Overall: 3 stars
This was an interesting, if very uneven, true crime book.
I'd never heard of Mike DeBardeleben before reading this, and the fact that he committed so many different and varied crimes is fascinating (in a horrible way): kidnapping, extortion, blackmail, counterfeiting, sexual assault, AND murder. He eluded arrest for years and carried on his crime spree in every part of the US, in multiple states. He was never tried for murder (although he committed multiple) but was sentenced to 375 years in prison. That's just a weird, weird criminal history. And to top it off, he was caught for counterfeiting by the Secret Service who had no idea of his rapes and murders, which they discovered by accident by finding his many, many crime diaries.
As that quick summary shows, this is a weird case, and as a true crime nerd, I find that interesting. However, the writing in this book was a little uneven, and I somehow found it difficult to keep track of different victims and different crimes. Other reviews mention that the book spends too much time on counterfeiting, and I heavily disagree. There was just one chapter on the history of the Secret Service and counterfeiting; the vast majority of the book covers DeBardeleben's many crimes, focusing extensively on his victims and wives (who were also victims in their own ways). The focus on counterfeiting is not the book's problem: it's pacing and narrative flow (which could have been exacerbated by the fact that I listened to the audiobook version; maybe in print it's easier to follow the story).
Regardless, the story is very interesting, and there's a lot of attention paid to the victim's stories, which I appreciate. Just be aware that the pacing is a little choppy and the organization confusing at times.
CW: I usually don't include CWs for true crime because, well, it is what it is, but this book is more gruesome than most. Not because it's particularly gory (it spends very little attention to describing bodies or autopsies), but because it includes several excerpts from DeBardeleben's crime diaries, which include some of the most awful misogynistic thoughts I've ever encountered, and I read a lot of true crime. So watch out: this book is disturbing because of how absolutely garbage and full of hate this man's brain was. Gross.