From international NGOs to UN agencies, from donors to observers of humanitarianism, opinion is in a context of the alleged "clash of civilizations", our "humanitarian space" is shrinking. Put another way, the freedom of action and of speech of humanitarians is being eroded due to the radicalisation of conflicts and the reaffirmation of state sovereignty over aid actors and policies.
The purpose of this book is to challenge this assumption through an analysis of the events that have marked MSF's history since 2003 (when MSF published its first general work on humanitarian action and its relationships with governments). It addresses the evolution of humanitarian goals, the resistance to these goals and the political arrangements that overcame this resistance (or that failed to do so). The contributors seek to analyse the political transactions and balances of power and interests that allow aid activities to move forward, but that are usually masked by the lofty rhetoric of "humanitarian principles". They focus on one key what is an acceptable compromise for MSF?
This book seeks to puncture a number of the myths that have grown up over the forty years since MSF was founded and describes in detail how the ideals of humanitarian principles and "humanitarian space" operating in conflict zones are in reality illusory. How, in fact, it is the grubby negotiations with varying parties, each of whom have their own vested interests, that may allow organisations such as MSF to operate in a given crisis situation - or not.
In an impressive gesture of transparency and act of self-assessment, this book details a series of case studies that lay out MSF's historical missions across the globe and its interactions with warring, opposing, or otherwise belligerent parties in its attempts to gain access to populations in need. These interactions are positioned in the interplay between MSF's main mission to provide medical care to its target populations and its principle of "bearing witness" to violations of international law. The prologue then analyzes these efforts in the framework of "confrontational," "realistic," and "abstinent" politics, each yielding to different outcomes in different geopolitical contexts and from different functional perspectives. A must read for anyone interested in the political history of modern humanitarian efforts in general, and MSF's in particular.
This is a great book to understand MSF's internal debates and functioning, but also to get a glimpse at some of the complex situations in which humanitarian NGOs must work in.
interesting discussion about the role of MSF and it's evolving approaches to it's work. All from the insider perspective though. No real critical discussion (one can of course read between the lines if one so chooses) nor a more concrete description of real life dilemmas. More could have been made of that.