Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

La Taberna Errante

Rate this book
A lo largo de estas páginas, un par de proscritos hacen rodar por toda Inglaterra, huyendo de la justicia, el último barril de ron de la isla después de que un decreto gubernamental haya ordenado el cierre de todas las tabernas en nombre del ecumenismo y el entendimiento entre culturas. Allí donde los fugitivos se detienen y abren la espita del barril, enseguida cristaliza una sociedad en miniatura, como una perla alrededor de un grano de arena. La gran carcajada que truena juguetona en "La taberna errante" es la manera de G. K. Chesterton (1874-1936), el descomunal escritor inglés, de identificar y conjurar una amenaza. Chesterton, autor de "El hombre que fue Jueves" o "El Napoleón de Notting Hill", siempre se defendió a risotadas, porque le hacía mucha gracia no ser Dios y tener que conformarse con ridiculizar los errores y disparates de sus enemigos. ¿Y qué terrible peligro revela, pues, la irresistible comicidad de esta novela de dignos borrachines vagabundos? ¿El Islam? ¿La abstinencia? ¿El arte abstracto? Desde luego, "La taberna errante" es un formidable, hilarante alegato contra el vegetarianismo y la abstinencia, lo que ya es desafiante en un mundo monstruosamente higiénico en el que los asesinos de masas se preocupan por su silueta y el negocio farmacéutico amarga y abrevia la vida de los otrora risueños, saludables y respetables barrigones. Pero el asunto es todavía más serio. Cuando Chesterton defiende el ron, defiende en realidad las tabernas, y cuando defiende las tabernas, defiende en realidad algo mucho más universal y razonable que el ecumenismo y el entendimiento entre culturas: defiende la sociabilidad. El ecumenismo separa a los hombres; las tabernas son los lugares comunes donde se encuentran. "La taberna errante" narra este conflicto "civilizacional" -como está en boga decir hoy- entre una cultura de vínculos y una cultura de místicos, entre la raza de los racimos y la raza de las esferas. En su "Autobiografía", Chesterton advertía lúcidamente sobre el único destino que cabía esperar si los proscritos eran derrotados y se cerraban las tabernas: "se ciernen ya en el horizonte vastas plagas de esterilización o higiene social, aplicadas a todos y que nadie impone". Era 1934.

346 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1914

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

G.K. Chesterton

4,302 books6,092 followers
Gilbert Keith Chesterton was an English writer, philosopher, lay theologian, and literary and art critic.

He was educated at St. Paul’s, and went to art school at University College London. In 1900, he was asked to contribute a few magazine articles on art criticism, and went on to become one of the most prolific writers of all time. He wrote a hundred books, contributions to 200 more, hundreds of poems, including the epic Ballad of the White Horse, five plays, five novels, and some two hundred short stories, including a popular series featuring the priest-detective, Father Brown. In spite of his literary accomplishments, he considered himself primarily a journalist. He wrote over 4000 newspaper essays, including 30 years worth of weekly columns for the Illustrated London News, and 13 years of weekly columns for the Daily News. He also edited his own newspaper, G.K.’s Weekly.

Chesterton was equally at ease with literary and social criticism, history, politics, economics, philosophy, and theology.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
296 (27%)
4 stars
390 (36%)
3 stars
275 (25%)
2 stars
98 (9%)
1 star
24 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 124 reviews
Profile Image for Dave/Maggie Bean.
155 reviews15 followers
June 11, 2011
Yep. Chesterton again. Manic-depressive bastard that I am, I love his work and Joseph Conrad’s equally. Chesterton’s thinking is very similar to mine when I’m hypomanic, while Conrad’s is similar to mine when I endure depressive and "mixed" episodes. This book is a thoroughly enjoyable, manic romp across Chesterton’s rich, ever-optimistic mental landscape.

A more mature work than The Napoleon of Notting Hill, The Flying Inn is an examination (and indictment) of authoritarianism and progressivism, and an expression of distrust for power in and of itself. Written on the eve of World War I (when the European empires’ chickens first came home to roost), …TFI proved even more prophetic than the former. Set in a UK besieged by theosophists, vegetarians, rabid xenophiles and other turn-of-the-century fruitcakes, TFI accurately presaged the modern, NuLab-dominated, post-British Britain we modern Americans have ironically (and hypocritically) come to pity.

An allegory, romance, and expression of populist defiance all at once, TFI chronicles the adventures of one Humphrey Pump (an English pub owner) and his friend, Captain Patrick Dalroy -- a truculent, red-bearded Irish giant in the service of a decaying, increasingly ridiculous and dwarfish Britain. Opposing them is a cast of silly (but sinister) villains -- villains rendered all the more sinister by their inability to perceive their own silliness.

The novel begins with one of the protagonists, Captain Patrick Dalroy (an Irishman serving in the British navy) resigning his commission at the conclusion of a ridiculous, one-sided treaty with the Turks, courtesy of his nemesis, Lord Ivywood.

Dalroy then returns to England and renews his acquaintance with his friend, Humphrey Pump. When the Ivywood-dominated government, under the influence of a Turkish mystic and pseudo-scholar (my bone of contention, incidentally: no son of the grey or red wolf –however strident -- ever influenced the UK as profoundly as even the most transparently fraudulent cow-worshipper of the Subcontinent) prohibits the sale of alcohol, Pump and Dalroy load an immense hoop of cheese and a keg of rum into a donkey cart and hit the road, dispensing good cheer (and populist defiance) the length and breadth of the country.

I won’t ruin the story, but I’ll add that Ivywood is perhaps the most sinister of Chesterton’s villains – all the more so because he’s ridiculous without being funny. Embodying the almost mechanistic irrationality of the ideological fanatic, Ivywood is Hoffer’s "true believer" – but at the opposite end of the social "food chain."
Profile Image for J.Aleksandr Wootton.
Author 9 books222 followers
January 8, 2021
Chesterton's essays are brimming with mini-parables and illustrative anecdotes, peopled by persons both historical and imagined. This story feels much as if he set out to write an essay, but the anecdotes took over: the characters broadened and clambered right out of the mini-parables and seized upon lives of their own. The result is The Flying Inn, a string of episodes into which mini-essays (and dozens of uproarious songs and poems) keep on breaking.

The tale is told with exuberance and does, finally, resolve into something like a novel. But you've got to keep with it, and resign yourself from the outset to a story rather thickly yet entertainingly mediated by a storyteller who wishes to make a number of observations and points; indeed, he has spun his yarn for no other purpose.

Once you've got to the end, and learned what the story you've been reading is, you'll be prepared to fully enjoy the book. But not before.
Profile Image for Manuel Alfonseca.
Author 81 books245 followers
August 14, 2016
ENGLISH: This is Chesterton at his best. In this book, one century ahead of his time, he foresees the current garrulousness about "an open and inter-religious education, rather than an exclusivist and intolerant religious indoctrination."

He also foresees correctly the attempt to introduce Islam in Europe, if not as a full-fledged religious option, at least as a weapon to attack Christianity.

But the people revolution that saves England from the post-modernist politically-correct stunt is little credible. I'm afraid I'm far less optimist than Chesterton.

ESPAÑOL: Este es el mejor Chesterton. En este libro, que se adelantó un siglo a su tiempo, prevé la locuacidad actual sobre "una educación abierta e interreligiosa, en lugar de adoctrinamiento religioso exclusivista e intolerante".

También prevé correctamente el intento de introducir el Islam en Europa, si no como opción religiosa en toda regla, al menos como arma para atacar al cristianismo.

Pero la revolución popular que salva a Inglaterra de las argucias posmodernistas políticamente correctas me parece poco creíble. Me temo que soy mucho menos optimista que Chesterton.
Profile Image for F.R..
Author 38 books227 followers
January 6, 2015
Definite mixed emotions on picking up this one: eager to read, but trembling a tad at the prospect.

Reading one hundred year old novels about the clash of cultures is something that will generally make your liberal leaning twenty-first century man (that’s me, by the way) quake with nerves. The world has moved so far in the last hundred years, what’s accepted in society is so different. So while reading a novel from 1914, there’s the good possibility that in amongst the plot, the characters and the themes, there will be a good bit of nose holding as offensiveness levels rise. Yet there was something so tantalising about a G.K. Chesterton novel where he examines Islam in Britain that I just couldn’t resist.

Looking back on the news of 1914, it’s hard to believe that the threat of hard-line Muslims impinging on British society was something was high up in British people’s minds. In 2015 scarcely a week (or maybe two days; or this past terrible week, one day) goes by without a comment piece or two in the press. Yet a hundred years ago, given that a huge European war was about to ignite, it doesn’t feel like it’d have been that big an issue at all. But there you go, this book somehow exists. I found myself wondering: how much of it would be pertinent and relevant today?

For all my worries of blatant intolerance just pouring off the page though, it seems like Chesterton didn’t do much research into what Islam actually meant. Basically he boils the faith down to just stopping people having a drink. Yes, it’s enforced abstinence which is the main thrust and driver of the book. Islam may be the face that’s given to it, but really it’s impossible to ignore that the Christian temperance movement was much more lively and healthy in 1914 (and would soon achieve success with prohibition in the USA). That’s the real target of this book: how wrong it is – whether the impulse comes from an Islamic preacher or a wrong-headed aristocrat – to stop an Englishman indulging his God given right to have a sip of rum or wine or beer. Rather than dealing seriously with Islam, Chesterton is just taking on puritanism and dressing it up in Arabic robes for fun. Yes there are nods towards not eating pork and polygamy at points later in the book, but it’s decoration with no willingness to engage beyond the narrowest viewpoint.

The plot, such as it is, sees an English Lord fall under the influence of an Islamic preacher and start to shut down pubs, while making a law that no alcohol can be sold unless there is a pub sign present. If there are no pubs though, there can’t be any pub signs and so no alcohol can be sold. A couple of eccentric radicals rescue a sign, a cask of rum and a wheel of cheese and travel around the country flaunting the rules. It’s a picaresque tale, one with frequent deviations which become so overwhelming that by the end Chesterton has completely lost control of his book and it splutters to a halt.

Novels are of course being written today about the relations between Islam and The West (Michel Houellebecq was on the front cover of Charlie Hedbo this week promoting his). And these books will be more challenging than ‘The Flying Inn’ as they’ll actually engage in the subject, rather than using the garb just for dressing up. Some of them, if we’re honest, will actually go out of their way to be far more offensive than this tome. As ‘The Flying Inn’ is merely an intermittently amusing book, one whose offensiveness comes from its Western imperialistic refusal to take other cultures remotely seriously. It doesn’t address, challenge or comment on anything beyond the most narrow concerns of 1914, and so has little to say for itself today. It’s a long, bawdy, drunken tale which has little of pertinence and is utterly innocuous and toothless.

In short I'm not disappointed in it because there are meaningful points in between some truly offensive and jingoistic passages which don't sit well with a 2015 audience; instead I'm disappointed with it because it never rouses itself to engage with its subject and so offends in the most blase, careless and self-righteously casual way. There's no meat, only blather.
Profile Image for Reagan Dricken.
19 reviews
September 26, 2026
My Goodreads hiatus means I wasn’t able to clock the fact that I listened through once and read it cover-to-cover twice. It just shows you I shelved it. Sad. If you’re wondering whether you should read it, this book is about…

- Rum
- Cheese
- Taverns
- Christendom
- Lawbreaking
- Chivalry
- Overthrowing Progressive Tyrants
- Magnificent Humanity (ring any bells?)

…need I say more? Why have you not read this yet? Go fix that.
Profile Image for Cornelia.
226 reviews42 followers
April 14, 2018
I miss those kind of stories-do they make it still nowadays? A satirical, humorous story that makes you curl with a soft blanket next to the fire sipping a hot chocolate and indulging yourself with earthly delights. Making fun of legalism or prohibition-Chesterton paints a picture so real. From finding loopholes in keeping a pub open-a flying inn, to the atrocious speeches "important people" give, to the conformism of the masses, you will laugh, wonder, and laugh again.
Profile Image for Данило Судин.
594 reviews437 followers
Read
February 15, 2026
Читати цю книгу в Україні в 2026 році — доволі бентежне заняття. Адже роман вперше видано в 1914 — якраз напередодні Першої світової війни. І через це він набуває подвійної анахронічності.
1️⃣ По-перше, на момент виходу книги європейський порядок та світогляд розвалилася. Більш пафосно можна було б сказати: загинув в битві на Марні у вересні 1914 року.
2️⃣ По-друге, після 1945 року світ рушив зовсім в інший бік. І 2008/2014/2022 лише посилив проблеми, породжені Ялтою'45.

А тому більшу частину книги я не міг позбутися почуття, що автор нас застерігає від проблем, які ніколи в історії Європи не постали.

⚠️ Але одразу мушу застерегти: анотація роману спонукає думати, що роман з часом став тільки ще більш актуальним, ніж в часи Честертона. На жаль, це не так. Звісно, одна з загроз, з якою борються головні герої, це ісламізація Великобританії. Втім... Честертона іслам як такий не цікавить. Замість ісламу в центр твору він міг з таким же успіхом поставити буддизм, конфуціанство чи іудаїзм... Іслам потрібен Честертону з двох причин:
1️⃣ тому що в ісламі заборонено вживати алкоголь;
2️⃣ тому що іслам протягом V–XI ст. був джерелом європейських знань про Античність.

Ці дві ідеї дозволяють Честертону поставити два гострих питання:
❓ Чи культурна вищість в минулому дає право на привілеї в теперішньому?
❓ Чи має право влада регулювати повсякденне життя своїх громадян?

Обидва питання звучать дуже актуально, але спосіб, в який їх ставить Честертон, а також відповіді, які він пропонує, адекватні для ХІХ ст. і абсолютно хибні для ХХ чи ХХІ ст.

Щодо першого, Честертон ставить його не в контексті міграцій (коли населення Великобританії перестає бути однорідним), а в контексті ідей та мрій британської аристократії...
Щодо другого, то ідеалом Честертона є держава, яка є "слабкою", тобто її інститути не пронизують повсякдення, але водночас правовою, коли дотримання законів — неухильне і абсолютне.

Втім, найбільшими проблемами книги — якщо її читати в 2026 році! — є дві речі.
1️⃣ Честертон критикує британську аристократію, ні слова не кажучи про сильні та слабкі сторони пересічних британців. Через це складається враження, що основна проблема — недолугість владних еліт. І це веде до другої проблеми.
2️⃣ Честертон критикує не універсальні риси владних еліт, а специфічно британські. Зокрема, на перше місце виходить спадковість аристократії: оскільки в Британії аристократи живуть в соціальному та фізичному відокремленні від решти суспільства, то вони не виявляють розуміння проблем, з якими стикаються прості британці. І це могло бути сюжетом критики, яка є універсальною для всіх суспільств. Але не сталося. І все тому, що Честертон починає критикувати речі, які зрозумілі британцям в 1914 році, але абсолютно недоступні всім решта — чи в часі, чи в просторі.

Але й це можна було б витримати, якби твір мав сюжет. Але роман розпадається на низку окремих історій, які об'єднані спільними персонажами, але не більше. Деколи здається, ніби герої забули, що і навіщо вони робили в попередніх розділах — і їхні дії ніяк не складаються в узгоджену послідовність. Завдяки цьому стежити за їхніми переміщеннями по сюжету та просторі Англії стає просто неможливим...

Не варто й казати, що характерів в персонажів тут і близько немає. Звісно, в сатирі вони наче й не обов'язкові, але... Сатира тут дуже контекстуальна. І тому твір вона не "витягує". Цьому б зарадили характери героїв, але Честертон їх не прописав.

Тому й вийшла історія, яка століття по написанні не звучить цікаво. Шкода, але "маємо те, що маємо".
Profile Image for Magread.
153 reviews21 followers
May 8, 2026
Багато англійської іронії, але боюся, що я не зчитали все, що закладав автор
Profile Image for Ero.
193 reviews25 followers
September 26, 2008
An odd book.

Chesterton's an amazing proser, and his books are pretty much always delightful from a using-the-english-language point of view. And there's a lot to like about this book, which is sort of a love letter to alcohol and the Traditional English folk who drink it. There is much silliness and romping around with a keg of rum and a giant wheel of cheese. There are many rollicking songs to sing while rolling said keg of rum down the road. But there's also a darkness to the book, a deep anxiety and shadow that seems very timely: the fear of arabs.

In this semi-sci-fi alternate britain, 'oriental' influences have banned booze, promoted (gasp) vegetarianism, sought to replace christianity with idol-worship, and in general replaced dear old england's can-do spirit with a lurking islamic/hindu voodoo. The books reveals a bit too much xenophobia for my taste.

In times less full of fear (I just got that anti-islam propaganda DVD in the mail yesterday) this would be fine and I could ignore it and enjoy the playful parts of the book. Reading it now though was fairly unpleasant, and will make it harder for me to enjoy Father Brown in the future.
Profile Image for CJ Bowen.
653 reviews22 followers
April 13, 2012
Chesterton's writing is too big for his books as he maintains an extra storyline or two and suffuses the narrative with poems, but he remains Chesterton, and such trivial flaws are quickly forgiven. This story was particularly amusing, as inns and pubs, really any place that serves alcohol, are closed down as the Muslim religion conquests ideologically through England. A wildly Chestertonian character and a common Britisher band together to exploit a loophole in the law, bringing Christian rum across the country by means of the Flying Inn. Chesterton is unafraid to view the conflict of religions through the lens of apparently trivial liberties, and rompingly makes his case by means of a silly novel. He would, of course, consider silly novels to be the most potent kind, and I for one wouldn't mind many more such efforts replacing earnest Amish fiction everywhere.
Profile Image for Miguel Gonzalez-Feliciano.
103 reviews
May 6, 2024
In the same vein as The Ball and the Cross, the Flying Inn is a fictional work that expounds the ideas and concepts of G.K. Chesterton's work, What's Wrong With The World. Full of humorous moments and thought provoking dialogue, The Flying Inn was an enjoyable read.
Profile Image for Anna.
18 reviews2 followers
September 8, 2009
Fighting an evil regime with beer! Only Chesterton could do it, and so well.
Profile Image for Jordan.
Author 5 books116 followers
October 21, 2024
A difficult Chesterton book to rate. On one hand, there is much to enjoy here and the novel as a whole presents a great argument against the overweening and smothering moralistic progressive state that aims to reshape the common people for their own good and ends up making them miserable. In that way it prefigures books as different as That Hideous Strength and Atlas Shrugged. On the other, it doesn't really work as a novel, being basically a picaresque series of sketches and allegorical incidents with hardly any forward momentum. Full review for Chestertober at the blog.
Profile Image for Temucano.
634 reviews24 followers
September 26, 2025
Una cruzada en defensa del líquido espirituoso, sátira continua de humor mordaz que combina diálogos con situaciones jocosas y sobre todo caracterizando fuerte a sus personajes, logrando caricaturizar la acción de forma perfecta. Lástima que tiende a emocionarse con cualquier tema, irse por las ramas y ya nunca volver a la trama principal, acompañando además este despliegue con canciones y poemas a destajo. Al principio partí entusiasmado pero ya por la mitad comprendí que no llegaría a ningún lado así que mejor pisé el acelerador. No me equivoqué.
Profile Image for Adam Marischuk.
248 reviews30 followers
February 14, 2018
Fun and prescient

In a world gone mad, two drunk friends decide to save the world with a keg and a barsign. The best way to fight the tyrrany is with a cultural revolution, or at least a drunken spin.

The reason it is so prescient is that Chesterton foresaw the queer alliance between the political left and what he calls 'the orient' but what we would understand to be Islam and Buddhism. Written before prohibition, it is eerily prophetic. Chesterton foresaw the bizarre alliance between feminism, low-Church evangelicalism, Germanic utilitarianism and the quasi-mysticism of the orient, along with a political class too far removed from the hopes, dreams and desires of the general population.

The book is full of Chesterton's folksy wisdom and belief in common-sense. And while this is generally to be expected in any Chesterton novel, in this one it sometimes becomes too dense and exaggerated. The characters are caricatures and vehicles for Chesterton's philosophical and cultural opinions. Either you like it or you don't.

"The sun was sinking: but the river of human nonsense flowed on for ever." (p.17)

"feeding on fanatical pleasure: the pleasure his strange, cold, courageous nature could not get from food or wine or women." (p.51)

"Lord Ivywood shared the mental weakness of most men who have fed on books; he ignored, not the value but the very existence of other forms of information." (p.52)

"Country folk will forget you if you speak to them, but talk about you all day if you don't." (p.53)

"There was a faint renewal of that laughter that has slept since the Middle Ages." (p.62)

"I have long been increasingly convinced that underneath a certain mask of stiffness which the Mohammedan religion has worn through certain centuries, as a somewhat similar mask has been worn by the religion of the Jews, Islam has in it the potentialities of being the most progressive of all religions" (p.78)

"He chopped and changed his original article in such a way that it was something quite beyond the most bewildering article he had written in the past; and is still prized by those highly cultured persons who collect the worst literature of the world." (p.101)

"Then there was a weak plea for Eugenics; and a warm plea against Conscription, which was not true eugenics." (p. 102)

"All that was natural in her was still alive under all that was artificial." (p.111)

"The next best thing to really loving a fellow creature is really hating him...the desire to murder him is at least an acknowledgement that he is alive." (p.192)

"There are crowds who do not care to revolt; but there are no crowds who do not like someone else to do it for them." (p.234)

"Not seeing any rational explanation of this custom of dying, so prevalent among his fellow-citizens, he concluded that it was merely tradition." (p.235)

Feast on wine or fast on water,
And your honour shall stand sure;
God Almighty's son and daughter,
He the valiant, she the pure.
If an angel out of heaven
Brings you other things to drink,
Thank him for his kind intentions,
Go and pour them down the sink.

Tea is like the East he grows in,
A great yellow Mandarin,
With urbanity of manner,
And unconsciousness of sin;
All the women, like a harem,
At his pig-tail troop along,
And, like all the East he grows in,
He is Poison when he's strong.

Tea, although an Oriental,
Is a gentleman at least;
Cocoa is a cad and coward,
Cocoa is a vulgar beast;
Cocoa is a dull, disloyal,
Lying, crawling cad and clown,
And may very well be grateful
To the fool that takes him down.

As for all the windy waters,
They were rained like trumpets down,
When good drink had been dishonoured
By the tipplers of the town.
When red wine had brought red ruin,
And the death-dance of our times,
Heaven sent us Soda Water
As a torment for our crimes.
Profile Image for Robert.
63 reviews5 followers
June 21, 2024
This was an enormous struggle to read. I thought the premise of this book was that Britain had become an Islamic state, so I expected a British version of Submission by Michel Houellebecq, with the added treat of it being written in 1914. However, if I had started reading this without any prior knowledge, I don't think I'd ever have known that was the plot.

Supposedly, the plot is that England somehow becomes a colony of the Ottoman Empire and transforms into an Islamic country. This is something I only know because of things written about the book. The backstory you think is coming never materialises. The story just goes on and you never know why anything is happening.

It begins with an Islamic preacher of some kind giving a speech to one woman in a seaside town. No one else is even interested. Therefore, at the start of the story, we're led to believe this movement hasn't yet gained traction. How much, and when this changes, is never made clear. The story remains vague and confusing from beginning to end.

The only thing made clear is that alcohol is banned unless a venue has a sign outside it. But doesn't that mean it's not banned at all? Just make a sign and then you can carry on serving alcohol. It seems like this supposed ban on alcohol has a loophole so large it could fit around a planet. This loophole is never addressed.

It is only for the last thirty or so pages that the apparent Islamic transformation of England is alluded to in any kind of detail, but even then it's vague.

The narrative of this book is so confusing, so meandering and so full of different characters that I never knew where it was going and why anything was happening. For that reason, it was never easy. You cannot enjoy a story if you permanently have no idea why anything is happening and where anything is going. At the start of the story, I held out hope that we would get into some detail about the supposed plot. But it never arrives.

If I hadn't read in advance that this is supposedly about England becoming a Muslim country, I wouldn't even know that now, having read it in full. Never have I a finished a book that was so arduous and so unrewarding.
Profile Image for Іван Синєпалов.
Author 3 books45 followers
July 20, 2021
Честертона ще за життя називали найвправнішим майстром англійської мови серед сучасників. Не знаю, як він звучить в оригіналі, але навіть в перекладі - дуже живо.

Писати антиутопію після Орвелла - задум доволі самовпевнений, але писати антиутопію до Орвела і навіть Замятіна - це взагалі зухвалість найвищого ґатунку. Тим паче, коли антиутопія ця сатирична.

Перші два-три розділи книги ніби налаштовують на поважний лад, але потім швидко стає ясно, що поважності там нема і сліду, а є тільки суміш грубої насмішки з пацифізму і неприхованого страху перед ісламом та Оттоманською імперією. Страх, власне, виправдався дуже скоро: перша світова війна почалася десь у той же час, як текст було закінчено.

Події у романі надзвичайно стрімкі, обставини абсурдні, а персонажі - кмітливі. Жодних сумнівів, що це зерня пізніше проросло і у Пелема Вайтгауза, і у Дуґласа Адамса. Та й навіть основна думка "1984" цілком може бути відповіддю на питання, поставлене у "Летючому шинку": хіба можна збудувати імперію, якщо казати, що 2 на 2 дорівнює 5?

Якщо відкинути розбіжності у формі, то за суттю Честертон пише про прислужливий мультикультуралізм, покірну толерантність і культуру скасування. Ну принаймні вірить в одужання пацієнта.

Сухі закони завжди призводять до появи летючих шинків, а здача національних інтересів завжди призводить до появи Патріків Делроїв.
73 reviews22 followers
January 21, 2013
Didn't really know how to rate this. There's some fantastic Chestertonian wit (the satirical account of Hibbs However's journalistic style is hilarious and still pertinent today), some lusty, loveable, eccentric characters and, whatever I think about other ideological elements in the books, it's hard not to admire, in a general sense, Chesterton's championing of individual liberties.

But...this is probably one of the most racist books I have ever read. I know Chesterton was of another age and is hardly known for his political correctness, but, while in other of his books I can gloss over the occasional racist remark, here the entire basis of the book is Islamophobic and anti-oriental.

It also meanders on aimlessly for a bit too long. I rarely get bored reading Chesterton, but with this one I did.

There's also FAR too much poetry padding it out.
1,167 reviews41 followers
January 19, 2013
The first half dragged rather, but once they had dealt with the man who watered the milk then the book caught fire and felt typical Chesterton. And what can be better than that? There are plenty of his wonderful descriptions of skies - no-one can make you see a sunset like him. The hero Dalroy is excellently realised, the women are more differentiated than usual, and the issues raised in the fantastical plot are as relevant today.
But, I regret to say, the charges against Chesterton of anti-Semitism are given plenty of evidence here. I'm not saying they are the views of the man himself, who apparently was tolerance personified, but I still don't like the way he writes about Jews. Which is what knocks off the last star.
1 review1 follower
June 8, 2014
The main summary of this book fails to mention its chief feature ! It takes place in a Britain which has become part of the Ottoman Empire. As this makes it a Muslim country, it has a certain relevance today, presumably never dreamed of by the author (who was trying to make various other points through this unlikely situation).
Profile Image for Andrew Orange.
Author 5 books27 followers
April 7, 2017
Fine!
Dedicated to fans of no alcohol law.
In addition, Chesterton correctly indicates that the ruling "elite" of UK are traitors to Christianity.
Profile Image for Shauna.
413 reviews34 followers
February 11, 2022
Although there were moments of highbrow humor to keep it interesting, the story was just okay.
Profile Image for JaggedHighways.
50 reviews
November 14, 2026
In The Flying Inn, G.K. Chesterton imagines a Britain where, due to swift ideological shifts forced by the Aristocracy on the citizens, Alcohol sale is now banned. With this book, G.K. Chesterton tries to murder multiple birds with one stone, but his primary target is the tone-deaf attitude of the rich aristocracy towards the sentiments of the common people, and their hypocrisy in the implementation of restrictions. The book follows a stream-of-consciousness style narration which is incredibly imaginative, borderline dreamy, and transports the reader to a world that seems uncanny, but is relatable enough to make sense. However, as the story progresses, this style leads to monologues and descriptions that are often convoluted and self-absorbed.

What makes this book worth reading is its critique of the snobbery of the upper class, and its needless suppression and exploitation of the lower classes. Throughout the book, Chesterton's writing of various events and dialogue exchanges is humorous, and he shows that he can make the reader chuckle with ease. However, the second half of the book is less anecdotal and more self-indulgent, and it continuously feels as if Chesterton hypothesized a very specific premise of this story, with a very specific protagonist (who is so obviously meant to represent him in the book with zero subtlety), and a very specific set of villains, just to win hypothetical arguments and turn the book into a series of "gotcha" moments. I do believe that underneath that mess is a good story that could have been way more effective and entertaining without all the needless monologues and casual bigotry, but towards the end it feels less like a story and more like a series of essays.

Expanding on the bigotry part, the premise of the book, the scattering of racist remarks, and most importantly, Chesterton's representation of Islam and Muslims feels very inconsistent with the deep understanding that he claims to show of all the issues that he discusses in the book. All the commentary and gotcha moments in the book might have been pulled of well if they had been set up in earnest, and if depicting prohibition of alcohol in a satirical way was the goal, there were other more plausible means to achieve that (the US demonstrated that in real life a few years later) rather than hypothesizing a very unlikely scenario where Muslims hypnotize the elites and ban alcohol straightaway, among other ridiculous actions they're shown to take. For someone whose narration was meant to be a brag about his layers of understanding on several subjects, his representation of Islam was superficial and absolutely intended to be malicious, all so he could win some hypothetical arguments.

Despite its overall tone, this book does have some saving graces, which I mentioned above, and it offers a peek into the mind of an author who was an undoubtedly talented writer, albeit one with biased ideological leanings, because of which this book might not be everyone's cup of tea.
6 reviews
May 15, 2026
Começo por uma evidência: é um livro difícil de ler; e é também uma crítica: porque se em Chesterton o estilo e a substância vão habitualmente lado a lado, aqui os temas muitas vezes afogam as descrições, os diálogos e as personagens e tornam a leitura custosa.
E, ainda assim, é Chesterton.
A premissa do livro é de que o Islão foi tomando de assalto Inglaterra até levar avante o proibicionismo.
Chesterton faz a defesa do álcool, o que é excelente, mas escuda acima de tudo aquilo que lhe era e nos devia ser caro: senso comum, liberdade, tradições partilhadas, justiça e humildade, respeito pelo povo e em particular pelos pobres, desconfiança das elites intelectuais que querem refazer o mundo e dá-lo de comer aos outros.
É um livro sacramental, pois baseia-se no facto que uma tabuleta de uma estalagem produz sempre aquilo que significa: uma estalagem.
É um livro escatológico, pois o super-homem do livro, que pretendia refazer o mundo, termina inacessível a si próprio e aos outros - no Inferno.
E é um livro que ilustra melhor que nenhum a guerra de culturas, pois a religião que tem no seu livro a proibição da imagem é derrotada por aquela que tem no seu Deus Aquele que Se fez imagem.
É profético como só Chesterton sabe ser; a ele só peço que rogue por nós, pois todos os males que afligem os heróis do livro ainda hoje nos afligem.
333 reviews30 followers
August 14, 2022
[3.7 stars, I really liked it, but suspect it is a one-time read]

The good news is that The Flying Inn is humorous, witty, and well-written. The bad news is, Chesterton does a terrible job with endings. Further, it's not exactly fast-paced though that's in part due to the singing (or verse anyway). It was not easy for me to follow Chesterton's train of thought, but slowing down allowed me to enjoy it.

The Flying Inn pits the excesses of the temperance movement against the populace, and in general, discusses a great deal how unpopular laws can be brought to pass. It is remarkable what similarities one finds between banning alcohol and requiring masks, in terms of how the privileged ensure they are not impacted.

Favorite quote: "It is wonderful how easily one outlives someone else’s crucifixion."
Profile Image for Drew.
41 reviews
May 11, 2025
My first Chesterton novel. It took a minute to realize it is satire which keeps company with Adam’s and Pratchett. A chapter or two were good, a few more pages were excellent, and there were a multitude of genius sentences and phrases. This, unfortunately, didn’t add up to a good novel. It was scattered and convoluted. A screen adaptation perhaps would be able to reconcile and trim this into a good farce.

I can’t recommend it, but I have several pages dogeared for quotations.
Profile Image for Laurel Hicks.
1,163 reviews123 followers
November 9, 2020
This is one that I’ll have to read another time or two to digest fully. That worked for me with GKC’s amazing The Man who was Thursday.
42 reviews
July 5, 2025
G. K. was a prophet... or do we continually not learn from our mistakes?
A fun read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 124 reviews