What do you think?
Rate this book


Audio
First published December 9, 2008
Love doesn't weaken us. It makes us stronger. I wish Padmé and I could show him that. He's very alone.
• Immediately post-AOTC context. The scene of Anakin shouting at Obi-Wan when he wakes up in the Halls of Healing after Geonosis... burned indelibly into the gray matter of my brain.
• Yoda is NOXIOUS in this. He is so hard on Obi-Wan when Obi-Wan, again, I cannot emphasize enough, is not having a good time. Not only does he take Obi-Wan to task for not training Anakin well and force Obi-Wan to go and try to order Padme to break it off with Anakin, he delivers the worst line of all time: "But mothers die, Obi-Wan. Sad it is, but distract a Jedi death must not." Okay! All right! 'Mothers die,' thanks so much! I have to hand it to the Jedi haters - as a dedicated Jedi apologist, even I felt the tides of disdain rising inside me after reading that. If this was the only Yoda content I'd read, I would hate his guts.
• Padme and Obi-Wan's fight is sooooooooooooooooooooooooo awkward and I hate it. This is the ONLY thing I can think of during the horrible Padme/Anakin/Bail/Obi-Wan dinner party from Clone Wars Gambit: Stealth.
• Padme in general in this is kind of underwhelming. With only the possible exception of Queen's Shadow I struggle to think of a time when Padme was written really well, and not as a weeping, fragile damsel with very little to do on-screen except emote. Even her "don't diminish me!" speech to Anakin, which specifically addresses this, doesn't actually take the edge off her portrayal where she just comes off as immature and almost naive. TCW itself does a much better job at letting her be a real character.
• The one good Padme moment is when she yells at Bail on behalf of the Jedi while Obi-Wan just stands there awkwardly with (I'M SURE) his hands tucked into his cloak sleeves.
• I love this book SO MUCH for putting so much work into Bail's outsider POV. He flags so many things that we always just take for granted, like Padme's weirdly close relationship with the Jedi. The overall freakiness of Force powers. How far the ordinary people are from understanding anything about the Jedi and how they work.
• The LEGENDARY Obi-Wan & Anakin sparring scene... To the other 56 people who also highlighted the passage at the end about Obi-Wan touching Anakin's cheek and telling him 'well done,' I see you. I GET you. We are brothers in arms.
• I enjoy the Ahsoka highlights and POV as well. It's interesting to see rocky moments and missteps in her and Anakin's early relationship that never really get explored in TCW. She kind of has a rough time in this book, but I think it's very realistic given all *gestures at Anakin* that.
• It's so funny to me that TCW 1.06 "Downfall of a Droid" is happening offscreen during this. That's such a dumb little episode, meanwhile Obi-Wan is off somewhere in Wild Space psychically fistfighting the devil.
• Anakin redesigning the Venators. <3<3<3 I know the engineers HATED to see him coming.
• The entire Obi-Wan and Anakin relationship insanity is just cranked up to 100 throughout the entire book, which is impressive given that they actually don't spend that much time together. When Anakin is with Padme and then just goes 'wait... Obi-Wan is injured... I can feel it...' When Obi-Wan and Anakin are constantly fighting to see each other when, at different points, they each spend time in the Halls of Healing. When Obi-Wan is having prescient dreams about Anakin while he's lightyears away. When Anakin can just TELL something is going wrong with Obi-Wan from across the entire galaxy and says the only reason he's not disobeying the Council's orders and going to find him is because no one knows where he is. 'You don't ever keep him waiting.' Like, it's not made up. It's not fans exaggerating. They're just like this.
• Bail and Obi-Wan's relationship is incredible. They are so mean to each other and for literally no reason. The constant veiled insults. The weird power play and competitiveness. Bail making sure to land the ship in the most flawless way because he knows Obi-Wan is watching. Obi-Wan refusing to drink with Bail because 'alcohol is not recommended for Jedi' just to be petty even though we KNOW he drinks. It's like two hissing wet cats the entire time and it's so funny.
• Bail's progression went like this: that's Master Kenobi and he's kind of an uptight jerk --> that's Master Kenobi and he is LITERALLY a superhero --> that's my best friend Obi-Wan <3
• Am I stupid, or did Palpatine try to get Bail killed because he was worried he'd disrupt his plans by... having an affair with Padme? Sir, that's unhinged, and also the LEAST of your worries when it comes to Bail 'co-founder of the rebellion' Organa.
• I haven't even talked about actual Zigoola. I'm not sure I even can.
• Okay, I love how this book talks about Obi-Wan and the Force. I do wish Star Wars books in general put a LOT more prose effort into conveying to us how it feels, as a Jedi, to live in the Force, and this does a far better job than most.
• YODA AND MACE GOING TO EXTRAORDINARY MEASURES TO FIND OBI-WAN BECAUSE "HE HAS A DESTINY AS IMPORTANT AS ANAKIN'S." They've talked about this before, about what might happen if Obi-Wan was lost, but where??? I don't remember hearing about this in other media? DID OBI-WAN KNOW ABOUT THIS? I guarantee he did not.
• Anakin's insane, grandstanding warm-up routine................! He's got a massive case of main character syndrome and what makes it worse is that he's RIGHT.
• "You don't ever keep him waiting." I mentioned this before but I have to again just to say that this is what the extant canon Obi-Wan and Anakin books are missing: the vital undercurrent of mental illness.