For everyone who is interested in recent Albanian history, Communist studies or just wants to gain insights into the mind of a dictator, I recommend Fevziu’s biography of Hoxha. Unlike other despots Hoxha used to be a prolific writer (as well as a tireless reader): already during his reign he published a great many books, undergirding his self-proclaimed image of an impeccable leader; nevertheless, there has never been a really critical/insightful book about his persona, let alone in English. In this study, though, Fevziu puts new information together about the life of Enver Hoxha from interviews conducted after the fall of Communism in Albania (1991) as well as from files and documents which were not accessible until recently.
From 1944 until 1985 Hoxha ruled Albania with an iron fist; in my opinion, a comparison to today’s North Korea is fitting to what Albanians went through. For almost half a century nothing got in and nothing got out of this small country, seemingly so full of contradictions: from a colony of Fascist Italy to a Stalinist state, to an overnight democracy, and finally becoming a narco-state, eager to enter the European Union, Albania was and still is in many regards a mystery to me.
To come back to the book, Fevziu describes how Communism sprouted in Albania after Nazi-Germany pulled out of it in 1944. In fact, already during the occupation, various resistance movements, including Communist and nationalist groups, formed and fought against the Axis powers. Quite remarkably, Hoxha joined the Communists early on but was never more than just an inconspicuous follower, who at times even denied being part of the movement. Later on, when Hoxha was in power, he substantially altered the story, portraying himself as a fervent revolutionary of the very first hour. In actual fact, Hoxha was at best an opportunist who happened to be at the right place at the right time – just like in 1943, when the two main figures of the CPA were in a stalemate over the party leadership. On this occasion, Miladin Popovic, Tito’s emissary to the CPA put his eyes on Hoxha as a compromise solution, since he seemed to the Yugoslavians a “handsome” man who was “easy to control” and who could be pushed aside if need be. In hindsight, this assessment turned out to be terribly wrong.
Under Hoxha, the CPA - which was renamed to PLA (Party of Labour of Albania) due to the lack of an actual proletariat - became the most rigidly anti-revisionist party in the Eastern Bloc. Known for his staunch adherence to Marxist-Leninist principles, Hoxha tolerated no deviation from pure Socialism or simply any form of criticism. In big parts the book just recounts the trail of blood Hoxha left behind himself on his way to unquestioned power: to put it simply, he just viciously murdered anyone who could pose a threat, real or imagined. Even his closest friends were not safe from falling out of favour. The most dramatic case in this regard must be the “suicide” of Mehmet Shehu, PM of Albania from 1954 until his death in 1981 if not Hoxha’s closest comrade for more than 40 years. What costed Shehu his life was allowing his son, without Hoxha’s consent, to marry a woman whose parents turned out to have had anti-Communist sentiments in the past according to Segurimi files (Hoxha’s infamous secret police). Such circumstances were enough to convince Hoxha that he must have been betrayed all along; Shehu was found dead with a bullet wound to his head. The rest of the Shehu family, previously the neighbours of the Hoxha’s for decades, were either imprisoned or relegated to forced-labour.
Diplomatically Hoxha was as also as uncompromising as he was with his foes: Hoxha's relationship with Josip Broz Tito, the leader of Yugoslavia, was particularly strained. The rift between the two leaders deepened over ideological and geopolitical differences. Hoxha accused Tito of pursuing a revisionist form of Communism, and Albania distanced itself from Yugoslavia. Hoxha's relationship with the Soviet Union, especially during the era of Nikita Khrushchev, was also complicated. Hoxha criticized Khrushchev's policies and condemned what he perceived as Soviet deviations from true Marxist-Leninist principles. This consequently led to a cooling of relations between Albania and the USSR. The only major non-West aligned power which remained an option at this point was China: good relations were beneficial to Hoxha but only until 1971, when Nixon visited Mao. Hoxha considered the rapprochement an unforgivable betrayal. At this stage Albania was internationally isolated, incredibly poor and badly governed – according to Fevziu, Hoxha’s persecution of the intelligentsia (prison sentences of 20 years were handed out left and right) led to governments where ministers had no further education than elementary school.
In 1985 Hoxha died in his house in the Blloku neighbourhood of Tirana, today’s fancy nightlife district of the Albanian capital. Tens of thousands of people were either imprisoned or killed in the political purges, forced labor camps, and executions, carried out under the guise of combating perceived “enemies of the state” or “counter-revolutionaries”. Additionally, Hoxha's policies, including the isolationist and autarkic economic model, resulted in widespread poverty and hardship for the Albanian population, further exacerbating the suffering of the people during his rule.
On one of the final pages Fevziu rightfully concludes that “[the] Albania Hoxha has promised 40 years earlier did not exist. It was never achieved. What Albanian people were left with is best described as a nightmarish caricature of Stalin’s Soviet Union, a carbon copy of Stalinist oppression crammed within the borders of a small country of 3 million people”.