Although Brazier seems, in my opinion, to over-intellectualize Buddhism, his book is a solid explanation of the lifestyle. At points it was too dense for me, and — perhaps in Buddhist scholarship fashion? — very vague. To take one example of a practice recommended in Brazier's interpretations, I found I couldn't relate to the exultation of meditation. Perhaps some would dismiss my persistent ambivalence toward meditation as "unenlightened," but I simply don't see the point in persisting with something that is told to bring a good quality to life but doesn't, for me. Certainly, it's something you practice, but I find meditation and some of the other Buddhist rituals to be a bit like museums: we're told they enrich us, and that if we bring the right mindfulness to it, we'll appreciate them. But if they simply don't appeal to an individual or "do anything" for that person, there is little point in pursuing the practice of exploring them, I think.
The more I read about the Buddha, the more I respect the authors who write about him, but for reasons I'm not sure they themselves would realize. Essentially, they all say that the Buddha became enlightened by living his life the hard way, by finding enlightenment for himself on his individual journey. He had few guides but the ordinary experiences and people he encountered. True, he preached and he lived in such a way that others found worthy of imitating. But if the enlightened one reached enlightenment purely through his own experience, isn't that the model we should seek? Not one of meditating or following ritualized practices because it's what "Buddhists" do, or begging for food because the Buddha did. Not the mimicry and adulation of mass religion, just living in a way that helps us find our purpose and our happiness.
Not everyone is destined to be the Buddha or the Dalai Lama. Our everyday lives do not necessarily need to be like theirs, if theirs are not the practices we feel organically moved to keep. It amazes me that some people do not come to this realization on their own; some do, but still have difficulty making it real. But that, to me, is the real lesson in the Buddha's life: live it for yourself and make it worthwhile, on your own terms, because that's all you've got.
To actually give a review to this book, since I haven't yet: let's just say that it made me think enough to put words to this philosophy, so it's got to be worth something!