I really wanted to like this. I did like the first tale, the Christmas Whore tale and the final little bit, but everything else was just too, too much, especially the letter and the one-upmanship story.
The Christmas Family update letter was just awful. I know what Sedaris was going for. We have friends who send those obnoxious letters and include a heavily airbrushed studio portrait. Those of us that are close to them know the "real story." How close they got to divorce, the teen pregnancy scare, the brush with being cut from the football team for grades. Still, they insist on sending these braggy, upbeat letters that paint their lives in increasingly fake technicolor. Blech. His offering was just too over the top. I want a few happy words and some Christmas cheer, not the whole unvarnished truth with a plea for character witnesses for Pete's sake!
The stories Sedaris writes from a personal point of view are the most successful. Even if they aren't actually true, they feel true in that we've all been there. The people he describes exist. Maybe not quite that flamboyantly, but they do exist. I wish he would stick to memoirs. Or, even, pretend memoirs.
sigh