Started out pretty good, but devolved into the same thing over and over and over again. The author completely misses some huge points, which she could have talked about instead of regurgitating the same points for like 2/3rds of the book.
1. Despite talking multiple times about how changed the world, the book is 100% focused on the US. It never talks about world-wide social media behemoths, especially in Asia. If the author wants to stick to just the US, that’s fine. But the book repeats over and over again about the impact on the world. The summery of the book doesn’t mention this either.
2. Incredibly narrow definition of “creator” or “influencers”, which is white people on their teens and early twenties. What about sports stars hyping their shoe collabs? What about musicians who are a brand in and of themselves (Beyoncé, Taylor Swift, BTS, etc)? What about Martha Stewart or Oprah? They are always promoting something, and millions of people put enormous weight on what they say and do. I’m a young millennial, consider myself very online, and work in tech, but I have never heard of like half the influencers she talks about in the book. This especially applies to many of the people she interviewed, most of whom had eye rolling takes that were just fluff. I almost died when people were saying that gen z is keeping it more genuine. They’re not. They spend a lot of time and effort making it look like they’re not spending a lot of time and effort.
3. Completely ignores other social media giants throughout history. Reddit (one of the top 20 website in terms of traffic) is mentioned in passing. No mention of Digg and the drama that went down with that site, which was surprising because it totally fit into topics raised in the book. No mention of Discord. Other than referring to Twitch in passing, no mention of hugely popular gaming platforms with social elements. No mention of big failures and what went wrong, like Google+. No mention of Medium, Substack, etc. Fleeting references to Pinterest, which is crazy given everything else she talked about. No mention of SoundCloud, and barely any mention of any other platform for artists to get their own music out.
4. Extremely focused on white creators and lazily mentions how unfortunate it is that non-white creators aren’t nearly as successful because of racism. Come on. You can say that AND dive into spaces where black and other people of color are influential. I swear it’s like the author doesn’t even think black people are even on social media outside a handful of creators. At least mention black Twitter ffs.
5. Acting like something is new and unique, even though she spent forever talking about nearly the same thing for previous platforms.
6. Inexcusably limited space spent on the most serious way people influenced others through social media: by promoting election lies, spreading covid misinformation that literally killed people, and attempting to end democracy as we know it. She talked a little bit about this on TikTok (all positive of course 🙄), but how can you possibly not mention Facebook and Twitter when talking about this? It’s mind blowing. Racism, antisemitism, anti-lbgtq, and other hate flourished on ALL platforms in recent years. She brought up TikTok being used for good during the pandemic to help stop misinformation. Like…what. Did she look at TikTok at all during the pandemic? Because it was a mess with all that bs.
7. There were several points in this book where I seriously thought she was being paid by TikTok to write this book. It legitimately sounds like propaganda or advertising for the platform throughout the entire TikTok sections, especially towards the end. The embellishment and straight up lies about how rainbows and sunshine TikTok is was ridiculous. Like you’d think that 15 year olds on TikTok singlehandedly ended racism, reversed climate change, and saved democracy after reading those last couple of chapters. And it was like none of the other social media platforms existed in the last 1/4 of the book. Part of me truly would not be surprised if TikTok compensated her for its sections.
I’d love to know how well this book stands up in 5-10 years. The epilogue could not have misread the room more. The author grossly underestimates the impact that gen ai is going to have on social media and content creators. The future of creators is not nearly as bright as she thinks it is. AI is going to flood the market and make it nearly impossible for people to break through. And I don’t think people are going to be turned off by human-like AI generating content as I imagine she thinks they would.