Spoilers
All That Falls is the second book in the Etherlin series, the first being All That Bleeds where readers were introduced to Etherlin’s most famous muse, Alissa and her forbidden vampire lover, Merrick. All that Falls focuses on the romance between Alissa’s muse friend, Cerise and Merrick’s fallen angel friend, Lysander.
Cerise is struggling to cope with the loss of her musician boyfriend, she has no memory of the night of his death and she’s been unable to use her muse powers since he died. Cerise is certain that the loss of her powers is somehow tied into her boyfriend’s death, so she begins to investigate the mysterious circumstances surrounding his death.
Fallen angel Lysander can’t get distracted from his mission to gain entry back into heaven, but he can’t seem to get Cerise out of his head. He does his utmost to avoid Cerise but is thrust into her life when she’s targeted by vampires and demons.
I was excited to read Cerise and Lysander’s story after their heated exchange at the end of All that Bleeds. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to expectations, I felt that there was something missing in their romance. It was obvious that Lysander and Cerise were attracted to each other and cared for one another, but I didn’t feel the love and passion between them, their relationship was largely underwhelming. Lysander seemed more concerned about his own goals than he did Cerise, I don’t mind that he had other priorities but I felt as if Lysander put Cerise and his potential future with her at the bottom of his list. At one point he says that she’s become just as important as Merrick, was that supposed to be romantic or flattering? The woman he loves should be more important than anyone, Merrick is Lysander’s friend and distant relation – his love for Cerise should far eclipse his love for Merrick. I would have liked it made clear that even though he had other important people and objectives in his life that Cerise would always come first.
On a positive note I feel that Cerise is a far better heroine than Alissa, Alissa is far too perfect and too much of a Mary Sue. Alissa comes across as delicate and useless - without Merrick she would never have had the guts to leave Etherlin. Cerise is far more capable, she can actually look after herself and she has to actually prove herself to people whereas Alissa seems to gets everyone’s adoration instantly. Lysander was the typical hero – alpha male, overly powerful and excessively broody.
The storyline was predictable and mostly boring. The fighting and action scenes were ok, but I would have preferred if Cerise had gotten more involved with the actual fighting at the end rather than standing on the sidelines whilst the men folk fought. I found Cerise’s interactions with her younger sister, Dorie the most interesting parts of the book. Dorie was a complete cow but I’m starting to prefer female characters that are bitchy and selfish over do-goody, speshul heroine’s.
I wasn’t impressed that Cerise’s ex turned out to be a selfish loser who put her life in danger. Why do authors feel the need to utterly destroy and diminish the heroine’s past loves?? If the hero has been in love previously, his past love is usually never vilified and so his feelings for her don’t change. I’ve noticed that most authors tend to allow the hero’s past relationships to remain loving, pure and memorable but they all too happily wreck any of the heroine’s past relationships so that the hero is the only man that they’ve had a warm, healthy relationship with. Please authors stop doing this.
I was mystified as to why Cerise’s father showed more feelings for Alissa than he did his own daughter, he acted like he loved them both equally. It was so unrealistic, sure he watched Alissa grow up and was a good friend to her parents but surely it wouldn’t elicit the same amount of love that he’d have for his own flesh and blood daughter who he raised since birth. It was bizarre that he had no meaningful interactions with Cerise yet he opened up to Alissa and showed his love and concern for her. Growing up Cerise always had an inferiority complex when it came to Alissa - feeling that her father preferred Alissa over her and it seems like he does. I was disappointed that Cerise didn’t get a heart to heart with her dad and that there was no closure on how he showed favouritism towards Alissa and treated Cerise like second best. I felt Cerise’s complicated relationship with her father was wasted, if it had been explored more it could have added more layers to Cerise and added more depth to the story.
The villains were one dimensional caricatures and over the top cheesy. They were so lazily written and their reasons for being evil were underdeveloped and weak. I wish authors would put more effort behind their villains and not make them so black and white – most people that are evil/bad aren’t simple or have one track minds, they’re complex and have shades of grey. I don’t why authors resort to so many clichés and tropes, it’s like they all have a secret book given to them by publishers on how to write generic paranormal romance.
I think fans of typical paranormal romance will enjoy the Etherlin series but I most likely won’t be reading anymore in the series or anything else by the author, it’s apparent she just writes the same old storylines and romances as every paranormal romance author. I would only be tempted to read another book if Dorie were to be a heroine – but I doubt that’ll happen, she was obviously just a female character that was inserted to make the heroines look good.