For this week’s read, I wanted something quick and easy and I had been wanting to do another randomized Fear Street. May as well kill 2 birds with one stone. Plus, gives me more fodder for the Fear Street wiki I’ve been working on! Shameless plug.
This one I’ve been curious about, not knowing too much about it. After reading it, it turned out to be fairly interesting. It’s one I do wanna review, as it made me conflicted. In general, I liked it well enough. The setup is solid with this group of teens getting into starting little fires for fun. Jill Franks is our lead who is the typical plain jane, her friend Andrea is more the wild card who is similar to another Stine Andrea I know, her other friend Diane is the nice one who finds fire upsetting, and her old family friend Gabe comes in to start all this.
Pacing is mostly decent, with a fair amount of action and tension in the back half. Writing is good with some solid moments, and I generally like the character dynamics here. There are solid little moments that build to create some good scenes and moments. The mystery is kind of mixed, it’s more obvious to me who is behind some stuff but as a kid/teen it would have mostly fooled me as it does a decent job in making most seem sus.
The characters can be off at times, with Jill not seeing the red flags with Gabe, and the usual petty fighting over boys stuff. The villain reveal is interesting, the backstory is pretty messed up and sad, and while the motivation is weak at first, there is a sad aspect to make it deeper. The issues comes more from little things that lead to a rushed ending.
That ending hurts it, as it kinda ignores a bunch of important stuff with the characters. Things were building decently until it just stopped. This is a common issue with these and this is one of the more notable examples, bringing the story down.
My mind went back and forth on this one so a full review down the line will clear my head and go into more detail. For now, I think this was mostly enjoyable enough. A fair bit was above average for these, whale a fair bit was just the average. Nothing is below that at least, so while it is indicative of the major problems Stine can have, it’s not a bad effort all things considered. Hope to get to it on the blog someday.
CONTINUITY WATCH; When a fire breaks out, Terry Ryan (Halloween Party) tells her the fire is in the library. This made me so happy. Plus, they mention that a fire burned down a house holding a Halloween Party, likely a nod to those events. Simon Fear is brought up. Jill mentions that some friends were almost killed by a nut with a chainsaw at a house on the corner, likely referencing Wrong Number. Cuz we can’t not mention Deena somehow. Nick says “I know a girl whose parents disappeared from here”, maybe a reference to Missing?
One of the cops to show up is Detective Frazier (and his partner Monroe) who was in Wrong Number, and appears a few other times. I always wondered if one of the cops recur and while most don’t, he does. Check my continuity doc for more on that.
LOCATION WATCH: Pete’s Pizza visited and dissed by Gabe. The club Red Heat is mentioned too.. Division Street Mall is visited. Old Mill Road is mentioned, as is Waynesbridge.
(Also, Center City is mentioned which was also brought up just two books later in Lights Out and is also mentioned in Camp Nightmare).
POP CULTURE WATCH: Freddy Krueger (spelled as “Kreuger”), The Fly (both versions), Three’s Company, James Bond.
RED HEAD: Andrea
ANIMAL DEATH: There’s one in a dream, Bob thought he was slick with that one.
STIM-ISMS: Sour, “opened her mouth to scream, but no sound came out”,.
FAKE OUTS: 2
That will be it for now. No idea what’s next, it’s all up in the air so I won’t make strict plans and we’ll see where the wind takes us. See ya then.