I really enjoyed Byzantium and the Roman Primacy. I found it well-written, not polemical, balanced, and enlightening. I don't have the energy right now to write an extensive review, but here is a solid ChatGPT summary for my future reference:
Central thesis
The Byzantine Church historically recognized the Bishop of Rome as possessing a genuine primacy that extended beyond mere honorary precedence, including significant doctrinal and appellate authority. However, East and West developed different understandings of the basis, extent, and exercise of that primacy, largely because of their different political and ecclesiastical circumstances.
Dvornik argues that the East–West Schism was not inevitable but resulted substantially from political developments, historical misunderstandings, and competing traditions of church government.
Main arguments
1. The Eastern Church recognized Rome's Petrine connection. Eastern Christians acknowledged that Peter had ministered, been martyred, and was buried in Rome. They recognized the special prestige this gave the Roman Church, although they did not necessarily accept all the jurisdictional claims later derived from it.
2. The early Church developed its hierarchy largely according to the Roman Empire's political organization. Bishops of provincial capitals became metropolitans, and major imperial cities acquired broader ecclesiastical responsibilities. Dvornik calls this the principle of accommodation, which helps explain the development of patriarchates.
3. Two different principles of ecclesiastical primacy developed.
- The principle of accommodation: Ecclesiastical importance was closely connected to the political importance of a city. This principle was originally recognized throughout the Church but remained particularly influential in Byzantium.
- The principle of apostolicity: Ecclesiastical authority was grounded in a church's apostolic foundation. Rome increasingly emphasized its connection to Peter as the basis of its primacy.
- Both East and West recognized Rome's political and apostolic significance, but they increasingly differed over which principle provided the fundamental justification for its primacy and what authority followed from it.
4. Constantinople's elevation did not originally constitute a rejection of Roman primacy. The Councils of Constantinople (381) and Chalcedon (451) elevated Constantinople because it was New Rome. Dvornik argues that the Eastern bishops did not intend to deny Rome's primacy. Pope Leo I objected especially to Chalcedon's Canon 28 because it expanded Constantinople's jurisdiction and grounded ecclesiastical rank in political considerations rather than Petrine authority.
5. The Acacian Schism (484–519) strengthened Rome's claims to primacy. Popes increasingly emphasized their Petrine authority, particularly Pope Gelasius. The schism ended with Eastern bishops accepting the Formula of Hormisdas, which affirmed that Christ's promises to Peter were fulfilled in the Roman See and that Rome had preserved the apostolic faith without error. This was a remarkably strong acknowledgment of Rome's doctrinal authority. However, Patriarch John of Constantinople qualified his acceptance by emphasizing the unity of Old and New Rome, illustrating the continuing effort to reconcile Petrine primacy with Constantinople's ecclesiastical standing.
6. Justinian explicitly recognized Rome as the first see of Christendom. His legislation described Rome as the head of the churches and placed Constantinople second. Nevertheless, Justinian maintained substantial imperial authority in ecclesiastical affairs. His policies offered a possible reconciliation between Eastern and Western understandings of church government.
7. During doctrinal crises, Eastern Christians repeatedly appealed to Rome as a guardian of orthodoxy. During the Monothelite and Iconoclast controversies, figures including Sophronius of Jerusalem, Stephen of Dora, Maximus the Confessor, Theodore the Studite, and Patriarch Nicephorus made remarkably strong statements about Roman authority.
- Some attributed authority over the universal Church to Rome, including the power to command other churches.
- Others emphasized Rome's unique responsibility to preserve orthodoxy and intervene in doctrinal controversies.
- The Sixth Ecumenical Council (680–681) formally praised Pope Agatho's doctrinal intervention, declaring that Peter had spoken through him.
- However, that same council condemned Pope Honorius, demonstrating that recognition of Rome's doctrinal authority did not preclude condemnation of an individual pope.
- Dvornik distinguishes statements by individual Eastern theologians from official declarations of the Byzantine Church, while regarding both as significant evidence for Roman primacy.
8. The Byzantine doctrine of the Pentarchy did not originally exclude Roman primacy. The five patriarchates—Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem—shared responsibility for safeguarding orthodoxy, particularly through councils. But this did not imply absolute equality: Rome remained first. The Pentarchy also protected ecclesiastical authority against imperial interference.
9. Photius did not reject Roman primacy as commonly supposed. One of Dvornik's most important arguments is that Photius has been wrongly portrayed as an enemy of the papacy.
- The Synod of 861 explicitly acknowledged Rome's right to review episcopal cases under the canons of Sardica, demonstrating Byzantine acceptance of meaningful appellate authority.
- The reconciliation of 879–880 preserved strong Petrine claims in the Greek versions of papal letters, including Rome's authority to bind and loose.
- Photius defended Constantinople's autonomy and opposed particular papal interventions without necessarily rejecting Roman primacy itself.
- Dvornik concludes that Photius accepted genuine Roman primacy, including appellate authority, while resisting claims to unrestricted papal jurisdiction over the Eastern churches.
10. The Gregorian Reform fundamentally transformed Western understandings of papal power. Beginning in the eleventh century, reformers sought to liberate the Church from secular interference. They increasingly asserted direct papal jurisdiction over all churches and the superiority of spiritual over temporal authority. Dvornik argues that this went substantially beyond the understanding of primacy traditionally accepted in Byzantium.
11. The events of 1054 did not produce a definitive schism. The conflict between Cardinal Humbert and Patriarch Michael Cerularius involved competing ecclesiastical assumptions, liturgical disputes, political tensions, and mutual hostility. Dvornik places substantial responsibility on Humbert's conduct but also criticizes Cerularius. The conflict did not amount to a complete rupture between the Churches, and reconciliation remained possible.
12. Even after 1054, Byzantine theologians continued to recognize meaningful Roman primacy. A particularly important example is Nicetas of Nicomedia in his discussion with Anselm of Havelberg in the twelfth century.
- Nicetas acknowledged Rome as the first see.
- He recognized Rome's authority to hear difficult ecclesiastical appeals.
- He rejected the Pope's claim to exercise unrestricted authority over Eastern bishops without their participation.
- Thus, the dispute concerned the extent and exercise of papal authority, not necessarily primacy itself.
13. The Fourth Crusade and sack of Constantinople in 1204 made the schism effectively definitive. The conquest and installation of a Latin patriarch profoundly alienated Byzantine Christians. They now experienced direct papal administration that contradicted their ecclesiastical traditions. Opposition to Roman primacy became substantially more entrenched.
14. Later Byzantine arguments against papal primacy were heavily shaped by polemical circumstances. After 1204, Byzantine theologians increasingly challenged Roman claims and developed arguments that:
- Peter's primacy did not pass uniquely to the bishops of Rome.
- All bishops succeed Peter insofar as they preserve his orthodox faith.
- Rome's primacy rested substantially on ecclesiastical custom and conciliar recognition rather than exclusively on divine institution.
- Rome had forfeited its primacy by departing from orthodoxy, particularly through the Filioque.
Nevertheless, some continued to recognize Rome's historical primacy and were prepared to acknowledge it again if Rome returned to what they considered orthodox faith. Dvornik argues that these later polemics should not be projected backward onto the earlier Byzantine Church, which had generally recognized Roman primacy much more positively.
15. Reunion requires recovering the earlier, shared understanding of Roman primacy. Dvornik believes the fourth through tenth centuries offer the strongest historical foundation for reconciliation. Both Churches must distinguish the essential nature of Roman primacy from historically conditioned forms of its exercise. Most important conclusion for evaluating the papacy
Dvornik's historical argument supports three conclusions of increasing specificity:
1. Roman primacy of honor: Clearly and consistently recognized in Byzantium.
2. Real Roman authority beyond honor: Broadly recognized in Byzantium, encompassing a special responsibility for doctrinal orthodoxy and an acknowledged role in ecclesiastical appeals. This authority was more than ceremonial, although its precise nature and limits were never clearly or uniformly defined.
3. Direct, immediate, and universal papal jurisdiction: Claimed by certain earlier popes, notably Gelasius, Symmachus, and Nicholas I, and substantially expanded by medieval reformers. Byzantium generally resisted these claims insofar as they entailed unilateral papal governance of the Eastern churches and threatened their traditional autonomy.
The central unresolved question is whether the universal jurisdiction claimed by the later papacy represents a legitimate development of the primacy recognized in the early Church or a departure from it.
A very detailed yet accessible exposition on the attitudes of both Western and Eastern Christendom towards the Papacy in the pre-schism era, and the development thereof after the ecumenical councils and then after the Crusades. I highly recommend it to anyone (including both Catholics and Orthodox) who wants to really understand the Primacy of Rome without polemics from either side.
Easy read. The book discusses the most important historical events surrounding the question of Roman Primacy from western (Latin) and eastern (Greek) perspectives.