Determined to get to the bottom of things, Izumi has it out with Hayase, whose head butting with Shikimori comes from a deep sense of disappointment. Sort of. Then dates happen and we get another one of those hopeless game parodies.
Whatever I get into with this volume, let me be perfectly clear about one thing - Hayase makes a fantastic addition to the cast once she gets over her hangups with Shikimori. And those are basically stemming from a long-standing hero worship.
It’s interesting because it seems like their past encounter was far more formative for Hayase, who was so impressed by Shikimori that she chased her down several paths in life. And now she’s stuck standing up to her because Shikimori doesn’t recognize her and Hayase can’t figure out how to break the cycle.
That’s a really believable pattern of learned behaviour that just causes problems and it turns out that Shikimori got a lot from that encounter too, but she had her reasons for staying silent. It’s always a nice change to have Izumi come through in the clutch.
The only problem is that the solution basically boils down to conforming at school and, sigh, I said my piece on this last time and I am not one for dress codes, so this didn’t feel great. Coupled with a later scene on a date where Shikimori barely flashes her stomach at Izumi for two seconds and he loses it and there’s still this odd moralizing cropping up here that I don’t love.
Anyway, Hayase and Shikimori head out on a date to shop and Hayase is basically a hot mess of adulation that can’t handle being this close to her personal sun. Which makes for a great bit of silliness and even brings Hachimitsu into the mix in a move that turns out to be very boneheaded.
Hachimitsu is an excellent character when deployed properly, but her awkward interaction with Hayase is only half as bad as the sudden revelation that she and Hayase have a secret connection that suddenly gets brought to light and just doesn’t work at all.
The odds, outside of narrative fiat, are so long against this and none of this has come up before, which makes it feel like a real pull from nowhere rather than an organic storytelling moment. Coupled with an annoying Maple Story parody it’s super rough.
Oh, but then Izumi and Shikimori play a battle royale parody game and these can be fun when they’re done right, but an action manga this ain’t. Instead it’s a set-up for a lame gag where Shikimori kills somebody with a frying pan and also gains amazing gaming skills in no time at all.
(Also, this is so specific that only a total pedant would notice, but the game seems very obviously based on PUBG, yet the death box in said game is absolutely a total carbon copy from Apex Legends, something I only know because I spent most of lockdown playing it.)
It’s a real mess of a volume, honestly. Most of the Hayase plot resolution is good, minus my own bias, and she really does add some pep to a cast that mostly just tows the line of normal. Somebody a bit flashier is a welcome change.
And the stuff where Shikimori is setting herself up to be the breadwinner while Izumi keeps house is pretty great and more like the spirit the story had before. I think this series has just been going for probably longer than it necessarily needed to, is the issue.
I mean, I will stick with it. I like these characters for the most part and I have seen enough thin copycats to appreciate what I experienced as the original. And it’s no lie to say that this series had an absolutely amazing run of perfect to near-perfect volumes for a while. I miss those days.
3 stars - Shikimori, no, is not just a cutie. But she used to be a lot more than what we get here too.