What do you think?
Rate this book
Heart of the Rockies #2
A Love Forbidden
Moved by the desire for adventure and a yearning to help the Ute Indians, twenty-year-old Shiloh Wainright impulsively accepts a teaching position at the White River Indian Agency in northwestern Colorado. The new job, however, isn't what she imagined it would be, and Shiloh soon finds herself caught in the cross fire between the Utes, their unyielding Indian Agent, and the unrealistic demands of the US government. Her unexpected encounter with Jesse Blackwater, an embittered half-breed Ute and childhood friend, only complicates matters as they battle their growing feelings for each other amidst the spiraling tensions threatening to explode into a catastrophic Indian uprising.
Set amongst the wilds of the Colorado Rockies in 1879, this is a tale of a forbidden love and a faith tested in the cauldron of intolerance and the harsh realities of life on the untamed frontier. Bestselling author Kathleen Morgan deftly explores themes of mercy, fidelity to one's beliefs despite what others think or do, and compassion for those different from oneself as she plumbs the depths of the human heart and the healing power of God's love.
Set amongst the wilds of the Colorado Rockies in 1879, this is a tale of a forbidden love and a faith tested in the cauldron of intolerance and the harsh realities of life on the untamed frontier. Bestselling author Kathleen Morgan deftly explores themes of mercy, fidelity to one's beliefs despite what others think or do, and compassion for those different from oneself as she plumbs the depths of the human heart and the healing power of God's love.
320 pages, Paperback
First published May 1, 2012
50 people are currently reading
972 people want to read
About the author
Kathleen Morgan
37 books382 followersLibrarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Kathleen began her career writing contemporary romances and soon moved to historical and futuristic romances. She sold her first book, a futuristic romance, in April 1990 while stationed in Korea as an Army nurse. Additional romances soon followed, until she had sold a total of fifteen books in the general market, establishing a loyal readership along the way.
Since that time, she has received numerous awards for her work, including a Romantic Times Reviewer's Choice award and Career Achievement award, and The Literary Times award for Literary Excellence in the Field of Romantic Fiction. She was also a Romance Writers of America RITA finalist.
Kathleen now focuses her writing talents in the area of inspirational fiction, offering readers characters who struggle to redefine their growing faith in everyday life.
Kathleen began her career writing contemporary romances and soon moved to historical and futuristic romances. She sold her first book, a futuristic romance, in April 1990 while stationed in Korea as an Army nurse. Additional romances soon followed, until she had sold a total of fifteen books in the general market, establishing a loyal readership along the way.
Since that time, she has received numerous awards for her work, including a Romantic Times Reviewer's Choice award and Career Achievement award, and The Literary Times award for Literary Excellence in the Field of Romantic Fiction. She was also a Romance Writers of America RITA finalist.
Kathleen now focuses her writing talents in the area of inspirational fiction, offering readers characters who struggle to redefine their growing faith in everyday life.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews
May 21, 2012
There is just something about forbidden love that draws me to the story every time, especially when it has to do with Native Americans and the many prejudices they suffered over the years. There was little to compromise when it came to love. If you married you either lived with the tribe and were persecuted, or you lived among the whites and were persecuted. At any rate, I find many historical battles quite fascinating as well as the way different cultures saw things such as marriage, family, and God. The part where the massacre took place was terrifying and I felt the horror of it. But I also saw what Meeker did to provoke the situation in the first place.
This book intrigued me because of the plot and conflict and I read it quickly. The beginning was fairly traumatic and I couldn't help loving Jessie as a result. He suffered a lot over the years that it was easy to see why he was distrustful of people. I could also see the draw Shiloh felt toward him. There was something very passionate about Jessie that made me care about him. I also cared for Shiloh and appreciated her heart for people who were in unfortunate circumstances. The characters were well drawn out and the conflict kept me reading. And those ardent, searing kisses... whew! Kathleen Morgan sure knows how to stoke a romantic fire in her novels. This was a very enjoyable read!
This book intrigued me because of the plot and conflict and I read it quickly. The beginning was fairly traumatic and I couldn't help loving Jessie as a result. He suffered a lot over the years that it was easy to see why he was distrustful of people. I could also see the draw Shiloh felt toward him. There was something very passionate about Jessie that made me care about him. I also cared for Shiloh and appreciated her heart for people who were in unfortunate circumstances. The characters were well drawn out and the conflict kept me reading. And those ardent, searing kisses... whew! Kathleen Morgan sure knows how to stoke a romantic fire in her novels. This was a very enjoyable read!
May 15, 2012
The cover on this book pulled me in, but it took me awhile to get into the story. The setting of the book is in beautiful Colorado in the late 1870's, and we get to travel through this area with the characters.
Jesse Blackwater and Shiloh Wainwright end up in the same Indian Village, when Shiloh tries to take a job there as a teacher. What a hard life poor Jesse has had and he really touched me....things that should never go on in a child's life, happened to him.
You can feel the sparks fly between the two, but Jesse or Nuaru has lost site of the God he accepted in his youth. I can see God's hand in putting Shiloh and Jesse back into ones lives in the Ute's Village.
We follow the Goverment plan to move these people off their land and onto a Reservation. Of course, there is resistance...I tried to think how I would feel with someone coming in and taking my land??
You will wonder how all of this is going to come out, and if they will survive to marry?? Also will both come to terms with Forgiveness?
This is a reality read, things that happened mixed in with a different type of Love story.
Enjoy!
I received this book from the Publisher Revell, and was not required to give a positive review.
Jesse Blackwater and Shiloh Wainwright end up in the same Indian Village, when Shiloh tries to take a job there as a teacher. What a hard life poor Jesse has had and he really touched me....things that should never go on in a child's life, happened to him.
You can feel the sparks fly between the two, but Jesse or Nuaru has lost site of the God he accepted in his youth. I can see God's hand in putting Shiloh and Jesse back into ones lives in the Ute's Village.
We follow the Goverment plan to move these people off their land and onto a Reservation. Of course, there is resistance...I tried to think how I would feel with someone coming in and taking my land??
You will wonder how all of this is going to come out, and if they will survive to marry?? Also will both come to terms with Forgiveness?
This is a reality read, things that happened mixed in with a different type of Love story.
Enjoy!
I received this book from the Publisher Revell, and was not required to give a positive review.
September 2, 2020
This second book in The Heart of the Rockies series was a good book even though it started off slow. Shiloh feels called to teach the Ute children on the White River Indian Reservation but it doesn’t exactly go as she planned. She had many things to face including getting reacquainted with Jesse Blackwater, a half breed from her past. Her very faith in her God is tested to the breaking point when she has to make a choice between the man she has loved since she was just a child and the God who loves her above all. I enjoyed this book and recommend it to historical fans.
May 20, 2012
A quick glimpse at the title of this book conjures up a torrid romance. However, that is not the case in Kathleen Morgan's book, A Love Forbidden.
The story takes place around 1878-79 in Colorado and involves the Ute Indians, the Indian Agency, troubles of a half-breed Indian, and a single white woman, Shiloh Wainwright, who simply wants to help educate the children of the Ute tribes. She accepts a position teaching the Ute children and settles in the White River Indian Agency in Northwestern Colorado. There she discovers a long-lost childhood friend. Embittered half-breed Jesse who had once worked on Shiloh's father's ranch. In the past they had held a strong friendship, but Jesse had left the ranch under seriously disturbing circumstances.
Shiloh is now caught in the seething tensions of territorial conflict between the U.S. Government - enforced by an unyielding Agency official, and the Ute Indians who do not wish to change their way of life and settle down in the restrictive area of the reservation. Not only is an Indian war brewing, a conflict of hearts and civilizations is brewing between Shiloh and Jesse.
My thoughts: Ms. Morgan deals fairly with the history of the U.S. Government's dealings with the Ute Indians presenting both sides without taking sides. She shows the firm and the tender emotions of each - the Indians and the white settlers. She shows mercy in the hearts of each peoples. She also shows the determination of each to do as they believe is right. She delivers the strong adherence to one's spiritual beliefs in spite of what others might think or do or say. Ms. Morgan shows us, too, how forgiveness is bound up in the healing power of God's love. Forgiveness of others and forgiveness of ourselves.
I liked the characters and found them believable and well developed by Ms. Morgan. The story line was interesting (enough to get me to Google some information online) and held quite well to the truth of history.
Ute Chief Ouray, a real Indian who is mentioned in the book
Of interest: The Ute Indians settled in Colorado prior to the time of Christ. The State of Utah is named for the Utes. There is some interesting information on the Ute and their history at the following link. http://www.southern-ute.nsn.us/history.
“Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell,
a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
I was provided a complimentary review copy of A Love Forbidden in order to render an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own and I was not required to write a favorable review.
The story takes place around 1878-79 in Colorado and involves the Ute Indians, the Indian Agency, troubles of a half-breed Indian, and a single white woman, Shiloh Wainwright, who simply wants to help educate the children of the Ute tribes. She accepts a position teaching the Ute children and settles in the White River Indian Agency in Northwestern Colorado. There she discovers a long-lost childhood friend. Embittered half-breed Jesse who had once worked on Shiloh's father's ranch. In the past they had held a strong friendship, but Jesse had left the ranch under seriously disturbing circumstances.
Shiloh is now caught in the seething tensions of territorial conflict between the U.S. Government - enforced by an unyielding Agency official, and the Ute Indians who do not wish to change their way of life and settle down in the restrictive area of the reservation. Not only is an Indian war brewing, a conflict of hearts and civilizations is brewing between Shiloh and Jesse.
My thoughts: Ms. Morgan deals fairly with the history of the U.S. Government's dealings with the Ute Indians presenting both sides without taking sides. She shows the firm and the tender emotions of each - the Indians and the white settlers. She shows mercy in the hearts of each peoples. She also shows the determination of each to do as they believe is right. She delivers the strong adherence to one's spiritual beliefs in spite of what others might think or do or say. Ms. Morgan shows us, too, how forgiveness is bound up in the healing power of God's love. Forgiveness of others and forgiveness of ourselves.
I liked the characters and found them believable and well developed by Ms. Morgan. The story line was interesting (enough to get me to Google some information online) and held quite well to the truth of history.
Ute Chief Ouray, a real Indian who is mentioned in the bookOf interest: The Ute Indians settled in Colorado prior to the time of Christ. The State of Utah is named for the Utes. There is some interesting information on the Ute and their history at the following link. http://www.southern-ute.nsn.us/history.
“Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell,
a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
I was provided a complimentary review copy of A Love Forbidden in order to render an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own and I was not required to write a favorable review.
May 27, 2012
MY THOUGHTS ON THIS BOOK
When Shiloh Wainright accepts a teaching position at the White River Indian Agency in northwestern Colorado, she never dreamed of catching up with her old childhood best friend Jesse Blackwater. Though she is thrilled to see him again, and see that he is doing well after his abrupt leave almost ten years ago from her families ranch. Could their friendship rekindle now that they were back together, and now that they were nine years older than before?
Trouble is, Shiloh is from a white family and Jesse is half-breed. Half white and half Ute Indian. Which means any attraction they might have toward each other cannot happen. A relationship between the two of them would be unheard of and forbidden.
Kathleen Morgan writes a heartwarming and at the same time heart wrenching story about two people from completely different cultures, two completely different worlds represented here. As we follow Jesse and Shiloh’s story, Kathleen takes us on a journey like no other we’ve been on. The differences between the Ute and white man’s life is nothing to be compared. And with a dad like Jesse’s, being abusive and hating both Jesse and is mother, Jesse could only find acceptance with his mother’s people, the Ute.
Shiloh wasn’t the only one so drawn to Jesse, he was just so adorable! And the hurt he had always suffered, and still was suffering was heartbreaking to read about. It was a hurt that not even Shiloh could help him with. And Shiloh had her own hurt and heartache over what happened to Jesse years ago when he left the ranch.
I had a difficult time getting into this story, but it was because of the information on the Ute Indians, and the background for the story. It was just kind of boring for me. But it then the story took off and I found myself not wanting to put the book down. I was so heartbroken for Jesse that I wanted to make sure everything turn out for him ok. The story is sometimes not so easy to read, I found myself reading, but not taking it in at times because of the nature of the scenes with the Indians trying to defend what they had. Wonderful writing of the author in the vivid details of the Ute’s way of life. And I appreciate the author describing God’s way of salvation so plain and clear, and for showing that only God can break through those barriers and change lives.
I highly recommend this book for anyone wanting a really good read, and especially those who enjoy historical fiction. And if you enjoy a good old Indian story, this one is for you as well!
I received this book from the publisher Revell to read and review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 55
October 25, 2012
first reviewed here: http://belovedgraceful-carissasbooksh...
Title: A Love Forbidden
Author: Kathleen Morgan
Series: Heart of the Rockies
Chapters: 20
Pages: 310
Genre: Christian Historical fiction, Christian Historical Romance, Western romance
Rating: 5 Stars
A Love Forbidden is the second book in the Heart of the Rockies series. It however is not really a true squeal to first book, you could read this book without reading the first if you wanted, but if you’re like me then chances are you read books in order. You First meet Shiloh Wainwright in the first book, but A Love Forbidden is entirely Shiloh’s story.
Shiloh takes a teaching job at the White River Indian Agency to teach the Ute Indian children English. She hopes that the fact that she speaks Ute will allow the Ute to open up to her. In the process she runs into her childhood friend Jesse Blackwater; who is half Ute half white and doesn’t really know where he fits in.
As the second book in the Heart of the Rockies series it is written a little different from the first book. The plot development is different it is a little slower than in the first book. Even though Jesse and Shiloh knew each other before they have to rebuild their friendship. They danger strikes and they are torn apart again. Will things end differently this time? Will Jesse and Shiloh find a place together or will a difference of skin tone and family tear them apart again.
Even though A Forbidden Love was different from A Heart Divided I found myself liking this one even more than the first. That’s what I love about books in a series that are written slightly different, because that way everyone can find something they like. A Forbidden Love has something for everyone action, adventure, and love. There is even a Red Shirt style hero (though you would only get that if you have read Courting Morrow Little by Laura Frantz.) I hope that there is a third book in this series.
I checked this book out from my local library because it looked good. I wrote the review of my own choosing to tell others about this book.
Title: A Love Forbidden
Author: Kathleen Morgan
Series: Heart of the Rockies
Chapters: 20
Pages: 310
Genre: Christian Historical fiction, Christian Historical Romance, Western romance
Rating: 5 Stars
A Love Forbidden is the second book in the Heart of the Rockies series. It however is not really a true squeal to first book, you could read this book without reading the first if you wanted, but if you’re like me then chances are you read books in order. You First meet Shiloh Wainwright in the first book, but A Love Forbidden is entirely Shiloh’s story.
Shiloh takes a teaching job at the White River Indian Agency to teach the Ute Indian children English. She hopes that the fact that she speaks Ute will allow the Ute to open up to her. In the process she runs into her childhood friend Jesse Blackwater; who is half Ute half white and doesn’t really know where he fits in.
As the second book in the Heart of the Rockies series it is written a little different from the first book. The plot development is different it is a little slower than in the first book. Even though Jesse and Shiloh knew each other before they have to rebuild their friendship. They danger strikes and they are torn apart again. Will things end differently this time? Will Jesse and Shiloh find a place together or will a difference of skin tone and family tear them apart again.
Even though A Forbidden Love was different from A Heart Divided I found myself liking this one even more than the first. That’s what I love about books in a series that are written slightly different, because that way everyone can find something they like. A Forbidden Love has something for everyone action, adventure, and love. There is even a Red Shirt style hero (though you would only get that if you have read Courting Morrow Little by Laura Frantz.) I hope that there is a third book in this series.
I checked this book out from my local library because it looked good. I wrote the review of my own choosing to tell others about this book.
May 21, 2012
Kathleen Morgan is such a talented writer. I've read many of her books and have enjoyed each and every one unfortunately A Love Forbidden was not one of my favorites. This series started off with a bang in the form of A Heart Divided with perfect chemistry between the characters, great message in what I felt to be a very entertaining Christian romance. Book 2 I'm afraid suffers from the dreaded sophomore slump. It's not the characters, both Shiloh and Jesse are very likable and I wanted them to overcome the obstacles that were in their way and rekindle their friendship. It was very interesting to read about the conflict between the US government and the Utes but since this is labeled as historical romance I wanted more of Shiloh and Jesse's back story! I would have loved to have read more about their interaction as a young girl and boy and just HOW they became to be such strong friends rather than the short prologue showing why Jesse left the Wainwright ranch. My feeling is it would have made it more believable for her to have been held up on him so far into her adulthood like she was. There are bits and pieces of both their past's scattered throughout the book but in spite if it all I thought when I turned the last page that there was so much more I wanted! I'm not saying this is a bad book because it isn't, but I suggest A Heart Divided if you're looking for a great romance by this author. I'm very much looking forward to reading book three in this series and hopefully find out what's going on in the lives of the other Wainright siblings, Nick and Jordan!
*I received my complimentary copy from the publisher in exchange for posting my review for the tour. I was not compensated in any way.*
*I received my complimentary copy from the publisher in exchange for posting my review for the tour. I was not compensated in any way.*
May 25, 2012
This is the first book I’ve read written by Kathleen Morgan and it won’t be the last. From the very first page to the last there wasn’t one page that wasn’t interesting and I was so eager to read, but hated the book to end.
Usually in some books you have some parts that you skip over that aren’t exciting or help the story in any way, but A Love Forbidden was wonderful in every page and every line.
I really like how deep Shiloh’s love runs for Jesse and the Indian people. She puts others ahead of herself and thinks of how she can help.
This book is full of love, acceptance and forgiveness. It also shows us how we can let things remain in our lives, like hurts and bad feelings until they grow out of control and how the only way to get rid of these feelings is to turn it all over to God.
This book A Love Forbidden is a Historical Romance and it tells of the Indians and how things happened in the late 1800’s for both white and Indian. It gives you a look at how hard it was for a white person and indian person to marry or have a life together. This book is a wonderful story and I highly recommend it for all.
“Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
I received my free copy from Donna Hausler from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group for my review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255
Usually in some books you have some parts that you skip over that aren’t exciting or help the story in any way, but A Love Forbidden was wonderful in every page and every line.
I really like how deep Shiloh’s love runs for Jesse and the Indian people. She puts others ahead of herself and thinks of how she can help.
This book is full of love, acceptance and forgiveness. It also shows us how we can let things remain in our lives, like hurts and bad feelings until they grow out of control and how the only way to get rid of these feelings is to turn it all over to God.
This book A Love Forbidden is a Historical Romance and it tells of the Indians and how things happened in the late 1800’s for both white and Indian. It gives you a look at how hard it was for a white person and indian person to marry or have a life together. This book is a wonderful story and I highly recommend it for all.
“Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
I received my free copy from Donna Hausler from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group for my review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255
January 23, 2016
A LOVE FORBIDDEN was a good story, especially for those with historical interests. But, as for the romance, it left me a little bit wanting.
Shiloh Wainwright enjoys adventure and wants to use her teaching skills for good. When she accepts a job to teach Ute Indian children, she realizes only upon her arrival that she wasn’t told about the obstacles that were plaguing the Agency encampment. Convincing the Ute’s to allow their children to be taught by the same people who are forcing them to give up their land might be more than she can overcome. When Shiloh unexpectedly runs into Jesse Blackwater, a friend from her childhood, old feelings she thought she’d dealt with quickly come to the surface.
Jesse Blackwater, is a half-Ute who worked on the Wainwright ranch. In fact, it was an incident on Shiloh’s family ranch that convinced him he would rather live with his People than in the white man’s world. Knowing an uprising is sure to happen, Jesse denies his rekindled feelings for Shiloh and does his best to convince her to leave.
A LOVE FORBIDDEN had all the elements for a good love story but not quite the intensity. I really liked the characters of Jesse and Shiloh but wished the author would’ve given us a better glimpse into the relationship that grew between them as kids. I prefer more interaction between the leads in a romantic book. Keeping relationships at arm’s-length for too long only tends to frustrate me.
Book provided for review purposes.
“Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
Shiloh Wainwright enjoys adventure and wants to use her teaching skills for good. When she accepts a job to teach Ute Indian children, she realizes only upon her arrival that she wasn’t told about the obstacles that were plaguing the Agency encampment. Convincing the Ute’s to allow their children to be taught by the same people who are forcing them to give up their land might be more than she can overcome. When Shiloh unexpectedly runs into Jesse Blackwater, a friend from her childhood, old feelings she thought she’d dealt with quickly come to the surface.
Jesse Blackwater, is a half-Ute who worked on the Wainwright ranch. In fact, it was an incident on Shiloh’s family ranch that convinced him he would rather live with his People than in the white man’s world. Knowing an uprising is sure to happen, Jesse denies his rekindled feelings for Shiloh and does his best to convince her to leave.
A LOVE FORBIDDEN had all the elements for a good love story but not quite the intensity. I really liked the characters of Jesse and Shiloh but wished the author would’ve given us a better glimpse into the relationship that grew between them as kids. I prefer more interaction between the leads in a romantic book. Keeping relationships at arm’s-length for too long only tends to frustrate me.
Book provided for review purposes.
“Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
May 19, 2012
Title: A LOVE FORBIDDEN
Author: Kathleen Morgan
Publisher: Revell
May 2012
ISBN: 978-0-8007-1971-5
Genre: Inspirational/historical
Shiloh Wainwright fell in love with a young man who worked on her father’s ranch when she was a young girl. But he was a “half-breed” and after being falsely accused of attacking the boss’ older daughter, he was whipped and sent away. Now, Shiloh is a grown woman and she has a love for Indians. This takes her to an Indian Agency in Colorado. Shiloh hopes to improve the lives of Ute Indian children.
But, her new job isn’t all sunshine and roses. Shiloh soon finds herself caught in the cross-fire between the Utes, their Indian agent, and the US government. Her unexpected encounter with her family’s former employee, Jesse Blackwater, only complicates matters.
As tensions spiral, will Jesse and Shiloh find love? Or will the catastrophic uprising tear them apart?
A LOVE FORBIDDEN is the latest by award winning author, Kathleen Morgan. I was drawn into the story from the very first pages, though my heart broke for Jesse. I had to find out what happened and hoped that Jesse and Shiloh would find a way to be together.
Ms. Morgan is definitely a talented author, and one that I can recommend if you like historical fiction. She takes characters that should be impossible to find common ground, and throws them together. The resulting story is a page-turner. Loosely based on real events—my favorite type of historical. $14.99. 310 pages.
Author: Kathleen Morgan
Publisher: Revell
May 2012
ISBN: 978-0-8007-1971-5
Genre: Inspirational/historical
Shiloh Wainwright fell in love with a young man who worked on her father’s ranch when she was a young girl. But he was a “half-breed” and after being falsely accused of attacking the boss’ older daughter, he was whipped and sent away. Now, Shiloh is a grown woman and she has a love for Indians. This takes her to an Indian Agency in Colorado. Shiloh hopes to improve the lives of Ute Indian children.
But, her new job isn’t all sunshine and roses. Shiloh soon finds herself caught in the cross-fire between the Utes, their Indian agent, and the US government. Her unexpected encounter with her family’s former employee, Jesse Blackwater, only complicates matters.
As tensions spiral, will Jesse and Shiloh find love? Or will the catastrophic uprising tear them apart?
A LOVE FORBIDDEN is the latest by award winning author, Kathleen Morgan. I was drawn into the story from the very first pages, though my heart broke for Jesse. I had to find out what happened and hoped that Jesse and Shiloh would find a way to be together.
Ms. Morgan is definitely a talented author, and one that I can recommend if you like historical fiction. She takes characters that should be impossible to find common ground, and throws them together. The resulting story is a page-turner. Loosely based on real events—my favorite type of historical. $14.99. 310 pages.
August 14, 2015
I didn't like this book as well as the first book in the series. While I did enjoy the historical look at the area and the difficulties between the Indian nation and the Agency, that's about all the book had going for it. Most of the secondary characters were annoying and selfish and at times Jesse and Shiloh did not act in a realistic manner. The book was very slow moving at times and didn't hold my attention much. The romance was practically non-existent, as we got background on Jesse and Shiloh in little snippets, and they waffled between hatred and love for one another. The ending also was vaguely unsatisfying to me, after all that we had invested in the book. Not sure I am going to continue to read the author's work after this one.
February 21, 2014
I wish I could give this one 3.5 stars because I did enjoy the story and liked both of the lead characters. I was a bit disappointed, though, in how little of the relationship we actually see of Jesse and Shiloh. When Shiloh spoke of the past between them, I kept thinking that I wish it would have been written into the book instead of just talked about. Also, I like a lot more interaction between the couples involved in the romance. Jesse and Shiloh spent so much time apart that it was hard to get into the romance. There was a lot of history about the Utes and the conflict with the government which was both interesting and heartbreaking.
April 8, 2019
A Love Forbidden had great tension and turmoil. Right from the start, Jesse and Shiloh's history established a very upsetting foundation for their relationship. Then later on, the situation Shiloh walked in to as a teacher was tenuous. The unpleasant relations between the Utes and the whites made everything unpredictable and filled with impossible choices. Shiloh was an excellent example of what it means to stick to your beliefs even if you feel your heart calling you in a different direction. She was also a teacher who we never got to see teach throughout the entire book. Overall, it was a good story with a lot of ups and downs and hard things to work through. The ending was hopeful and pleasant. I still felt like Shiloh and Jesse had a lot of things to work through and questions that remained unanswered despite their reconciliation. I wish there had been more cross over with character's stories from the first book. It would have been nice to see more about where Jordan's future was heading or maybe learn a little more about what Nick was up to. You could have given them more of a side story to round out the main story. I did really like reading about Shiloh and Jesse's stories within this tense time in history.
February 27, 2024
I really liked this one! It took me multiple years to finally pick it up, but I'm glad I finally did!
I liked Shiloh as a character, and the way her personality just fits with Jesse's is delightful. I liked her desire to help people, and how she was willing to stand up for herself in order to do this.
I also liked how the relationship develops between Shiloh and her sister, Jordan.
It was also really cool to see a fictionalised retelling of an actual event in American history, which took place at the Indian Reservation that Shiloh goes to work at.
Throughout the book, I didn't really know how I wanted the relationship between Shiloh and Jesse to develop. Based on the various reasons they give in their POV chapters, part of me wanted to see them end up together, and part of me didn't.
I liked Shiloh as a character, and the way her personality just fits with Jesse's is delightful. I liked her desire to help people, and how she was willing to stand up for herself in order to do this.
I also liked how the relationship develops between Shiloh and her sister, Jordan.
It was also really cool to see a fictionalised retelling of an actual event in American history, which took place at the Indian Reservation that Shiloh goes to work at.
Throughout the book, I didn't really know how I wanted the relationship between Shiloh and Jesse to develop. Based on the various reasons they give in their POV chapters, part of me wanted to see them end up together, and part of me didn't.
August 30, 2020
Although I loved the romance part of the book I fear the political issues in it were bot handled with enough care. It was so rough at some parts that I would literally cringe and have to put the book down for a couple days. I am not saying the book was terrible, I have lived every K. Morgan book I have read. This one just was not quite my cup of tea.
November 25, 2022
Thoroughly Enjoyed This Book!
This is a story that will keep you captivated. It has some historical events intertwined in it which add greatly to the story! It has the love and forgiveness of God and loyalty to family and one’s heritage at the heart, as well as prejudices and pain to overcome. Read and enjoy. I promise you it will be worth your time!
This is a story that will keep you captivated. It has some historical events intertwined in it which add greatly to the story! It has the love and forgiveness of God and loyalty to family and one’s heritage at the heart, as well as prejudices and pain to overcome. Read and enjoy. I promise you it will be worth your time!
November 27, 2018
After reading the first book in this series I almost didn’t read this second one. However the idea of a love story involving a white woman and a Native American male always intrigues me. I’m glad I gave it a chance. It drew me in much more and the plot was so much more interesting.
July 12, 2017
Did not like this book, I just couldn't get into the characters
July 30, 2017
Very good book. I love all of Kathleen's books.
June 7, 2018
Jesse and Shiloh
A few good parts with boring parts in between.
A few good parts with boring parts in between.
July 5, 2018
This book didn't pull me in like the first one in the series did. I found myself skimming through some of it.
December 4, 2023
Not well connected to the landscape. A bit overly simplistic.
June 24, 2024
Kathleen Morgan has done it again! Another riveting and exciting tale of a Wainwright! I absolutely loved reading this book, and had my heart in my throat the entire time!
May 20, 2012
A Love Forbidden by Kathleen Morgan immerses readers in the majestic Colorado Rockies during the era of tumultuous relations between Native American tribes and settlers. The plot is fraught with danger and tension with some unexpected detours along the way. I initially expected more focus to be placed on Shiloh's attempts to educate the Ute children, but a significant portion of the novel is spent away from the Indian camps. The deteriorating Indian-white relations ignite a rapid plot progression during the second half of the novel. After learning in the Author's Note that some of the events were based on historical accounts, the tragedy became more real and heartbreaking. While reading the novel, I felt a bit detached from the emotional turmoil that certain events would have caused. Shiloh witnessed disturbing scenes but seemed to have little difficulty healing, and her emotions focused more on her relationship with Jesse. Shiloh's strength and bravery is admirable, as well as her unwillingness to sacrifice her faith for Jesse's love. She faces each challenge resolutely, but I would have connected more with her character by witnessing more of her deep emotions and weaknesses.
Through Jesse's character, Morgan shows the vast differences between the Ute and white ways of life. Jesse has experienced life in both cultures, but faces an inner battle when he must decide where he belongs. As an adult, Jesse embraces the Ute faith and turns his back on his childhood Christian beliefs. The insights into his past make it easy to sympathize with his struggle to choose between life with the Utes and life with Shiloh; life with one means life without the other. A transformation in Jesse's faith is the key to his inner peace and future happiness and is pivotal in the ultimate outcome of the novel. I find it more impactful to witness life-changing events in a novel, but Jesse's decision to re-embrace the Christian faith is recounted in a conversation. Regardless, the ending is pleasing and hopefully Morgan will revisit Shiloh and Jesse into future novels.
Kathleen Morgan weaves messages of forgiveness and healing throughout the plot while incorporating romance and a breathtaking landscape. She blends historical events into the fictional plot and conveys a factual account of the events leading up to the Meeker Massacre without overwhelming the reader. A Love Forbidden is an enjoyable read with some classic western excitement that will keep readers turning the pages.
Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Revell through their book review program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed above are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Through Jesse's character, Morgan shows the vast differences between the Ute and white ways of life. Jesse has experienced life in both cultures, but faces an inner battle when he must decide where he belongs. As an adult, Jesse embraces the Ute faith and turns his back on his childhood Christian beliefs. The insights into his past make it easy to sympathize with his struggle to choose between life with the Utes and life with Shiloh; life with one means life without the other. A transformation in Jesse's faith is the key to his inner peace and future happiness and is pivotal in the ultimate outcome of the novel. I find it more impactful to witness life-changing events in a novel, but Jesse's decision to re-embrace the Christian faith is recounted in a conversation. Regardless, the ending is pleasing and hopefully Morgan will revisit Shiloh and Jesse into future novels.
Kathleen Morgan weaves messages of forgiveness and healing throughout the plot while incorporating romance and a breathtaking landscape. She blends historical events into the fictional plot and conveys a factual account of the events leading up to the Meeker Massacre without overwhelming the reader. A Love Forbidden is an enjoyable read with some classic western excitement that will keep readers turning the pages.
Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Revell through their book review program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed above are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
May 25, 2012
Kathleen Morgan in her new book, “A Love Forbidden” Book Two in the Heart Of The Rockies series published by Revell takes us to the Colorado Rockies in 1879.
From the Back Cover: They’re from two different worlds. Can love cross the divide?
Moved by a compassionate heart and the desire for adventure, twenty-year-old Shiloh Wainwright impulsively accepts a teaching position at the White River Indian Agency in northwestern Colorado. Eager to use her skills to help improve the lives of Ute Indian children, she looks forward to a fulfilling, independent life on the Colorado frontier.
But her new job isn’t what she imagined it would be, and Shiloh soon finds herself caught in the cross fire between the Utes, their unyielding Indian agent, and a demanding US government. Her unexpected encounter with a half-Ute childhood friend, Jesse Blackwater, only complicates matters as they battle their growing feelings for each other amidst spiraling tensions that threaten to explode into a catastrophic uprising. Set amongst the wilds of the Colorado Rockies in 1879, this tale from bestselling and award-winning author Kathleen Morgan explores the transformational power of forgiveness, compassion, and God’s healing love with artistry and authenticity.
A white woman who is a teacher and a half-breed Indian try t build a relationship in a time when the whites and the Indians are not getting along. Once again Ms. Morgan examines a complicated relationship in ”A Love Forbidden”. For this relationship to grow and survive only God can make it happen. ”A Love Forbidden” is more than just a love story it is a story of history and it is a thriller as we do not know who will survive in the events leading up to the Meeker Massacre. Ms. Morgan does an outstanding job of taking us back in time and developing the prejudice and feelings of that time. Ms. Morgan is an excellent writer and makes all her characters believable and you care deeply for them as she deftly unfolds the plot before us. This is a nice romance with great themes. I am looking forward to the next book.
If you would like to listen to interviews with other authors and professionals please go to www.kingdomhighlights.org where they are available On Demand.
To listen to 24 Christian music please visit our internet radio station www.kingdomairwaves.org
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Revell Publishers. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
From the Back Cover: They’re from two different worlds. Can love cross the divide?
Moved by a compassionate heart and the desire for adventure, twenty-year-old Shiloh Wainwright impulsively accepts a teaching position at the White River Indian Agency in northwestern Colorado. Eager to use her skills to help improve the lives of Ute Indian children, she looks forward to a fulfilling, independent life on the Colorado frontier.
But her new job isn’t what she imagined it would be, and Shiloh soon finds herself caught in the cross fire between the Utes, their unyielding Indian agent, and a demanding US government. Her unexpected encounter with a half-Ute childhood friend, Jesse Blackwater, only complicates matters as they battle their growing feelings for each other amidst spiraling tensions that threaten to explode into a catastrophic uprising. Set amongst the wilds of the Colorado Rockies in 1879, this tale from bestselling and award-winning author Kathleen Morgan explores the transformational power of forgiveness, compassion, and God’s healing love with artistry and authenticity.
A white woman who is a teacher and a half-breed Indian try t build a relationship in a time when the whites and the Indians are not getting along. Once again Ms. Morgan examines a complicated relationship in ”A Love Forbidden”. For this relationship to grow and survive only God can make it happen. ”A Love Forbidden” is more than just a love story it is a story of history and it is a thriller as we do not know who will survive in the events leading up to the Meeker Massacre. Ms. Morgan does an outstanding job of taking us back in time and developing the prejudice and feelings of that time. Ms. Morgan is an excellent writer and makes all her characters believable and you care deeply for them as she deftly unfolds the plot before us. This is a nice romance with great themes. I am looking forward to the next book.
If you would like to listen to interviews with other authors and professionals please go to www.kingdomhighlights.org where they are available On Demand.
To listen to 24 Christian music please visit our internet radio station www.kingdomairwaves.org
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Revell Publishers. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
May 25, 2012
A Love Forbidden is the second book in the Heart of the Rockies series, the first being A Heart Divided. After reading and greatly enjoying the first book, I had very high expectations for this book. Unfortunately, even though the story was still good, I was a little let down with it.
I loved the characters of Nick and Cord in A Heart Divided, but they played such a small role in this book. When they were mentioned, which was hardly ever, they didn't even seem like the same people.
There was a bit of a discrepancy between the books in regards to the age difference between Shiloh and her sister Jordan. In A Heart Divided it says that they are almost 4 years apart in age (pg 204?), yet in the beginning of A Love Forbidden, when they are both children, it says that Shiloh is 12 years old and Jordan is 14 years old. To me that makes them 2 years apart and at max you could say they are almost 3 years apart - I don't see any way they could be 4 years apart. Also, when Jordan was 14, it says that she caught the breath of every man who saw her. Now I don't know about you, but I think that 14 is a bit young for grown men to be interested in her - in fact, I think it's gross.
I thought that the strained relationship between Shiloh and Jordan was very well written and very believable. In the beginning of the book, Jordan is a person that is very hard to like and the way Shiloh feels towards her is completely understandable. However, by the end of the book, after learning more about Jordan, I started to like her.
I loved the fact that the author used a historical site as the setting of this book. I had never heard of it before, but it was very interesting to learn about it and also more about Native American life in the late 1800's.
The ending of the book was very abrupt and left many things unclear. I would say what was left unclear, but I don't want to ruin parts of the story for you - in case you decide to read it. Even if there will be a third book in this series, I don't think it justifies leaving the ending the way it did.
I still greatly enjoyed A Love Forbidden and would recommend this series.
***I received a complimentary copy of this book to review. I was asked to give my honest opinion of the book - which I have done.***
“Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
I loved the characters of Nick and Cord in A Heart Divided, but they played such a small role in this book. When they were mentioned, which was hardly ever, they didn't even seem like the same people.
There was a bit of a discrepancy between the books in regards to the age difference between Shiloh and her sister Jordan. In A Heart Divided it says that they are almost 4 years apart in age (pg 204?), yet in the beginning of A Love Forbidden, when they are both children, it says that Shiloh is 12 years old and Jordan is 14 years old. To me that makes them 2 years apart and at max you could say they are almost 3 years apart - I don't see any way they could be 4 years apart. Also, when Jordan was 14, it says that she caught the breath of every man who saw her. Now I don't know about you, but I think that 14 is a bit young for grown men to be interested in her - in fact, I think it's gross.
I thought that the strained relationship between Shiloh and Jordan was very well written and very believable. In the beginning of the book, Jordan is a person that is very hard to like and the way Shiloh feels towards her is completely understandable. However, by the end of the book, after learning more about Jordan, I started to like her.
I loved the fact that the author used a historical site as the setting of this book. I had never heard of it before, but it was very interesting to learn about it and also more about Native American life in the late 1800's.
The ending of the book was very abrupt and left many things unclear. I would say what was left unclear, but I don't want to ruin parts of the story for you - in case you decide to read it. Even if there will be a third book in this series, I don't think it justifies leaving the ending the way it did.
I still greatly enjoyed A Love Forbidden and would recommend this series.
***I received a complimentary copy of this book to review. I was asked to give my honest opinion of the book - which I have done.***
“Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.”
September 2, 2012
"A Love Forbidden" is the second in the Heart of the Rockies series by Kathleen Morgan. Morgan is an experienced writer, and you may recognize her name from some of her earlier series, such as These Highland Hills or Brides of Culdee Creek.
This particular series is one you can jump into mid-stream and never know you missed the first book. I didn't have the opportunity to read book one, "A Heart Divided," and didn't realize it until just now. I love it when an author does such a good job of including back story that, as a reader, we don't feel left out!
In "A Love Forbidden," the main character, Shiloh Wainwright, decides to go into Colorado Territory to educate the Ute Indian children. The book is set during the time the U.S. government was hustling American Indians out of their native homes and into reservations. Battles ensue, and tension is high. Meanwhile, Shiloh comes back into contact with Jesse, a man she met many years ago when he worked at her parents' ranch. As half-Ute, half-white, Jesse doesn't easily fit in and their relationship promises to be rocky right from the beginning. It gets much more difficult when the Utes attack the American fort, massacring the agency employees and taking the women hostage. Shiloh is one of those women. As was common at that time, as a captive she was about to be taken as an unwilling "wife" of one of the Indian warriors. In the nick of time, Jesse steps in and takes her as a wife instead. At this point, the story really begins for me. As a married couple, they must work through many issues, including that during a battle he chooses to fight with the Indians against the white man, which is Shiloh's people. Other issues include the fact that Shiloh feels a great need for a church wedding, while Jesse feels that the Ute way of taking a wife is perfectly acceptable and refuses to a wedding white-style.
Unbeknownst to me, the book is based on a true story. I appreciated the author writing the story as if it were entirely fictional, then clarifying in the end which points were factual. This allowed me to dive into the story without constantly second-guessing which parts were fact versus fiction.
I highly recommend this book, and by extension, the first book "A Heart Divided," which I haven't yet had a chance to read. I was able to do some research and saw the plot for "A Heart Divided" looked very exciting.
This book was a complimentary copy from the publisher in exchange for an objective review.
This particular series is one you can jump into mid-stream and never know you missed the first book. I didn't have the opportunity to read book one, "A Heart Divided," and didn't realize it until just now. I love it when an author does such a good job of including back story that, as a reader, we don't feel left out!
In "A Love Forbidden," the main character, Shiloh Wainwright, decides to go into Colorado Territory to educate the Ute Indian children. The book is set during the time the U.S. government was hustling American Indians out of their native homes and into reservations. Battles ensue, and tension is high. Meanwhile, Shiloh comes back into contact with Jesse, a man she met many years ago when he worked at her parents' ranch. As half-Ute, half-white, Jesse doesn't easily fit in and their relationship promises to be rocky right from the beginning. It gets much more difficult when the Utes attack the American fort, massacring the agency employees and taking the women hostage. Shiloh is one of those women. As was common at that time, as a captive she was about to be taken as an unwilling "wife" of one of the Indian warriors. In the nick of time, Jesse steps in and takes her as a wife instead. At this point, the story really begins for me. As a married couple, they must work through many issues, including that during a battle he chooses to fight with the Indians against the white man, which is Shiloh's people. Other issues include the fact that Shiloh feels a great need for a church wedding, while Jesse feels that the Ute way of taking a wife is perfectly acceptable and refuses to a wedding white-style.
Unbeknownst to me, the book is based on a true story. I appreciated the author writing the story as if it were entirely fictional, then clarifying in the end which points were factual. This allowed me to dive into the story without constantly second-guessing which parts were fact versus fiction.
I highly recommend this book, and by extension, the first book "A Heart Divided," which I haven't yet had a chance to read. I was able to do some research and saw the plot for "A Heart Divided" looked very exciting.
This book was a complimentary copy from the publisher in exchange for an objective review.
June 1, 2012
A Love Forbidden (Book 2 in the Heart of the Rockies series) is a compelling, historical novel filled with elements of adventure, tension, faith, and romance. The book seemed a little slow at first, but things really picked up about a third of the way in. That's where the story really grabbed my interest, and I was pulled into the action. There were several tense moments throughout the book, as well as the passionate moments that romance fans love!
Kathleen Morgan has done a fantastic job filling the pages with historical details, realistic characters, and an interesting plot. The story certainly depicts a difficult time in U.S. history where tensions were high between the Native Americans and the U.S. government. Morgan has combined this historical element beautifully with her fictional creation, and the tensions and difficulties clearing come across the page -- leaving the reader full of anticipation for what will happen next.
Shiloh and Jesse are realistic and enjoyable characters, and I found their relationship to move along at a believable pace, while at the same time a little frustrating because of its back-and-forth nature. I would get the impression that the relationship was going in one direction, and then it would go the other way. Despite this, their struggles seemed natural as they both tried to navigate their way through the uncertainty of their relationship. It was this aspect that kept me guessing until the very end.
The faith aspect to the story is perfectly done, and Morgan does a wonderful job weaving the message of Christ's salvation, love, and forgiveness throughout the story. It's nice to see how this plays out for Shiloh, as well as Jesse.
Despite the slow start, the story really picked up, to the point where I couldn't put the book down! I found this to be a satisfying read, and would recommend it those who enjoy historical novels set during the late 1800's, as well as those who love a sweet, clean romance.
** Thank you to Revell for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for my fair and honest review. **
** Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.**
Kathleen Morgan has done a fantastic job filling the pages with historical details, realistic characters, and an interesting plot. The story certainly depicts a difficult time in U.S. history where tensions were high between the Native Americans and the U.S. government. Morgan has combined this historical element beautifully with her fictional creation, and the tensions and difficulties clearing come across the page -- leaving the reader full of anticipation for what will happen next.
Shiloh and Jesse are realistic and enjoyable characters, and I found their relationship to move along at a believable pace, while at the same time a little frustrating because of its back-and-forth nature. I would get the impression that the relationship was going in one direction, and then it would go the other way. Despite this, their struggles seemed natural as they both tried to navigate their way through the uncertainty of their relationship. It was this aspect that kept me guessing until the very end.
The faith aspect to the story is perfectly done, and Morgan does a wonderful job weaving the message of Christ's salvation, love, and forgiveness throughout the story. It's nice to see how this plays out for Shiloh, as well as Jesse.
Despite the slow start, the story really picked up, to the point where I couldn't put the book down! I found this to be a satisfying read, and would recommend it those who enjoy historical novels set during the late 1800's, as well as those who love a sweet, clean romance.
** Thank you to Revell for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for my fair and honest review. **
** Available May 2012 at your favorite bookseller from Revell, a division of Baker Publishing Group.**
May 24, 2012
As a young girl of 12, Shiloh Wainwright befriends a Ute Indian named Jesse, a hired ranch hand. 17 year old Jesse is a 'half breed', part Ute, part White and is not treated very kindly among the white community apart from his friendship with Shiloh.
False accusations come against Jesse and he is punished unfairly, whipped and beaten. Shiloh intervenes just shy of Jesse's death. Jesse gathers himself and leaves, never returns but is always near Shiloh's heart.
9 years later, educated Shiloh heads out to an Indian Reservation to teach the Ute Indian children. Relations have been tense between the Utes and US Gov Agency located in the Colorado Rocky's where Shiloh is to teach. The Utes are not allowing their children to be taught the 'white' ways, though the Agency and Shiloh believe it is a way to preserve the Ute Nation by giving them the ability to read and write. Shiloh's job is to convince the different tribes represented to allow their children to be taught under her.
Rivalry continues in other ways as the Agency and Ute tribes differ in lifestyle and the way they want to live. the Gov continues to infringe on the land and the Utes rights, causing a great deal of tension.
In the middle of that tension is Jesse, now living among his Ute relations and rejecting the White that streams through his blood.
Racial injustices and differences have been a theme for the world since the early Bible times, which must greatly sadden the Creators heart. In this novel we see the injustice by the early Indian reservations and the fight between the whites and Ute. Shiloh and Jesse caught in the middle. A love forbidden, and not acknowledged for fear between Shiloh and Jesse. I love how Kathleen Morgan shows a realistic, historical background in this 1800's setting. The characters where well developed and often the book read as if I was watching a movie with a similar plot, just lost in the adventure and the hope of reconciliation. Sometimes you want to root for Jesse, others you want to kick him! Shiloh is the heroine throughout and she has such a great fire and red headed nature about her, the only kind that would survive this environment.
A book about forgiveness and God making a way!
I received a copy of this book from Revell in exchange for an honest review.
False accusations come against Jesse and he is punished unfairly, whipped and beaten. Shiloh intervenes just shy of Jesse's death. Jesse gathers himself and leaves, never returns but is always near Shiloh's heart.
9 years later, educated Shiloh heads out to an Indian Reservation to teach the Ute Indian children. Relations have been tense between the Utes and US Gov Agency located in the Colorado Rocky's where Shiloh is to teach. The Utes are not allowing their children to be taught the 'white' ways, though the Agency and Shiloh believe it is a way to preserve the Ute Nation by giving them the ability to read and write. Shiloh's job is to convince the different tribes represented to allow their children to be taught under her.
Rivalry continues in other ways as the Agency and Ute tribes differ in lifestyle and the way they want to live. the Gov continues to infringe on the land and the Utes rights, causing a great deal of tension.
In the middle of that tension is Jesse, now living among his Ute relations and rejecting the White that streams through his blood.
Racial injustices and differences have been a theme for the world since the early Bible times, which must greatly sadden the Creators heart. In this novel we see the injustice by the early Indian reservations and the fight between the whites and Ute. Shiloh and Jesse caught in the middle. A love forbidden, and not acknowledged for fear between Shiloh and Jesse. I love how Kathleen Morgan shows a realistic, historical background in this 1800's setting. The characters where well developed and often the book read as if I was watching a movie with a similar plot, just lost in the adventure and the hope of reconciliation. Sometimes you want to root for Jesse, others you want to kick him! Shiloh is the heroine throughout and she has such a great fire and red headed nature about her, the only kind that would survive this environment.
A book about forgiveness and God making a way!
I received a copy of this book from Revell in exchange for an honest review.
May 21, 2012
3.5 Stars
I was really drawn in by the summary of this one, I really like reading this type of story in this time period and setting. However, the story seemed a little slow for me. I really wanted to like it, but I kept finding myself trudging through lots of political facts when i wanted to read about the feelings of the characters. The book is based on real events, so I can see how the author got caught up in explaining all the facts of the situations. However, I would have preferred those events to have been the backdrop for the love story instead of the other way around.
Even though I didn't really think there was enough of it, I thought that the romance was extremely well done. I really felt the chemistry between Jesse and Shiloh. I loved that they had a history together, and I think that really strengthened their bond. Their scenes together were so believable and it was easy to be caught up in their love story. Unfortunately, the rest of the book moved rather slowly for my tastes.
Wow, was Jesse stubborn! There was one part of the book where another character advises Shiloh that if Jesse didn't fight for her then that tells her that he's not that interested. And honestly, there were only one or two times where I felt like he did stand up and fight for her, and all the other times he ran fast in the other direction. He asked Shiloh to give up a lot and never really showed her how much he wanted her. Interesting things to ponder in my opinion.
I liked seeing Shiloh show real emotion about her sister, Jordan, who had done some very bad things. A lot of times in inspirational fiction, the characters aren't shown to have such real feelings of resentment and anger. It was nice to see her have real feelings instead of glossed-over and goody-goody feelings. It was more real and meaningful when she was able to come to terms with her sister and their past.
I thought that I would enjoy this book more, since I really like reading about the setting and era. However, I did have fun seeing the sparks fly between the two leads.
book sent by publisher in exchange for honest review
reviewed for http://inthehammockblog.blogspot.com
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews