What do you think?
Rate this book
OLD ABE: THE STORY OF A LINCOLN SHEEP
Old A Novel recounts the last five years of Abraham Lincoln’s life, the most cataclysmic years of America’s history. We are at Lincoln’s side on every page of this vivid novel as he presses forward amid disaster and comes to life once again fighting to save the country. The story begins in the spring of 1860 in Illinois and follows Lincoln through his election and the calamity of the Civil War to his assassination at the height of power. During the war, he walks the bloody battlefields of Virginia and Maryland. He peers down the Potomac River with a spyglass amid terrifying reports of approaching Confederate gunboats. Death stalks one summer evening, a would-be assassin fires a shot at him, and the bullet passes through his hat. At the White House, he weeps over the body of Willie, his second son to die in childhood. As he tries desperately to hold the Union together, he searches for a general who will fight and finds him at last in Ulysses S. Grant. Amid national and personal tragedy, he struggles to find meaning in the war and bring freedom to Southern slaves. Central to this novel is a love story—the story of Abraham and Mary Lincoln’s sometimes stormy yet devoted marriage. Mary Todd Lincoln’s strong will and ambition for her husband have helped drive him to the White House, but the presidency takes an awful toll on her, and she grows increasingly frightened and insecure. Lincoln watches helplessly as she becomes emotionally unstable, and he grasps for ways to support her. As Lincoln’s journey unfolds, Old Abe probes the enduring character and spirit of America. This story portrays Lincoln not only as a flesh-and-blood man, but a hero who embodies his country’s finest ideals. Set amid America’s most devastating tragedy, Old Abe captures the triumphs and defeats of one of the greatest leaders in US history, the one who set a divided country on track to become a great nation.
Unknown Binding
First published September 15, 2020
112 people are currently reading
3338 people want to read
About the author
John Cribb
6 books55 followersJohn Cribb is a bestselling author who has written about subjects ranging from history to education. His work includes coauthoring The American Patriot’s Almanac and The Educated Child, both New York Times bestsellers; co-editing The Human Odyssey, a 3-volume world history text, and developing on-line history courses. His writing has been published in the Wall Street Journal, USA Today, the Chicago Tribune, National Review Online, The Hill, Real Clear Politics, and several other publications. Old Abe is John’s first novel. Learn more at johncribbauthor.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews
June 4, 2021
Everyone knows about Abe Lincoln, but do you really know Abe Lincoln? Author John Cribb seeks to reveal the man behind the public image in this fictionalised life story of the 16th president of the United States of America.
The book begins in 1860, with Lincoln’s first presidential race and ends with his funeral. These last five years of the president’s life are publicly known to be quite difficult what with the Civil War and his personal tragedies. Cribb deftly shows his reimagining of Lincoln’s probable reactions and responses to the daily challenges of his presidency. While the story begins in 1860, the narrative provides enough flashbacks for us to know his humble roots, his family, and the path that led him to politics. There are many popular anecdotes about Lincoln’s life that have been woven into the narrative smoothly.
As a non-American, I have no school knowledge of Abraham Lincoln. So I can’t comment much on the accuracy of the events. But it sure felt authentic. You must have a basic knowledge of American history otherwise you'll feel a little lost. I felt that the author might have written this book mainly for the American readers who are already aware of common historical facts. But Lincoln’s appeal goes far beyond American borders and to those who wish to know more about Lincoln, this book is the wrong place to start. The content is interesting but becomes a tad dry at times when it focusses more on the history than on the person in focus. But I loved the glimpse the book provides into Lincoln’s personal life, especially his complicated relationship with his wife Mary and his love for his sons. I also appreciate how the author didn’t milk out the event of the assassination with undue gore or an exaggerated display of emotions. That death scene is beautifully written and I sure hope Lincoln’s last thoughts might have been as peaceful.
A special mention is merited to the foreword by William J. Bennett. He sets the tone for the novel beautifully.
Where the book experience soured a little for me was in the narration. I heard the audio version of this novel. At 11 hrs. long, the audiobook shouldn’t have been too taxing. But the narrator was so dull and his voice so lulling that I couldn’t keep up my interest in the book. Eventually, I had to crank up the audio speed to 1.75x so that I didn’t end up dozing to his soothing hushed tones. He also voiced most of the characters similarly with the sole exception of Tad, Lincoln’s youngest son. So the audio version was a little disappointing.
Lincoln is frequently known as one of the greatest, most ethical and most honest men who ever lived. Politicians today would do well to learn from his moral values and incorporate them. At the same time, this book will better serve those who already have some knowledge about Lincoln and the history of his times. It’s historical fiction for a reason; don’t substitute it for a biography.
Thank you, NetGalley and Orange Sky Audio, for the audio ARC of the book in exchange for an honest review.
***********************
Join me on the Facebook group, Readers Forever! , for more reviews, book-related discussions and fun.
Follow me on Instagram: RoshReviews
The book begins in 1860, with Lincoln’s first presidential race and ends with his funeral. These last five years of the president’s life are publicly known to be quite difficult what with the Civil War and his personal tragedies. Cribb deftly shows his reimagining of Lincoln’s probable reactions and responses to the daily challenges of his presidency. While the story begins in 1860, the narrative provides enough flashbacks for us to know his humble roots, his family, and the path that led him to politics. There are many popular anecdotes about Lincoln’s life that have been woven into the narrative smoothly.
As a non-American, I have no school knowledge of Abraham Lincoln. So I can’t comment much on the accuracy of the events. But it sure felt authentic. You must have a basic knowledge of American history otherwise you'll feel a little lost. I felt that the author might have written this book mainly for the American readers who are already aware of common historical facts. But Lincoln’s appeal goes far beyond American borders and to those who wish to know more about Lincoln, this book is the wrong place to start. The content is interesting but becomes a tad dry at times when it focusses more on the history than on the person in focus. But I loved the glimpse the book provides into Lincoln’s personal life, especially his complicated relationship with his wife Mary and his love for his sons. I also appreciate how the author didn’t milk out the event of the assassination with undue gore or an exaggerated display of emotions. That death scene is beautifully written and I sure hope Lincoln’s last thoughts might have been as peaceful.
A special mention is merited to the foreword by William J. Bennett. He sets the tone for the novel beautifully.
Where the book experience soured a little for me was in the narration. I heard the audio version of this novel. At 11 hrs. long, the audiobook shouldn’t have been too taxing. But the narrator was so dull and his voice so lulling that I couldn’t keep up my interest in the book. Eventually, I had to crank up the audio speed to 1.75x so that I didn’t end up dozing to his soothing hushed tones. He also voiced most of the characters similarly with the sole exception of Tad, Lincoln’s youngest son. So the audio version was a little disappointing.
Lincoln is frequently known as one of the greatest, most ethical and most honest men who ever lived. Politicians today would do well to learn from his moral values and incorporate them. At the same time, this book will better serve those who already have some knowledge about Lincoln and the history of his times. It’s historical fiction for a reason; don’t substitute it for a biography.
Thank you, NetGalley and Orange Sky Audio, for the audio ARC of the book in exchange for an honest review.
***********************
Join me on the Facebook group, Readers Forever! , for more reviews, book-related discussions and fun.
Follow me on Instagram: RoshReviews
November 30, 2020
I LOVED THIS BOOK!!
You all know how much I love historical fiction and this may be the best Abraham Lincoln stories I have ever read.
John Cribb’s writing of Abraham Lincoln in fiction really brought this amazing life story in a more intimate setting as we see Abraham Lincoln transformed from a distant historical figure, to a living and breathing man of flesh and blood within the pages of this book.
This was a truly fascinating read I enjoyed!!
You all know how much I love historical fiction and this may be the best Abraham Lincoln stories I have ever read.
John Cribb’s writing of Abraham Lincoln in fiction really brought this amazing life story in a more intimate setting as we see Abraham Lincoln transformed from a distant historical figure, to a living and breathing man of flesh and blood within the pages of this book.
This was a truly fascinating read I enjoyed!!
November 16, 2020
"This nation is the world's best hope for freedom...If we save the Union, we prove that popular government is not an absurdity. We save a government founded to elevate the condition of men- to lift artificial weights from all shoulders, to afford all an unfettered start."
Abraham Lincoln
Old Abe
John Cribb
I am picky about my historical fiction, and reading Old Abe over the past week checked off all my boxes. Growing up in Boston gave me an early love of American history, but I was also raised by a father who had me walk the battlefields of Gettysburg at a young age. I might have whined about it then, but I am incredibly grateful now.
Cribb's novel brings one of our nation's icons to life and gives us the backstory of what Mr. Lincoln was experiencing on a personal level while also trying to save the country. We learn more about his troubled wife, Mary, the relationships with his sons and the men he chose to help guide him through some of our darkest hours.
Old Abe humanizes a man we have all studied and idolized and brings to light the weight that was on Lincoln's shoulders; it is astounding. The physical copy of Old Abe is a booklover's treasure. The cover is antiqued and the pages are thick and deckle edged - I've already purchased my father a copy for Christmas.
Old Abe reads like a novel, but is packed with the facts from the years leading up to Lincoln's assassination -- I think this is the most accessible way to process history. It is also a solid reminder that as a nation we have risen from some very dark times and we will rise again. Great book.
Abraham Lincoln
Old Abe
John Cribb
I am picky about my historical fiction, and reading Old Abe over the past week checked off all my boxes. Growing up in Boston gave me an early love of American history, but I was also raised by a father who had me walk the battlefields of Gettysburg at a young age. I might have whined about it then, but I am incredibly grateful now.
Cribb's novel brings one of our nation's icons to life and gives us the backstory of what Mr. Lincoln was experiencing on a personal level while also trying to save the country. We learn more about his troubled wife, Mary, the relationships with his sons and the men he chose to help guide him through some of our darkest hours.
Old Abe humanizes a man we have all studied and idolized and brings to light the weight that was on Lincoln's shoulders; it is astounding. The physical copy of Old Abe is a booklover's treasure. The cover is antiqued and the pages are thick and deckle edged - I've already purchased my father a copy for Christmas.
Old Abe reads like a novel, but is packed with the facts from the years leading up to Lincoln's assassination -- I think this is the most accessible way to process history. It is also a solid reminder that as a nation we have risen from some very dark times and we will rise again. Great book.
November 21, 2020
Unfortunately! This book wasn’t for me. If you enjoy history then you’ll like it. I liked some parts but I just couldn’t get into it.
What I discovered is that Abraham Lincoln had a strong personality and kept his promises to the American people.
What I discovered is that Abraham Lincoln had a strong personality and kept his promises to the American people.
February 12, 2021
"...With malice toward none; with charity for all; with firmness in the right, as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in; to bind up the nation's wounds; to care for him who shall have borne the battle, and for his widow, and his orphan-to do all which may achieve and cherish a just, and a lasting peace, among ourselves, and with all nations."
It is mind boggling to think that President Lincoln spoke these words over 150 years ago at his second inauguration and they can still apply to heal our divided nation..."to bind up the nation's wounds."
I share today, my birthday, with one of the greatest presidents to serve the office. He is an example of what leadership can be and should be and author John Cribb brings him to life in his remarkably humbling novel Old Abe.
With over 15,000 books written about Abraham Lincoln this writer made a very conscious decision to write this as historical fiction so that we could better understand the man, the human behind the legendary stories in the last five years of his life.
The author has succeeded in humanizing President Lincoln. We see him as a conscientious lawyer, a hesitant politician, a loving father who grieves the loss of two young sons, and a very devoted husband to a wife who eventually succumbed to severe depression from the death of her children and the pressures of being the First Lady.
I have always felt an affinity with Old Abe. We share a birthday, a love of country, and immense pride in our children. My birthday wish this year is that Lincoln's wish for a healed prosperous nation finally comes true and we can all get along and live in peace.
I won this book in an Instagram giveaway from the amazing Michelle @nurse_bookie and am giving an honest and fair review. All opinions are my own.
It is mind boggling to think that President Lincoln spoke these words over 150 years ago at his second inauguration and they can still apply to heal our divided nation..."to bind up the nation's wounds."
I share today, my birthday, with one of the greatest presidents to serve the office. He is an example of what leadership can be and should be and author John Cribb brings him to life in his remarkably humbling novel Old Abe.
With over 15,000 books written about Abraham Lincoln this writer made a very conscious decision to write this as historical fiction so that we could better understand the man, the human behind the legendary stories in the last five years of his life.
The author has succeeded in humanizing President Lincoln. We see him as a conscientious lawyer, a hesitant politician, a loving father who grieves the loss of two young sons, and a very devoted husband to a wife who eventually succumbed to severe depression from the death of her children and the pressures of being the First Lady.
I have always felt an affinity with Old Abe. We share a birthday, a love of country, and immense pride in our children. My birthday wish this year is that Lincoln's wish for a healed prosperous nation finally comes true and we can all get along and live in peace.
I won this book in an Instagram giveaway from the amazing Michelle @nurse_bookie and am giving an honest and fair review. All opinions are my own.
November 24, 2020
Oh Abe Lincoln, you were truly one of the greatest men who’ve ever lived.
This fiction by John Cribb read very much like a nonfiction novel because Cribb did not skimp on his research! The historical fiction lover and scholastic nerd in me truly appreciated the amount of work this took and the rich element it added to the story of Lincoln’s time in the presidency. I felt completely immersed in the history and time. Of course, enhancing this is the fact that I’m a distant cousin of many greats to Abe Lincoln- a fun fact I like to flaunt whenever I can. ;)
I like that Cribb didn’t portray Lincoln without human flaws because I feel that history sometimes leaves out the fact that Lincoln wasn’t always right and wasn’t always cheerful. He was human. That’s realistic.
We all know how Lincoln met his tragic end (no spoilers here) but I found the way Cribb described his passing to be very gentle and forgiving, not to mention, beautiful. I was surprised to find myself getting nervous as I read the moments leading up to his assassination even though I already knew what was coming and the outcome. That’s the mark of a good writer.
For all of my history buffs and lovers of American history, I highly recommend this novel because although fiction, I believe much of what was researched became truly engrained in this story and holds true to history.
Thank you to UpLit Reads, John Cribb, and Republic Book Publishers for a gifted copy in exchange for an honest review!
This fiction by John Cribb read very much like a nonfiction novel because Cribb did not skimp on his research! The historical fiction lover and scholastic nerd in me truly appreciated the amount of work this took and the rich element it added to the story of Lincoln’s time in the presidency. I felt completely immersed in the history and time. Of course, enhancing this is the fact that I’m a distant cousin of many greats to Abe Lincoln- a fun fact I like to flaunt whenever I can. ;)
I like that Cribb didn’t portray Lincoln without human flaws because I feel that history sometimes leaves out the fact that Lincoln wasn’t always right and wasn’t always cheerful. He was human. That’s realistic.
We all know how Lincoln met his tragic end (no spoilers here) but I found the way Cribb described his passing to be very gentle and forgiving, not to mention, beautiful. I was surprised to find myself getting nervous as I read the moments leading up to his assassination even though I already knew what was coming and the outcome. That’s the mark of a good writer.
For all of my history buffs and lovers of American history, I highly recommend this novel because although fiction, I believe much of what was researched became truly engrained in this story and holds true to history.
Thank you to UpLit Reads, John Cribb, and Republic Book Publishers for a gifted copy in exchange for an honest review!
November 17, 2020
In this fictional account of the last five years of Abraham Lincoln’s life, Cribb draws on copious research to provide an in-depth and personal account of a turbulent time through the eyes of the great man himself. Opening with Lincoln’s presidential bid and subsequent election, Old Abe follows Lincoln as he heads to Washington, D.C. for his inauguration, evades assassination attempts, tries to hold the country together, and ultimately oversees the Union’s defeat of the Confederate forces and the reassembling of a battered and bruised country. The political climate and certain hotly contested issues from the mid-1860s are uncannily similar to what the United States is experiencing now, and Old Abe will make readers long for a leader like Lincoln.
Want to hear more about this book from John? Listen to my podcast interview here: https://www.thoughtsfromapage.com/31. For more of my reviews, check out my Instagram account: https://www.instagram.com/thoughtsfro....
Want to hear more about this book from John? Listen to my podcast interview here: https://www.thoughtsfromapage.com/31. For more of my reviews, check out my Instagram account: https://www.instagram.com/thoughtsfro....
May 4, 2022
An incredibly beautiful portrayal of Lincoln. There is a deeper humanity in this literary presentation of Lincoln than the more famous Lincoln by Gore Vidal. The sweet relationship between Lincoln and Tad, and how they all mourned the loss of little Willie are powerful moments of this read. The final spiritual ending as Lincoln's life ebbs away touched me as the great president was reunited with his deceased loved ones. I highly recommend this novel, especially if you read a lot about Lincoln and the Civil War.
dnf
April 19, 2021DNF
Had some good moments but overall not into this :(
Had some good moments but overall not into this :(
June 20, 2021
Old Abe is a historical fiction work that recounts the final 5 years of Abraham Lincoln's life. It mostly sticks to what we know is true but ventures into what Lincoln might have been thinking, bringing it into the fiction realm. Follow Lincoln from his election campaign until the fateful night he was shot in Ford's Theater.
Despite this being a historical fiction book, I felt like we were still held at a distance from Lincoln; I believe the author didn't want to take such a famous and beloved public figure and go too far beyond the bounds of what are known, but the distance kept me from really connecting with the story. I had wondered how Cribb would write the end, when Lincoln gets shot. I thought he did a fabulous part with that job; it was my favorite part of the book. Overall, this was a good book; I just didn't connect with it the way I had hoped to.
Many thanks to NetGalley for providing me an audio ARC of this book.
Despite this being a historical fiction book, I felt like we were still held at a distance from Lincoln; I believe the author didn't want to take such a famous and beloved public figure and go too far beyond the bounds of what are known, but the distance kept me from really connecting with the story. I had wondered how Cribb would write the end, when Lincoln gets shot. I thought he did a fabulous part with that job; it was my favorite part of the book. Overall, this was a good book; I just didn't connect with it the way I had hoped to.
Many thanks to NetGalley for providing me an audio ARC of this book.
June 7, 2021
This book had an interesting view on the Civil War and Lincoln’s time as president. The war is described through the eyes of Lincoln and his cabinet. I enjoyed this perspective. This is a great story for history lovers and those who would like to understand Lincoln’s emotions and feelings during the war. I listened to this story and enjoyed the narration.
November 19, 2020
I was gifted this book from uplit reads and all I have to say is WOW, WOW, WOW, if you love history and good ole Abraham Lincoln you will most likely enjoy this book. The reader is almost able to transport themselves back in time with Lincoln. This novel takes you back to 1860 in Illinois and takes you through Abraham Lincolns election as well as the height of the civil war and his Assassination. Everything about this book brings the reader closer to Lincoln and shows insight to the last 5 years of his life. I personally enjoyed the trials and triumphs that I was able read about throughout this novel it really allowed me to see through Lincoln’s eyes
November 12, 2020
I have always enjoyed learning more about history through story. This was a great way to learn more about Lincoln. John Cribb included so much detail that made it easy to connect with Lincoln. Even though we all know how it ends, I still found myself struggling to put this book down! I would highly recommend this book for history fans!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
November 23, 2020
This was such a great book! Old Abe opened my eyes to so much about Abraham Lincoln and the Civil War. John Cribb was able to bring Lincoln’s personality to life, which made him so likable. Not only did Lincoln receive harsh criticism about the loss of lives in the war and ending slavery, but he had his own personal losses that were devastating for their entire family. I have an even greater respect for him and his wife and all of those who have made this country what it is today.
December 18, 2021
I know this was a fictionalised account of Lincoln’s last five years (and must be judged on that basis), but as both a Lincoln admirer and a History graduate I found it faithful to what we know of Lincoln in all but a few inconsequential particulars and a compelling read. I highly recommend it as if nothing else a good read and a genuine piece of Americana.
June 28, 2021
The final chapter when Abe is on his way to heaven and all those family members and friends embraced him was very moving. I have discovered what ever you think you know about Mr. Lincoln you learn something new every time you read a book about him.
Our Country could sure use you today Mr. Lincoln.
Our Country could sure use you today Mr. Lincoln.
June 7, 2024
Oh my GOD you can’t leave me weeping and expect me to just continue on 😭😭😭
2nd reread: still as amazing as the first time. The most beautiful and heartbreaking ending I’ve ever read. Did start the crying earlier this time
2nd reread: still as amazing as the first time. The most beautiful and heartbreaking ending I’ve ever read. Did start the crying earlier this time
January 12, 2025
Cribb’s novel allows us to see Abraham Lincoln’s own point of view regarding his presidential candidacy and the civil war. In addition to dealing with national issues, we hear Lincoln’s thoughts and feelings regarding his personal tragedies in that time period. His wife Mary Lincoln had family that Abraham loved and respected, who sided against him in the civil war. Two of Mary’s brothers died in the conflict. They also lost one of their two youngest sons, William to illness as the country was tearing itself apart.
What I really like about “Old Abe” is that it goes out of its way to describe a time that no longer exists. As Lincoln rides the railroad during his presidential candidacy, he gives us insight into his job as an attorney. It was common then for him and several other lawyers to travel the country by train on a biannual migration from courthouse to courthouse. Their cases revolved around complaints about stolen hogs and cows trampling people’s corn fields. During his time as an attorney, he obtained a reputation for being able to use common every day expressions to explain the law in the courtroom. His ability to make the law understood gave him a reputation as one of the cleverest attorneys in Illinois along with the nickname Old Abe.
Cribb’s description of Lincoln at the Illinois Republican State Convention I think sets the tone for the type of man Lincoln became as president. There huddled admit three thousand farmers and shopkeepers who were whooping for joy, Lincoln occupied himself by whittling on a pine stick. Then they forcibly lifted him into the air carrying him helplessly to the podium so he could make a speech, after they announced him as their choice to run for president.
As Lincoln endures this with a quiet dignity you can’t help see this as a foreshadowing of what is to come. How one man is placed in a position of power but the events happening around him are for the most part out of his control. But even though he couldn’t succeed in stopping the south from starting the civil war he still managed to be true to himself. This is demonstrated by Lincoln’s answer to one of his advisors when they ask him early on if he could make concessions to appease the south.
Lincoln’s answer is to tell him about Aesop's fable of the lion who fell in love with a beautiful maiden and asked for permission to marry her. “Her parents didn’t like the idea, but they told the beast they would gladly give their consent if he would have his fangs and claws removed, to be sure he never hurt her by accident. The lion was so desperately in love, he did as they asked. When his claws and teeth were gone, the maiden’s father took a club and knocked him on the head.”
Through out his presidency he also went out of his way to stay connected to his constituents. Lincoln’s door was always open to anyone who wanted to talk to him. People would ask for favors, give him advice and sometimes just drive him a little crazy. When asked why he continued to see them, Lincoln said he said he wanted to know what people actually thought of him even if it wasn’t something he wanted to hear.
Cribb’s book paints a man, who is aware of the cost that the country is paying to persevere the union. Though he doesn’t second guess his decision to keep the country together or to eventually end slavery, he is very much aware of how his actions are responsible for the deaths of soldiers on both sides of the conflict.
I highly recommend this book. It is a well written time capsule allowing us to see Abraham Lincoln not as a famous historical figure but as a human being doing his best to be true to himself in a difficult era.
What I really like about “Old Abe” is that it goes out of its way to describe a time that no longer exists. As Lincoln rides the railroad during his presidential candidacy, he gives us insight into his job as an attorney. It was common then for him and several other lawyers to travel the country by train on a biannual migration from courthouse to courthouse. Their cases revolved around complaints about stolen hogs and cows trampling people’s corn fields. During his time as an attorney, he obtained a reputation for being able to use common every day expressions to explain the law in the courtroom. His ability to make the law understood gave him a reputation as one of the cleverest attorneys in Illinois along with the nickname Old Abe.
Cribb’s description of Lincoln at the Illinois Republican State Convention I think sets the tone for the type of man Lincoln became as president. There huddled admit three thousand farmers and shopkeepers who were whooping for joy, Lincoln occupied himself by whittling on a pine stick. Then they forcibly lifted him into the air carrying him helplessly to the podium so he could make a speech, after they announced him as their choice to run for president.
As Lincoln endures this with a quiet dignity you can’t help see this as a foreshadowing of what is to come. How one man is placed in a position of power but the events happening around him are for the most part out of his control. But even though he couldn’t succeed in stopping the south from starting the civil war he still managed to be true to himself. This is demonstrated by Lincoln’s answer to one of his advisors when they ask him early on if he could make concessions to appease the south.
Lincoln’s answer is to tell him about Aesop's fable of the lion who fell in love with a beautiful maiden and asked for permission to marry her. “Her parents didn’t like the idea, but they told the beast they would gladly give their consent if he would have his fangs and claws removed, to be sure he never hurt her by accident. The lion was so desperately in love, he did as they asked. When his claws and teeth were gone, the maiden’s father took a club and knocked him on the head.”
Through out his presidency he also went out of his way to stay connected to his constituents. Lincoln’s door was always open to anyone who wanted to talk to him. People would ask for favors, give him advice and sometimes just drive him a little crazy. When asked why he continued to see them, Lincoln said he said he wanted to know what people actually thought of him even if it wasn’t something he wanted to hear.
Cribb’s book paints a man, who is aware of the cost that the country is paying to persevere the union. Though he doesn’t second guess his decision to keep the country together or to eventually end slavery, he is very much aware of how his actions are responsible for the deaths of soldiers on both sides of the conflict.
I highly recommend this book. It is a well written time capsule allowing us to see Abraham Lincoln not as a famous historical figure but as a human being doing his best to be true to himself in a difficult era.
October 29, 2020
No matter how much you learned about Abraham Lincoln in your last American History class, there’s more to appreciate in John Cribb’s book, OLD ABE:A Novel.
Perhaps you remember stories of him splitting fence rails or wearing a black top hat. Maybe you’ve heard a few interesting tidbits about his wife, Mary Todd or their children: Bob, Tad, and Willie. Most people think of Lincoln when they discuss the Civil War, the Emancipation Proclamation and the Thirteenth Amendment of the Constitution.
You’ll find all of these things and much more in this 400-page hardcover book written by John Cribb.
OLD ABE is an historical fiction novel. The author chose to compile his years of research into a more personal presentation of Lincoln. Using hundreds of primary and secondary resources, Cribb unfurls the facts in a more intimate manner.
What part of the book is fiction?
“In many cases, I’ve taken artistic license to provide details of action and dialogue, and I’ve occasionally bent the timeline for minor events, but I’ve tried to stay faithful to the historical record.
I hope this book brings Lincoln to life and that it helps you better understand the tragic circumstances he faced and the heroic service he rendered to a nation that seemed hopelessly divided.” - John Cribb
The book covers the last five years of Abraham Lincoln’s life. However, Cribb expertly pulls in Lincoln’s earlier days as well. There isn’t a heavy focus on faith in OLD ABE, but it is in there, including Lincoln’s remarks regarding the Bible and its influence in his life.
Through vivid descriptions and realistic dialogue, Cribb draws readers into Lincoln’s personal life. There are joyous moments, especially between Lincoln and his children. However, these were Lincoln’s most challenging years. As the story unfolds, our eyes are opened and our hearts are broken as we walk alongside Old Abe.
Throughout the book, a recurring dream of Lincoln’s subtly floats in the background. As Lincoln gradually contemplates its meaning, so do we. The author does a beautiful job sewing this dream-thread into the story to its bittersweet end.
The timing for the release of this book is perfect. If you think today’s political arena is the most malicious it has ever been, OLD ABE will enlighten you. It did me. I had no idea what Abraham Lincoln experienced prior to moving in the White House, nor the full extent of what he had to endure after.
I highly recommend adding this book to high school reading lists. Even middle school students will glean from it. But, be aware there is a tiny scattering of curse words and two or three racial slurs. These words weren’t thrown in haphazardly.
OLD ABE reveals Abraham Lincoln more as a man than an icon. His deep love and concern for his family and for his country unfold on every page as he does his best to preserve them both.
Perhaps you remember stories of him splitting fence rails or wearing a black top hat. Maybe you’ve heard a few interesting tidbits about his wife, Mary Todd or their children: Bob, Tad, and Willie. Most people think of Lincoln when they discuss the Civil War, the Emancipation Proclamation and the Thirteenth Amendment of the Constitution.
You’ll find all of these things and much more in this 400-page hardcover book written by John Cribb.
OLD ABE is an historical fiction novel. The author chose to compile his years of research into a more personal presentation of Lincoln. Using hundreds of primary and secondary resources, Cribb unfurls the facts in a more intimate manner.
What part of the book is fiction?
“In many cases, I’ve taken artistic license to provide details of action and dialogue, and I’ve occasionally bent the timeline for minor events, but I’ve tried to stay faithful to the historical record.
I hope this book brings Lincoln to life and that it helps you better understand the tragic circumstances he faced and the heroic service he rendered to a nation that seemed hopelessly divided.” - John Cribb
The book covers the last five years of Abraham Lincoln’s life. However, Cribb expertly pulls in Lincoln’s earlier days as well. There isn’t a heavy focus on faith in OLD ABE, but it is in there, including Lincoln’s remarks regarding the Bible and its influence in his life.
Through vivid descriptions and realistic dialogue, Cribb draws readers into Lincoln’s personal life. There are joyous moments, especially between Lincoln and his children. However, these were Lincoln’s most challenging years. As the story unfolds, our eyes are opened and our hearts are broken as we walk alongside Old Abe.
Throughout the book, a recurring dream of Lincoln’s subtly floats in the background. As Lincoln gradually contemplates its meaning, so do we. The author does a beautiful job sewing this dream-thread into the story to its bittersweet end.
The timing for the release of this book is perfect. If you think today’s political arena is the most malicious it has ever been, OLD ABE will enlighten you. It did me. I had no idea what Abraham Lincoln experienced prior to moving in the White House, nor the full extent of what he had to endure after.
I highly recommend adding this book to high school reading lists. Even middle school students will glean from it. But, be aware there is a tiny scattering of curse words and two or three racial slurs. These words weren’t thrown in haphazardly.
OLD ABE reveals Abraham Lincoln more as a man than an icon. His deep love and concern for his family and for his country unfold on every page as he does his best to preserve them both.
July 5, 2021
I totally enjoyed this although there is sadness of course. 4.5 of 5.0 Overall; Content 4.5; Narration 4.5.
I was captivated by this historical fiction from beginning to end. I had to remind myself that it is fiction although I have little doubt that it is based on journals, notes and other historical support. Mr. Cribb makes Abe Lincoln a very real, beleaguered man who struggles with his leadership responsibilities while he leans on faith in God as well as a little bit of mysticism.
It has been years since I studied the Civil War so some of the details seemed new to me. The time frame is short, being the presidential election through the assassination and funeral. Everything focuses on Abe Lincoln, his personal thoughts, his family, friends in his cabinet and the pressures and stresses that challenge him.
I really wasn’t aware that President Lincoln had to deal with so much negative criticism and name calling, although it makes sense considering the divisions of the times. I also did not recall how fragile, and at times, unpleasant, Mary Todd Lincoln was. I had an Aunt who was devastated by the loss of a young son and Mrs. Lincoln had to cope with the loss of two. The deaths are a reason for extreme grief but no justification for social ineptitude, out of control spending for social impressions, and ugly personal interactions. I was sad to think Old Abe had to cope with these issues close to home while facing the severe issues of civil war, political pressures and threats of assassination. Of course, knowing how the story would end, expanded my sadness.
I was impressed how Mr. Cribb made the story so real to life. I loved the depiction of Old Abe’s relationship with his sons. The author also provides good insight on President Lincoln’s mindset and determination to save the Union, “… the last best hope” for freedom. I appreciated the inclusion of Frederick Douglas and his meetings with President Lincoln. I also liked the scenes of Lincoln interacting with political opponents, the different Union Generals, Confederate prisoners, and men and women in the street. I recommend this story to anyone who enjoys Civil War history.
Audio Notes: Gary Bennett does a good job with the narration. He provides a solemn delivery with voices that fit the characters. I am glad that I had the opportunity to listen to this.
Source: NetGalley 2021.
I was captivated by this historical fiction from beginning to end. I had to remind myself that it is fiction although I have little doubt that it is based on journals, notes and other historical support. Mr. Cribb makes Abe Lincoln a very real, beleaguered man who struggles with his leadership responsibilities while he leans on faith in God as well as a little bit of mysticism.
It has been years since I studied the Civil War so some of the details seemed new to me. The time frame is short, being the presidential election through the assassination and funeral. Everything focuses on Abe Lincoln, his personal thoughts, his family, friends in his cabinet and the pressures and stresses that challenge him.
I really wasn’t aware that President Lincoln had to deal with so much negative criticism and name calling, although it makes sense considering the divisions of the times. I also did not recall how fragile, and at times, unpleasant, Mary Todd Lincoln was. I had an Aunt who was devastated by the loss of a young son and Mrs. Lincoln had to cope with the loss of two. The deaths are a reason for extreme grief but no justification for social ineptitude, out of control spending for social impressions, and ugly personal interactions. I was sad to think Old Abe had to cope with these issues close to home while facing the severe issues of civil war, political pressures and threats of assassination. Of course, knowing how the story would end, expanded my sadness.
I was impressed how Mr. Cribb made the story so real to life. I loved the depiction of Old Abe’s relationship with his sons. The author also provides good insight on President Lincoln’s mindset and determination to save the Union, “… the last best hope” for freedom. I appreciated the inclusion of Frederick Douglas and his meetings with President Lincoln. I also liked the scenes of Lincoln interacting with political opponents, the different Union Generals, Confederate prisoners, and men and women in the street. I recommend this story to anyone who enjoys Civil War history.
Audio Notes: Gary Bennett does a good job with the narration. He provides a solemn delivery with voices that fit the characters. I am glad that I had the opportunity to listen to this.
Source: NetGalley 2021.
May 21, 2021
In the forward by William J. Bennett (former US Secretary of Education and author of The Book of Virtues), more than 15,000 books have been written about Lincoln; with one exception (Jesus Christ) more books have been written about Lincoln than any other person. Bennett goes on to say "But you must read this book. This is the best book about Lincoln that I've ever read. ... This book makes you love Lincoln."
Don't you hate it when someone tells you what you must do? And that you will love something? So my immediate thought was, "Nope! Not me! I'm NOT going to love this book." Ok. I admit it. I was wrong; I was wrong. I was dead-set against it, but I fell in love with this book.
This book was written in a way so that you feel so near to Lincoln, with his thoughts and feelings during Lincoln's last 5 years of his presidency. Things you've always "known" are put into a completely different perspective when you are "sitting on Lincoln's shoulders". I knew that Lincoln was president during the Civil War, but I didn't know that six states seceded from the union and that Jefferson Davis was sworn in as president of the Confederacy Feb 18, 1861 ... BEFORE Lincoln's inauguration in March 1861.
Lincoln was so compassionate. Usually when an army is ultimately victorious, they want to ruin the losers. Lincoln had the band belt out Dixie; more than anything he wanted to join the country and patch the wounds. He went out of his way to pardon folks and probably saw more visitors than any other president. Who doesn't like Lincoln? But with this book, I fell in love with Lincoln!
The audiobook was outstanding and narrated by Gary Bennett.
Thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to review this book in exchange for an honest review. Also many thanks to the publisher OrangeSky Audio and to the author John Cribb. Nicely done! Publication date for the book is Sept 2020; bummed that I had missed this book in 2020. Publication date for the audio is 1 June 2021.
Don't you hate it when someone tells you what you must do? And that you will love something? So my immediate thought was, "Nope! Not me! I'm NOT going to love this book." Ok. I admit it. I was wrong; I was wrong. I was dead-set against it, but I fell in love with this book.
This book was written in a way so that you feel so near to Lincoln, with his thoughts and feelings during Lincoln's last 5 years of his presidency. Things you've always "known" are put into a completely different perspective when you are "sitting on Lincoln's shoulders". I knew that Lincoln was president during the Civil War, but I didn't know that six states seceded from the union and that Jefferson Davis was sworn in as president of the Confederacy Feb 18, 1861 ... BEFORE Lincoln's inauguration in March 1861.
Lincoln was so compassionate. Usually when an army is ultimately victorious, they want to ruin the losers. Lincoln had the band belt out Dixie; more than anything he wanted to join the country and patch the wounds. He went out of his way to pardon folks and probably saw more visitors than any other president. Who doesn't like Lincoln? But with this book, I fell in love with Lincoln!
The audiobook was outstanding and narrated by Gary Bennett.
Thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to review this book in exchange for an honest review. Also many thanks to the publisher OrangeSky Audio and to the author John Cribb. Nicely done! Publication date for the book is Sept 2020; bummed that I had missed this book in 2020. Publication date for the audio is 1 June 2021.
May 30, 2021
*Note: I received a digital copy of this audiobook in exchange for my honest review. This has in no way affected my thoughts or opinions on the book.
This was a beautiful book, and although it was fictionalized, I feel that it provided a very realistic, sticks-to-the-truth depiction of Lincoln's life during this time period. I think Cribb really nailed Lincoln's attitude, thoughts, manner, and disposition. The "important dialogue" was, of course, taken from historical records, so it was hard not to get those bits right, but even in the fictionalized private moments... he did an excellent job of portraying how I feel Lincoln was probably feeling at certain moments.
I wasn't there when Lincoln was president (obviously. Ha.), but I've dedicated countless hours on end reading and researching the man, his policies, and everything I can get my hands on surrounding him. Some of the moments seemed so real, it's hard not to think Cribb was pulling them straight from Lincoln's diary.
The heartbreaking scenes between Lincoln and his wife, Mary, whenever she showed early symptoms of her declining mental health were incredibly poignant, and it was hard not to feel Lincoln's pain for the woman he obviously loved very much but didn't know how to help.
The scenes with Tad and Willie in them were also wonderfully done, and while the source material was great, I have to give major kudos to the audiobook's narrator for making me absolutely adore sweet Tad. His character was well-written, but the narrator knocked it out of the park with his portrayal of the youngest Lincoln child, who was born with a cleft lip that contributed to an embarrassing (for him) speech impediment.
I really enjoyed every bit of this book, from beginning to end. I have no complaints with it at all.
This was a beautiful book, and although it was fictionalized, I feel that it provided a very realistic, sticks-to-the-truth depiction of Lincoln's life during this time period. I think Cribb really nailed Lincoln's attitude, thoughts, manner, and disposition. The "important dialogue" was, of course, taken from historical records, so it was hard not to get those bits right, but even in the fictionalized private moments... he did an excellent job of portraying how I feel Lincoln was probably feeling at certain moments.
I wasn't there when Lincoln was president (obviously. Ha.), but I've dedicated countless hours on end reading and researching the man, his policies, and everything I can get my hands on surrounding him. Some of the moments seemed so real, it's hard not to think Cribb was pulling them straight from Lincoln's diary.
The heartbreaking scenes between Lincoln and his wife, Mary, whenever she showed early symptoms of her declining mental health were incredibly poignant, and it was hard not to feel Lincoln's pain for the woman he obviously loved very much but didn't know how to help.
The scenes with Tad and Willie in them were also wonderfully done, and while the source material was great, I have to give major kudos to the audiobook's narrator for making me absolutely adore sweet Tad. His character was well-written, but the narrator knocked it out of the park with his portrayal of the youngest Lincoln child, who was born with a cleft lip that contributed to an embarrassing (for him) speech impediment.
I really enjoyed every bit of this book, from beginning to end. I have no complaints with it at all.
June 2, 2021
Old Abe by John Cribb
Narrator - Gary Bennett
Genre - Historical Fiction
Rating - 3 out of 5 stars
Narration - 4 out of 5 stars
While this book was a very good IF you take it as fiction. I have done a lot of research on the Civil War and Abraham Lincoln and found the history a bit changed where it did not have to be.
This book starts when Abraham Lincoln was chosen for the Republican candidate for the state of Illinois. Then goes on to describe how he was elected to run for president. This is one of those places where I feel the writer took extreme artistic liberties.
The book goes on to tell about Abraham’s time in the White House and how the Civil War was played out. Telling about how Abraham ran his campaigns in the war and his life at home. It also goes into a little of Mary Todd Lincoln’s decent into madness. Which I felt was a great way to take the story.
There were some very historically documented facts in the book. For example when he showed Mary the insane asylum and told her if she didn’t shape up she would end up there. Another example was him calling her excessive spending on what he called “flubdubs.” This is something I have come across in much of my research.
I only gave the narrator 4 stars because while he did an excellent job at the narration I found myself falling asleep at certain points because they were dry and he did not make them exciting enough to keep me interested. Also he was not the greatest at making the characters different except when it came to Tad Lincoln. Excellent job there.
Once again the is categorized as Historical Fiction so the author is able to take certain liberties. Although with a man this famous I do not believe fiction books should be written about him.
I want to thank NetGalley and Orange Sky Audio for letting me review this book.
Narrator - Gary Bennett
Genre - Historical Fiction
Rating - 3 out of 5 stars
Narration - 4 out of 5 stars
While this book was a very good IF you take it as fiction. I have done a lot of research on the Civil War and Abraham Lincoln and found the history a bit changed where it did not have to be.
This book starts when Abraham Lincoln was chosen for the Republican candidate for the state of Illinois. Then goes on to describe how he was elected to run for president. This is one of those places where I feel the writer took extreme artistic liberties.
The book goes on to tell about Abraham’s time in the White House and how the Civil War was played out. Telling about how Abraham ran his campaigns in the war and his life at home. It also goes into a little of Mary Todd Lincoln’s decent into madness. Which I felt was a great way to take the story.
There were some very historically documented facts in the book. For example when he showed Mary the insane asylum and told her if she didn’t shape up she would end up there. Another example was him calling her excessive spending on what he called “flubdubs.” This is something I have come across in much of my research.
I only gave the narrator 4 stars because while he did an excellent job at the narration I found myself falling asleep at certain points because they were dry and he did not make them exciting enough to keep me interested. Also he was not the greatest at making the characters different except when it came to Tad Lincoln. Excellent job there.
Once again the is categorized as Historical Fiction so the author is able to take certain liberties. Although with a man this famous I do not believe fiction books should be written about him.
I want to thank NetGalley and Orange Sky Audio for letting me review this book.
March 12, 2021
A fictionalized version of the last 5 years of Lincoln's life, Old Abe is among the best, most insightful renderings of the life and times of Lincoln that I've read. It is filled with exceptional detail and painfully renders the terrible toll that the succession and Civil War had on the nation as a whole and Lincoln as it's President.
The novel form allows Cribb to take us further into the mind of the President than most works of history would allow. Inherently the personal interactions and internal thoughts of the President are more speculative, but the book explores the emotional palette of Lincoln's life in greater depth than any history book could. If feels like we're there with Lincoln suffering the terrible losses of two close friends in the early days of the war, and even more tragically, his son Willie who died of typhoid in the White House. Much has been written about the impact of Willie's death on Mary Lincoln, but the novel puts us inside the Lincoln household as Mary begins to lose her grip on reality. It is exceptionally painful to read and raises the question of how President Lincoln kept his own sanity given the depth of his grief. More than any history book I've read, the depth of grief and the terrible strain it placed on the family is laid bare here.
My only slight quibble is that there are times in the book when Cribb speaks less with Lincoln's voice than as if someone is reporting on Lincoln's actions and thoughts. Despite these lapses, this is a valiant effort to give the reader a deeper, more personal look at one of the nation's greatest and most complex Presidents.
If you are a Civil War or Presidential history buff, this is a great book to read. But as purely a novel, I wouldn't put this near the top of my list.
The novel form allows Cribb to take us further into the mind of the President than most works of history would allow. Inherently the personal interactions and internal thoughts of the President are more speculative, but the book explores the emotional palette of Lincoln's life in greater depth than any history book could. If feels like we're there with Lincoln suffering the terrible losses of two close friends in the early days of the war, and even more tragically, his son Willie who died of typhoid in the White House. Much has been written about the impact of Willie's death on Mary Lincoln, but the novel puts us inside the Lincoln household as Mary begins to lose her grip on reality. It is exceptionally painful to read and raises the question of how President Lincoln kept his own sanity given the depth of his grief. More than any history book I've read, the depth of grief and the terrible strain it placed on the family is laid bare here.
My only slight quibble is that there are times in the book when Cribb speaks less with Lincoln's voice than as if someone is reporting on Lincoln's actions and thoughts. Despite these lapses, this is a valiant effort to give the reader a deeper, more personal look at one of the nation's greatest and most complex Presidents.
If you are a Civil War or Presidential history buff, this is a great book to read. But as purely a novel, I wouldn't put this near the top of my list.
June 2, 2021
I love historical fiction, though American historical themes are not my usual choice. However, I was interested in reading this fictionalized account of the last 5 years of Lincoln's life. I actually listened to the audiobook version at 1.75x speed.
This book was well written and well-researched. Every American child learns about Abe Lincoln in school. We all basically know the story. We certainly know how it ends. In this novel, the author created conversations Lincoln may have had, words he may have said privately, and thoughts that may have crossed his mind. The author did this very respectfully and brought Lincoln to life, to a point. In my opinion, this novel was more driven by historic events than characters. That may be expected due to the subject matter, but I did not feel like I "knew" Old Abe from reading this book. However, it is definitely a more interesting way to learn about this period in US history than reading a textbook. It would make a great read-and-discuss assignment for a high school or college freshman US history class.
The part I liked the most was the ending when Abe was getting ready to go to the theater. The author successfully created tension. Everyone already knows what is going to happen in that theater; everyone but Abe and his contemporaries. At this point, Abe is at his most tangible and human in the novel. As a reader, I wanted to shout at him to stay home. The author's accounts of the funeral procession through the country to Lincoln's home town were absolutely vibrant. I could see this part of the story the most clearly. It was beautifully presented.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
This book was well written and well-researched. Every American child learns about Abe Lincoln in school. We all basically know the story. We certainly know how it ends. In this novel, the author created conversations Lincoln may have had, words he may have said privately, and thoughts that may have crossed his mind. The author did this very respectfully and brought Lincoln to life, to a point. In my opinion, this novel was more driven by historic events than characters. That may be expected due to the subject matter, but I did not feel like I "knew" Old Abe from reading this book. However, it is definitely a more interesting way to learn about this period in US history than reading a textbook. It would make a great read-and-discuss assignment for a high school or college freshman US history class.
The part I liked the most was the ending when Abe was getting ready to go to the theater. The author successfully created tension. Everyone already knows what is going to happen in that theater; everyone but Abe and his contemporaries. At this point, Abe is at his most tangible and human in the novel. As a reader, I wanted to shout at him to stay home. The author's accounts of the funeral procession through the country to Lincoln's home town were absolutely vibrant. I could see this part of the story the most clearly. It was beautifully presented.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
November 21, 2020
I am giving this book 3 stars.
This historical fiction is a recollection of the last five years of Abraham Lincoln’s life with some details about his life growing up. It’s told through Lincoln himself and starts as his political journey to presidency begins.
There are some very poignant parts. The pain the Lincoln family faced is so much more than I had indeed known. Losing any child is hard on a parent. I couldn’t have imagined losing two.
The part when Lincoln’s son Willie dies is so unbelievably sad. There was the unknown of what was happening, thinking he might be getting better only to have him take a dire turn. That part brought me to tears.
There are significant parts of the war and the turmoil Abraham went through to try and do the right thing. With his emancipation vision and wanting to stand by his word but feeling pressure to save the Union. He was a true leader. Lincoln was a great President, willing to put aside differences to do what needed to be done. He chose the best person for the jobs at hand despite their political differences.
I don’t know if I would say this made me fall in love with him, but I do have a newfound appreciation for the things he did and went through.
There was a lot of detailed history, names, events that made some parts a bit slow for me, to be honest.
Overall it was an excellent historically based fiction about Abraham Lincoln’s last years.
This historical fiction is a recollection of the last five years of Abraham Lincoln’s life with some details about his life growing up. It’s told through Lincoln himself and starts as his political journey to presidency begins.
There are some very poignant parts. The pain the Lincoln family faced is so much more than I had indeed known. Losing any child is hard on a parent. I couldn’t have imagined losing two.
The part when Lincoln’s son Willie dies is so unbelievably sad. There was the unknown of what was happening, thinking he might be getting better only to have him take a dire turn. That part brought me to tears.
There are significant parts of the war and the turmoil Abraham went through to try and do the right thing. With his emancipation vision and wanting to stand by his word but feeling pressure to save the Union. He was a true leader. Lincoln was a great President, willing to put aside differences to do what needed to be done. He chose the best person for the jobs at hand despite their political differences.
I don’t know if I would say this made me fall in love with him, but I do have a newfound appreciation for the things he did and went through.
There was a lot of detailed history, names, events that made some parts a bit slow for me, to be honest.
Overall it was an excellent historically based fiction about Abraham Lincoln’s last years.
December 3, 2020
3.75/5:
This book was very well researched, and Cribb is a talented writer. However, the first half of the book was very slow. Part of the problem is that as a reader you know Lincoln will get elected, you know the Civil War will start, you know Lincoln will put in place the Emancipation Proclamation, etc. Because the majority of American readers know the basics already, spending lots of time on, "Will he get elected, etc" dragged the first half of the novel. Perhaps if the timeline of the book was less linear, the pacing would have been more engaging.
Once Willie passed away and grief fraught the White House, Lincoln felt more human, and I became a lot more invested in the rest of the story. The toll that the Civil War took on Lincoln and his household is really felt. I enjoyed how Cribb wrote in Tad's speech impediment. The ending felt a little strange, but the book is "historical fiction" after all (though it read more like just a dramatized biography).
In conclusion, the book is fairly well done. If you are a history buff, Lincoln lover, or enjoy slower paced historical fiction, Old Abe does the trick.
This book was very well researched, and Cribb is a talented writer. However, the first half of the book was very slow. Part of the problem is that as a reader you know Lincoln will get elected, you know the Civil War will start, you know Lincoln will put in place the Emancipation Proclamation, etc. Because the majority of American readers know the basics already, spending lots of time on, "Will he get elected, etc" dragged the first half of the novel. Perhaps if the timeline of the book was less linear, the pacing would have been more engaging.
Once Willie passed away and grief fraught the White House, Lincoln felt more human, and I became a lot more invested in the rest of the story. The toll that the Civil War took on Lincoln and his household is really felt. I enjoyed how Cribb wrote in Tad's speech impediment. The ending felt a little strange, but the book is "historical fiction" after all (though it read more like just a dramatized biography).
In conclusion, the book is fairly well done. If you are a history buff, Lincoln lover, or enjoy slower paced historical fiction, Old Abe does the trick.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 13, 2021
Old Abe is the story of the last five years of Abraham Lincoln’s life, the most cataclysmic years in American history. We are at Lincoln’s side as he weeps over the body of Willie, his second son to die in childhood, as he walks bloody battlefields in the North and the South, as he wrestles with slavery, and as he cares for his emotionally unstable wife, Mary Todd Lincoln.
The author portrayed Lincoln as not only a president, but as a flesh-and-blood man. This fictionalized account of one of the greatest figures in American history offered a fresh perspective, while being so thoroughly researched that it will appeal to Civil War history buffs. I was hoping for a more content about him as a husband and father and a less on war strategy and play-by-play of battles, but the author’s depiction of Lincoln’s passage into eternity was inventive and touching, so much so that I had to wipe my eyes. I alternated between reading the book and listening to it, and much preferred the eBook. Still, I would give either version 4 stars.
The author portrayed Lincoln as not only a president, but as a flesh-and-blood man. This fictionalized account of one of the greatest figures in American history offered a fresh perspective, while being so thoroughly researched that it will appeal to Civil War history buffs. I was hoping for a more content about him as a husband and father and a less on war strategy and play-by-play of battles, but the author’s depiction of Lincoln’s passage into eternity was inventive and touching, so much so that I had to wipe my eyes. I alternated between reading the book and listening to it, and much preferred the eBook. Still, I would give either version 4 stars.
December 2, 2020
I love historical fiction but I’ve never read any set in the Civil War era. This book looks at the last 5 years of Abraham Lincoln’s life - from running for president through his assassination.
John Cribb did an incredible amount of research for this book, making it much more historical than fiction, yet with the flowing narrative of a great novel. We get a peak inside his marriage and home life. We feel the heartbreak of loss he experiences. And we get to see that Lincoln was a man of convictions who would not be swayed by all the competing voices around him. Instead, he listened to everyone’s viewpoints and made them feel heard, while still sticking with what he believed was right.
This is a book all politicians should read! Maybe it would help us get back to a time where both sides of the aisle worked together. Did you know that for his second term in office, he chose a new Vice President? He dropped his Republican running mate and chose a Democrat to be his VP!
John Cribb did an incredible amount of research for this book, making it much more historical than fiction, yet with the flowing narrative of a great novel. We get a peak inside his marriage and home life. We feel the heartbreak of loss he experiences. And we get to see that Lincoln was a man of convictions who would not be swayed by all the competing voices around him. Instead, he listened to everyone’s viewpoints and made them feel heard, while still sticking with what he believed was right.
This is a book all politicians should read! Maybe it would help us get back to a time where both sides of the aisle worked together. Did you know that for his second term in office, he chose a new Vice President? He dropped his Republican running mate and chose a Democrat to be his VP!
May 31, 2021
Not being from America, however very interested in world history. I chose this book to learn and I was not disappointed. The author wrote about the last 5 years of one of America most loved presidents Abraham Lincoln. Written more like a fiction book but learning all the time I could not put it down. The author created a great atmosphere throughout. Presented the president in a great light. Of course deciding to free slaves in those times was a very difficult decision but this man changed the course of history. In realising everybody is equal he presented himself as more of a loving father figure to the whole nation. where there is light there is always shadows.
This should be read in every school across the world. I really recommend this book to all. Great praise for the author and to orange sky audio for producing this epic book.
This should be read in every school across the world. I really recommend this book to all. Great praise for the author and to orange sky audio for producing this epic book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews