This memoir had so much promise, but it was disappointing and I struggled to finish it.
Margaret Roach was a big-shot editor at Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, and then in 2007, after years of anxiety and stress, she left her job to go live in a country home in upstate New York and have a nice big garden.
The book is titled "And I Shall Have Some Peace There," but I saw little evidence of a peaceful person. Roach's writing is scattered, constantly jumping topics and flitting around, filled with immature asides in parenthesis (it is possible to overuse parenthesis, you know) and way too many random references to song lyrics. It was like reading a teenager's diary.
Again and again she asks: Who am I if I am not mroach@marthastewart.com any longer? The first time I read it, I thought, "Nice line." The second time, I thought, "OK, I get it, a little repetition to make your point." But she used it a ridiculous number of times in a 260-page book.
I think the problem here is that Margaret was good at magazine editing, and when she focused her writing on her garden, there were some good sections. But she lacked the ability to write a cohesive book. This story would have been a much better magazine article.
There were a few quotes I liked:
"If you think you want to live in the country, start by clearing a thicket of brambles, invasive woody vines, and choked, decaying trees, and then decide. This or its equivalent will basically become your life practice. There are always thorny bits in your path, always."
"I garden because I cannot help myself. It is no wonder so much of gardening is done on one's knees; this practice of horticulture is a wildly humbling way to pass one's days on Earth ... To be a gardener is to come face-to-face with powerlessness, and to cultivate patience as actively as you do botanical things. In spite of following all the directions gleaned from Grandma and from garden books, despite considerable years of hands-on experiments and personal access to some of the most knowledgeable masters of the breed, I know only one thing for certain about gardening now, thirty years in: Things will die."
"For better or worse, this is how I live now, no longer waiting to be reassured by the percentage of my annual bonus or any other tangible marker of progress like a job promotion. Randomness, along with instinct and, if you are lucky, scrappiness, are what you have left when you take the detour that I did."
Margaret did have some amusing stories about country living, but there was so much slogging to get there that I don't think it was worth it. If you just want to see pictures of her beautiful garden, check out her blog, "A Way to Garden."
A much better book about an independent woman moving to the country is Anne LaBastille's "The Woodswoman." Go read that instead.