I begin this review with a confession. I stole this book.
At the age of 12, I found this in my school library. I borrowed it, devoured it and loved it so, so much that I couldn’t bear to part with it. So I lied to the library staff, telling them that I’d lost the book. They charged me a fee, but I was more than happy to pay, because it meant the book was mine. And still is!
This is the book that introduced me to Lovecraftian and Cthulhu fiction. I’ll never forget the thrills, chills and sheer joy that came to me when reading. Ever since, when I’ve gone back and read it, I still experience those feelings and I believe this is one of the finest anthologies out there.
IMPORTANT NOTE - For some reason, the ‘70s UK edition (Panther paperback) I read has different stories to the US editions. Some are missing, and others are included (the C. M. Eddy ones). I’ve listed the entire contents in my book in any case.
We open with the titular story of THE HORROR IN THE MUSEUM by Hazel Heald. As with all the stories collected in this anthology, H. P. Lovecraft isn’t actually the author; but he had a hand in helping the individual authors give a distinctly Lovecraftian feel to their work, so his presence is obvious. This effort, by Hazel Heald, is truly top dollar: packed with hideous creatures, plenty of suspense and foreboding and some gruelling, slithering horror. Thoroughly engrossing stuff.
THE CRAWLING CHAOS, by Elizabeth Berkeley, is less effective, more of a macabre fantasy than true horror. It concerns an opium eater’s vision of a future Earth transformed into alien landscape, and packs some impressive detail. The next, Sonia Greene’s FOUR O’CLOCK, is a straightforward story of supernatural revenge, with nothing very memorable about it.
Hazel Heald’s second story is WINGED DEATH and it’s another cracker. The diary format is put to fantastic use in the story of a doctor in African breeding a horrific revenge on a rival. I found this sickening, disturbing stuff and I’ve never looked at a common bluebottle in the same way since.
C. M. Eddy, Jr.’s THE LOVED DEAD is the book’s most controversial work, a much-banned tale of a ghoulish necrophile scouring the countryside, looking for food and more besides. The descriptive text provokes images of dank crypts, rotting corpses and filthy hovels and as a whole the story is a masterpiece of the grotesque. The author’s follow-up, THE GHOST-EATER, is less memorable and a more traditional pulp horror outing, but still an atmospheric effort set in some haunted woods.
William Lumley’s THE DIARY OF ALONZO TYPER is Lovecraft through and through: a man living in a haunted house discovering something unnameable beneath the foundations of the building. There are slimy trails in the basement, ancient gods and rituals, standing monoliths and a hero whose adventures are contained within an abruptly-ending journal. I loved it to bits.
THE ELECTRIC EXECUTIONER, by Adolphe de Castro, is a lesser effort about a man trapped in a train carriage with a psychopath, but not without merit. It’s a classic two-hander with moments of suspense and a macabre climax.
And then we have the last story. My personal favourite, and indeed one of my favourite Lovecraftian stories of all time: THE MOUND, by Zealia Bishop. This is splendid stuff. In essence, an archaeologist investigates a strange burial mound in Oklahoma which is reputed to be haunted. He soon uncovers a complex series of events involving a historical diary and a whole subterranean world outside of man’s knowledge. This is a lengthy story, told at novella length, and quite slow moving in places, but I loved every second of it. It builds atmosphere admirably and has an undercurrent of unseen horror running throughout, right up until a memorable climax. For me, this is brilliance in writing, and on par with Lovecraft’s best work. A tremendous way to end what is one of the greatest horror anthologies of all time.