I learned recently in a review that The Poky Little Puppy is considered a classic Little Golden Book beloved of children everywhere. As it happened, indeed as it often happens in these circumstances, a copy then fell into my hands during one of my street library rambles. And while I learned of story’s reputation I didn’t realise how old it is. The Poky Little Puppy is one of the twelve stories first published in October 1942 when Little Golden Books were launched. *
The Poky Little Puppy is the biggest selling children’s story in American history; the only one of the original twelve included in the 75th anniversary boxed set.
So why is it so good? Or is it? The story concerns five puppies who go adventuring in the wide, wide world after they dig a hole under the fence (the illustrations by Gustaf Tenggren are charming). On their adventures they discover animals and insects; a lizard, a brown hop-toad, a little grass snake. Except for the poky little puppy who lurks behind attracted by the smells of supper; rice pudding, chocolate custard and such. The four puppies miss out on supper because their mother is cross with their hole digging, but by staying behind the poky little puppy gets to eat the goodies. This routine is repeated several times until the four puppies reform, fill in the hole and get to eat strawberry shortcake. This time the poky little puppy, coming back late, misses out, feels sorry for himself and sees the writing on the fence – no dessert for digging dogs.
So what does it mean? Puppies should not be adventurous? Mother is always right? Her food choices are certainly not suitable for dogs in my view. A puppy can’t get away with mischievous behaviour forever? I readily admit I am way out at the wrong end of the demographic for this story, but I was puzzled. Maybe it’s an American thing.
* The twelve stories published in 1942 are:
1. Three Little Kittens, by Marie Simchow Stern
2. Bedtime Stories, illus. Gustaf Tenggren
3. Mother Goose, by Phyllis Fraser, illus. Gertrude E. Espenscheid
4. Prayers for Children, by Rachel Taft Dixon
5. The Little Red Hen, illus. Rudolf Freund
6. Nursery Songs, by Leah Gale, illus. Corinne Malvern
7. The Alphabet from A to Z, by Leah Gale, illus. Vivienne Blake and Richard Peck
8. The Poky Little Puppy, by Janette Sebring Lowrey, illus. Gustaf Tenggren
9. The Golden Book of Fairy Tales, by Winfield Scott Hoskins
10. Baby's Book of Objects
11. The Animals of Farmer Jones, by Leah Gale, illus. Richard Scarry
12. This Little Piggy and Other Counting Rhymes, by Phyllis Cerf Wagner, illus. Roberta Harris Pfafflin Petty