1983 Doubleday hardcover, Phyllis A. Whitney (Sea Jade). Ever since New York journalist Carol Hamilton was a young girl, her great-aunt Monica Arlen has been for her the stuff of glittering, starry-eyed fantasy. Now, the reclusive movie star offers Carol an escape of another kind. In flight with her son from an abusive marriage, she’s come to Monica’s isolated, fortress-like home on Mt. San Jacinto in Palm Springs—and not only for sanctuary. Carol hopes to do research for her biography of a once-celebrated life that has receded into the dark shadows of Hollywood history. - Amazon
Phyllis Ayame Whitney (1903 – 2008) was an American mystery writer. Rare for her genre, she wrote mysteries for both the juvenile and the adult markets, many of which feature exotic locations. A review in The New York Times once dubbed her "The Queen of the American Gothics".
She was born in Japan to American parents and spent her early years in Asia. Whitney wrote more than seventy novels. In 1961, her book The Mystery of the Haunted Pool won an Edgar Award from the Mystery Writers of America for Best Juvenile novel, and she duplicated the honor in 1964, for The Mystery of the Hidden Hand. In 1988, the MWA gave her a Grand Master Award for lifetime achievement. Whitney died of pneumonia on February 8, 2008, aged 104.
Phyllis A. Whitney continued her string of early 80s successes with "Emerald." A young writer, Carol Hamilton, flees an abusive marriage to an unsavory business tycoon for the sanctuary of the Palm Springs estate of her great-aunt, a former Hollywood legend whom she's revered all her life but never previously met. While the novel owes more than a little to Whitney's "Listen for the Whisperer" of the previous decade, she nevertheless creates an enjoyable thriller with a final twist that—in her characteristically professional manner—has laid out its clues all along for the reader to miss. As had been the case in several of the novels immediately preceding it, the romantic subplot in "Emerald" takes up much less room and is less of emphasis in the story, suggesting that Whitney was perhaps responding to what she thought readers of the late 70s and early 80s wanted.
I used to read Phyllis Whitney's books when in my 20's and recently came across Emerald. Taking into consideration that this was written over 25 years ago, the subject of Hollywood actors from its golden era was still interesting, and references to the 'modern-day' main character using a typewriter and pay phone made me smile. That being said, with the exception of Monica - the reclusive old Hollywodd star - none of the characters, including the divorced Mom on the run with her young son - ever came alive in the story. Still, the ending DID surprise me and, perhaps, this is why I used to enjoy reading her books so much.
This book was awful. I did not like that flow of the book as there were very choppy sections. I also did not like the "this happened" "then this happened" it bugs me. The only reason I gave it one star was because of the ending twist.
I randomly grabbed this book from a thrift store years ago bc it was titled “Emerald” which is my birthstone and I just wanted it on my shelf as decor. For some reason I decided to read it and I was not disappointed!! This was such a good book! Published in 1983, it felt like I was transported to another time. The author did such a great job at describing every scene. I sometimes struggle bc of aphantasia, but I was always feeling like I knew the setting perfectly. Was a great mystery and the ending was unexpected, but so good!
Very good story with a surprising twist at the end. Didn't see that one coming.
Only problems were the length of the book, which was a little long for Whitney, and I didn't care for the way she set up the two protagonists as having the same problem. I guess Whitney was trying to find a way to make the characters relatable to each other but it wasn't necessary and just dragged the story a bit when it was mentioned.
The November 2026 #TBRChallenge is "Wrath." This blurb sounded promising, and boy did I underestimate the amount of wrath to go around in this story!
As per the blurb, the novel opens with Carol Hamilton speeding her way across the California desert with her six-year-old son, Keith, heading for the safety of her great aunt's fortress in the mountains above Palm Springs. She is fleeing from her extremely abusive ex-husband, who turned his wrath on their son the last time he saw him. Carol is in absolutely no doubt that Own Barclay would kill her in order to get to their son. Her parents died when she was a child, and she was shifted from foster home to foster home. The only living relative she was aware of was the great movie star Monica Arlen, who famously went into seclusion after an explosive breakup with her on- and off-screen lover, Saxon Scott. Carol has never met Monica, but she is their last hope for a shred of safety. Owen Barclay is extremely wealthy and extremely powerful. He has already abducted Keith once before, and will not hesitate to do it again.
Carol flees to Monica's estate, where she is met by Monica's secretary/companion, Linda Trevor, and the man about the place, Ralph. Everyone is extremely on edge. Linda knows of Carol's flight but has not yet told Monica, who is extremely fragile. Carol takes an instant dislike to Ralph, not helped by the fact that Linda obviously loathes him as well. Ralph is 100% an asshole, but apparently Monica requires the presence of a man who can be anything from a bodyguard to a handyman, and thus Ralph's presence.
It soon becomes clear that everyone around Carol is hiding something. It takes a few days for her to even see Monica, such is the lengths that Linda will go to to protect her employer from, well, anything. Carol has already seen the other half of the infamous pairing, Saxon Scott, who runs a restaurant not far from Monica's estate. The restaurant is an exact replica of the restaurant in the last Arlen-Scott film, The Mirage, which is kinda creepy. Carol is extremely curious about all this, and feels her writerly instincts going into overdrive. There's a story here, and Carol thinks if she can dig it out, she can reboot the career she gave up after marrying Barclay.
Once Monica summons Carol into her presence, the story starts moving along at a decent clip. Monica agrees to have Carol write her life story, but she is very controlling about how she wants to tell it. She doesn't want Carol going anywhere near Saxon or anyone else from the old Hollywood days. Carol pushes back, telling her that she can't write a real biography without knowing everything, including why Monica and Saxon broke up so spectacularly all those years ago. It eventually surfaces that Monica's original assistant, Peggy Smith, died during the shoot for the final Arlen-Saxon film, The Mirage, and Monica believes that Saxon murdered Peggy. For the last 36 years she has lived in fear of Saxon and of the truth of Peggy's death coming to light. Not only this, but Monica blocks Carol at every turn from finding out any information about who she is as a person, as opposed to an actress.
Meanwhile, Saxon has given his support to a gala showing of The Mirage for a fundraising event, and wants Monica to appear with him, on stage and in public, for the first time since their split. Monica is extremely upset by this request at first, but then decides that yes, she wants to make a grand reappearance in public - all the better if she can control every aspect of this re-emergence from seclusion.
Over all this also hangs the specter of Owen Barclay, who not only finds Carol in record time, but manages to breach the fortress walls and meet with Monica Arlen herself. He is also quickly entangled in Saxon Scott's affairs, which only serves to shrink Carol's world even more than before. And then Keith is abducted again...
Y'all, this was a ride. I was especially primed for this after re-reading Leading Couples by TCM, about the best screen teams from the Golden Age of Cinema. Monica Arlen and Saxon Scott are supposed to fit right in with these famous, exploding-chemistry pairings, but I hope the real folks had at least some grasp of reality. These people, very emphatically, did NOT. Everyone is living in a dream world: Monica Arlen, whose moods (and decisions) change on a dime, who spends most of her time living in her past; Linda Trevor, who has put Monica on a pedestal and treats her like a porcelain doll; Saxon Scott, who has some touch with the real world but apparently believes himself to be the strong, tough-talking heroes he played on screen, until he fails in a BIG way to protect Carol from Owen's violence.
The only person who seems to be living in the present moment is Linda's brother, Jason Trevor, who works at the nearby Desert Museum. He has a massive chip on his shoulder and seems to hate Carol on site, but she quickly learns that they are actually in the same position: divorced, with their exes abducting their children and absconding with them. Whitney makes a BIG DEAL out of how, at that time, noncustodial parents kidnapping their own children was not taken seriously by the authorities. Jason has been searching for his daughter for months, following leads from private detectives. Once he realizes that Carol is not like his ex (keeping her son from his father because she's the mother), he comes around to her side and proves to be a very strong ally. Their romance is very blink-and-you'll-miss-it.
The mystery of Peggy Smith's death starts to unravel almost as quickly as both Monica and Saxon do.
I'm actually not sure how I feel about this. It was only 99c when I purchased the e-book edition, and I have now read work by one of the more famous "gothic romantic suspense" writers ever. I don't regret it...but somehow, that crazy twist ending just soured the whole thing for me.
“We don’t talk about Peggy, no no no…” is my review title here. The twist in this one just seemed forced, or maybe just that there was a lot of effort to point the reader toward it before it was revealed at the very end. I give this one three stars because I still wanted to keep reading even though the narrator drove me a little berserk with her repeated over-description of everyone she was interacting with. It’s also a story that only works in an era where DV was considered ‘less of an issue’ because there were multiple points where I would’ve gotten the hell out of this place. As a teen who hadn’t read much adult mystery, I could enjoy these more; as an adult I’m frequently finding myself yelling “OMG don’t go for an evening stroll on the balcony with this guy; he tried to f***ing drown you! Get a knife for protection and stop letting him babysit your kid!!! Oh, your child was kidnapped; shocker.”
I haven't read a Phyllis Whitney book in years. I now remember why. The stories are very similar. There is a young woman in a strange, usually wealthy, location. She enters an atmosphere filled with distrust, anger and hidden secrets. The secrets are just about to be revealed. There is a troubled man who distrusts the young woman, usually for no reason at all. This will lead to a light romance. There is a murder or two to make the atmosphere even scarier. Then the person who no one suspects, including the reader, is found to be the murderer.
This book follows this model. It is easy to read and you will be surprised at the conclusion. Enjoy.
Another Whitney masterpiece, Carol Hamilton is running from her rich, but abusive husband. He will stop at nothing to recover their young son, who he has already beaten. Carol has no one to turn to but her great-aunt, a famous classic movie star, who lives in a secluded mansion in Palm Springs. A journalist by profession before her marriage, Carol decides to write a book about the famous Monica Arlen only to discover there are some secrets best left buried in the past. As with all Whitney books, the setting is beautifully described and the ending is not at all what you expect. Another gem!
To my embarrassment I enjoyed this melodramatic mystery romance. I fear I'm getting hooked on Whitney's novels. I can't understand why. The plots are all similar: a young woman is faced with difficult circumstances and there is a set of villains and a set of support--yet there is also some mystery with both sets that isn't explained until the last few pages. Yes, that's it! I like that unexpected twist at the end. Plus, the books are slim and undemanding.
Well, I finished it but am not really sure why -- I didn't really like any of the characters -- the writing, even tho Phyllis Whitney is supposed to be good, made the characters shallow. Maybe because the book was about the Hollywood scene of long ago -- i'm not sure. I gave it an "ok" but don't really recommend it.
Due to other distractions , it took me longer to read than it would normally , at times I wondered where it was going but as the book progressed I became more engrossed in the storyline and by the end I could'nt wait to pick it up and finish it , all in all it was a good read , and I will be reading the next book the Heirs of Eldon
Phyllis Whitney was definitely my favorite author years ago. Back then, I'd rate these at a 4, but if I was to read them now, they'd be between a 3 and a 3.5. Good mysteries, well written. They all neatly wrap up and are a bit sophomoric though.
Great mystery. Woman runs from hurtful husband with small son. Seeks refuge with distant relative, a former movie star who lives on side of San Jacinto Mt. Many long kept secrets are destroying her aunt. She sets out to write a book about her.
Well written enough, just sort of boring I guess. I wasn't very attached to any of the characters, can and the one plot twist (while I didn't see it coming) wasn't terribly exciting. I wish I had loved it!
**Hollywood Glamour, Dangerous Secrets, and Romance in *Emerald***
Phyllis A. Whitney’s *Emerald* offers an intriguing blend of gothic atmosphere, romantic suspense, and the dark mysteries hidden behind Hollywood glamour. At the center of the story is Carol Hamilton, a New York journalist seeking refuge with her great-aunt Monica Arlen, a once-celebrated movie star whose reclusive lifestyle only deepens the mystery surrounding her past.
Carol’s arrival at Monica’s isolated home in Palm Springs serves two purposes: escaping an abusive marriage with her son and researching a biography of the legendary actress. What begins as an opportunity to uncover the truth about Monica’s life soon becomes something far more complicated. Monica’s willingness to share her story comes with an important condition—Carol must be prepared to confront the truth about everything, including the enigmatic leading man Saxon Scott.
The novel’s appeal lies in its layered secrets, atmospheric setting, and the uncertainty surrounding the people Carol encounters. As she explores Hollywood’s faded legends and becomes romantically drawn to a new man, she must decide whom to trust while navigating a past that may conceal genuinely dangerous truths. Her search for understanding gradually becomes a mystery in which the consequences could be deadly.
Fans of gothic fiction will appreciate the isolated mansion, the mysterious celebrity, and the sense of unease beneath the glamorous surface. Readers of romantic suspense may also enjoy Carol’s struggle to rebuild her life while confronting the possibility of love—and betrayal.
*Emerald* promises a compelling mix of old Hollywood intrigue, family secrets, emotional vulnerability, and suspense, making it an appealing choice for readers who enjoy mysteries where the past refuses to remain buried.
This mystery book is a 4/5 for me. My parents and I were visiting the local library's book sale, and we ran across Emerald. My mom said she read a lot of Phyllis A. Whitney when she was young woman and recommended I give her a shot.
I was really drawn to the backdrop of Palm Springs as I have family in the area and find it a very pretty location and just a little mysterious. That, in addition to the references to old Hollywood, painted a really lovely veneer of mystery and intrigue right from the start.
Initially, I wasn't very fond of the main character, Carol, as she seemed to fall in love very quickly to a terrible guy. However, I did enjoy the fact that she was a writer and willing to risk everything to get her young son away from his horrifying father/her horrifying husband.
Once in Palm Springs at the home of her distant aunt who once was a Hollywood star, Carol meets several interesting characters. Of course, she gets off on the wrong foot with one of them, a good-looking man named Jason who has more in common with Carol than he first thinks. Every character seems to have his or her own secret, and they are wound up in a way that makes the ending a big surprise!
I found that the more cliched parts of the story balanced out nicely with the twists and turns. I stayed up late to see what would happen at the end and found myself telling my mom the next day that I was happy she'd recommended Whitney to me.
Old novels are getting a second life as ebooks, which is how Emerald by Phyllis A. Whitney caught my eye. Reading this mystery/suspense novel from 1983 was like watching an old movie—a welcome escape from the harrowing days of the coronavirus pandemic.
The novel is about a recently divorced woman attempting to find a safe place to shelter with her young son where her abusive ex-husband can’t snatch the boy a second time. The safe place to which she flees is a lavish fortified estate in Palm Springs, California, owned by her great-aunt who was a once celebrated movie star but now lives as a recluse. But the great-aunt seems less than welcoming and even within the walls of the estate the narrator doesn’t feel safe, especially after a mysterious attacker tries to drown her in the swimming pool. There’s romance too and a surprise ending I didn’t see coming. (I had guessed at an ending, just not this one.)
Whitney is the author of more than 70 novels, which in itself is quite an accomplishment. She died in 2008 at the age of 104 after a long and prolific career. While her novels are a bit dated in ways (after all, we live in different times), they still can provide stories about men and women who are not so very different from us.
This was more of a mystery novel than a romantic suspense novel; compelling and fast-moving for what it was, with some good twists and turns. On the one hand I appreciated the way Carol's ex-husband is portrayed as a stereotypical alpha male hero (self-made, compelling, sharp-witted) whose macho posturing and controlling nature quickly turns into abuse; on the other hand, he's portrayed as a self-made, dark-haired man whose name was originally "middle European" (changed to something Anglo-Saxon to get in good with all the WASPs) with curly hair and a "full, sensual mouth" - honestly to me that's coded obliquely Jewish and it's discomfiting that he's the villain of the piece.
Pretty typically Whitney, which is what I like about reading her, but which can also be incredibly frustrating. There were definitely times here when I was super impatient with our heroine and the not-so-smart things that she did, but whatever. The twist was pretty good and the setting decent, although it could've been edited down a bit, as a dragged at times. Still, pretty much what I was in the mood for and I immediately started another, because apparently I'm feeling the Whitney and have quite a backlog I've acquired during sales.
Altho she is a famous writer who has long passed, I have never read Phyllis A. Whitney. She has an easy flowing writing style and her progression of the story line pulls you in immediately. I thoroughly enjoyed this book - almost a marathon read for me. You know who the bad guys are, but surprises continue to change your opinion of the characters. You worry for the heroine and what is ahead for her (you think) only to encounter surprises she (and the reader) did not even imagine. I am thrilled that I enjoyed this book so much, but more so that I discovered this author!
Okay this read was quite an exciting one. It was set in recent times, but went back to the days of early Hollywood. When women wore the dazzling gowns and were the movie scene's main focus as they leisurely strolled into each one making her leading man physically overcome by her voluptuous entry. And, there's a lot about the Hollywood home areas as well. And, a bit of mystery too from a cold case. Very, very good read!
This would've been a great thriller, if Whitney had cut at least 100 pages of the main character's anxiety. The refrain of ex and son was so frustrating, and boring. The characterization is interesting. The main character had hers through exhaustive repetition of her concerns. The other all clearly had secrets, and the surprise villain was written in a way to obfuscate a shocking secret. Tempted to read another by this author, but sadly in no hurry.
Gave up halfway through, one day I might spend time skimming through the rest. Characters are unlikeable, I am not particularly interested in the plot and the author hasn't given any indication that things will get more interesting. Back in the day my mom had read Whitney, which is why I wanted to check her out. I've also picked up Rainsong and will give it a go down the road.