I'm really torn on the review for this book. In fact, I finished it a couple of weeks ago and have been coming up with excuses to not post a review because I wasn't sure what to say. Here are some of the problems:
The story is very fun. I loved the mythology angle and the steampunk aspect. The variety of demons was also well done and interesting, and I got a kick out of reading a tale about out-smarting the devil, which you just don't get very often anymore.
In general, the story was also well-told with some fun action sequences and the afore-mentioned out-smarting the devil, which was just great.
There were also some really great lines in it. I loved that little boys were a bit more tart because of all the puppy dog tails while girls were too sweet because of the sugar and spice. Great imagery and great use of a phrase we all know. I laughed out loud and even posted that part on Twitter.
So why the three stars?
Well, first of all, the book needs serious revision. There are typos and problems throughout. I'm not talking about grammar faux pas or sentence structure, I'm talking about straight up typos and word misuse. For example, in one place, the author used the word "concur" instead of "conquer" and so on. I can forgive a few typos here and there, but in this case it was over the top. One appeared on practically every page. For the most part, you can figure out what was intended, but more than once they impede understanding. I didn't feel like I could give the book full marks with that hanging over it.
The second problem was the main characters. The opening sequence (which I really enjoyed), started with a particular character, Moira. I thought she was a great character. She revealed a little depth, a lot of spunk, and had a great attitude. I also love the name Moira, so that was a big plus At the end of the first chapter, it seemed to set her up for a quest.
And then it skipped forward a couple of years and switched to an entirely different character. Ok, I thought, we'll get back to her in a bit. But we never did. In fact, she turned out to be relatively minor after that. You didn't really learn more about her and the payoff wasn't there. It was a bit frustrating because I thought she was one of the strongest characters in the book.
The main character, Halloween Jack, was ok. But there was a problem with him—he was extremely one-dimensional. Pretty much what you saw was what you got. That isn't always a major problem in straight-up action stories like this, but here it really didn't work. Jack is supposed to be extremely clever and secretive and trapped in a life he didn't want and so on. And he just never came across that way. He accepted everything very quickly, came up with a plan on the spot, and rarely made a mistake or regretted his decision. He just wasn't deep enough for me. I kept wanting the book to get back to Moira.
The finally issue is that I wanted to know more. I especially wanted more information about Jack-of-the-Lantern and his legend. You got hints of it but not enough to form a full picture. Steam soldiers are nice, but I really wanted some great mythology thrown in and the book left me wanting.
I think that is a great way to describe this book: it left me wanting. I wanted more from the characters and more from the mythology.
Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the book. 3 stars means "I liked it," so please take it that way. I'm also more than ready to read more from Gallowglas (I've already downloaded another of his books). The idea behind the story was excellent, some of the dialogue was really well done, and there were moments in the story that were absolutely magical. I just wanted a bit more.
And, again, it really needs some editing.