This was a lovely book. Overall, the art is gorgeous, the stories are meaningful, and there are many good messages of being who you are and existing how you want to exist. Because this is a collection of short comics, I'll review each story separately.
Intro: The Color of Always
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Two pages long, this is a short but sweet introduction to the book. Two girls holding hands walk past a crowd of anti-gay protestors. One of the girls is wearing a rainbow necklace, and she takes it off and places it around one of the protestors' necks. Then they walk past. This shows that queer people don't have to respond to hate with hate or let the haters affect them. They can stand up to the haters and still be strong and love themselves.
Claddagh
⭐⭐⭐⭐
I like how this is in a letter form. The boxes with text drift kind of whimsically through the story, which gives it and aura of love and magic. Claddagh shows what it feels like to be in love for the first time, and also to have a crush. This story is relatable to me as a sapphic queer person, but I think it could be relatable to anyone who has ever been in love. I love how the ring symbolizes love, and now it's something the main character got from her Irish family. Her heritage helps her with how she shows love for someone. The art in this one wasn't my favorite.
Tethered
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
This story gets an easy five stars! The two main characters have never heard each other's voices; their communication has always just been through text. One character is an artist: they make clothing for their friend while "hiding" in their basement room. The other is working at pub, serving people. The second character's friends and coworkers tease him about falling for the other person, but they also encourage him tonight to call the other person. The two get on the phone, and it's a beautiful moment of Wow. I can hear you. It brings a kind of closeness.
Sea Change
⭐⭐⭐⭐
The main character, someone who is neither a boy nor a girl, falls into the sea on a stormy night. When they are rescued by the other sailors, they don't look male or female. Instead, they look relatively androgynous. My favorite line is this:
Other character: "You look… different."
Main character: "I feel different. More alive than I've been in years."
Letting It Fall
⭐⭐
The only thing I really liked about this was the message of giving up what you don't need anymore. For the main character, that's boys. She would chase boys because she needed their approval. I didn't really care for the art or plot.
Long Away
⭐⭐⭐
The art was okay, but I liked the idea of the main character going back in time, seeing their father who died when she was young. The character wants to see him and know him a bit because she feels like she doesn't know him and she's never had a chance to. I love when she realizes that he recognized her as his child, even after she has transitioned and is not a boy anymore.
All That Glitters
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
This was unquestionably my favorite story in the whole book. The main character, Dane, is a trans boy who wants to be femme, but he hides that part of himself because his male friends, with whom he wants to fit in, make fun of him if he ever lets it out. Dane brings lipstick to the place where he went with his friends, but when he puts it on, his friends laugh at him and accuse him of not being a real boy. He wipes it off furiously. He ends up encountering a drag queen in the bathroom when he goes in to wash the makeup off. The queen puts glitter on his cheeks. I have some favorite lines from this story:
Queen: "Don't let anyone tell you who you are. You can be anyone you wanna be."
And also…
Queen: "Now. Tell Mama she looks pretty."
Dane: "You… look perfect."
Queen: "I know. So do you."
Hollow Wolf
⭐
Sadly, I didn't care for this one. It was too nonlinear and the art wasn't as good as I would have hoped. This story just wasn't for me.
Extra Pages
⭐⭐⭐⭐
This story shows two characters who have a rather bad first meeting ending up friends and then falling in love. Roel hasn't been in pictures with his family for a long time, and I love how these two boys end up in love and Roel gets to have pictures with his new happily queer family.
Leaves
⭐⭐
I couldn't really follow this story, so I didn't care for it much. The art was only okay.
Ever More Myself
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Absolutely beautiful story. The main character, Kaj, wants to be androgynous and they're uncomfortable being perceived as female. As a trans person myself, I appreciate how the only dysphoria Kaj feels is social dysphoria. I also feel only or mainly social dysphoria. I like how Kaj also said that they don't hate the female parts of their body. They just want more. How their partner, John, is immediately so supportive makes my heart happy. I also like how this story shows a bi person, which isn't super common. So, yay! This is an amazing story!
Both Sides
⭐⭐⭐⭐
This story shows people learning to live apart after the end of the relationship and also learning to open up to each other about the pain. It's about learning to cope with the trauma.
Drawing Lines // Posting Signs
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The story shows a queer person who grew up in the Mormon community learning to accept themself and be openly queer. They're learning not to hide the LGBTQ part of themself, instead letting themself fall in love. I appreciate this story for that. Nothing can hold them back now from falling in love. And the art is also absolutely beautiful, so that makes it even better.
An Open Love Letter
⭐⭐⭐⭐
I like this. It's not so much a story, but a love letter, as the title says. This doesn't have to be a linear love story to show that love. This is a letter to a supportive loving amazing partner, and the letter shows how much these people love each other. The art behind the words just makes it better, too, as it's lovely art.
I 100% recommend this book to high schoolers and older, but also possibly middle schoolers. Note that there are sexual scenes in the following stories: "Letting It Fall", "Hollow Wolf" (I think), and "Ever More Myself". "An Open Love Letter" also has mention of sex, but nothing shown. Highly recommended!
- Echo (they/xe) ⚧️