True-crime author Rosie Lowan and her struggling actor husband, Chad, have just laid their last family member to rest. After caring for Chad’s Uncle Ivan at his glamorous Murray Hill apartment until his last dying breath, they’re shocked to find out at the reading of the will that it now belongs to them. A posh apartment in the historic Windermere on the East Side of Manhattan, it’s worth nearly $5 million dollars. A figure well outside of either Rosie or Chad’s financial constraints.
Moving into the building, the smartly dressed doorman and opulent surroundings take on new meaning now that Rosie and Chad call it home. They are quickly welcomed into the fold by their affluent neighbors who seem to relish a new, young couple living amongst them. It seems as is life couldn’t be better as Chad and Rosie’s dreams start to come true.
As the days pass, however, the Windermere and the neighbors take on a darker tone. Why does it seem that the doorman, Abi, is always around? How could she have missed the security cameras that are located all over the building? And what about the new intercom feature that seems to always be listening? The longer she lives within its walls, the more Rosie begins to wonder about the decades of horrifying accidents and crimes that make up the dark history of her new home.
And then more death visits the Windermere. Within a week, two residents meets their demise. Worried for her own safety, Rosie takes it upon herself to get to the bottom of what has been occurring behind the building’s doors. Can she uncover the truth before she too meets a horrible end? Or was her fate already decided the moment she moved into the apartment? One thing is for sure, Rosie better watch her back. Especially since others just might be watching it as well.
Holy cannoli! What a strange yet captivating tale. From nearly the start, The New Couple in 5B was a total departure—but also not—from Unger’s prior books. Working in plenty of details pertaining to the supernatural, anyone with a penchant for horror will absolutely love what they find within these pages. At the same time, it was also yet another one of Unger’s typical suspense-laden plots, filled with growing unease and characters that hit just the right chord.
Speaking of those characters, I was captivated by Rosie. Complex and finely layered, her persona revealed how her past left an impression upon her and how she so desperately wanted a future separate from it as well. It was the rest of the cast, however, that truly brought this one home. An eclectic group of wealthy individuals, they were kind and welcoming to start, but each morphed as the page count grew into darker versions of themselves. But even as I second-guessed their motives and looked at them with suspicion, there wasn’t a chance that I was going to be able to guess where this plot was headed.
Just like the characters, the plot shifted from merely creepy to a more claustrophobic, adrenaline-pumping beast. Don’t get me wrong, it wasn’t exactly a horror novel, even though it was inspired by Rosemary’s Baby. No, it was instead a well-written exploration of what else might exist beyond what we can see with our own eyes. With clear-cut occult vibes and a definite gothic atmosphere, Unger nailed it in one with the setting. After all, the Windermere could easily count as a character itself in all of its spine-chilling, The Shining-esque glory.
By the end, however, I was thrilled to find that the mystical aspects weren’t the end-all-be-all to the plot. With plenty of tricks up her sleeves, Unger brought the rising crescendo of suspense home with an even better climax, all said and done. And while it wasn’t anything like I was expecting, it was everything that I wanted and more. An addictive, binge-worthy book, I was lost in the pages until I finished the very last word. Bravo, Ms. Unger, you’ve done it yet again! Rating of 4.5 stars.
Thank you to Lisa Unger, Park Row, and NetGalley for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
Trigger warning: suicide, anxiety, gaslighting, miscarriage, infidelity, strangulation, getting drugged, abduction, mention of: stalking, blackmail