For pure entertainment, Ellis Vidler’s Cold Comfort deserves five stars, not four: it has pace and a compelling plot that kept me guessing what was going on right up to the concluding chapters. It’s also a relief to read good writing after a lot of material by people who’ve no grasp of the concept of editing.
If in the end I settled on four stars, it was because some of the devices were a little predictable: the tough guy who’s suffered a tragedy over a woman he was unable to protect and has decided that he will never get himself dragged into anything similar again; the jilted woman, bruised by betrayal, who has to turn to him for protection. I think we know where this is heading. And: will she do what her protector tells her or will she strike out on her own? And if she insists on taking her own initiative, how well do you think that’s going to work out?
Similarly, is the senator who champions the wetlands, a hypocrite in hock to the mob or the mob’s victim? If the supremely competent male protagonist says he’s going to get hold of ostensibly secret information, what are the chances that he'll come back empty-handed and admitting failure?
That being said, not every narrative device has to be brilliantly original: what matters is not how innovative it is by how well it’s handled, and Ellis Vidler handles hers with consummate skill.
But if I do have another criticism of the book, it would be its simplicity: it doesn’t challenge thought, it doesn’t give any sudden insights into the worlds of US politics or organised crime, both of which it touches on. Again, though, that has its benefits as well as its drawbacks: I found the book just what I needed, in bed or bath, when I wanted a break from work and a little relaxation and entertainment. It would work brilliantly on holiday too.
A thriller needs a sense of threat, and Cold Comfort introduces it from the first sentence: Claire is already checking for the anonymous figures she’s noticed on her tail for some days, as she’s driving home from work. That work provides an ironic contrast to the peril gathering round her: she brings pleasure, and entirely innocent pleasure, to people’s lives through a shop called ‘Mistletoe’ which sells Christmas decorations (I wondered at first how she lived for the rest of the year, but she also does Easter, and I can only assume Valentine’s Day, the 4th of July, Labor Day and Halloween as well).
However, Claire’s wholesome life is about to be torn apart when her fears are proved well-founded by an anonymous men attacking her in her own drive. It is that shocking incident that will drive her to seek protection and provide the starting point of the main story.
We’re soon introduced to the recent sorrow in her life, her jilting six months earlier, but there are far deeper secrets in her past, unknown – unguessed – to Claire herself. Unravelling the mystery of the assault on her takes her into a process of discovering those secrets, and therefore on a voyage of self-discovery.
She’ll be accompanied on that voyage by a man with a distinguished past as a soldier and, since leaving the military, a career in shadowy security assignments, often with his band of brothers of former crack military men like himself. It is, however, a past marked by tragedy involving a young woman he had been unable to save; as for the present, in another attractive contrast, he varies his secret and dangerous assignments with a career as a successful painter, betraying a sensitivity which is a key ingredient of the story.
All these elements become the driving force behind an effective combination of mystery, suspense, a little violence, romance shading into tactfully presented sex, and a fast-moving plot that draws you along with it.
My feeling is that anyone who likes a thriller combined with a romance will enjoy this one, and many will want to give it five stars; I think I would have needed a little more of an intellectual challenge to give it the top ranking. Even so, I certainly intend to read more of Vidler and I have no hesitation recommending Cold Comfort to anyone who wants an enjoyable and exciting read providing effortless entertainment.