4, 2024
I absolutely love the cover, and it drew me in immediately, but the book itself fell short. The writing style was extremely plain and flat, the characters were dull and one-dimensional, and the pacing was inconsistent. The insipid writing made all of the book's flaws stand out even more. The story and idea did have potential, though.
I won this book through Goodreads Giveaways. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
I won this book through Goodreads Giveaways. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 670 reviews