I bought this book while traveling in Oregon. It breaks my black authors streak, but I was looking for a book set in Oregon by an Oregonian author, and this coming of age story fit the bill. I started reading the book on the plane on the way home, but then chaos ensued.
For some reason I read the preface, which I normally never do. From the preface, I learned some startling facts about the book's publication history. It was originally published in 1992. The subsequent paper back edition was taught in schools, particularly in Oregon. Unfortunately, parents complained because Ricochet River features brief scenes of teens drinking and engaging in bumbling, awkward sexual activity. When the original printing press went out of business in 2002, the book disappeared. In 2004, the author approached Ooligan Press about publishing a FUCKING CENSORED version with all of the sex taken out in an effort to get it back into schools. What a fucking travesty. My edition, the special 25th anniversary edition published in 2017, left the book in its censored form.
After reading this in the preface, my initial reaction was to return it. I don't need a few uptight parents in Oregon telling me, an adult woman, what I can and can't read. But I was already on the plane, so getting back to the Portland bookstore was impossible. And, being captive on a plane for 5 hours, I had nothing else to do but read it. However, I am still VERY UPSET. I understand the author's 2004 predicament - let the book die or begrudgingly self-censor to give it a new life in schools. It is ridiculous that he had to make that choice. The parents who complained are not professional educators, writers or librarians. All they did was have unprotected sex that resulted in spawn, and they somehow believe that qualifies them to make curricular decisions????? Fucking idiots. School boards are spineless twats.
I finished the censored edition and then had to use library resources to request a copy of the first edition through inter-library loan. Thank you the fine staff at UMass Amherst for sending me the book, and the staff at my own institution for requesting, delivering and returning it. The fact that I had to use library and postal resources to read a few pages of teen sex and send the book back somehow feels more weird than if they had just left it in there, but that is what these irresponsible parents want.
What upsets me the most is that this new, 25th anniversary edition, PUBLISHED IN 2017, is still censored. From 2004 to 2017, both the worlds of young adult literature and pornography changed dramatically. The YA industry exploded, proving there is a financial market outside of schools. Additionally, several authors have won some significant battles to keep banned books in schools. Most importantly, most teens now have 24 hour access to porn in their pocket. With porn being so ubiquitous, it is more important than ever that teens see honest, realistic portrayals of sex. When discussing the book's sex scene, Cody says, "The scene is comic and bungling and incomplete, but still- taken out of context and read aloud to the school board, that passage is trouble." But the context is what is so important! Free internet porn reduces sex to a five minute clip of people smashing - this book and others like it do the important work of putting sex in the context of a relationship and its emotional consequences. Wade, the male protagonist, specifically mentions how different and more difficult his sexual experience is than how sex is portrayed in film. While my rage is up, I would also like to note that in the beginning of the book, when asked about his and Lorna's sex life, Wade repeatedly says, "Lorna is not that kind of girl." As his views and experience with sex evolve, you see that Wade and Lorna can have sex while maintaining their relationship and it does not change "what kind of girl" she is. Without the sex, the idea that there are certain kinds of trashy girls who have sex, and that makes them worse, is left in place. Fucking outrageous. I could go on about how the book features condoms, cunnilingus and other parts of the teen sexual experience missing from porn, but it doesn't matter to those fucking moronic parents.
ANYWAY, given that the world of YA literature is so much more open, WHY NOT USE THE OPPORTUNITY OF A 25TH EDITION TO RESTORE THE BOOK TO ITS ORIGINAL TEXT????? That is what I want to know. Why are my complaints and needs less valid than those of some completely ridiculous parents in Portland? I'm sure many English teachers and librarians would have advocated for it. This country is so stupid.
Also, be forewarned, this book will make you want to eat salmon every day, so have some on hand.