Sankaran Nair was knighted in 1912. In 1915 he joined the Viceroy's Council as member for education. In that office he frequently urged Indian constitutional reforms, and he supported the Montagu-Chelmsford plan (1918), according to which India would gradually achieve self-government within the British Empire. He resigned from the council in 1919 in protest against the protracted use of martial law to quell unrest in the Punjab. n his book Gandhi and Anarchy (1922), Sankaran Nair attacked Gandhi's nationalist noncooperation movement and British actions under martial law. A British court held that this work libelled Sir Michael Francis O'Dwyer, lieutenant governor of India during the Punjab rebellion of 1919.
Chettur Sankaran Nair noted both with alarm and anger how Gandhi systematically began to hoodwink the Congress and the gullible Indian masses with his loin-cloth trickery. The outcome was the classic book, "Gandhi and Anarchy."
The book is a critique of the the Non-Cooperation Movement launched by Mahatma Gandhi after the the Great War when the British reneged on their promise of Home Rule to India. The author labors hard to discredit the movement as well as Gandhi without even attempting to understand the philosophy of the Mahatma behind the non-violent Civil Disobedience movement and this gets reflected in "How on earth is it possible to imagine that all activities would be non-violent when those who are carrying them proclaim themselves against constitutional authority and are bent upon destroying it; when they say that they must commit civil disobedience of a character that would compel the officials to shoot them!". Here in lies the problem. This is what the British and their lackeys failed to understand.
★★★★☆ (4/5) Gandhi and Anarchy by Chettur Sankaran Nair is a provocative and historically significant critique of Mahatma Gandhi’s Non-Cooperation Movement. Writing from the perspective of a constitutionalist, Nair questions whether mass civil disobedience, however noble its objective, could ultimately weaken institutions, encourage disorder, and replace the rule of law with the influence of charismatic leadership.
The book’s greatest strength is its fearlessness. Nair does not treat Gandhi as beyond criticism. He challenges his political methods, examines the risks of mixing religion with mass politics, and argues strongly for reform through constitutional and institutional means. His experience as a judge, administrator, and member of the Viceroy’s Executive Council gives the arguments considerable weight.
At times, however, the writing feels repetitive and sharply polemical. Nair’s distrust of popular mobilisation also seems to underestimate why Gandhi’s methods resonated with millions who had little faith in colonial institutions.
This is not a neutral history of India’s freedom struggle. It is a dissenting contemporary voice that complicates the familiar narrative. Even when one disagrees with Nair, the book forces the reader to confront an enduring question: can a morally justified cause excuse political methods that may weaken institutional order?
A demanding but rewarding read for anyone interested in Gandhi, colonial India, constitutionalism, and the tensions between principled resistance and political stability.
Explains Gandhi's civil disobedience and his way of handling the swaraj and khilafat movement and which lead to the 1920s during the period of Independence and how it led to the riots in different parts of the country in India.
A piercing critique from a former Congress insider, Gandhi and Anarchy dissects the contradictions in Gandhi’s ideology and the chaotic consequences of the Non-Cooperation Movement. Nair unpacks Gandhi’s disdain for modern institutions—railways, doctors, lawyers, English education, and parliamentary democracy—highlighting how his vision of Swarajya bordered on spiritual escapism and anti-modern regression. Particularly searing is the exposé of Gandhi’s political compromise on the Khilafat Movement, which, Nair argues, sacrificed Hindu interests at the altar of Muslim appeasement.
The appendices are a treasure trove—juxtaposing first-hand accounts of the horrific Moplah massacres with British hypocrisy in lamenting civil unrest. MacPherson’s legislative speech and Hazrat Mohani’s Muslim League address offer scathing insights into the growing communal fractures Gandhi chose to overlook.
Despite its invaluable content, the Kindle edition suffers from sloppy formatting and careless repetition. The substance, however, remains a sobering counter-narrative to the Gandhian mythos that shaped India's political discourse.
I finished this book on 15th Aug 2026, exactly at 12:27 am and I have never felt so "learned", I strongly suggest everyone to read this book to understand what was going around in our country during the Jalianwala Bagh massacre time.
Things which are missed in history books have been clearly stated here and the mindset in which Gandhi was acting, boils my blood.
The appendix section is where you will see the whole story and trust me, your whole perspective will change when you hear few things from his own mouth.
I am not saying that Gandhi wasn't the reason for our freedom, all I am saying is that HE IS NOT THE ONLY ONE who is behind our freedom.