Ifor Evans first published his "Short History of English
Literature" in 1940 and by 1976 it had gone through many
reprints as well as an end chapter by Bernard Bergonzi bringing
it up to date with critiques of new writers such as Phillip
Larkin, Anthony Burgess and John Osbourne.
The interesting thing about Evans is that he had been around
for long enough to see poets that were highly thought of in their
lifetime, then spend years in obscurity, then in the 50s and 60s
have a popularity revival (Tennyson) and is able to discuss them.
As the back cover claims Evans is "fair to all and gushes over
none". The book is divided into poetry, drama and prose - English
drama, according to Evans, seemed to go downhill after Shakespeare
and his contemporaries (Thomas Kyd, Christopher Marlowe).
He also gives praise to Samuel Richardson who he feels has never
received his due from critics, especially contemporary novelist
Henry Fielding who wrote his novels "Joseph Andrews" and "Tom
Jones" as satirical comment on Richardson's "Pamela". There is
Tobias Smollett, a rough seaman who wrote about the reckless and
ferocious naval life in "Roderick Random" and "Peregrine Pickle",
both from the mid 1700s. At the other end of the spectrum Laurence
Sterne's "Tristam Shandy" which sounds a lovable but illogical
book - I must search for my lost copy!!
From the 1800s on there is a grab bag of names - Charles Dickens
he feels was the master and how, he wonders, did the Brontes
create such a phantasm world out of such austere reality. With
"Middlemarch" George Eliot achieved genius, Henry James so
desperately wanted the refinement of Britain but when he settled
here the reality was not what he imagined. Thomas Hardy, roughly
the same age, lived and wrote about a Britain that James would
never enter.
You also won't find many books that give even a passing mention
to George Gissing - Evans places Gissing as a writer who followed
his art into difficult places rather than Kipling who adapted
himself to the public taste. He feels there was no other writer
like Gissing who delved into the corruptions of society but
refused his audience an ending of easy solutions.
Evans also has a theory on the demise of the three volume novel.
He feels that by 1880, through free schooling, reading was enjoyed
by the greater public and people were looking for shorter books -
and Robert Louis Stevenson with "Treasure Island" and "Kidnapped"
was one of the first writers to profit by it. And I never realised
that it was Dr. Samuel Johnson who created the dictionary!!
I do agree with the reviewer who said it was all a bit of a boy's
club. Especially with Bergonzi, who wrote the last chapter. There's
no mention of Vera Brittain, Winifred Holtby, Barbara Pym or even
Elizabeth Taylor and those that are mentioned are sneered at for
writing about "women's subjects". While Malcolm Lowry who was known
more for his erratic private life and Angus Wilson are afforded
pages and pages!!