I have to be honest; the first time reading this I did not do the assignments and didn't "study" the materials. Regardless of that, I think this book has done more for my physics/mechanical thinking than 5 years of High School has done for me!
The book starts out with the simplest of machines: Levers and inclined planes. Every chapter adds more to the equation and before you know it, you're reading about the working of Diesel Engines and Power Trains.
Throughout the book there are several assignments to test your knowledge. Like I said, personally I skipped them but the knowledge given beforehand should be enough to solve the assignments.
With that said, there are some issues I have with this book. None of them have to do with the content necessarily.
- The images are rather low in quality. They are printed out in a large format luckily, but the contrast and overall blurriness of them do make it harder to make out certain things.
- There are a lot of spelling mistakes, ranging from small errors I overlooked in the first place all the way to forming new words ('bum' instead of 'burn') and messing up part names ('vale springs' instead of 'val e springs'). For it being a guide for the military, you would think errors like that would be nipped in the bud.
- The layout is horendous. In the earlier chapters, this is hardly noticable (besides the Bible like text layout). In the later chapters however, the text referred to images that were placed 1-2 pages prior! This too is really confusing and rather odd, as there are a lot of ways around this.
-This might be my biggest pet peeve but THERE ARE NO ANSWERS TO THE ASSIGNMENTS. The only way to get your answers checked, is to send them over mail to an address mentioned in the first few pages. Seeing as this book is several decennia old, I assume the address is not in use anymore. I have no way of testing this though; I DON'T LIVE IN THE UNITED STATES.
Now I understand this guide was meant to train the U.S.A. Navy, but since it's still being published (even overseas might I add!), I think it's a lot of hogwash that these issues remain since they are really easy to fix. For example, post the answers to the assignment online on the publisher's website, make the layout work with the text you are writing (at the very least keep referred to images on the same page as the text), have someone spell check the writing before publishing it, remake/rescan the images (color would be very much appreciated too).
But, maybe I am being to harsh. It is an older book, and I get that it might be too much effort for the gains made on these changes. It saddens me though; the content of this book is AMAZING, and you would be pressed hard to find a similar book for this price point with the amount of depth the writing covers.
I think this book is great for the mechanically inept (like me), engineering students and serious hobbyists who'd like to step up their game