Middle School Is the New Noir
I'm a big fan of high school and middle grade noir. Apart from the fact that good ones are entertaining, I especially like the idea of younger readers developing a taste for tightly plotted and snappily written books. Such books can also be a bracing balance to a diet otherwise heavy on fantasy or action/adventure. (Wow, that sounds pretty full-of-itself, doesn't it?) The fact is that I particularly liked this book because it did so many things so well.
First off, the book has a twisty honestly noir plot. NO SPOILERS, but we have a MacGuffin that everyone wants, blackmail, rubouts, corruption, good gals in trouble, femmes fatale, some good cop/bad cop, double-crosses, squealers, former partners, a dependable bartender, and the list goes on and on. You can't read this and not think of "Maltese Falcon", "Big Sleep", "Out of the Past", and other classics. (If you're too young to know those noir films, that's fine; someday you will.)
But when authors set these books in high school or middle school they have to perform a second level of technical magic. They have to translate all of the noir conventions into a middle school world. Cops become hall monitors. Torch singers become head cheerleaders. Bootleggers sell candy and drug pushers push flavored all-sugar Pixie Sticks. This is wildly difficult to do and it is done here with great humor, imagination and finesse. The author makes it all plausible. Well, not plausible. The author makes all of the noir conventions fit into the middle grade world and work just like they do in the adult world.
That is an amazing achievement. And, it gets you thinking that all of the aspects of 30's and 40's noir - worry about an uncertain future, lost freedom, the sense that one is not in control of one's own destiny, despair, and so on - actually fit very comfortably into high school life. High School noir is not an oxymoron.
Finally, none of this works unless the snappy patter and the noir sensibility work. Here, our hero is a Raymond Chandler style hero. As Chandler said, “...down these mean streets a man must go who is not himself mean, who is neither tarnished nor afraid. He is the hero....". Substitute "hallways" for "streets" and you have this book's hero. He's funny, he's smart, he is hopeful and yet resigned; he is noble and yet human. And, bonus, some of his dark observations about school life are both memorable and full of gallows humor.
So, if you like to see how far noir conventions can be stretched, if you are looking for a little middle grade variety, or if you just want an entertaining witty read, this is an excellent choice.
Please note that I received a free ecopy of this book in exchange for a candid review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.