I really liked this book. I've been floating around the boarders of graphic novel reading for a few years. My original entry point was trying to read books by authors who's novels I'd liked, then adaptations of urban fantasy novels I'd enjoyed. It took me a long time to train my eyes to follow the format and to enjoy it, but it finally sunk in this year and I've been on a graphic novel binge, so when I saw the title of this book, it seemed like a natural fit. To be honest, it only sort of was. I'm not really any of these women. I came to it late and I don't dig superhero comics yet. Most of these women adore superheroes, that the major theme of the book. Most of them had issues with being one of the few or only women or girls they knew who liked comics and faced a lot of discrimination because of it. I was hoping to find some entry points into the big convoluted mess of superhero comics. I saw a few openings perhaps. So I came away thinking that I'm just not really one of this particular handful of women after all. Traditional superhero comics probably aren't going to float my boat. But it's remarkable how much so many of these women moved me. I finished almost every one of these essays just saying, "Good for her," or just feeling really touched or kind of thrilled or really just moved by their experiences. I'm not that woman, but I'm honored to have been let into a bit of her experience.
One thing that I really loved was that three of the women compared comics to soap operas. Seanan McGuire mentioned it briefly, Sue D went into it a greater length, bringing up specific references to Another World, comparing soap and comic supercouples (Luke and Laura vs. Scott/Emma or Scott/Jean, what's the difference?), and Colleen Doran briefly referenced it as well. Because what else can you compare them to? What other media has stories that continue for generations, with rotating writers and producers, characters who continually die and get resurrected, and that kind of loyal fan base? I'm sure the men who stymied these women would hate it this comparison. The only thing they'd hate more is my sports/soap analogy. But it's true nevertheless. Sports, comics and soaps fulfill the same slots in our hearts as multi-generational ongoing escapist dramas. And chicks like sports too, guys. Just saying.
As for a few specifics, Marjorie M. Liu's essay was perfect. "Indeed, our obsession with the end of the world in popular media is as much an obsession with heroes." These apocalyptic or scary books, movies, stories are about what scares us most, but the heroes inspire us, empower us, give us hope. "Hope is our superpower." She made me see many of the books and movies I've been enjoying for years (her's included) with new eyes. Fantastic.
Elizabeth Bear's was great too. Not just because she was one of the very few to write about books that aren't about traditional superheroes, which made me feel a bit more included (Warren Ellis's Fell and Global Frequency). She just got to the heart of things, that each of us kind of hopes to be a hero and Ellis gets that by making his heroes sort of everymen and women.
But really, I enjoyed the entire book. I'm not a non-fiction reader. I'm not a biography reader. But I really enjoyed these essays, what frequently kind of amounted to origin stories. I might not be these women, but I liked getting to know them. I appreciate their experiences. And who knows, maybe I'll get into their favorite comics someday too.
-----
Nominated for the 2013 Hugo Award for Best Related Work