"Fireside" was my first experience with author Susan Wiggs, and I have to say, I'm not impressed. Despite a good premise for the plot and a decent effort at redeeming plot twists, this book as a whole doesn't merit even a mediocre rating.
The first problem I had with "Fireside" was its use of similes. Yes, illustrative language is important to set the scene, but it shouldn’t be so conspicuous and formulaic, not to mention overly abundant. Plus, they're almost all references to baseball! I understand why - Bo Crutcher is a minor league player hoping to join the Yankees, and his romantic interest, Kimberly van Dorn, is his PR coach - but it felt like the writer pitched in a baseball analogy every chance she got (pun intended).
My second complaint is the sudden intrusion of the secondary plot line. In the middle of chapter 9, the storyline switches focus without warning to a completely new set of characters, and jumps back into the main plot just as abruptly. Ten chapters later, the two threads are tenuously connected, but soon the secondary plot line is dropped again and never returns. Obviously, this whole interlude is a setup for a later book in the series, but instead it only ostracizes those of us who haven't read the rest of the Lakeside Chronicles.
Finally, I couldn’t stand the inconsistencies in the main characters’ personalities; it destroyed their credibility and detracted from what could have been a very likeable cast. Bo's whiny attitude during their snowboarding lessons is a grating contrast to his otherwise playful, adventurous maturity. The demeanor of his 12-year-old son A.J. changes randomly from a bratty but insecure 5 year-old, to a sulky teenage rebel, to a world-weary old man. And at one point, steady, self-sufficient Kimberly inexplicably dissolves into uncontrollable tears - twice in one chapter! Perhaps these variances were meant to give the characters more depth, but it didn't work.
I did like the alternating viewpoints, shifting between Kimberly, Bo and A.J., and I found it interesting how the author dealt with issues like foster care, racism, and immigration. These elements and a few genuinely touching moments kept the book from being a total loss, but unless you've read the previous books in the series and just have to see what happens next, I would recommend leaving this one on the shelf.