This is not your average romance novel, nor historical fiction for that matter. It’s more religious psychological thriller plus medieval blood feud (lots of battle scenes!) centered around one adulterous romance and the chaos and warfare that follows.
It was a page-turner, though decidedly not an easy read, with lots of names and places to keep straight (Russian novel style, but with too many Guillelms rather than Ivans). Nature descriptions were a bit too plentiful. But it’s worth persevering!
The main character’s struggle with his sin and how it plays out is refreshing in a way a novel set today couldn’t pull off - even all the sword fights, horseback getaways, and ransacking aside. Fulcun knows there is a God and that sin is real. Maybe even as is, many modern readers will resent Alde returning to a loveless, but lawful, marriage. I appreciated the look back to a traditional (medieval, if you prefer) perspective, as well as the different marriages we get to observe (all the casual domestic violence was a bit jarring, though!).
The varying portrayal of religious figures, too, was insightful. There are no perfect characters. Although I was fully engrossed in Fulcun’s wrestling match with God throughout the book, his resulting disregard of people and events around him make him not a super likeable protagonist. You’re rooting for him, but also wanting to give him a good shake to wake him up.
I recommend it. It left me with much to ponder.