This was a sweet book with an even sweeter elderly dog. It's almost enough to make me want to be a dog owner again. It's really good for beginning readers, as the words are simple and there's only a sentence or two per page. The art--done with watercolor and pencil--was painted in soft, muted color, using a mostly cool palette. It gave the illustrations a calming, comforting feeling that radiates off the page. I do love a nice relaxing book, so I highly recommend this for all ages, especially the 8 and under age group.
I suppose Homer's lack of desire for activity is to demonstrate a sense of contentment, and being satisfied with the simple things . . . but I'd be concerned if my dog were this lethargic.
With lovely watercolor illustrations by the author.
As both the humans and other dogs in his family set out one day, intent on various activities, Homer sits peacefully on the porch, turning down every invitation to join in. After a peaceful day spent observing the world, he welcomes canine and human family back, before coming inside for some kibble, and another rest. In the end, Homer has everything he needs, in the form of those he loves...
Having greatly enjoyed author/illustrator Elisha Cooper's Magic Thinks Big, about a cat who prefers dreaming of big things to doing them, I was almost guaranteed to appreciate Homer, which also features a family pet who likes to laze the day away. The text here is simple, and captures the sense of peace and restfulness of Homer's day, while the beautiful watercolor artwork depicts both our canine hero's repose and the active things his family like to do. Recommended to young dog lovers, or to anyone who has had an older canine companion.
This book featured some beautiful illustrations and a great dog. Homer sits on the porch watching everyone else frolicking around on the beach and in the yard and patiently waits for them to return home. If you've ever had or loved a dog this is a great little book to share with a young reader. There's not much in the way of story, but the pictures are beautiful and offer a lot to talk about with your young one.
Book Talk: If you have ever loved an old dog than this is a sweet picture book for sentimental adult readers and their compassionate listeners. The story doesn’t come right out and say it, but Homer is an old dog in a dog loving family. He vicariously experiences all that goes on in the lives of his household members through his birds’ eye view from the front porch. Homer is invited, but is content to watch. There are his fellow dogs, excited to play and his owners, each and everyone, asking him to join in. They recognize that Homer has his reasons, so they give him an up-date upon their return to the house. At the end of the day, we see why Homer is so happy.
The illustrations include many details in which to elicit predictions and discussions. The first time I read this book, I thought of my “old friend” Lucy. In her last year, I often had to give her a helping hand under the haunches before she could, “get up from the porch.” While I read it to my 7-year old son, we discovered that the question/answer format of the text lent itself to my reading the questions, and he answering for Homer.
There is plenty of room to take a picture walk and make some predictions before reading the book. If not, take a leisurely stroll through the book enjoying the story and pictures and any conversation that might arise.
Wonderful, soft, inviting, heart-warming illustrations. This book made me melt. Deceptively simple, the illustrations have details that I just want to keep searching out. Great sense of place, of home, of family, of calm and serenity and peace. This book brings an important message -- of living life slowly, of savoring the moments, of taking the time to just sit and ponder and *live*. This is exemplified not only by Homer, but also by the family he lives with. Lovely, lovely book.
"...Soft-focus watercolor illustrations effectively convey the seaside atmosphere with a combination of formats, including some pages with consecutive panels and wordless double-page spreads showing a wide view of the cottage and beach and the inside of the home with the family getting ready for bed..." -- Kirkus.
So sweet! A celebration of a dog of a certain age. No more frolicking in the waves, no more jumping like a puppy. Homer is a quiet, older dog content with watching his family be their busy selves, all the while patiently and comfortably waiting on the porch for them to return. This story will resonate with all families who have loved a dog who expresses his affection in subtler, quieter ways than younger pups do.
If you're an animal, especially dog, lover, this will certainly appeal. Of all the things, experiences, etc offered to Homer it seems his needs/wants are very simple. He wants a home, and a family to love and to love him in return. The illustrations and brief, well-chosen words, say it all.
Summary: "Homer" is about an old dog who watches the adventures and activities of his owners or friends. While he is constantly asked if he wants to join, he remains on the porch of the house and just watches from a distance. All his friends bring him keepsakes from the day and he is happy. By the end of the story, he says he has everything he needs: the company and love of his friends.
Analysis: I really, really loved this book. It was very sweet and the precious dog was an adorable character. It was honestly really heartwarming how the dog didn't need all these material things, and didn't need to go out and do activities with them all the time. He was simply happy to be with his owners or friends.
How I will use this book: I would love to use this book to teach students about how important friendship and love is, and that what matters is what's inside, not gifts or money or even doing fun things. Especially during a time like right now, with COVID-19 preventing people from going out and doing a lot of fun stuff, it is so important to be with family and to appreciate our love for each other.
This book should not have been published as it is nor do I recommend that any children read it! I hate being a spoilsport but authors and publishers, who write and publish children's books in general and especially books about pets, need to be hyper aware about safety and what messages the children are picking up from the story and its illustrations. While it is a fine story, not a spectacular one, one illustration totally makes the book inappropriate for children. That is the illustration of a girl sitting on top of this old dog as if she is riding him. It is outrageous to show this behavior and teach children something that might get them bitten and get the dog injured or declared a "dangerous dog". I am really angry, frustrated, and saddened by this book and the high reviews it has gotten! Are there no real dog people out there that see this problem!
Contemporary fantasy picture book (dog's POV, otherwise realistic) K-3
Anyone who has ever had a dog will connect with this picture book story. It shows a day in the life of an elderly dog, as he watches all of the younger dogs and the family members going about their days activities at the beach. He declines to participate in any of the activities, saying that he is happy exactly where he is. And when the owner towards the end, asks if there's anything he needs, the old dog walks inside eats his meal and curls up on his favorite chair, saying he has everything he needs.
Text is very low density, and the pictures tell most of the story.
I absolutely adored this book. The illustrations were lovely and the story about an old dog quietly enjoying his golden years is perfect. Everyone in the family invites Homer to do things with them. The things he likely enjoyed when he was young, but now he just wants to watch from a comfortable napping place on the porch. Each family member tells him about their day and he quietly listens. Everyone wants to know what he wants or needs, but when the family is all home together, he has everything he needs!
What a sweet story! An old dog prefers to stay at home while the family that owns him goes out to do the various things they enjoy. He's there waiting for them on their return. The illustrations give the reader the sense of "being there".
Homer was hard to read because he reminded my grandson (and me) too much of our sweet little girl we lost recently. She and Homer might have been twins.
5 stars for a home loving, FAMILY loving white lab.
For anyone that has or has had an old dog in their lives, this story will ring true, it's a love letter to our 4 legged friends and it's told beautifully
Sweet, sweet story about an older dog and the family that loves him as much as he loves his family. I really liked seeing the children being so considerate of him.
This story by Elisha Cooper is a great nominee for the 2013 Caldecott Medal. This story is about a dog named Homer that lays on the porch all day while his family and dog friends go out and play and go to the beach. Homer does not want to participate in any of the activities and when asked if he wants or needs anything he says "No, I have everything I need." At the very end of the story he says "I have you." Through the illustrations we know that he means his owners. Each illustration in this book contributes to the story being told. Cooper does a great job illustrating the pictures to the words. I love how in each picture she adds another person or object that Homer has come across and they all build up through out the story. At one point, a double spread picture shows all of the activities that people asked Homer to do but he did not want to. You can see him still lying on the porch where he wanted to be. This book is appropriate for ages up to and including 14. Although it is an easy read for older students, they can appreciate the illustrations and the story that is being told. Cooper created original illustrations that went along with the theme of the book. If the words had been removed, the story would still be able to be told through the pictures.Most children can relate to this story because they have a dog or pet and they feel like they understand it better. For all of these reasons, I feel that Homer is a great nominee for the 2013 Caldecott Medal.
Homer is an older, laid-back family dog (he looks to be a golden retriever or yellow lab). He spends a day on the porch while the other members of his family (other dogs and people, too) come and go about their business. Everyone checks in with him – inviting him along on their adventures and activities – but Homer is happy where he is. As the day draws to a close, the family returns – taking a few minutes to share something with Homer. And when the sun sets, Homer walks into the house, has his dinner, and curls up in a chair for the night.
Very sweet story. Very sweet dog. Homer has a lovely dog smile, and you can almost hear the soft thumps of his tail as he wags his greetings. He’s tolerant, patient, and interested in all of the goings on around him – albeit from his quiet vantage point (surrounded by home, family, and wrapped in love). This would be a great, reassuring bedtime read.