Narrated by a one-handed juggler who moonlights as a drug trafficker, a talented young boy who longs to escape the shadow of his abusive father, and a police inspector whose overzealous efforts to solve a murder result in a series of calamitous missteps, Jonah Man explores the dark side of life behind the curtain, where artists resort to the most extreme measures—including drug dealing, self-mutilation, even murder—to prolong their time in the limelight. Resurrecting the lost language of vaudeville—a “Jonah Man” was a performer who, despite his best efforts, had stalled in his career—Jonah Man is a gripping portrait of people torn between their greatest hopes and fears, while trying to keep reality at bay.
This is an interesting but very odd look at the dark side of vaudeville as the one-handed juggler and a young boy's life intersect in unique ways. There's a police inspector that figures in as well, but overall this was just too disjointed for me to enjoy as much as I'd hoped. It does speak to people's hopes and the realities that often replace them so if this is your "thing," this book is for you!
It’s difficult to talk about Jonah Man without giving it away. The story is told through four narrators and alternates between past and present; the broken chronology makes for a tight, dense (even at 200 pages) narrative.
Jonah Man could easily have been delightful pulp novel: The basic story focuses on traveling sideshow performers in the early 1900s, who resort to self-mutilation for bigger crowds and drug dealing for bigger paychecks. And there is no lack of action: Narozny writes with a rhythm and economy that reminded me of Patrick DeWitt’s The Sisters Brothers, another book I really enjoyed. The dialog is quick, bleak and cuts like Cormac McCarthy’s, and like him, is peppered with bouts of lyricism that make you read lines twice.
What elevates Jonah Man beyond pulp-fare, is the bulldozing sense of history that motivates the characters. Every character is laced with sadness, and even when they resort to abuse, murder and cutting off their own arms, it suggests a fight against modernity and a struggle to keep their acts relevant.
I don't know if "literary historical pulp" is an established genre or if Narozny invented it with his debut novel, but I could read writing like this all day: punchy prose, snappy dialogue, memorable characters, and slick scenes that evoke a lost time and a world that's gone forever.
This book started out simply great. Intriguing characters, mystifying plot and a very authentic feeling glimpse into 1920's vaudeville. How can you not like the thought of a one-armed, drug dealing juggler, right? Well, unfortunately, the plot twisted into a vague mire of innuendo and did not satisfy. I hate when that happens.
Jonah Man started out as a fantastic novel. Full of terse language, Narozny's use of space reminded me of Cormac McCarthy. Told from 4 different points of view, Jonah Man addresses the seedier side of life in a roadshow culture. The ending is not bad at all, but it's certainly bleak and unresolved. It's worth the read but it's not earthshaking.
The novel's ars poetica comes as (what else?) a catalogue of one of its characters' collection of prosthetic arms: "The hooks varied in size and shape, with some as big as a double fist and others only slightly larger than a walnut, some so curved they nearly closed off, others with just a subtle bend at the tip." A description as apt for the characters Narozny presents as their stories—some closed off, others with just a subtle bend at the tip. The book, too, nearly closed off, with just a subtle bend at the tip.