Wow. Where do I start? First, let me say I'm having issues with my vision right now, so please forgive any issues with my writing.
I read about a third of this novel and had to find out, before I continued, the back story. I contacted the author on Twitter and learned, to my disappointment, that she researched TBIs. I was so hopeful that she, herself, or someone she knew had one. So with that sad reality, I continued after looking into other's reviews.
I have to point out there are many reviews, all over the internet, referring to how "funny" it was. I just finished this book. I have a moderate TBI. Funny? I sat and cried through the first part of the book. Funny? I'm thinking most mean the shower section. Yeah, it's real funny when you can't remember how to take a shower. Or in my case: how to drive, how to turn on the sink, how to turn on the oven, how to operate the TV, how to open even a door. Real funny there. I'm being sarcastic, btw. It's not funny. It's pure hell for those that have been there, that are there.
That being said, the book was good. I did cry for a very long time and struggled to read it, especially early on, due to how close it was to my life. To reality of a TBI. I had no idea it was a YA book, because I had no memory of even getting this book. I must have gotten it from Amazon at some point. So I was a little surprised it was YA. Don't get me wrong, it was a great YA. It was in the right genre, it was myself who just wasn't aware - you know, TBI and all.
I'm trying to figure out how to form my words right now. It is a great book. Very accurate, in the beginning. The story line of the two friends and the one's struggles without her were very well written and kept me hooked.
I loved this book. I really did. So, why 4 stars instead of 5? Simple: TBIs that last more than a few months tend to not have a full recovery. I mean, the wounds close, some things come back, actually in some cases, most things come back. But you are still changed. There is something still not the same as you were before. Something different. It could be minor, it could be major (like in my case: I can't remember a single thing for more than about a week since 2007 when I had my TBI, can't do basic math, hearing issues, vision issues, headaches that make migraines look like a picnic, concentration issues, anger issues, personality changes, and the most devastating one: I lost my ability to manipulate words into a beautiful story.) It was not clear what little issues she had. It's not usual for someone to have a complete and total recovery with no signs of it ever happening. I even asked my neurologist about this as well. I needed to know in case I was wrong. Nope, it's very very rare.
I think the story would have been better if she continued to write notes to herself. That she learned to adapt to the new girl she became. That she is doing well despite still having some issues. Instead, it was written in a way that made one think she totally recovered. I was hopeful to read a more common ending - that she accepted who she was and her little quirks.
That being said: I didn't write this novel. It was totally on the author how it would end and it was a very happy ending. I can understand that, on the other hand, because it is YA and it is not based on any real person. I just can't help but wonder if someone reads this, who is a teenager, because they or a friend has a TBI. They might expect the same sort of happy ending. They may get it, but it's more likely that they will have some remaining issues that, with time, they will learn to adapt to - like I am.
I still write notes to myself - otherwise I wouldn't have a clue about anything, still, all these years later.
I will suggest others read this, especially my children, but will explain, as they already know, not everyone fully recovers, most have some issues - I happen to have a number of them, but we get by. Day by day.