This was a great story although very sad. The ending was a huge bummer. Overall, I really liked the story. The biggest problem for me is that I am an HEA kind of a girl and this book did not have one.
WARNING, CONTAINS SPOILERS:
Leah checks herself into the hospital with a broken finger alone because her mother is on her honeymoon with husband #5. She meets Rebekah, a little Amish girl that is admitted for a spider bite. Soon, Rebekah's Amish brother, Ethan, and sister, Charity, show up for a visit and Leah immediately hits it off with both of them. She starts to fall fast and hard for Ethan. The obvious problem with this situation is Leah is "English" or non-Amish and Ethan is Amish. They are world's apart. Any relationship between the two of them would be forbidden. Leah gets the devastating news that she has bone cancer and is told she will need chemotherapy and possible amputations. She is visited by the mysterious Gabriella and is suddenly "cured."
Leah moves to the town her Amish friends reside for the summer and spends the summer with Ethan. They fall desperately in love. Ethan is having his fling or Rumspringa which is when an Amish kid turns a certain age he is allowed to experience the English world until he decides to become baptized in the church or leave the church and be shunned. Anyway, so he spends the summer dating Leah.
Ethan is now dressing in regular clothes, driving, dating Leah and partying with his friends. Leah eventually convinces him to move in with her and her mother and step-father after Ethan's sister, Rebekah, is killed when she is hit by a truck. Ethan agrees and gets help finding his estranged brother Eli who left the Amish Community. Ethan sees Eli, tries to convince him to go visit their parents. Meanwhile, Neil, Leah's step-father gets devastating news that he is most likely going to die from cancer, which he does. Ethan then decides he misses his family and wants to return. Leah begs him not to leave her crying and sobbing, saying I thought you loved me. Ethan who is holding her, crying and telling her that he loves her more than anything and everything, but still must leave her to go back to his family. So in a nutshell, Leah loses Neil and Ethan. The book ends with Leah heartbroken and devasted over her step-father's death and her boyfriend's decision to break things off and return to his Amish family. Although they both still love each other, they will never ever be together again because he will be baptized in the Amish church, expected to court an Amish girl, marry her and have a bunch of kids. How is that for a depressing ending?