I felt like this book was more of a 2.5 as opposed to a 3, and for a variety of reasons. Firstly, I found that there were so many clichés that the author spoke of in this book that made me cringe. He talked about how Professor Rosa didn't want to tutor Carter because he hates tutoring 'jocks', then Carter told Professor Rosa the only reason he wanted to learn Italian was because he wanted to woo a girl that he met ONCE after a sports mishap, and fell 'instantly in love' with (this is the part in which I rolled my eyes). More clichés followed, such as Carter's construction job, and eating 'hamburgers' since he was so hungry, with Professor Rosa being angry about it. Another was Carter not knowing that he needed a passport to go to Italy, oh come on, jocks can't be that clueless can they? Nevertheless, the clichés continued throughout the entire book, which made me want to turn the pages faster. Secondly, I felt that the entire story was one soapy drama, with Carter learning Italian to find a girl that he loves, then having to bring the pocketwatch back to Professor Rosa's brother, and Giorgio needing Professor Rosa for some 'drastic' need, with him having to come into contact with his brother's wife, whom he once loved. Too many situations in which were quite predictable, making the book uninteresting most of the time. Lastly, I felt that there were so many events in which the author just dragged on to fill page space, such as Carter's tour of Italy, meeting various individuals, which had absolutely no connection to the plot at hand. Those events just made me yawn even more, as I wondered why I was even wanting to finish the book. Overall, this book just didn't leave a good taste in my mouth, and I wouldn't recommend it unfortunately.