Although War is an obvious improvement on Hunter’s Planet, it still fails in comparison to Prey and ends the series in a far less exciting note than promised.
War has some good moments. The last 50 pages are non stop, gore infused action that rival anything these titular characters ever displayed on the big screen. Perry also fixes a bunch of issues that came in the previous book and makes the overarching theme of Xenos vs. Predators make more sense. The side story (while not nearly as fleshed out or as detailed as it should have been) is good and leads into the penultimate showdown at the conclusion of the book.
The issue however, comes at just now weak this series ended up being. As I mentioned, Prey was a great start to this trilogy and made these 2 creatures fun again. I know Bischoff kind of ruined the series with the next book (though I’m of the belief that Hunters Planet wasn’t nearly as terrible as some say), so Perry had no choice but to backpedal and fix where the story was going, but because of that, the entire 3 book arc just got lost in the mess and, in turn, lost its theme. Yes, aliens and predators face off once in a while but the story became more of a Heart of Darkness kind of thing where the creatures are replaced with a main character and her issues.
Also, War, while in and of itself is had a decent plot, completely threw off the timeline. It’s been mentioned in a ton of other reviews, so I’ll keep mine succinct, but basically War doesn’t fit chronologically with Hunters Planet. So get ready to see some characters twice and prepare yourself to see the same characters die twice, in 2 different ways. Also get ready to be totally confused as to why Noguchi is back with the Predators after she took of from them in the last one.
I feel like this entire series had the potential to be awesome, but mismanagement of authors and a lack of focus kept it from reaching those heights. Still though, it’s still a good bit of xenomorph fun and its better than any films Hollywood managed to produce.