I can't help but feel the author is naively optimistic, perhaps he's a humanist and believes in the inherent good nature of people. Odd since Maister is supposedly known as a world renowned consultant on helping professional service firms (law, tax, accounting, etc.). I would have thought that his books would not be filled with you should do this, and you ought to do that.
Maybe it's because Maister does an awful lot of telling and not too much showing. In many of the other good "management" books I read I am not just told what is wrong with current system, and what to do to better manage things, but also why and then proof that it works. I can't help but feel that Maister posits a lot of "wouldn't it be great if..." but never has anything to back it up with, at least nothing other than his name. And an appeal to authority is not what I'm looking for.
Or maybe it's because I work for a professional services firm that professes to like what Maister espouses, but doesn't actually do it. Not sure why. Maybe they've tried in the past (this book is 20 years old) and it didn't work for whatever reason.
It's not all a loss though. I found chapters 13 & 14 good. 13 provides a way to categorize the type of work you (or your firm) takes on, and why you might want to take on different work. 14 goes into how you would calculate profit/engagement in a helpful way so you can get away from simplistic measures like billable, realization, etc.
I've now read 3 of Maister's books and I have to say I think I'm done for now. I'll look for other authors in the field. Perhaps they have something to offer.