Sir Harold Anthony Nutting, 3rd Baronet was a British diplomat and Conservative Party politician who served as a Member of Parliament from 1945 and 1956. He was a Minister of State for Foreign Affairs from 1954 until he resigned in 1956 in protest against the Suez invasion.
During WW2 he entered the Foreign Service, serving as an attaché at the British Embassy in Paris. When France fell, he was assigned to the embassy in Madrid, where he organised escape routes for Allied servicemen caught behind enemy lines from 1940 to 1944. He joined the Embassy in Rome from 1944 to 1945 and was briefly private secretary to Anthony Eden, the then Foreign Secretary.
At the 1945 general election, at 25, Nutting was elected as the MP for Melton in Leicestershire. He served as chairman of the Young Conservatives (1946 - 47) and he was the youngest member of Winston Churchill's Government in the 1950s.
He was made a Privy Councillor in 1954 and he led the British delegation to the United Nations General Assembly and Disarmament Commission in 1954 and 1955. He was an internationalist, an early enthusiast for British membership of the European Economic Community and an Arabist who was a founding member of the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding (CAABU) in 1967.
In 1954, he negotiated the final steps of the treaty with President Gamal Abdel Nasser of Egypt under which British troops withdrew from Suez; so when he discovered the joint British and French invasion plan at a meeting on 14 October 1956, he believed that the mission was mistaken and deceitful. On 31 October, despite attempts by future Prime Minister Harold Macmillan to persuade him not to resign, Nutting quit his post as Minister of State for Foreign Affairs. He did not give the customary resignation speech in the House of Commons for security reasons, and his unexplained action proved so unpopular that his constituents forced him to give up his seat in Parliament.
The author of this book was educated at Eton and Cambridge and was a baronet to boot. He was thus born with a silver spoon in his mouth. He served in the British diplomatic community at least part of which career was in the Middle East, where he negotiated a treaty with Nasser, a treaty which was treacherously trashed by the 1956 invasion of Suez by Britain, France and Israel. Nutting resigned over the issue and was never accepted back into politics, having been declared virtually a traitor. He had been spoken of as a future PM. I’m not sure that this career qualifies him as a historian; he studied agriculture at university. However, given the broad perspective imparted by top British education, his work here is not bad by any means. And I think resigning was the right thing. Born in 1920, he must have absorbed history during his education in terms of leaders and battles. Later trends in the field did not impact him much, so that such areas as religion, philosophy, agriculture, land ownership, trade, diplomacy, etc. do not appear much in “The Arabs”. The first chapter covers the Arab world before Islam, the last ones look at the various parts of that world in the years before 1964, when the book was published. In between, the chapters deal with the rise of Muhammad and the beginning of empire after his death, the conquest of Iran and Egypt, the civil war which led to the division between Sunni and Shi’a, and so on past the oft-romanticized age of Harun al-Rashid and the “Arabian Nights”, the Crusades, the Mongol invasion, the Turkish domination, and the appearance of the Europeans which ultimately turned into the colonial era. The last 120 pages (out of 397) deal with the Arab revolt against the Ottomans and subsequent events in Arabia, Iraq, Syria, Palestine, Egypt and North Africa. In good British tradition, he has absolutely no use for France or the French, penning some scathing criticism, which (not in anything I’ve read personally) must have been returned toward the British by various Gallic authors. He also feels the creation of Israel was a big mistake. While Israel has never tried to “fit into the neighborhood”, ignored Palestinian rights, and has presently committed what can be called genocide, what, I wonder, was his idea for Jews around the world? Wait for the next general massacre? Apologize for their existence?
Nutting often focuses on one or two important figures of a certain time—Khalid ibn Walid of 7th century Arabia, Abd al Rahman of Spain and Harun al-Rashid of Baghdad in the 8th, Saladin (Salah-ad Din Yusuf ibn Ayyub) of Iraq in the 12th century, and such figures as Nuri es-Said (Iraq), Nasser (Egypt) and Bourguiba (Tunisia) in the 20th. This too is a style dating from earlier times.
In short, this is a popular history (very readable if you can absorb a huge number of facts) of the Arabs over 1,400 years. It may contain a fair number of personal observations in the last chapters, and gloss over many important subjects, but I think it was inevitable in a book of such breadth. I'm giving it three stars because 1) it is an amateur work even though substantial and 2) because it is written in that older style.
When I was at the University of Akron (1970s), the powers that be determined that to graduate all students had to have at least three quarters of non-Western culture. One of the cultures I chose was Middle Eastern. The two books that we used for texts were The Arabs by Anthony Nutting and Islam by Alfred Guillaume. Author Nutting, a noted Arab scholar, English diplomat, and writer perhaps best remembered for his biography of (T. E.) Lawrence of Arabia, was Minister of State for Foreign Affairs under British Prime Minister Anthony Eden. He resigned his ministerial post in protest against Eden's agreement with France and Israel to attack Nasser's Egypt in 1956 during the Suez incident, so he might be considered somewhat sympathetic to the Arabs. Both Islam and The Arabs contain lots of historical information, but while the former emphasizes religion, the latter focuses primarily on the social and political ramifications.
This is a well written, comprehensive history of the Middle East up to the mid 1960s. After an opening chapter on “The Arab World Before Islam,” Nutter, who is uniquely qualified to interpret the passionate and controversial history of the Arabs, depicts the Arab world through its leaders, great and corrupt, famous and infamous, beginning with the birth of the Prophet in ca. 570/571 A.D., through the eras of Arabian conquest, the Omayyad dynasty in Damascus, the Abbasid caliphate in Baghdad, the Moors in Spain, the empire building Saladin, and the Turks, to the overthrow of colonialism and the rise of Egypt’s Gamal Abdel Nasser, the hero and prophet of modern Arabism. Again, I must point out that while we’re being told that Islam is a religion of peace, the Journal of International Affairs calls even this book a “bloody chronicle” that “describes the fiery conquests and struggles” of the Islamic Arabs.
A highly informative and detailed biography of the Arab people that deals with the political & military history & events that have shaped at least Arabs from the birth of Islam through to the mid-60s. Obviously there has been a lot to happen since then that could easily fill a second volume! The subject matter is dealt with in an intriguingly fair minded and in-depth manner though one glaring omission is the complete absence of any mention of the cultural or social history of Arabs - such as food, art, popular movements etc - which is why I felt compelled to knock off a star.
The total abhorrence for paragraphs that was the norm when the book was published can make it fairly hard to keep track of all the twists and turns especially in the more internecine conflicts but that is hardly the authors fault. Overall, not quite as conclusive a history I was looking for but all the same a very good place to start.
I do not think the author is neutral, he always implying that Prophet Mohammed was taught by a Monck whom in reality profit Moh'd never met . Nutting is trying to illustrate a misleading image regarding the Arabs origins. he based his research and reference on limited number of books which were written by orientalists.