There was nothing redeeming about this book for me. Nothing. I was so fed up with it that I finally returned it at 92%. I didn't even care about the ending. I couldn't stand any of the characters. They were all stupid. And annoying. And had no depth. SEP is one of my favorite authors, but I REALLY hated this book.
Ok, here is the rest of my review....I just didn't have the energy to type it out on my phone. I have to say, it about killed me to give SEP a 1 star rating. Even the books that weren't my favorite by her got a decent rating, this one just simply contained all of my pet peeves in one book. AGH!
1. Seriously, I was over 30% through the book before there was an actual conversation in the story. 30%. Ugh. My issue with books that have little dialogue is that they tend to read as overly dramatic, to me that is. And it's hard to feel like the plot is driving the story, and then I start to feel like the author is "info dumping" on us-- it feels text bookish-- character A does this and so character B feels this way and then does this. It's not my favorite style.
2. Once again, a book that has the h/h "fall in love" without A) having a conversation, B) communicate with any method other than a passive aggressive one, C) get to know each other. But hey, why don't we just fall into bed together and then because we had great sex it's obvious that we HAVE to be in love and everything is just going to be hunky-dory. ugh. Oh, I why don't I throw in some minor stalking while I'm at it?
3. This isn't a pet peeve, but usually I like SEP's secondary characters. I really didn't this time. To be honest I didn't think any of the characters were all that likable. She TOLD us that they were, but I didn't particularly care for them. Nothing really drew me in.
4. I couldn't help but feel like this book was a recycled "Natural Born Charmer," which I love, but this was a watered down, boring re-write of it. And I was so excited for it....heck, I pre-ordered it months ago.
5. And can I just roll my eyes at the token gay character????? Yeah, I felt like that entire story line was thrown in there just to have a token gay character-- it read quite disjointed to me, I didn't believe it and so it pushed the "drama for drama sake" button for me. I don't have issues with gay characters, this one just didn't do it for me. I can't really explain why, maybe the entire book just soured me on any twist and turn.
6. I left my biggest frustration for last-- apparently calling a half black little boy a "boy" is racist????? What the crap???? I grew up in the south and never heard that one. Maybe I was just too sheltered in my over-half black school???? The racial storyline REALLY got on my nerves. REALLY. The kid didn't feel persecuted, held back, different, etc, so why, WHY, did she feel the need to try and make him feel that way???? Isn't the point of all the racial awareness/education to have everyone judged on their own merit, not their skin color???? I get that she was trying to have Bree bring an avenue for him to feel pride in his heritage, but it's not like he was ashamed of being half black! He simply didn't focus all of his energy on his skin color. It just frustrated me.
I'll stop now and maybe just cross my fingers that her next one is more my style.