"Jordan's memory was a powerful force. A moment from the past would sneak up and kidnap her and then force her to think about it until she discovered something she didn't know she knew."
―About Average, P. 9
Andrew Clements has put together a pretty good book here. Sturdy characters, a sincere sense of humor and an unexpected twist or two are all important to the story, and the references sprinkled in to pop culture are refreshing and not as prone to dating the book as in some novels. I especially like the low-key tribute to Patricia MacLachlan's classic Newbery Medal winner of 1986, Sarah, Plain and Tall, with the occasional juxtaposition of other assorted adjectives to replace those in that famous title as a way for Jordan to describe her friend, Kylie. What better way to attract the attention of the Newbery Committee than to seed a few references to one of its most famous honorees in one's own book? Even if it didn't work that way for About Average when it came to the 2013 Newbery awards (which I'm sure wasn't really his goal, anyway), it was still a fun nod to classic literature.
Many people who could be counted average have little aversion to the concept. Often, this indifference to standing out from the crowd is the reason one is average. If only a select few can rise to the top as exceptional, then it stands to reason the ones most likely to do so are those possessed of a burning desire to succeed, a need to be extraordinary that propels them above most of their peers until their goals have been reached. Sixth grader Jordan Johnston, however, breaks this mold. Though she is only average in most of what she does (babysitting being one notable exception), Jordan isn't comfortable remaining an average person in perpetuity. She wants to be great, to establish herself as more than just a middle-of-the-road kind of girl. She isn't sure how to go about such a transformation, though. How is she to parlay an aptitude for babysitting and an agreeable personal disposition fawned over by all the grownups in her life into something truly special? It doesn't make Jordan any happier with the status quo when a scornful girl from her class, a girl just as good-looking and popular as Jordan's friend Kylie but without her winning personality, finds the list Jordan made of her own levels of accomplishment in a variety of specific skills, dividing them into groups of things she's great at, thinks she's okay at and those things she doesn't do well at all. Now it's all babysitting jokes and the like for Jordan to endure, and she's becoming angry about it. Why should the fact that she's average make her a target for mean-spirited teasing by unsympathetic girls?
Perhaps Jordan has underestimated her skills, though, despite her frankness in categorizing them on the list. Even being a standout in something as ostensibly mundane as babysitting can have its rewards, and Jordan and the rest of the student body will learn this in convincing fashion one day when the unexpecteds of a crazy outside world intrude on the typical school day and force the quickest thinkers in the room to take immediate and decisive action. The superintendent may be right in what he says about the graduation of Jordan's sixth-grade class: "After all, this certainly isn't an ending. It is more like a great beginning." If what Jordan will be moving on to truly is a new beginning, the onset of middle school when she moves up to seventh grade next fall, then she has shown herself to be as well prepared for it as any other student in her class, even if she continues to be average in most aspects of her life.
What I like best about the Andrew Clements books I've read is the warm welcome they are to the reader, opening the front door wide and inviting us in to be part of the school world of the main characters. Not many authors provide that welcome as consistently or completely as Andrew Clements, and it makes for a really nice reading experience from start to finish. About Average isn't likely to blow anyone's mind, but it's a good, solid story with a central character who is easy to relate to, and I recommend it for anyone who has previously liked the author's material. I'm confident this book will draw its share of enthusiastic fans.