The preface had me on the toilet 'til my legs went numb. Some chapters lagged a bit, and the later chapters dealing with near death experiences sometimes ventured into territory I'm not even sure I can lend credence to, especially Tompkins's coverage of Frederic Myers's posthumous writing via a medium... Meanwhile, however, this extension of credulity makes the book stronger and more surprising. Tompkins tested my limits to the point of disbelief. Why should a book about the most unknown of unknowns not venture into such murky territory? Tompkins himself makes the point many times over that writing books about 'life' beyond the material zone we're locked in tends to either be overly scientific and limited by a finite range and methodology (and not to mention dryness), or too 'new age-y' and bereft of any evidence or factual anchors with which to anchor ourselves.
This isn't a great book, but maybe that's because a book of this nature has to straddle two worlds, two prospective demographics of readers, and can only be so effective before it veers too far one way or the other. Books about the preternatural tend to be so skeptical of their evidence they end up portraying their amazing subject matter as mundane and improbable fluff, else they blindly throw their weight behind unverified (and perhaps unverifiable) claims from potential crazypantses and con-artists. I think Tompkins was aiming to find a middle ground with this book. That approach works for him and against him. I admire the ambition, but I can't say this is anything groundbreaking. There are probably better books on the subject, but perhaps none with such a conscious attention to balance.
Got to love that new age aphorism, "The map is not the territory." And don't you worry, the feeling came back to my legs. Come to think of it, I finished this book on the can too, but my legs only went a little tingly the second time. It's a miracle!
I imagine my sarcasm probably isn't appropriate here. I liked this book, but I'm also glad to be free to move on to the next.