Title : The Dancing Turtle
Author: Pleasant DeSpain
Illustrator : David Boston
Genre: Myth
Theme(s): Music, Dance, Family, Jungle/Forest, Animals, Promises, Cleverness, Hunting Killing, Tribes, Suspense, Uncertainty
Opening line/sentence (type directly from text): Long ago, on the banks of the mighty Amazon River, Turtle played her flute while enjoying the sun.
Brief Book Summary :This story is about a turtle who can play the flute and dance, the turtle is captured and brought back to a tribe and locked in a cage. The turtle tricks the children of the tribe to let him out of the cage to play music and then naps. The turtle escapes and the story ends with the father of the children going out to hunt for the turtle again.
Professional Recommendation/Review #1: Julie Corsaro (Booklist, May 1, 1998 (Vol. 94, No. 17))
DeSpain's extensive storytelling experience comes through in this well-honed trickster tale from Latin America. It opens in the Brazilian rain forest as a flute-playing turtle is captured by a hungry man. Locked in a cage, Turtle tells the man's children that she will dance for them if they let her out. Turtle twirls, bobs, weaves, jumps, and crawls. Then pretending to be hot and tired, she escapes. The quality of the artwork isn't up to that of the text. However, the paintings, dominated by shades of green and punctuated by reds, oranges, and yellows, capture the diverse flora and fauna (people included) of theregion. This lighthearted tale ends on an understanding note as theboy and girl try--but fail--to pass off a painted rock as their missing dinner. For large collections. Category: For the Young. 1998, August House, $15.95. Ages 5-8.
(PUBLISHER: August House LittleFolk (Little Rock:), PUBLISHED: c1998.)
Professional Recommendation/Review #2: A. Braga (Parent Council Volume 6)
An old indigenous tale from the South American jungle, the "DancingTurtle" is a story of courage and wit. Having grown up in Brazil, I remember this fable about creative imagination in different forms. The storyteller captures it well, while the illustrations make you feel as if you were in the Amazon forest. 1998, August House Little Folk, $15.95. Ages 5 to 10.
(PUBLISHER: August House LittleFolk (Little Rock:), PUBLISHED: c1998.)
Response to Two Professional Reviews: Both reviews discuss how this book is a trickster tale that is full of “courage” and “wit”. The two reviews are at odds when it comes to illustrations, one review think s the illustrations, recognizing that the painting, full of mainly green, red and oranges are not as good as the texts themselves while the other thinks the paintings make you feel like you were in an actual Amazon forest. I agree with the second review, I found the illustrations extremely important to the story and do make you feel as if you are in the Amazon forest.
Evaluation of Literary Elements: This book is approachable for some readers depending on their age level and maturity level. The illustrations enhance the story and the illustrator’s depiction of the turtle is fantastically detailed. The turtle’s shell is rounded and the lines on his cage are drawn well, showing a separation and problem the turtle must face. The plot is different, allowing readers to hear an older tale with exciting action and pictures added.
Consideration of Instructional Application : This book is suitable for preschool to first graders. I personally would not choose it as a book to read in my classroom. I am not a fan of the overall theme and do not like having some animal possibly being killed as a main idea in the book, especially if you teach in an area of high crime. I also think the theme of tricking people to get what you want is not appropriate to teach young children. If need be students could dance and sing when the turtle does as I read the story.