Karl Edward Wagner was a vigorous, gifted writer whose swords and sorcery tales about the barbarian Kane—along with his groundbreaking horror fiction—is insufficiently remembered today. I recommend the Kane collection Death Angel’s Shadow and the Kane novel Bloodstone as well, but I cannot give my wholehearted recommendation to Wagner’s second Kane novel Dark Crusade.
Most of this has to do with particular difficulties inherent in the Kane character itself. He’s no rough-around-the-edges hero like Conan, no brooding Byronic wanderer like Elric, but something close to a stone cold psychopath, ancient and accomplished in death and evil, perhaps the original Cain himself.
Because of this, although Kane may be extraordinarily effective in short tales, he lacks the human sympathy necessary to sustain the reader of novels. In Bloodstone Wagner deals with the problem ingeniously and successfully, but he fails to do the same in Dark Crusade.
Wagner tries his best, compensating in four ways: 1) by extending the length of his superbly written battle sequences (Kane is always marvelous in battle), 2) developing the character of Kane’s enemy General Jarvo from a shallow poppycock into a pathetic—almost tragic—figure, 3) building to a climax in which Kane shifts allegiance, ending up of order and truth, and 4) adding an interesting psychedelic coda involving a wild gate-of-worlds in the Tower of Islsl, a narrative which strives to be a meditation on identity, thereby by-passing the problematic character of Kane.
Alas, Wagner’s fourfold method fails: 1) the major battle bores, for it is much too long, 2) Jarvo is only mildly interesting, 3) Kane’s moral reversal comes too late to restore our sympathies, and 4), the last chapter, “The Lair of Islsl” transparently reveals its origins, as a tacked-on, barely relevant short story.
Still, Dark Crusade is not a waste of time, for it is filled with exceptional prose, vivid scenes, horrific effects, and a pervasive irony. It fails as a whole, but—as the polite curate said of the rotten boiled egg—”parts of it are excellent.”